Peer-reviewed paper shows Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies

The "Methods" statement alone is enough to know that the paper cannot support the claim you made in the thread title.

The search methodology they used was neither new nor unique.

We conducted a standard snowball search27 of the Legacy Tobacco Documents Library, an online archive of over 80 million pages of previously secret tobacco industry documents.

The citation there is to this paper.
 
Last edited:
Astroturfing is intended to give the statements the credibility of an independent entity by withholding information about the source's financial connection."

Do you think statements are more or less credible based on the source's financial connections to other entities?

And I've yet to see a reasonable response to pointing out that the "peer-reviewed paper" is not science but simply an exercise in confirmation bias.
 
The search methodology they used was neither new nor unique.
:confused: You must've misread my post because I never said it was new or unique.

Creation Science isn't new or unique either. It's still not science.


If your methodology is to look at documents for evidence of connections between the Tea Party and tobacco companies, then the only thing you can possibly find is evidence of such connections. That is confirmation bias.

At any rate, finding any number of connections isn't the same as proving that the Tea Party movement was created by tobacco companies.
 
So you now contradict your statement that it could have become a grassroots movement.

No, I'm not. I'm saying that while it's possible that the percolating anger at the time could have become a grassroots movement, the existing movement known as the "tea party movement" is not a grassroots movement.

A bunch of people being mad over taxes or the stimulus or Obama or whatever are not a movement. A movement is organized.

You're now saying it doesn't matter what happened subsequently since its inception is what made it not a grassroots movement.

No, I'm saying that the coordination and control of the movement by groups like FreedomWorks (which still exists, as seen in the number of AFP and FW bigwigs speaking at the SC Tea Party Convention this year and last) are what make it not a grassroots movement.

Seriously, you're claiming the Tea Party ideology was handed down? No yahoo sitting in a bar already held that ideology?

"And very quickly, the FreedomWorks ideology became the Tea Party ideology."

In fact, the history of that ideology in our country goes way back. There's a great example of it in the drunken rantings of Huck Finn's Pap. Surely you aren't claiming that this ideology didn't already exist?

It certainly didn't exist as an organized, coordinated political force opposing things that the vast majority of individual members actually support (like smoke-free laws).

:confused: You must've misread my post because I never said it was new or unique.

Creation Science isn't new or unique either. It's still not science.

Creation science also doesn't get published in peer-reviewed journals run by the BMJ.
 
Last edited:
It's amazing how few people know about the JBS and the beyond-extreme-right wing views of the Koch family.

The JBS were seriously concerned about Nixon's and Reagan's communist ties. That's how far right wing the CTers we are talking about here are.

And lest you think the JBS has gone away, Sarah Palin reads their magazine.:p

Conservapedia conveniently leaves the Kochs out of their JBS info page.And of course we all know that 'infiltration' was a real threat.:rolleyes:

But even Conservapedia cannot deny how wacky the JBS was and still is:
However, it looks like they slipped that in for a couple reasons, one to give the piece some pseudo-objectiveness and two, so they could dismiss the wacky and actually make the JBS look reasonable and sane.

And, for a song from the time the JBS rectum breathers were very well known, the classic Chad Mitchell Trio's John Birch Society:
http://www.metrolyrics.com/the-john-birch-society-lyrics-chad-mitchell-trio.html
 
Last edited:
Do you think statements are more or less credible based on the source's financial connections to other entities?

If the group making those statements is saying they're more credible for coming from a grassroots organization of political independents instead of from "the Republican establishment", when in reality the group making those statements is and always has been organized and funded by that very same establishment, then yes.

And I've yet to see a reasonable response to pointing out that the "peer-reviewed paper" is not science but simply an exercise in confirmation bias.

So write in to the journal's editors. This isn't just some blog entry or website article, and there are avenues within academia for contesting the methodology and conclusions of a published peer-reviewed paper, if you think the paper is incorrect or erroneous.

EDIT: The authors of the paper also offer a free supplemental file to their paper, by the way.
 
Last edited:
Google: "quarterback behind the scenes": many people are writing about this and as usual errors propagate.

If you want to read an article from someone who was actually there, had read the paper the day before it was published, uses the LTDL heavily, and has spent hours with the 3 authors:
Google: mashey TEA Party: Tobacco Everywhere Always
Find the article at DeSMogBlog and read that.

Watch the video linked there, ~20 minutes.
This was superb scholarship by the authors, but of course it was history/investigative journalism, not science research, so arguments about replication are ill-informed. The crucial references are all easily accessible via URLs.

It was published in a premier international journal on tobacco control, in part because one of the paper's points was the recent expansion of the Tea Party outside the US. Tobacco business model =
1) kill children slowly, even after the end of Joe Camel and TwistaLime.
2) hide behind "independent" organizations to stop tax increases, one of the most effective ways to inhibit kids from smoking.
3) Item 2) has been getting much harder in the US, Australia, etc, so expand abroad even faster.
 
So you now contradict your statement that it could have become a grassroots movement.

You're now saying it doesn't matter what happened subsequently since its inception is what made it not a grassroots movement.

Seriously, you're claiming the Tea Party ideology was handed down? No yahoo sitting in a bar already held that ideology?

In fact, the history of that ideology in our country goes way back. There's a great example of it in the drunken rantings of Huck Finn's Pap. Surely you aren't claiming that this ideology didn't already exist?
By your definition there are no such things as astro-turf groups.

The definition of an astro turf movement does not preclude 'believers'. The difference is in how it sprang up, not what it looks like or how many followers they attract.

Astroturf refers to apparently grassroots-based citizen groups or coalitions that are primarily conceived, created and/or funded by corporations, industry trade associations, political interests or public relations firms....

...Unlike genuine grassroots activism which tends to be money-poor but people-rich, astroturf campaigns are typically people-poor but cash-rich. Funded heavily by corporate largesse, they use sophisticated computer databases, telephone banks and hired organizers to rope less-informed activists into sending letters to their elected officials or engaging in other actions that create the appearance of grassroots support for their client's cause.
Now it may bother you that they talk about less-informed activists in the definition. I'm sure there are plenty of TEA Party people who don't believe they are less-informed. But ignoring the ideology, how informed are TEA Party members about their financial backers?
William Greider's 1992 book, Who Will Tell the People, described an astroturf campaign run by Bonner & Associates as a "boiler room" operation with "300 phone lines and a sophisticated computer system, resembling the phone banks employed in election campaigns. Articulate young people sit in little booths every day, dialing around America on a variety of public issues, searching for 'white hat' citizens who can be persuaded to endorse the political objectives of Mobil Oil, Dow Chemical, Citicorp, Ohio Bell, Miller Brewing, United States Tobacco Company, the Chemical Manufacturers Association, the Pharmaceutical Manufacturers Association and dozens of other clients. This kind of political recruiting is expensive but not difficult. ... Imagine Bonner's technique multiplied and elaborated in different ways across hundreds of public issues and you may begin to envision the girth of this industry. ... This is democracy and it costs a fortune."
Those white-hat citizens are not duped into a new ideology, rather the recruiters find them and recruit them because they have the ideology the recruiters are looking for.

The result is the movement doesn't have the same extensive base of a real grass roots movement. As astroturf movement has a money base, not a masses base. And there's plenty of evidence that is true for the TEA Party.



I know you won't like this article but it has some important evidence: The Tea Party movement: deluded and inspired by billionaires. But try to ignore the part about duped and deluded and just look at the facts there re the funding:
The Tea Party movement is remarkable in two respects. It is one of the biggest exercises in false consciousness the world has seen – and the biggest Astroturf operation in history. These accomplishments are closely related.

An Astroturf campaign is a fake grassroots movement: it purports to be a spontaneous uprising of concerned citizens, but in reality it is founded and funded by elite interests. Some Astroturf campaigns have no grassroots component at all. Others catalyse and direct real mobilisations. The Tea Party belongs in the second category. It is mostly composed of passionate, well-meaning people who think they are fighting elite power, unaware that they have been organised by the very interests they believe they are confronting.

Here's where the delusion comes in:
The company has had to pay tens of millions of dollars in fines and settlements for oil and chemical spills and other industrial accidents. The Kochs want to pay less tax, keep more profits and be restrained by less regulation. Their challenge has been to persuade the people harmed by this agenda that it's good for them.

In July 2010, David Koch told New York magazine: "I've never been to a Tea Party event. No one representing the Tea Party has ever even approached me." But a fascinating new film – (Astro)Turf Wars, by Taki Oldham – tells a fuller story. Oldham infiltrated some of the movement's key organising events, including the 2009 Defending the American Dream summit, convened by a group called Americans for Prosperity (AFP). The film shows David Koch addressing the summit. "Five years ago," he explains, "my brother Charles and I provided the funds to start Americans for Prosperity. It's beyond my wildest dreams how AFP has grown into this enormous organisation."

And this is how you grow astroturf:
A convener tells the crowd how AFP mobilised opposition to Barack Obama's healthcare reforms. "We hit the button and we started doing the Twittering and Facebook and the phonecalls and the emails, and you turned up!" Then a series of AFP organisers tell Mr Koch how they have set up dozens of Tea Party events in their home states. He nods and beams from the podium like a chief executive receiving rosy reports from his regional sales directors. Afterwards, the delegates crowd into AFP workshops, where they are told how to run further Tea Party events.
 
I did find a link to a speech given by one of the authors on the paper. I cannot find it now but the site was hosted by San Diego State University.
While I have no doubt that corporate interests (tobacco included) have had some influence in the tea party movement the power point i saw reminded me of truthers and the we need a new Pearl Harbor document. There were "connections" from many years ago. There were things such as the organization that helped the early tea party received funding from the tobacco companies among other funding sources etc.
When someone goes looking for a specific conclusion and loose connections they can usually find it.
 
The heavy reliance on social media by the tea party movement is partly why it took so long for the groups who wanted to create a faux-grassroots campaign to actually get it off the ground. The tea party couldn't have been created in 1995 or 2002 (even though groups like the predecessor to the AFP and FW were really, really trying to start one) because the tools to make their astroturfing campaign successful simply weren't available yet.
 
Let me put it this way, have you considered what evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement would be? Have you looked for that evidence?

Or, can you name an example of something that is a grassroots movement and consider what the result of a similar "study" of its connections to any given corporation are and how you would know when those connections are enough to conclude that it's not actually a grassroots movement?

My criticism of confirmation bias stands. This paper only looks for evidence of connections. By definition it can find nothing else but evidence of connections. Before the "study" was conducted, there was no chance that it would conclude anything other than the existence of connections.
 
By your definition there are no such things as astro-turf groups.

Or more accurately, whether or not a group is an astroturf group is irrelevant to the question of whether or not it's a grassroots movement and irrelevant to the merits of that group's ideology.

But again, the paper cited in the OP is not science.
 
The heavy reliance on social media by the tea party movement is partly why it took so long for the groups who wanted to create a faux-grassroots campaign to actually get it off the ground.

So you take heavy reliance on social media as evidence that it's not a grassroots movement?

Again, what would you consider to be evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement?

The problem with confirmation bias is in not looking for evidence that would go against your hypothesis. That is, it's not enough only to consider evidence that confirms your hypothesis.
 
Let me put it this way, have you considered what evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement would be? Have you looked for that evidence?

Skeptic Ginger posted what some of the differences between a genuine grassroots movement and an astroturf movement are, and the tea party movement matches the criteria for the latter.

Or, can you name an example of something that is a grassroots movement and consider what the result of a similar "study" of its connections to any given corporation are and how you would know when those connections are enough to conclude that it's not actually a grassroots movement?

The antiwar movement, perhaps.

My criticism of confirmation bias stands. This paper only looks for evidence of connections. By definition it can find nothing else but evidence of connections. Before the "study" was conducted, there was no chance that it would conclude anything other than the existence of connections.

The involvement and influence of AFP and FW in creating and organizing the tea party movement were well-known long before this paper was written. The two books I quoted were published years before this paper (one is even cited in the paper itself).

So you take heavy reliance on social media as evidence that it's not a grassroots movement?

No, I take things like the fact that within days of Santelli's televised rant, a group that previously proposed a plan to create a Boston Tea Party-themed protest group by "till[ing] the ground for years [and] recruiting activists" was urging and instructing people to start local tea parties and making plans to embark on a twenty-five-city national tea party tour as evidence it's not a grassroots movement.

Again, what would you consider to be evidence that the Tea Party is a grassroots movement?

Independence from the organization, networking, and funding of the big political advocacy groups. When your very first big important national movement rally has a logo preselected for you by a group like FreedomWorks and you can't change it, you're not a grassroots movement.
 
Last edited:
I did find a link to a speech given by one of the authors on the paper. I cannot find it now but the site was hosted by San Diego State University.
While I have no doubt that corporate interests (tobacco included) have had some influence in the tea party movement the power point i saw reminded me of truthers and the we need a new Pearl Harbor document. There were "connections" from many years ago. There were things such as the organization that helped the early tea party received funding from the tobacco companies among other funding sources etc.
When someone goes looking for a specific conclusion and loose connections they can usually find it.
Koch's speech at the "Defending the American Dream Summit" was in 2009 and Americans for Prosperity was started by the Kochs in 2004. AfP claims to be all about grass roots but they are a classic astroturf front group organization.

I'm not suggesting the astroturf builders didn't have a substantial group of ideologues to exploit, clearly they did. Perhaps half astroturf half grass could be claimed. Given all the money and organization that went into stoking the fires, I'm not so sure.


Re the tobacco connection, I think you'll find a lot of the key players are the same, even if there isn't a currently connected umbilical cord to RJ Reynolds.
 
Last edited:
0) If people really want to learn about the tobacco business, the 2 best books I know are (read reviews at Amazon) by 2 of the top historians who've studied it:

Harvard: Allan M. Brandt, The Cigarette Century (2007) ~600 pages.

Stanford: Robert N. Proctor, Golden Holocaust: Origins of the Cigarette Catastrophe and the Case for Abolition (2012) ~700 pages

1) The LTDL @ UCSF is freely accessible to anyone online. The main challenge in using it is that it takes a while to frame queries to find what you're looking for, amidst the numerous hits. When someone spends hundreds of hours searching, they inevitably run across documents not germane to their immediate goals, but sometimes get tagged for later research. (I have at least a hundred documents bookmarked, of which I've used maybe 30%.)

2)The tobacco-Tea Party connection was not a starting goal, but an emergent property of decades of experience studying the evolution of tobacco company tactics, following the money flows (as found in the LTDL). Out popped CSE as the biggest thinktank/501(c)(3()/(4) recipient.

3) Merchants of Doubt (2010) included tobacco, but was not focused there, but rather on 4 scientists, of whom 2 had strong tobacco activities.

My report "Crescendo to Climategate Cacophony" (2010) included tables of funders versus organizations that did climate anti-science, but tobacco connections popped up so often that I included a checkbox (pp.93-95). However, I didn't include CSE, since it was gone. Likewise,
"Fakery 2: More Funny Finances, Free Of Tax" (10/25/12 @ DeSmogBlog) had extensive analysis (pp.37-41) of tobacco funding for thinktanks, and what thinktanks did for them (my favorite is "Access to GW Bush). I assume people are thrilled to know that tobacco companies get a tax-break by giving money to 501(c)(3) public charities to pay them for lobbying and PR.
p.3 there is the graph that Stan Glantz refers to in the Q&A at the end of Amanda's presentation.

4) The books above were looking at other areas, but both include cigarette companies' long history of trying to confuse people by using "independent" faux experts and organizations.

5) But the folks at UCSF had been running across CSE often enough to track it forward and back, and the long efforts of tobacco companies to use CSE (and others) to create something like the Tea Party *emerged* from that. That's the way good historical research often works - you find thigns you weren't looking for when you started.
 
...
Joe t J said:
Or, can you name an example of something that is a grassroots movement and consider what the result of a similar "study" of its connections to any given corporation are and how you would know when those connections are enough to conclude that it's not actually a grassroots movement?
The antiwar movement, perhaps.
The antiwar movement and the Civil Rights movements were real grassroots movements. The Occupy movement is a true grassroots movement. In none of those do you find the connections to any big money organizers you are suggesting:
Real Grassroots Populism vs. Surreal Tea Party Astroturf
 
Last edited:
...My criticism of confirmation bias stands. This paper only looks for evidence of connections. By definition it can find nothing else but evidence of connections. Before the "study" was conducted, there was no chance that it would conclude anything other than the existence of connections.
The confirmation bias is yours, Joe. Take this claim in your next post as a perfect example:
But again, the paper cited in the OP is not science.

How do you dismiss a university study funded by the NIH and the National Cancer Institute, published in a respected peer reviewed medical journal, using the also published peer reviewed Tobacco documents research methodology as "not science"? That is pure confirmation bias, yours.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom