I'm comfortable with your analysis. Personally I have a slightly different focus.. The history is that about two years ago I confronted M_T over the main problems I have identified with his posting style viz:
(In no order of priority)
1) His central error of logic IMO is various forms of "false globalisation" e.g. if he finds one error of detail in the NIST report he declares all of NIST totally useless;
2) Like most truthers he always plays for "reversed burden of proof" - I don't regard him as one based on his recent postings but it is a stock truther debating trick - the reversal is necessary to overcome the issue you identified - inability to put forward a reasoned argument and "None of them, Major Tom included, are ever able to summarise their own work";
3) Specifically I have explained many times in extensive detail what is wrong with the main errors of his logic. He describes my comments as "faeces" (the forum doesn't like the words us Aussies like to use.

) but will not say why; THEN
4) His standard tactic of evasion is the "Gish Gallop" which led me to propose renaming it the "M_T Gallop" (read that aloud to
see hear the double meaning

).
5) He relies on innuendo to put forward his untruths/lies;
6) he persists in insults;
7) It is rare for him to post without scorn and insult;
8) Denying the validity of any evidence which is not in visual form;
9) Therefore he denies any sound engineering reasoning about what cannot be seen as "mere conjecture". As you realise many hidden scenarios only allow of two or three possibilities and, provided you explain all two or three and they all support your overall claim, you don't need to know which it was - I can flesh out the legitimate logic of that but not now.
10) Plus a couple more.
My offers to help him have been repeated here and on his home forum at least three tines each at about 6 month intervals but I will not be doing it again. As soon as I get him to a point of definite commitment he aborts debate and starts with the insults. Plus trademark lies by innuendo etc.
However on a single narrow area - technical examination of WTC images - he has done some great work. Identifying how the perimeter columns broke up and peeled of landing where AND identifying the zone sequencing of the ROOSD collapse. I beat him to both by a few years but he took the analysis a lot further. Some folk don't see the utility of that research but that is not a valid criticism.
And all of that good work is over-ridden by his untruthful claims, evasive failure to support his claims and insulting comments.
Back to your points:
Same here.
I could give you the list of posters who I have 'scared off' and they are easy to see. I won't name them here for several obvious reasons. Not least I'm not yet ready to commit suicide by mod.

Look to my "serious" posts and see:
1) Who won't respond; AND
2) How often the thread dies after one of my serious posts
because the challenge I have set is too high. OR
3) Who tries to ridicule me and shows their own limits by making the attempt.
Jay is b.... good and I wouldn't want to take him on.
A good hint - I'll see if I can locate the video. That said my interest in Internet Forum topics these days is very much focussed on the remaining bit of 9/11 discussion. the real stuff - not troll feeding. I did my few years following political issues, creationism v evolution and gay marriage reform on two other forums - 2007-2010 then 2010-2011. A couple of years of that as politics moderator. I no longer have the buzz beyond the remnants of engineering aspects in these 9/11 threads. With an occasional excursion into legal stuff - my second field of qualification.
Thanks for your comments and insights. Including the "managed for controlled failure" stuff in those couple of "fill in the waiting time" posts.