Merged General Israel/Palestine discussion thread - Part 2

Status
Not open for further replies.
Yes, it takes a different approach.

There won't be any Palestinian state anytime soon. The reality is a one state solution, and the one state, equals Israel.

that is ok with me as long as the Zionists let the jews and arabs have equal rights. no peoples better than another. no rigths special for jews and not arabs. no special laws for jews and not arabs./
 
that is ok with me as long as the Zionists let the jews and arabs have equal rights. no peoples better than another. no rigths special for jews and not arabs. no special laws for jews and not arabs./
Does the same apply in the PA, or do they get to discriminate against Jews? Should someone get the death penalty for selling land to a Jew?
 
Hercules, have you studied all the ways the Israelis treat the Arabs as their equals, and how the Arabs treat the Jews?
 
Whenever the "Support Palestine" crowd comes a-knocking, I love to point out how the Palestinians' own leaders, not to mention the other Arabs, treat the Palestinians worse than Israel ever would.

But no, "support Palestine" only ever seems to extend to "support Palestine, as long as you can use it as an excuse to dislike da Joos".
 
Hercules, have you studied all the ways the Israelis treat the Arabs as their equals, and how the Arabs treat the Jews?

It is very funny that you think the Zionists treat Palestinians as equals especially since they have many laws that favor israeli jews over arabs, exiles hundrreds of thousands of arabs during and after the Arab-Israel war, destroyed thousands of mosques in "Israel", steal land in Palestine even today and even say that their own settlements in west bank are illegal(arab palestine according to the USA State Departmwnt) and violate the equal treatment and respect clauses of the Palestina Mandate and Balfour declaration!
 
"New Israel settlement homes anger Palestinians"

"Palestinians have reacted angrily to Israel's approval of nearly 1,200 new Jewish settlement homes, just days before peace talks are set to resume."

An Israeli attempt to sabotage the peace talks?

A "Sop to the right wingers in Israel" which may actually increase the chances that any agreement reached will get approval?

Opinions?

My only opinion is that it will probably not enhance the chances of successful peace talks.

New settlement homes ended the last peace talks. But there may have been more behind the stoppage?
 
Maybe if you found a less biased news article (as in, one that isn't 99% condemnation from all kinds of sources and 1% justifications from Israeli spokespeople) we migh actually learn something.
 
It is very funny that you think the Zionists treat Palestinians as equals
Again, what is a "Zionist":rolleyes:? Can you define this term in your own words? How many "Zionists" exist in Israel? Are they representative for the Israeli population as a whole?

especially since they have many laws that favor israeli jews over arabs
Yes, they do. Some of these can be justified in a number of ways, others perhaps not. You'll notice, however, that I asked you if you knew of all the ways the Israelis treat Arabs as equals, and how the Arabs in return treat Israelis. I take your non-answer for a no.

exiles hundrreds of thousands of arabs during and after the Arab-Israel war
Translation to English: they were invaded by a malevolent force hell-bent on wiping their country from the earth and killing them, and during the war hundreds of thousands of people, both Arabs and 800 000 Jews, were forced to flee, most of them never to return home.
Do the displaced Israelis mean anything to you? You know, the ones who were on the defending side of the war?

Also, I like how you have to dig all the way back to the fourties to find ammo for your Israel slamming. Do you judge the tolerance of all people on earth based on what their grandparent generation did, or is it only the Jews that get this treatment from you?

destroyed thousands of mosques in "Israel"
Again, who did this, and are they representative for Israel and Israelis as a whole?

steal land in Palestine even today
To call what is happening "stealing of land" is a rather biased and almost ignorant way of putting things. Read up on the relevant laws and UN conventions, please.

and even say that their own settlements in west bank are illegal
The West Bank I am familiar with was offered up to the Arabs in the Arab Peace Initiative. Is there more than one:confused:?
" (c) Accept the establishment of an independent and sovereign Palestinian state on the Palestinian territories occupied since 4 June 1967 in the West Bank and Gaza Strip with East Jerusalem as its capital. In return the Arab states will do the following: (a) Consider the Arab–Israeli conflict over, sign a peace agreement with Israel, and achieve peace for all states in the region; (b) Establish normal relations with Israel within the framework of this comprehensive peace.[2]"​

and violate the equal treatment and respect clauses of the Palestina Mandate and Balfour declaration!
To some of us, equal treatment and respect is something that should come naturally, so I'm not sure why you feel the need to cite legal documents here.
 
Last edited:
Maybe if you found a less biased news article (as in, one that isn't 99% condemnation from all kinds of sources and 1% justifications from Israeli spokespeople) we migh actually learn something.

Was that a reply to my post?

If so, it seems we learned that Israel is adding 1200 new settlement homes. That seems pretty clear. Wasn't really looking for opinions on the article though. But thanks just the same.

Do you have an opinion on the fact that Israel has announced the additional homes this close to the peace talks?

If that wasn't a reply to my post, then....never mind :)
 
It was more of an (admittedly possibly unneccessarily hostile, sorry about that) comment to the article itself more than your post.
 
Was that a reply to my post?

If so, it seems we learned that Israel is adding 1200 new settlement homes. That seems pretty clear. Wasn't really looking for opinions on the article though. But thanks just the same.

Do you have an opinion on the fact that Israel has announced the additional homes this close to the peace talks?

If that wasn't a reply to my post, then....never mind :)

not only are the Zionists building more homes for setlers in jerusalem but they are also buikding more homes in the West bank wich they said they would not do!!!!
 
Again, what is a "Zionist":rolleyes:? Can you define this term in your own words? How many "Zionists" exist in Israel? Are they representative for the Israeli population as a whole?

Yes, they do. Some of these can be justified in a number of ways, others perhaps not. You'll notice, however, that I asked you if you knew of all the ways the Israelis treat Arabs as equals, and how the Arabs in return treat Israelis. I take your non-answer for a no.

Translation to English: they were invaded by a malevolent force hell-bent on wiping their country from the earth and killing them, and during the war hundreds of thousands of people, both Arabs and 800 000 Jews, were forced to flee, most of them never to return home.
Do the displaced Israelis mean anything to you? You know, the ones who were on the defending side of the war?

Also, I like how you have to dig all the way back to the fourties to find ammo for your Israel slamming. Do you judge the tolerance of all people on earth based on what their grandparent generation did, or is it only the Jews that get this treatment from you?

Again, who did this, and are they representative for Israel and Israelis as a whole?

To call what is happening "stealing of land" is a rather biased and almost ignorant way of putting things. Read up on the relevant laws and UN conventions, please.

The West Bank I am familiar with was offered up to the Arabs in the Arab Peace Initiative. Is there more than one:confused:?
" (c) Accept the establishment of an independent and sovereign Palestinian state on the Palestinian territories occupied since 4 June 1967 in the West Bank and Gaza Strip with East Jerusalem as its capital. In return the Arab states will do the following: (a) Consider the Arab–Israeli conflict over, sign a peace agreement with Israel, and achieve peace for all states in the region; (b) Establish normal relations with Israel within the framework of this comprehensive peace.[
To some of us, equal treatment and respect is something that should come naturally, so I'm not sure why you feel the need to cite legal documents here.
​


all Jews who live in Israel are zioinists except for some of the crazy black hat guys.

and even the Israeli government has called many of the settlements "theft". When the zionists themselbves cal it stealing you know its stealing.
​
 
It was more of an (admittedly possibly unneccessarily hostile, sorry about that) comment to the article itself more than your post.

No problem! I may not know much, but I know anything Israel related tends to bring out emotions from both sides.

I tried to make my post as neutral as possible, because I'm not informed enough about the whole mess over there to have strong opinions one way or the other. I think both sides are living with crap no one should have to live with, and just hope someday things will be settled peaceably. I have doubts that it will be in time for me to see it though, I'm probably only good for another 20 years at best (any second now at worse;)).

But your post did get me to look for another source. This may be more to your liking - Israpundit

ETA - I think this is a Pro-Israel site, but the more I read the article, the more I wonder. If I picked a bad source, it was not intentional.
 
Last edited:
"New Israel settlement homes anger Palestinians"

"Palestinians have reacted angrily to Israel's approval of nearly 1,200 new Jewish settlement homes, just days before peace talks are set to resume."

An Israeli attempt to sabotage the peace talks?

A "Sop to the right wingers in Israel" which may actually increase the chances that any agreement reached will get approval?

Opinions?

My only opinion is that it will probably not enhance the chances of successful peace talks.

New settlement homes ended the last peace talks. But there may have been more behind the stoppage?

There is a lot of context missing in articles like this, but I'll respond as best as I can.

I don't think it is an Israeli attempt to sabotage the peace talks. If that's what Israel wanted, then they just need to have never authorized the release of Palestinian prisoners. It's the Palestinians who were not coming to the table, and who still may not come. Rather, this is development that was happening before anyone proposed these latest talks, and will continue after, unless pressure mounts and gets Israel to interrupt it.

The neighborhoods mentioned in the article, Har Homa, Gilo, and Pisgat Zeev, are all suburbs of Jerusalem. Adding additional homes to these suburbs doesn't take land away from Palestinians, it's developers building on land they already own.

Agree with it or not, Israel plans to keep Jerusalem. It is a Holy City to the Jewish people, and when Israel captured it back in 1967 it was a big deal to them. A very big deal, it's not possible to overstate that.

Israel plans to keep Jerusalem undivided, which is often seen as an obstacle to peace. Palestinian proponents say Palestinians need East Jerusalem as the capital of their country, when they get a country. Their critics point out that Ramallah is the natural capital of a Palestinian nation, and believe that Palestinians demanding East Jerusalem is a purposeful ploy to sabotage negotiations before they even start while maintaining plausible deniability in shifting the blame to the Israelis in being unwilling to compromise.

Har Homa, Gilo, and Pisgat Zeev all frame East Jerusalem, all demographically strengthen Israeli claims to East Jerusalem by putting a predominantly Jewish population there.

After the '67 war, the formula has always been to exchange land for peace. This formula was outlined in the United Nations Security Council Resolution #234, calling for an end to hostilities in the '67 war.

Since then, Israel made peace with Egypt, their neighbor to the south/west and in doing so gave up the captured Sinai Peninsula, which is a huge swath of land compared to the overall size of Israel. In that agreement, Egypt did not reclaim the Gaza Strip because that wasn't initially Egyptian land, but land which they had captured previously in the Israeli war of Independence.

In a similar fashion, Israel made peace with Jordan, Israel's neighbor to the East, agreeing to Jordanian sovereignty East of the Jordan River, with Jordan releasing claim to the West Bank, land that it had captured at the same time Egypt captured Gaza. It's important to note that Jordan didn't cede the West Bank to Israel, but rather left it's status undetermined pending Israeli negotiations with the Palestinians.

The Israeli position has always been that UNSCR 234 calls for Israel to trade land for peace, and doesn't put Israel under any obligation to give up land if they don't have a peace agreement to go along with it. In addition, which lands (East of the Green line) become Israel and which become part of the new state of Palestine are up for negotiation. For this reason, Israel considers the West Bank and the Gaza Strip to be disputed territory, and in the absence of a final peace agreement they should have the same rights to settle the land as they did under the British Mandate for Palestine. In practice, the period of building new towns on any piece of open land they could find or buy ended long ago, and now it's confined to building new apartment buildings or housing complexes on lands such as the ones mentioned in the article that are assumed to become part of Israel in the event of a final peace agreement.

The Palestinian position, as outlined in the original PLO charter, sees all of "Palestine", defined as the whole of the British Mandate territory, including all of Israel plus the West Bank and the Gaza Strip, as an "integral regional unit", which means that they don't recognize Israel at all, or with a reasonable interpretation, that their starting position for negotiations is with Israel having zero land and "Palestine" covering the who territory.

I hope some of this is helpful to you. Overall, it's very complex and this barely scratches the surface, so if you have any questions feel free to ask.
 
Thanks Myroft!

I'm on the way out to work ATM. I'll re-read this when I have more time to actually digest it.
 
The zionists fear peace more than war becaue they dont want to give up their precioius holy land given them by "God".
 
Then why is it Israel always seems to make the largest concessions only to have the Palestinians violate any agreements?
 
The zionists fear peace more than war becaue they dont want to give up their precioius holy land given them by "God".

They gave up Gaza and handed over millions of dollars of economically productive infrastructure and assets.

The Palestinians trashed it and started shooting rockets because they're a bunch of self-destructive idiots.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom