jhunter1163
beer-swilling semiliterate
jhunter1163, Sheep Marketplace was a secret site set up for drug dealers.
Here's a little light reading for you, meg. Perhaps these were all drug dealers?
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0
jhunter1163, Sheep Marketplace was a secret site set up for drug dealers.
It is not possible to make a strawman out of a post that is sheer fantasy.
Here's a little light reading for you, meg. Perhaps these were all drug dealers?
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0
Excellent post meg.
First off, I suggest you moderate your tone.
I Nominated meg's post.
I came to this thread to learn about Bitcoins. I was biased (negatively) and skeptical. After following the thread and researching more, my position has changed to "skeptical, but intrigued". Thanks to this forum, I feel a little less ignorant and a bit more enlightened about the bitcoin phenomenon.
As I've said in several previous posts, I think that the fundamental idea behind Bitcoin (creating a virtual, secure store of value) is a good one. Several of the major banks agree and are looking into duplicating the technology; I think we will see one (or more) of the biggies roll something similar out quite soon.
Bitcoin as currently constructed, though, is nothing more than a speculative tool. Its volatility renders it useless as currency. If it settled at some stable price and stayed there for some period of time, people might begin to feel differently; but as long as there are these 20 or 30 percent swings in value in a single day, potential business users will stay far, far away. Even Overstock wants nothing to do with that risk; they are letting Coinbase deal with the value fluctuations and taking those stodgy old dollars as payment.
And it isn't just Mt. Gox that is having problems redeeming BTC; there was a nice post above showing the difficulty one user had in converting his Bitcoins into something besides dodgy gift cards.
While that might serve some of the needs that bitcoin can fulfill, one of the major drawbacks of one of the “biggies” rolling out their own version is that the “biggie” will then own it, can manipulate it at their will, and will undoubtedly charge whatever fees they see fit to the users. It will lose the very feature that I think many find attractive. It will just be one more product in their payment processing line.
Bitcoin has opened up secure internet commerce to everyone. Anyone can now securely transact a sale without having to go through an intermediary. Perhaps JP Morgan/Chase or whoever can create a product that can compete with bitcoin. But if their idea is “Hey, we'll just create our own virtual coin, and people will use it just because we're big, and we can still charge whatever we want because people will have to go through us!” then they are doomed to fail. They do not understand what they're competing with.
You keep saying it's “nothing more than a speculative tool”, but that doesn't make it true. Hedging and derivatives are speculative tools. Bitcoin is a product/service that allows anyone to securely transact business. Overstock is using the bitcoin product in order to transact business at a lower cost then credit card payments. They are using Coinbase to mitigate risk now posed because of the price volatility. I have no doubt that the price will stabilize over time. Penny stock prices are volatile, too. But every company with a penny stock is not doomed to be forever volatile. Companies grow and their stock price becomes more stable as the value of the company rises above the power of speculators and traders to manipulate the market. Bitcoin too will grow and become more stable as more people use it to conduct business than those who speculate on and attempt to manipulate its price movements.
Bitcoin is in a growth phase. No one has ever said that bitcoin is an out of the box currency solution that guarantees everyone immediate liquidity at all time. This is a new technology, and like all new technologies, there are growing pains. Personally, I think if a potential investor is that concerned about price stability and immediate liquidity, they should stick to fortune 100 stocks and mutual funds and leave investing in new technology to someone else that understands the risks.
meg's post was good, but it does fail to address one of my concerns about bitcoin--the possibility that it was engineered in such a way (either intentionally or effectively) that the earliest bit coin owners have a built in corner on the market.
BTC exchanges and services like Coinbase are not free; they charge commissions comparable to what the major banks charge for debit- and credit-card transactions (2-3%).
Bitcoin, [Byrne] says, can directly reduce the costs incurred by retailers like Overstock. Because the bitcoin system is driven by open source software running across thousands of machines around the globe and doesn’t answer to any one central authority, it’s a much less expensive way to accept payments than the major credit-card processors or PayPal. Yes, Overstock pays a fee to Coinbase, but Byrne says this is far less than what the company is paying to other processors. What’s more, bitcoin lets Overstock more easily and inexpensively accept payments from overseas, because bitcoin is available everywhere.
The "biggies" won't create a virtual currency; they'll create a secure, anonymous wallet (along the lines of a BTC wallet) which will (and this is key) be denominated in USD. No need for exchanges, no worries about volatility, no worries about acceptance. You just transfer dollars from your wallet to the seller's wallet. Kind of like what Swiss banks used to do before they changed the laws.
You keep playing up the "currency" angle, but the fact of the matter is that the vast majority of BTC usage is for speculative purposes (and for gambling, but that's another discussion). Perhaps that will change, but right now, that's just how it is and how it will remain until such time as the volatility subsides by a considerable amount.
If someone invests in BTC with their eyes open about the risks, well, more power to them and FSM have mercy on their souls. Given the legal and financial uncertainties surrounding it, I would avoid it and recommend that others do the same. Your opinion differs, and I think we'll have to agree to disagree.
The earliest miners had potentially the greatest profits - providing they held onto the bitcoins they mined.meg's post was good, but it does fail to address one of my concerns about bitcoin--the possibility that it was engineered in such a way (either intentionally or effectively) that the earliest bit coin owners have a built in corner on the market.
People keep saying that bitcoin could become a useful currency once the price stabilizes, and they seem to attach to that the corollary that as it becomes more widely used the price will stabilize. But I have yet to see anyone, either here or elsewhere, explain what mechanism would allow for that to take place. As both demand for btc and the size of the market that bitcoin denominated increases in size, what prevents the increasing demand for currency from continually driving up the price of bitcoin? A very low rate of deflation might not be disastrous (probably not desirable from a macro standpoint, however) but how would ensure that?
This to me, along with the lack of protection for end users, is the big obstacle for wide adoption of bitcoin as a real currency. The technology is interesting and potentially very useful, but this implementation strikes me as heavily flawed, at best.