Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
It would seem mr. Hawking declined for health reasons, making whatever arguments in favour of his absence moot.

According to The Daily Beast, Hawking has confirmed he's not attending in order to honor the Boycott, not because of health reasons.

“I accepted the invitation to the Presidential Conference with the intention that this would not only allow me to express my opinion on the prospects for a Peace Settlement but also because it would allow me to lecture on the West Bank,” wrote Hawking. “However, I have received a number of emails from Palestinian academics. They are unanimous that I should respect the boycott. In view of this, I must withdraw from the conference. Had I attended, I would have stated my opinion that the policy of the present Israeli government is likely to lead to disaster.”
 
Having spent a few years as a resident of thezionistentity, I'm hoping the same intelligence, courage and resourcefulness I found among so many of its citizens will allow Israel to survive, as a Jewish state, the absence of boycotting celebrities. Time will tell.
 
Having spent a few years as a resident of thezionistentity, I'm hoping the same intelligence, courage and resourcefulness I found among so many of its citizens will allow Israel to survive, as a Jewish state, the absence of boycotting celebrities. Time will tell.

Israel can survive an academic boycott. They can even survive a tourist boycott.

But why would they want to?
 
Why is it so hard for you and others to simply admit & accept that BOTH sides have done some ********** up things? Why is this always a competition of who has done worse?

Because a good effort to solve any problem begins with an honest assessment of exactly what the problem is.
 
Because a good effort to solve any problem begins with an honest assessment of exactly what the problem is.

The discussion now is Hawking's boycott of Israel.

It is a valid decision to make and it will have an affect.
 
Who is more moral in your opinion, Hamas or Israel?
None of the two
Which speaks volumes about how much you've really studied the issue.

The discussion now is Hawking's boycott of Israel.

It is a valid decision to make and it will have an affect.
Do you have any kind of evidence of this? At least here in Norway, sales of Israeli goods go up most every time some fringe group or other decides they want to "boycott the apartheid state". I also have a strong feeling that activisim like this helps fuel animosity between Israel and the West and further entrenches radical groups such as the ultra-orthodox bloc. The negative efffects might outweight whatever positive gain you see.

So please, give me some sort of evidence that the boycott, apart from being the most hip and trendy way of attacking Israel these days, is a "valid decision" for those who want Israel to change its wicked ways. Whatever those might be -- simply not buying goods for someone isn't exactly sending them a clear message of exactly what it is you're angry with them for in the first place. It's more like teenage girls who suddenly stop talking to each others, with the victim often not having a clue why. Not exactly the kind of democratic dialogue we'd expect to take place between 2013 democracies.

Courier said:
The message is clear to Israel: what you are doing is wrong and we don't stand by it.
I'll give you a little hint here, and it won't even cost you: they already know people dislike them, so if that's your goal, "redundant" is too mild a word.

trustbutverify said:
According to The Daily Beast, Hawking has confirmed he's not attending in order to honor the Boycott, not because of health reasons.
Ah, okay.

Courier said:
Academic boycott of Israel is a good thing. But a more productive boycott would be one that sees tourists stay away. There are much lovelier & safer nations in the Mediteranean to visit than Israel.
Truly beautiful reasoning. I just love how you use terrorism against Israel as an argument to boycott her, and not, oh, the murderers who might her civilians and tourists feel unsafe in the first place. Did you boycott Oslo following the 22nd July bomb, too:confused:?
 
Last edited:
For every container of Israeli tahini that Hawking and friends don't buy, I am buying 2. :D
 
A large-scale boycott of Israel's academic institutions and academics would send a strong signal to Israel that their policies are unjust and an afront to any peace process.

A tourist boycott would hit Israel in the wallet, which is their most important asset. But that seems to be less likely.
 
Truly beautiful reasoning. I just love how you use terrorism against Israel as an argument to boycott her, and not, oh, the murderers who might her civilians and tourists feel unsafe in the first place. Did you boycott Oslo following the 22nd July bomb, too:confused:?

I said no such thing. If you can't honestly represent my views please don't respond to them.
 
Zelenius said:
For every container of Israeli tahini that Hawking and friends don't buy, I am buying 2. :biggrin:
Exactly.

A large-scale boycott of Israel's academic institutions and academics would send a strong signal to Israel that their policies are unjust and an afront to any peace process.

A tourist boycott would hit Israel in the wallet, which is their most important asset. But that seems to be less likely.
You already said that:confused:.

I said no such thing. If you can't honestly represent my views please don't respond to them.
You saidthat "a more productive boycott would be one that sees tourists stay away. There are much lovelier & safer nations in the Mediteranean to visit than Israel". Surely you see how this could be taken to mean that you think people should "stay away from" (boycott) Israel because it's unsafe? Since this is, after all, what you wrote?
 
Last edited:
Last year, the EU called upon Israel to meet its obligations which included halting forced transfer of population and demolition of Palestinian housing and infrastructure, simplifying procedures for building permits, ensuring access to water and addressing humanitarian needs.

But the AIDA report says there has been a 94 per cent rejection of Palestinian building requests and the demolition of 535 Palestinian structures, including emergency tents, houses, roads and water cisterns.

In contrast, the report says 1967 housing units for Jewish settlers have been included in new Israeli tendering processes and 613 new units built.

The report says in the last year there have been 150 Palestinians injured by violence from Jewish settlers, including 33 children.

The issue of settler violence was raised by President Barack Obama two months ago.

http://www.theaustralian.com.au/new...estinians-report/story-e6frg6so-1226650212608
 
In contrast, the report says 1967 housing units for Jewish settlers have been included in new Israeli tendering processes and 613 new units built.

The report says in the last year there have been 150 Palestinians injured by violence from Jewish settlers, including 33 children.

The issue of settler violence was raised by President Barack Obama two months ago.
So the Good Guys are on the case. Good. I don't think you'll find many people here supoprting extremist settlers in the first place, either.

...unlike when Palestinians attack and hurt Israeli civilians and are excused as "Just Defending their Country" by apologists and lauded as heroes by their governments which then gives them handouts for every Israeli citizen they kill (I wish I was making this up).
 
From reading this report, the extremist settlers have the official backing of the Israeli Government. The 'good guys' are not actually doing anything more than documenting a process.

If you can actually read the report, please link to it. The summary given in the news article you linked to doesn't say much.
 
From reading this report, the extremist settlers have the official backing of the Israeli Government. The 'good guys' are not actually doing anything more than documenting a process.

Retro-actively legalizing settlements that were built illegally doesn't say much for Israel's respect for the law.
 
Retro-actively legalizing settlements that were built illegally doesn't say much for Israel's respect for the law.

From the Israeli point of view, absent a peace agreement with agreed upon borders, it's disputed land. Their legal authority for settling there stems from the Mandate for Palestine from the League of Nations, which authorized Jewish settlement West of the Jordan River. Nothing since has revoked that.
 
From the Israeli point of view, absent a peace agreement with agreed upon borders, it's disputed land. Their legal authority for settling there stems from the Mandate for Palestine from the League of Nations, which authorized Jewish settlement West of the Jordan River. Nothing since has revoked that.

This is 2013 not 1926. The British Mandate has been over for 65 years. Israel accepted the borders of UN resolution 181 and those borders recognized by the UN when they accepted them as a member state.
 
This is 2013 not 1926. The British Mandate has been over for 65 years. Israel accepted the borders of UN resolution 181 and those borders recognized by the UN when they accepted them as a member state.

The selective recognition of law almost always favours the settlers, or even tolerates settlers who for years flout Israel's own laws.

"The International Court of Justice said that where the military wall encroaches on the Occupied Palestinian Territories it is illegal and should be removed. It said that those who suffered damages as a result of the wall are entitled to reparations. What is also clear under international law is that Israeli settlements are illegal and should be removed."

While the fence/wall was being constructed in the area, the Israeli army promised to allow the villagers free access to their land. Immediately after the fence/wall was constructed, permits were granted to most farmers. However, the army soon began refusing to renew the permits of a growing number of farmers, depriving them and their families of their livelihood.

Jayyus is an agricultural community of 3500 inhabitants, all of whom rely directly or indirectly on farming for their livelihoods. According to the estimates of the municipality of Jayyus, less than half of Jayyus farmers now have permits to access their land.

The settlement of Tsufim lies to the west, one of more than 130 settlements housing over half a million Israelis in the Occupied Palestinian Territories, which cause the violation of a range of Palestinian human rights including the rights to be free from discrimination and to an adequate standard of living.

http://www.amnesty.org/en/news/west-bank-wall-and-settlements-affront-palestinian-rights-2013-03-21

Ottoman rule

There is a law dating from the Ottoman empire in 1853, says Hilo, which states that any land left uncultivated for three years reverts to state ownership. "This law was introduced to boost tax revenues - because the Ottomans wanted food producers to produce," Hilo told Al Jazeera.

"But Israel applies the same law and blames the Ottomans in order to confiscate land within the occupied West Bank - except that the land becomes 'property' of the state of Israel, not the Ottoman empire.

"Our campaign is to help Palestinian farmers maintain ownership of their property - and once olive trees are planted, it is evidence that the land is being cultivated."

http://www.aljazeera.com/indepth/features/2011/08/2011823152713716742.html
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom