Meteor over Moscow

I disagree. I would say the sound is consistent with multiple objects creating multiple shockwaves; but the meteor breaking up and the meteor "exploding" are two different things. Photos of the smoke/vapor trail show a very consistent and smooth flight path, not punctuated by any large "explosion" traces.

Yep, thinking on it a bit more I suspect you're right.
 
Ok so it's the second time in about a hundred years that a huge meteor blew up over Russia. Either god hates russia, or maybe the way that most meteors hit earth have a greater chance of hitting Russia for some weird spin, trajectory reasons? Or chance but wtf?
Three quarters of the earth's surface are water and a lot of land in uninhabited or sparsely populated too. I've read somewhere before that for the people watching for secret nuclear explosions as from infrared satellite data see these types of things regularly. How regularly is apparently kept from the public.
 
I agree, but there seems to now be a fair amount of public doubt about an explosion. I don't think the doubt is consistent with the aural evidence.
Doubt among whom? Because any person familiar with meteorites would know this was clearly an air blast.
 
If this had happened during the height of the Cold War we might not have had a civilization left.
My first thought as well. If I heard that boom, a ballistics explosion would be the first thing on my mind, even having seen the fireball.
 
Three quarters of the earth's surface are water and a lot of land in uninhabited or sparsely populated too. I've read somewhere before that for the people watching for secret nuclear explosions as from infrared satellite data see these types of things regularly. How regularly is apparently kept from the public.

I hear tons of stuff from people, too.
 
Doubt among whom? Because any person familiar with meteorites would know this was clearly an air blast.

I was going to say Phil Plait, but I just looked at his site and he has updated it recently to say he now believes there were actual explosions. There were other credible sources, as well, that I came across through casual browsing; can't get back to them now that I'm home with a different browser history.
 
I disagree. I would say the sound is consistent with multiple objects creating multiple shockwaves; but the meteor breaking up and the meteor "exploding" are two different things. Photos of the smoke/vapor trail show a very consistent and smooth flight path, not punctuated by any large "explosion" traces.

A simple Google search finds a better answer than the speculating in this thread is doing.

Airburst Explained
It traveled through the atmosphere for about 30 seconds before breaking apart and producing violent airburst ‘explosion’ about 20-14 km (12-15 miles) above Earth’s surface, producing an energy shockwave equivalent to a 300 kilotons explosion. That energy propagated down through the atmosphere,
After a meteor explodes in the air, the pieces then continue on in their forward trajectory but fall at terminal velocity from there on.
 
I was going to say Phil Plait, but I just looked at his site and he has updated it recently to say he now believes there were actual explosions. There were other credible sources, as well, that I came across through casual browsing; can't get back to them now that I'm home with a different browser history.
If the BA ever expressed doubt it had to be before he saw the video clips.
 
I should mention, the cause of the explosion is the pressure differential of the incoming rock. The leading edge experiences tremendous pressure while the trailing edge is subject to a much lower pressure causing the rock to violently break apart.

There's a chart on this link showing what size rocks burn up, break up and make it to an impact crater.

10 - 100 megatons*, every 1000yrs: irons make craters like Meteor Crater; stones produce airbursts like Tunguska;
land impacts destroy area size of city

Read more about Meteors l Meteorites and Impacts by nineplanets.org
This won't turn out to be a nickel-iron.

*300 kilotons =0.3 megatons
 
Last edited:
Well, glad I'm not replacing all of our windows, but man! -- how cool would it be to see/hear that?

I saw a much smaller meteor a few years back while stuck in rushhour traffic...it was amazing. And that only lasted a couple of seconds before winking out. But it was clearly visible in daylight, and left a finger-width contrail in the sky for about 35 degrees of arc. Amazing, I'll never forget it. One moment of WTH followed by, "That's gotta be a meteor!" followed by relief that traffic was crawling so I could make notes of time, location, apparent size, etc.

Before I had a cellphone alas.
 
Well, glad I'm not replacing all of our windows, but man! -- how cool would it be to see/hear that?

I saw a much smaller meteor a few years back while stuck in rushhour traffic...it was amazing. And that only lasted a couple of seconds before winking out. But it was clearly visible in daylight, and left a finger-width contrail in the sky for about 35 degrees of arc. Amazing, I'll never forget it. One moment of WTH followed by, "That's gotta be a meteor!" followed by relief that traffic was crawling so I could make notes of time, location, apparent size, etc.

Before I had a cellphone alas.

As part of the select group that has heard such an airburst I can say that after the fact it is soooo cool to reflect on. At the time it is scary as hell!

When it happened to me the sound was so loud and sharp I instinctively dove to the floor thinking an airplane had struck the house. My cats freaked out and ran around like they were being chased by a pit bull made of fire. Bounding up walls, climbing curtains and you name it. Outside every car alarm in town was blaring away.
 
Many of the videos are actually really good reference for how people react when they see something totally unexpected in the sky (or in some cases on the ground after impact). It's amazing how different these videos look from any Bigfoot or UFO photos or videos I have ever seen. They're all so clear and steady, those filming try to follow the action to the best of their ability and in one case try to enter a burning building to film what happened. I think these videos need to be used for the new standard of what we expect from video sightings of unknown phenomena!
 
(Not the injured kids, though, if that was in fact the case. How did that happen? Shattered glass?)

Mostly shattered glass. Probably the worst case scenario is someone standing near a window looking at the trail wondering what it is and then getting a face full of glass for their trouble.
 
Many of the videos are actually really good reference for how people react when they see something totally unexpected in the sky (or in some cases on the ground after impact). It's amazing how different these videos look from any Bigfoot or UFO photos or videos I have ever seen. They're all so clear and steady, those filming try to follow the action to the best of their ability and in one case try to enter a burning building to film what happened. I think these videos need to be used for the new standard of what we expect from video sightings of unknown phenomena!

Very good observation!
 
Many of the videos are actually really good reference for how people react when they see something totally unexpected in the sky (or in some cases on the ground after impact). It's amazing how different these videos look from any Bigfoot or UFO photos or videos I have ever seen. They're all so clear and steady, those filming try to follow the action to the best of their ability and in one case try to enter a burning building to film what happened. I think these videos need to be used for the new standard of what we expect from video sightings of unknown phenomena!
After my initial reaction of "How Cool Is That?!", the above was my next thought.

UFO proponents have their work cut out for them now that this benchmark has been set.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom