WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

Again, we are talking about thermite. It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings. For steel structural columns and beams, you need a very high-velocity explosive to cut through the steel. A specialized explosive called RDX. This copper-encased high explosive is physically attached to the beam, and upon detonation 'slices' the steel at 27,000 feet per second. A small amount of conventional dynamite is sometimes attached to the beam to 'kick' it out of place so the structure will fall uniformly, in a direction predestinated by the blaster.

So…thermite…who cares! It’s a con job, thought up by the truther movement, when they couldn’t find any real evidence to support their “Control Demolition” theories.
 
BenjaminTR: As I understand it, everyone is basically on the same page. Careful reading of the Bentham paper shows Harrit et al treated all the red / grey chips as the same.

Not everyone, look at Gamolon. Most agree that there are a few different kinds of chips, this is even stated in Harrit´s paper, that there are also different chips with other chemicals and some in many layers. But none of those are studied in the paper. Harrit treated all the chips that were studied in the paper as the same, which is not at all the same as saying all the chips found in the dust are the same. Some people find that hard to understand for some reason, but what can you do?

Africanus: henryco confirmed the composition of the chips and says that this composition is compatible with the nanothermite chips.

BTW you do not identify a compound/composit by its reactions, but by determining the chemical composition of the compound/composit. That's the way a chemist works.

Your buddies here do not agree, including Chris Mohr. HenryCo identified the chips by composition as compatible to nanothermite, but Mohr did not accept that conclusion without successful ignition tests.
 
Again, we are talking about thermite. It's not a high explosive, it's an incendiary, and totally ineffective in the precision cutting of steel frame members, which is required for the controlled demolition of high rise steel frame buildings. For steel structural columns and beams, you need a very high-velocity explosive to cut through the steel. A specialized explosive called RDX. This copper-encased high explosive is physically attached to the beam, and upon detonation 'slices' the steel at 27,000 feet per second. A small amount of conventional dynamite is sometimes attached to the beam to 'kick' it out of place so the structure will fall uniformly, in a direction predestinated by the blaster.

So…thermite…who cares! It’s a con job, thought up by the truther movement, when they couldn’t find any real evidence to support their “Control Demolition” theories.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LNOM_U5UM6Q
 
Not everyone, look at Gamolon. Most agree that there are a few different kinds of chips, this is even stated in Harrit´s paper, that there are also different chips with other chemicals and some in many layers. But none of those are studied in the paper. Harrit treated all the chips that were studied in the paper as the same, which is not at all the same as saying all the chips found in the dust are the same. Some people find that hard to understand for some reason, but what can you do?


Your buddies here do not agree, including Chris Mohr. HenryCo identified the chips by composition as compatible to nanothermite, but Mohr did not accept that conclusion without successful ignition tests.

We have fantasy thermite and fake conclusions. Jones made it up, and Harrit made it dumber; seriously, hundreds of tons of thermite would leave real evidence. The steel shows no signs of thermite, like fused iron on the steel. Can't believe anyone falls for the delusional thermite claim.

Then we have reality. Millette did not find thermite.

This is why 911 truth remains a fantasy, not able to make 60 Minutes. Fake papers and silly old paranoid conspiracy theorists spreading lies only a fringe few fall for.
 
Can anyone post up links from Jones & Co where they directly state that Millette had the wrong chips because he did not do DSC ?

Thanks

Jones & Co must have ordered their followers to sow the seed for Millette having the wrong chips?

Or is this something jtl and semenut are making up :D not forgetting MM

I can't find the orders anywhere, infact Jones has gone right off the radar.:confused:
 
Jones & Co must have ordered their followers to sow the seed for Millette having the wrong chips?

Or is this something jtl and semenut are making up :D not forgetting MM

I can't find the orders anywhere, infact Jones has gone right off the radar.:confused:

No, this is something the Truthers pretty much made up out of whole cloth to get around the fact that Millette's more detailed study completely and utterly rules out thermite.
 
Not everyone, look at Gamolon. Most agree that there are a few different kinds of chips,

Let me explain where I stand as you obviously don't get it. I believe that there are different red/gray chips that are attracted to a magnet. Millette proved this. It's Harrit's Bentham paper that states otherwise thus making it a complete sham.

The isolation method for getting the correct chips is stated in the Bentham paper on page 9. There are two things they considered.
1. Attracted to a magnet
2. Had red/gray layers

If the resistivity test was the third isolation test used to "get the right chips" it would have been included in the isolation method paragraph on page 9 and would not have appeared on page 27.

After Millette's testing showed that there non-thermite chips, Jones comes out and says that Millette didn't do a resistivity test to determine if his chips were paint or not.

The way the paper reads, Harrit and his group didn't do a resistivity to isolate the red/gray chips into paint and non-paint and ten test the non-paint chips before performing all the other tests. They took random chips from the main pile, isolated by red/gray layers and attraction to a magnet, found that a couple that didn't match paint, and applied those results to the entire isolated pile. I have an email from Harrit stating that the resistivity test should be considered supplementary information.

The fact that the Bentham paper concludes that every single red/gray chip they collected was un-reacted thermite is a joke. And now they are trying to cover their mistake by implying (by Jones' "Millette didn't do a resistivity test" quote) that Harrit and his group had tested for and sorted out red/gray, magnetically attracted PAINT chips from their original isolation pile. This contradicts their paper's conclusion.

That's why Harrit and Jones refuse to answer my email to clarify if they did indeed separated their chips into high and low resistivity piles. If they admit they didn't do this, Jones looks like a fool for claiming that Millette "didn't do a the simple resistivity test and got the wrong chips" when they didn't do it themselves.

If they did do this resistivity test to separate red/gray chips in high and low resistivity piles like Jones implies they did, then the paper is proven to be garbage because they conclude in the paper that every single red/gray chip they isolated was thermite.

It's a double edged sword that makes them look like fools. That's why they beat around the bush when answering my emails until I pushed them for an exact answer. Better to ignore and hope I'll go away than to look like fools eh?

this is even stated in Harrit´s paper, that there are also different chips with other chemicals and some in many layers. But none of those are studied in the paper.
Please, by all means. Post the quote from the Bentham paper right here in this thread where they state that there were non-thermite, red/gray chips that were attracted by a magnet. I have asked for this many times and nobody has been able to provide anything.

There are now two different groups of you guys, one group says there is only one kind of chip attracted by magnet, but the other says there are many different kinds.[/edit]
No.

It's Harrit's Bentham paper that says there is one kind of red/gray, magnetically attracted chip.
 
Last edited:
...
That's why Harrit and Jones refuse to answer my email to clarify if they did indeed separated their chips into high and low resistivity piles. If they admit they didn't do this, Jones looks like a fool for claiming that Millette "didn't do a the simple resistivity test and got the wrong chips" when they didn't do it themselves.
...

For the record:

Harrit also totally refuses to answer my question:
Oystein said:
1. Is my understanding correct that your team used precisely the following two methods/criteria to isolate all the chips that are featured in your paper:
i.) Attraction to a permanent magnet
ii.) The visual appearance as "red-gray chips"?
The closest he came to answering this was:
Niels Harrit said:
Most of your inquiry is covered by the original paper. Basically, you ask me to confirm, that we believed and believe what we wrote. That is pretty insinuating and offending.
The best interpretation of this is that the answer is covered by the original paper. The original paper does in fact list only those two criteria under "Chip Isolation", and the paper describes the resistivity test only for one sibgle chip, of which we don't know if that chip is featured in any test that the paper describes.

Hence Harrit indirectly confirms what Gamolon, I and others assert: That the resistivity test was and is NOT a selection criterion. He thus definitely contradicts what jtl, MM and/or Senemut assert, and also contradicts Jones.

jtl, MM, Senemut: Why do you keep making statements that imply that Harrit et al are liars? Or are you lying? Then please stop lying!



ETA:
Also, David Griscom, the referee of the Harrit paper, stated his understanding in his first reply to me that, the red-gray chips are so distinctictive they are all thermitic and not paint. I specifically asked:
Oystein said:
2. Concerning the nature of chips thusly selected: Is it your impression, too, that the 2009 Harrit et. al. paper formed its conclusions based on the premise that all chips included in the study, and selected by exactly the two criteria I mentioned, are essentially the same kind of material - they are ALL thermitic, and none are non-thermitic (but instead, perhaps, paint)?
and he specifically answered:
David Griscom said:
Yes, see above.
(where "see above" contains no qualification whatsoever)

I further asked "3. Follow-up to 2.: Do you feel that such a premise is valid?" and he said "Yes." (a totally unqualified "yes").

So you see, the top physicist who refereed the paper and contributed twelve pages of peer-review to it was very clearly and uncinditionally under the impression that all red-gray chips are essentially the same, that only the two criteria "magnetic" and "red/gray chip" were used to select them, that all of these are thermitic, none are paint.

So jtl, MM and Senemut apparently think that Griscom is wrong, and they are smarter than him.
 
Last edited:
One of Harrit's responses to me:

The resistivity test were done in random on the chips already isolated as described. The information obtained must be considered "supplementary material".
 
Here is an exceprt from a Niels Harrit paper titled "WHY THE RED/GRAY CHIPS ARE NOT PRIMER PAINT", dated May 09.
http://www.ae911truth.org/downloads/documents/primer_paint_Niels_Harrit.pdf

It has been suggested, that the red/grey chips discovered in the dust from the WTC collapse catastrophe1 could originate from rust-inhibiting paint (primer paint) applied to the steel beams in the towers. This letter compares the elemental composition and the thermal stability of the two materials based on the description of the protective paint in the NIST report and observations on the red/grey chips.

If according to them, they had red/gray paint chips separated out via resistivity tests (as Jones claims), then why did they have to refer to the description of the protective paint in the NIST report?!

Why didn't they just examine the red/gray paint chips they separated out and compare/publish those results?

Because, once again, they thought ALL the red/gray chips were thermitic and they needed to go outside the box.
 
No, this is something the Truthers pretty much made up out of whole cloth to get around the fact that Millette's more detailed study completely and utterly rules out thermite.

No suprise there :D

Poor old jtl defends Harrit so often and he is one of the contributors of making Harrit look a jerk :cool:

Maybe this is how The Harrit and holocaust deniers came about.
 
No suprise there :D

Poor old jtl defends Harrit so often and he is one of the contributors of making Harrit look a jerk :cool:

Maybe this is how The Harrit and holocaust deniers came about.

The truly ironic bit is, as Gamolon and others who have contacted Harrit directly have shown, Harrit's so-called "defenders" are calling him a liar, because his plain words directly contradict their "wrong chips" fantasy.
 
so if he confirmed the composition that is compatible with the nanothermite chips and it did NOT react even when heated to 900C. what do you think about that?

This clearly proofs that the chips contain no nanothermite and are therefore not thermitic. And Millette showed why the chips are not thermitic: They contain no elemental aluminum.

Conclusio: The iron-rich microspheres are not product of a thermite reaction.
 
Your buddies here do not agree, including Chris Mohr. HenryCo identified the chips by composition as compatible to nanothermite, but Mohr did not accept that conclusion without successful ignition tests.

Henryco, as well as Harrit and Jones, only determined the elemental setup of the chips and not the actual composition of the chips, but Henryco's results show clearly that his and Jones chips have the same elemental setup. Millette identified the building blocks of the chips (a - d), Kaolinit, Hematite and Epoxy Primer. That's why we exactly know that the chips are not thermitic.
 
As Dr. Harrit et al have reported, they arrived at their conclusions, after examining and testing far more samples than just those given identification in the 2009 Bentham Paper.

As the chief researcher, Dr. Millette should have welcomed the additional chip-filtering information [Resistivity Test] described in the 2009 Bentham Paper that Chris Mohr asked him to duplicate.

By doing so, he could add to his claim that he had matched all the Bentham Paper qualifiers.

But.

If he did isolate 'chips of interest' by targeting those with relatively low readings (~10 ohms or less), and ignored those with relatively high readings (~100,000 ohms or more), he's not talking about it.

And if he did heat a few of those chips up to 430°C, he's not talking about that either.

But any claim that isolation by magnet does not work for successfully isolating 'chips of interest', is not true.

The issue is that after being magnetically isolated, you still end up with a lot of chips.

As Dr. Jones has stated, the resistivity test described in he Bentham Paper significantly simplified filtering of the pile of magnetically-isolated chips.

It speeds up the 'chips-of-interest' discovery process.

It also helps emphasize the fact that after being isolated with a magnet, there are so many red/gray chips that using a resistivity test becomes a valuable time saver.

And when someone like Dr. Millette is eye-balling under a microscope, a lot of opportunity exists to pick the many wrong chips based on the simple criteria of something red with something gray stuck to it.

MM
 
As the chief researcher, Dr. Millette should have welcomed the additional chip-filtering information [Resistivity Test] described in the 2009 Bentham Paper that Chris Mohr asked him to duplicate.

The Bentham Paper does not describe the use of a resistivity test as "chip-filtering information." Are you accusing the authors of misreporting their methods?
 
The Bentham Paper does not describe the use of a resistivity test as "chip-filtering information." Are you accusing the authors of misreporting their methods?
It's utterly astounding that MM and other truthers continue to expound the notion that a resistivity test is somehow a valid method of isolating chips of interest when both the paper itself, the authors of the paper and a reviewer expressly state that this was not a criteria for isolating chips.

They support the Harrit et al paper fully, yet roundly refuse to acknowledge the paper's wording and categorical statements made by the very same people who were involved in the production of the data and the paper itself.

They are making false statements against the very people they claim to support. That's illogical.

How can anyone have a rational discussion with such people? It's wanton dishonesty at an unprecedented level.
 
Sunstealer:
It's utterly astounding that MM and other truthers continue to expound the notion that a resistivity test is somehow a valid method of isolating chips of interest when both the paper itself, the authors of the paper and a reviewer expressly state that this was not a criteria for isolating chips.

HMMMMMMMMM

Steven Jones, one of the authors of Harrit´s paper, actually states:
Also, we checked the electrical resistivity of several paints – consistently orders of magnitude higher than that of the red material. We reported the resistivity of the red material in our paper, page 27 in the Journal. Millette did not report any electrical resistivity measurements. This measurement is rather easy to do so I was surprised when he failed to do this straightforward test. There is a lot of red material of various types in the WTC dust, so one must be careful to make sure it is the same as what we studied, and not some other material.

HMMMMMMMMMM

They are making false statements against the very people they claim to support. That's illogical.

How can anyone have a rational discussion with such people? It's wanton dishonesty at an unprecedented level.

Someone is indeed being very dishonest, and making false statements, and it is true, it is impossible to have a rational discussion with this person...so everyone should just ignore him from on:)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom