WTC Dust Study Feb 29, 2012 by Dr. James Millette

it might depend on the sample.:eek:
No, it can't possibly depend on the sample at all. In the Bentham paper which you claim to support; 4 samples were taken from 4 different locations in NY. From those 4 samples 4 identical chips labelled a, b, c and d were identified.

So if you agree that chips a-d are the same material, then you can't claim that the sample from which they were taken makes a difference. Therefore you can't claim that further chips isolated from other samples can be influenced by the sample because to do so goes directly against your agreement that chips a-d are the same material from 4 different samples.

This is another reason why truthers such as MM refuse to support Harrit et al. MM disagrees with Jones/Farrer/Harrit and all the other authors of the paper plus the likes of Basile. He purposely ignores the simple question because he can see what a pickle it would put him in, a pickle that you are in yourself.

And don't reply with any of that iron silicon microsphere or DSC nonsense, it's completely irrelevant.
 
you will have to ask them but if they did not do a dsc on the d/b sample, they sure should of.

The problem is you're reading the paper you wished they'd published instead of the one they did.
 
"Please answer the question that I asked:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
"
"it might depend on the sample.:eek:"
"In the 2009 Bentham paper which you claim to support; 4 samples were taken from 4 different locations in NY. From those 4 samples 4 identical chips labelled a, b, c and d were identified."

Similar chips which shared a common outcome when ignited.

As you well know, no two chips can be 'identical'. They are not similar in every detail and are not exactly alike.

"So if you agree that chips a-d are the same material, then you can't claim that the sample from which they were taken makes a difference."

If you deliberately make your questions unclear than so will be the responses.

The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common.

Oystein's question broadens the scope to include every red/gray chip magnetically drawn from the 9/11 WTC dust that was visually similar.

Steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material would not qualify as a 'chips of interest' in the 2009 Bentham paper but they could easily pass the initial isolation process.

Given the enormity of the 9/11 WTC devastation, it is absurd to suggest that every magnetically attracted red/gray chip produced in the dust would be of the same material.

"This is another reason why truthers such as MM refuse to support Harrit et al. MM disagrees with Jones/Farrer/Harrit and all the other authors of the paper plus the likes of Basile. He purposely ignores the simple question because he can see what a pickle it would put him in, a pickle that you are in yourself."

I fully support Dr. Harrit et al.

You can repeat your lies as often as want but it will not make them true.

My repeated responses to the question are simply ignored because you do not like what you hear.

"And don't reply with any of that iron silicon microsphere or DSC nonsense, it's completely irrelevant."

That of course is the discussion that you and Oystein are desperately trying to avoid.

A discussion of how the a-d red/gray chips behaved when heated to ~430 ̊C confirms the existence of a substance that Dr. Millette claims did not exist in the red/gray chip material.

Dr. Millette focussed on how his red/gray chip selections 'looked' while totally ignoring an easy test that would have shown how they actually 'behaved'.

You cannot dismiss the results of the 2009 Bentham paper a-d red/gray chip testing by arguing that Dr. Millette's red/gray chip selections were identical unless you can show that not only do they look similar, but they also produce similar behaviour.

How does Dr. Millette account for the red/gray chip behavioural findings of Dr. Harrit et al?

Published findings by several scientists that clearly dispute those in the unpublished paper by Dr. Millette..

For Dr. Millette to be correct, Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and Mark Basile, to name a few, must all be liars.

MM
 
The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common.

MM

This is a lie.

MM: Care to show where in the paper this is done?

Why do you support the paper when you disagree with it's contents? :confused:
 
The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common.

False.

Chips a-d in Fig. (2) were taken from each of the four samples noted below.

Benthem paper said:
For clarification, the dust samples collected and sent to the authors by Ms. Janette MacKinlay will be sample 1; the sample collected by Mr. Frank Delassio, or the Delassio/Breidenbach sample, will be sample 2; the sample collected by Mr. Jody Intermont will be sample 3; and the sample collected by Mr. Stephen White will be sample 4.

Fig. (19) shows ignition/DSC traces for the MacKinlay, Intermont, and White sample. NOTHING for the Delassio/Breidenbach sample.

So you are incorrect in stating that all four chips from each of the four samples shared similar results for the ignition tests as the D/B sample was not tested according to their own paper.
 
I fully support Dr. Harrit et al.

You can repeat your lies as often as want but it will not make them true.

My repeated responses to the question are simply ignored because you do not like what you hear.
No you don't support Harrit et al because you will not acknowledge the fact that they as does everyone else accept that the chips labelled a-d contain the same material, you refuse to answer the simple question even though you say the chips a-d were shown to be similar.

Are they the same material or not? What is your basis for your answer?

The only person dodging such simple questions is you. Oystein has even shown that the likelihood is that you didn't understand the labelling of the chips in the paper.

You carp on about DSC, but show us where on this Fig is the chip from the Delessio/Breidenbach (Brooklyn Bridge)
HarritChart.jpg



Reminder:

Fig. (1). Map showing collection locations of dust samples analyzed in this study with respect to the location of the WTC complex (marked area near location 1). 1: MacKinlay (113 Cedar St./110 Liberty St); 2: Delessio/Breidenbach (Brooklyn Bridge); 3: Intermont (16 Hudson
St); 4: White (1 Hudson St).

It's not there is it. So once again you are talking out your rear and making things up when you state:

Similar chips which shared a common outcome when ignited.

[snip]

The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common.


The simple fact of the matter is you do not understand the paper and you are not familiar at all with regard to what was and was not performed on what material.


You could have done a degree in the last 4 years that would help you understand this, but instead you remain ignorant and worse, make things up.

DSC is pointless. Resistivity test is pointless. MEK soaking is pointless. None of them tell you anything about the samples whatsoever. FTIR tells you exactly what you need to know as does proper SEM work. TEM-SAED tells you exactly what you need to know. XRD or microprobe tells you exactly everything you need to know.

The exercise isn't what happens to the chips when we apply a random test, it's what does this material consist of?

Harrit et al

No idea what the gray layer, carbon based matrix or hexagonal platelets are. Just identifies the whitish Fe2O3 particles. 1 out of 4.

Sunstealer.

Shows exactly what the gray layer, hexagonal and whitish particles are. Gets the carbon based matrix right but can't show it. 4/4.

Millette

Shows exactly what the gray layer, hexagonal and whitish particles and carbon based matrix are. 4/4.

MM.

No idea about any of it including taking 4 years to understand the labelling of chips a-d.

You are behind the curve by 4 years mate. Care to go back and answer Oystein's and my questions or are you going to ignore the argument in favour of making up your own nonsense such as resistivity testing to isolate chips? lol.
 
Last edited:
False.

Chips a-d in Fig. (2) were taken from each of the four samples noted below.



Fig. (19) shows ignition/DSC traces for the MacKinlay, Intermont, and White sample. NOTHING for the Delassio/Breidenbach sample.

So you are incorrect in stating that all four chips from each of the four samples shared similar results for the ignition tests as the D/B sample was not tested according to their own paper.
Odd thing is he already admitted to knowing this.

I stand corrected.

Only the results from 4 chips sampled from 3 of the 4 locations were shown in this DSC output.

MM

:confused:
 
MM,

Are you going to address your contradiction regarding...

The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common

...and...

I stand corrected.

Only the results from 4 chips sampled from 3 of the 4 locations were shown in this DSC output.

MM

...?
 
Last edited:
Oystein said:
I asked:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
Similar chips which shared a common outcome when ignited.
Chips a-d were not ignited.
Why do you lie?

You say they are "similar" - by what objective criteria (list them all, and be specific: What values?) are they - chips a-d! "similar"? You must not mention any criteria that have to do with heating, as chips a.d were not heated.

Are they (chips a-d!) "similar" to the four different chips in the DSC test (Fig 19)? If you say, "yes" (only "yes", "no" and "I don't know" are acceptable answers!), then by what objective criteria (list them all, and be specific: What values?) are they? You must not mention any criteria that have to do with heating, as chips a.d were not heated.

As you well know, no two chips can be 'identical'. They are not similar in every detail and are not exactly alike.
True, but they can be from the same material (examples for materials: "LaClede shop primer on A36 steel"; "Tnemec Red 99 primer on A242 steel"; "the nanothermite described by Gash et al in [citation] on page [x]").

If you deliberately make your questions unclear than so will be the responses.
My question is crystal clear:
Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?

It can be answered either with a "yes." Period. Or with a "no." Period. Or with a "I don't know".

The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common.
I am disgusted that you serve this blatant and obviousl LIE!

Chips a-d were NOT found to share ignition and residue results that were in common. They were not ignited. There are no residues to look at. The data that you speak of does not exist in this world.

And you know this damned well.

You are thus clearly a liar. Please do not lie! It disgusts me!

Please list all the criteria that are in fact available from the work of Harrit et al that you can use to actually determine that chips a-d are the same material, or not!
You must NOT mention any "ignition" or "residue" here, or be prepared to be found a liar once more - Harrit et al present ZERO ignition tests, and ZERO residues, for chips a-d. Please acknowledge this fact verbosely, so I can quote you in the future, should you then try again to serve that lie!

Oystein's question broadens the scope to include every red/gray chip magnetically drawn from the 9/11 WTC dust that was visually similar.
Correct. That is the scope that Harrit et al define in their section "2. Chip Size, Isolation, and Examination", as you extremely well know - we have quoted from this section many many times:
"The
red/gray chips are attracted by a magnet ...
"​
They describe no other method to further separate chips. As you perfectly well know:
  • Harrit wrote in a recent email that resistivity testing was done only on some, randomly selected, chips
  • The paper itself states that "Some samples were also tested in a differential scanning calorimeter" - not all!
So neither resistivity testing nor DSC scanning were used to select and separate chips - only magnetic attraction and visual appearance as "red-gray chips" were used. Period.


Steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material would not qualify as a 'chips of interest' in the 2009 Bentham paper
Show me in the 2009 Bentham paper where it is said or implied that "steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material would not qualify as a 'chips of interest'"!

Or retract that moronic (or dishonest) statement!

but they could easily pass the initial isolation process.
Yup, for sure. :)

So, having said that, isn't it clear what YOUR answer to my question is? Remember my question? Here it is:

Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
YOU, MM say:
Steel primer paint dust chips adhering to any gray material ... could easily pass the initial isolation process [of magnetic attraction plus visual selection of red-gray chips]
So your answer is: YES, there is a possibility that this method yields two or more different materials!

What took you so long?

Given the enormity of the 9/11 WTC devastation, it is absurd to suggest that every magnetically attracted red/gray chip produced in the dust would be of the same material.
Great! Let's repeat this:

Question Oystein: Are all red-gray chips that you pull from WTC dust with a magnet the same material, or is there a possibility that this method (magnetic attraction plus visual identification as "red-gray chips") yields two or more different materials?
Answer Miragememories: "Given the enormity of the 9/11 WTC devastation, it is absurd to suggest that every magnetically attracted red/gray chip produced in the dust would be of the same material. So YES, there is a possibility that this method yields two or more different materials!"

Thank you thank you! What took you so long to answer a simple question, when the answer is so obvious? What were you afraid of?



Now, having made this clear, and being in agreement with me on that question (and in disagreement with Harrit!), there is a corollary to your, MM's, answer:

We can't be certain, a-priori, that chips a-d are all the same material, when all we knew were that they were pulled from WTC dust with a magnet, and are red-gray. Because any two such chips could be different materials.

Agreed, MM? Of course you agree.


So we would have to analyse the chips a litte further to determine if they are the same material, right? So let's see, what analysis was done, what data do we have?
  • We have PLM micographs, showing color, luster, surface structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have SE-images, showing shape and microstructure of all of chips a-d
  • We have high-magnification BSE images to show the sub-micron structure of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the gray sides of all of chips a-d
  • We have XEDS spectra of the red sides of all of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have DSC results for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have any sort of ignition residues for any of chips a-d
  • We do NOT have resistivity measurements for any of chips a-d
So having clued you in on all the data and analysis we do have, and some that we don't, here is my next question to you:

Are chips a-d the same material?
I must insist that you answer this briefly. There are exactly three possible answers to this, and your answer must be one of those three, it can't be anything else:
  1. Yes.
  2. No.
  3. I, MM, don't know.
Notice the full stops at the end of each answer. No qualifications. In your opinion, chips a-d are the same material. Period. Or they are not the same material. Period. Or, if you can't decide on either yes or no, then evidently, you don't know if they are the same material or not. Period. There is no third possibility.


When you have decided on yes. or no., please follow up with this:

Give reasons - by what objective criteria (be specific!) did you determine that chips a-d are (or are not) all the same material?

Note the word "objective". By this I mean criteria that stem from scientific analysis that was actually done on chips a as well as chip b as well as chip c as well as chip d. Don't you dare introducing any criteria that are not objective - that can be verified by the data already published!
Note the word "specific": Name the criterion, explain how it is evalued, cite the values!
Note that this question is about chips a-d. This means: Whatever you answer has to pertain to all four chips. a and b and c and d. Don#t mention any other chip, as this question is not about any other chip.
No more wiggle room for you, MM. Just tell us exactly how you know, from scientific analysis, that chips a-d are (or aren't) the same material.
 
How does Harrit account for not performing a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach sample?

Careful:

make sure you don't mix up "Sample" and "specimen".

When Harrit et al talk about a "dust sample", they mean a collection. some grams perhaps, of mixed dust, contain millions of particles from thousands of vastly different materials, such as paints, poop, fibers, glasses, etc etc etc.

So, a term like "performing a DSC test on the Delassio/Breidenbach sample" is nonsense: The sample is a collection of all sorts of stuff, only 0.1% or less being red-gray chips.
Same goes for MM when he talks about DSC tests on the same samples.

What matters is that you know which specimens you test. Individual red-gray chips. Whether you put two from the same sample, or two from two different samples, in the DSC doesn't matter at all. They could be different materials despite being from the same sample, or they could be the same material despite being from two different samples.



What matters is that the set of four specimens (indivifual magnetic red-gray chips) comprised of {chip a|chip b|chip c|chip d} is DIFFERENT from the other set of four specimens (indivifual magnetic red-gray chips) comprised of {blue|red|black|green} that was tested in the DSC.

Two DIFFERENT can be disjoint, or they can have elements in common. We know for a damned fact that chip b is not in the DSC set. We know that one of the four specimens in the DSC is not in the chips a-d set. We don't know if perhaps chips a, c or d are also in the DSC-test - but that seems quite unlikely, and we can't assume it. We have to treat them as disjoint set, unless information surfaces that the sets have 1, 2 or 3 elements in common. (then we would still not know whether, for example, chip d is identical with the chip blue, red, black or green).


Again: The point is that we do not know that any of chips a- were at all tested in the DSC, and must assume that they were not.
 
Odd thing is he already admitted to knowing this.

:confused:
Truthers have the memories of goldfish. Just look at the number of times they have been corrected, yet time after time spout the same stuff that they were pulled up on 3 months ago. It shows a distinct inability to learn and retain facts. One of the reasons in this case is they must defend the Harrit et al paper at all cost even though to do so leads them into contradictions.
 
Truthers have the memories of goldfish. Just look at the number of times they have been corrected, yet time after time spout the same stuff that they were pulled up on 3 months ago. It shows a distinct inability to learn and retain facts. One of the reasons in this case is they must defend the Harrit et al paper at all cost even though to do so leads them into contradictions.
Worse, In order to defend it they must also disagree with it along with all it's data. (and it's authors).

Makes you wonder what they are actually defending.

;)
 
Last edited:
Truthers have the memories of goldfish. Just look at the number of times they have been corrected, yet time after time spout the same stuff that they were pulled up on 3 months ago. It shows a distinct inability to learn and retain facts. One of the reasons in this case is they must defend the Harrit et al paper at all cost even though to do so leads them into contradictions.

Worse, In order to defend it they must also disagree with it along with all it's data. (and it's authors).

Makes you wonder what they are actually defending.

They're defending a pre-conceived belief, and that's all that really matters.

Might as well argue with DOC over in the Biblical Flood thread.
 
"If you deliberately make your questions unclear than so will be the responses.

The sample chips a-d identified in the 2009 Bentham paper were shown to be similar and were found to share ignition and residue results that were in common."
"This is a lie.

MM: Care to show where in the paper this is done?

Why do you support the paper when you disagree with it's contents? :confused:
"

All this because Fig. 19 only showed 4 DSC curves?

This may be news to you, but most of the data collected does not get published.

My understanding is that most research scientists out of necessity keep very good records.

" Fig. (19) shows ignition/DSC traces for the MacKinlay, Intermont, and White sample. NOTHING for the Delassio/Breidenbach sample.

So you are incorrect in stating that all four chips from each of the four samples shared similar results for the ignition tests as the D/B sample was not tested according to their own paper.
"

See above.

Apparently you think scientists have to "show" and report, every set of curves for every test they run, as well as additionally explain every test they do not run.

2009 Bentham paper said:
"Analysis shows that iron and oxygen are present in a ratio consistent with Fe2O3. The red material in all four WTC dust samples was similar in this way. Iron oxide was found in the pre-ignition material whereas elemental iron was not."

Each of the a-d red/gray chips would not be characterized as a "pre-ignition" material unless they were ignited.

2009 Bentham paper said:
"As measured using DSC, the material ignites and reacts vigorously at a temperature of approximately 430 ̊C, with a rather narrow exotherm"

" DSC is pointless. Resistivity test is pointless. MEK soaking is pointless. None of them tell you anything about the samples whatsoever. FTIR tells you exactly what you need to know as does proper SEM work. TEM-SAED tells you exactly what you need to know. XRD or microprobe tells you exactly everything you need to know."

Finally you get to the point of all this a-d matching nonsense.

The DSC output shown in Fig. 19 clearly reveals that red/gray chips from the 9/11 WTC dust from 3 different NYC locations all ignited in the range 415-435 ̊C.

The DSC provided a means of measured chip ignition and and post-ignition debris collection.

The Resistivity test provided a quick and easy small/large electrical resistance test for eliminating red/gray paint chips.

That is why that test result was included in the published report and again referred to in that paper's conclusions

2009 Bentham paper said:
"We have discovered distinctive red/gray chips in significant numbers in dust associated with the World Trade Center destruction.

We have applied SEM/XEDS and other methods to characterize the small-scale structure and chemical signature of these chips, especially of their red component."

And it goes on to list a number findings about their red/gray 'chips of interest'.

But since Dr. Millette had no intention of replicating the 2009 Bentham paper findings, he probably stopped reading when the subject of heat came up.

But what you want is to 'slam the door shut' on what Dr. Harrit et al observed when they went where Dr. Millette feared to go.

"FTIR tells you exactly what you need to know as does proper SEM work."

Well it would appear that the combined SEM work on the 9/11 WTC dust red/gray chips by Dr. Harrit, Dr. Jones, Dr. Farrer and chemical engineer Mark Basile must far outweigh that performed Dr. Millette.

For only $1,000 he is not interested in looking further.

It is my understanding from Dr. Jones that someone among the original group of scientists has FTIR data but it won't be made public until there is a published response to the original 2009 Bentham paper.

Meanwhile everyone here continues to ignore the elephant in the room.

Those chips permeating all the 9/11 WTC dust do ignite exothermically in the range 415-435 ̊C and the residue produced provides conclusive proof of thermitic activity.

Even at this small amount; because it can be concluded that this material exists throughout all the 9/11 WTC dust, when you add in all the iron-rich spheroids that were already common to the dust, it can be concluded that there must have originally been a huge amount of this material.

A material so dangerous and in such a high quantity that it cannot be dismissed, especially after what occurred at the WTC on 9/11.

MM
 
Last edited:
All this because Fig. 19 only showed 4 DSC curves?

This may be news to you, but most of the data collected does not get published.
...MM
BINGO, If Jones published all the data it would be clear the dust was not thermite. It is not news that fraud papers hide the bulk of the data collected. They would ruin fooling the fringe few.

4 DSC curves that don't match thermite; hilarious. Notice MM can't ask Jones why the curves don't match, the cult leader can't be questioned. Thanks for the birthday comedy.


Millette' study is truth, Jones study is BS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom