How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
...Alternately, if you think of it a _different_, slightly more cynical way, there's almost no risk at all. Set up payment processor with angel/venture capital, skim as much as you can on transaction fees/membership fees off the top, and if Bitcoin crashes enough that you take a big hit, you've still got everything you've collected that _wasn't_ Bitcoin. You'd be rapidly converting BTC to USBGBPEURRMB all the while, of course, because you can't afford to _yourself_ get caught short on ability to push out money... but depending on how fast you moved the shells, you could keep it up for quite a long time and all that time you're collecting fees. Be sure you don't mix the fee pile and the funding pile though.

Perhaps I'm showing my ignorance here, but I've never seen this acronym and can't parse what it might mean.

ETA: Unless it's supposed to be USD/GBP/EUR/RMB?
 
Last edited:
And mhaze (good riddance to bad rubbish), and Tippit. There are some others who pass through but those were the only three "fiat is dying" fantasists that immediately spring to mind.
Three names to strike terror in the hearts of all "critical" thinkers. Whatever they say, we must say the exact opposite for fear of being called a kook otherwise. Such an ad-hom based "reasoning" process makes any realistic discussion of relevant issues impossible.

Considering that fiat currencies became the rule only since 1933 and that the international value of currencies became entirely floating only since the 1970's I see no reason for complacency with a debt based fiat money system. We have no historical precedent to demonstrate that it is permanently sustainable.

With private and public levels of debts reaching saturation levels, traditional methods of regulating the value of currencies are no longer proving effective. Printing new money doesn't automatically increase inflation or trigger new rounds of credit expansion. We have no way of knowing if money printing can be sustained safely indefinitely or if there is a critical threshold since we have no experience from the past that compares.

Bitcoin and its ilk may well be the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era. OTOH it may never be anything more than a novelty but any sensible discussion on it should be focused on the objective data and not on who is saying what.
 
Considering that fiat currencies became the rule only since 1933 and that the international value of currencies became entirely floating only since the 1970's I see no reason for complacency with a debt based fiat money system. We have no historical precedent to demonstrate that it is permanently sustainable.

Psion10, this isn't really right. While the dollar used to be pegged to gold, that doesn't mean the dollar wasn't a fiat currency. The government didn't need to hold gold equal to paper money so long as people accepted that it would convert a dollar to gold on demand.

There were long periods in which the government held much less gold than the stock of paper dollars. Here's a link to a picture: http://dollardaze.org/blog/?post_id=00751
 
Psion10, this isn't really right. While the dollar used to be pegged to gold, that doesn't mean the dollar wasn't a fiat currency. The government didn't need to hold gold equal to paper money so long as people accepted that it would convert a dollar to gold on demand.

There were long periods in which the government held much less gold than the stock of paper dollars. Here's a link to a picture: http://dollardaze.org/blog/?post_id=00751


I pretty much made the same point in another thread:
However, there was probably never a pure gold standard; a fiat element was often part of the mix. The 700 year tally-stick system in England operated in conjunction with gold. In the middle ages, debasement (adding base metal to the gold used to make coins) was a common method of increasing the money supply. Greenbacks were issued to help fund the civil war.

More recently, Treasury notes were over-issued. That is, the Treasury didn't have enough gold to redeem all of the notes it issued.
Nevertheless, the promise to pay gold coins in exchange for treasury notes put a brake on how much debasement the government could practise.

Of course, since bitcoin can't be debased, it would be a completely new ball game if crypto-currencies were to displace fiat money.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I'm showing my ignorance here, but I've never seen this acronym and can't parse what it might mean.

ETA: Unless it's supposed to be USD/GBP/EUR/RMB?

Correct. :)

Such an ad-hom based "reasoning" process makes any realistic discussion of relevant issues impossible.

You've deliberately got my post the wrong way around; it's the supposed 'death' of fiat currency which is irrelevant. Those three posters insisted on shoehorning it into a discussion about Bitcoin at every opportunity, which really decreased the signal-to-noise ratio there for awhile.

Considering that fiat currencies became the rule only since 1933 ... Bitcoin and its ilk may well be the next step in the evolution of money and signal the end of a fiat only era....

Fine, make that four then. It still doesn't make "death of fiat" junk relevant. There are other threads for that, which I quite deliberately do not participate in because doomsday predictions belong in CT, not in rational discussion.
 
You are saying it is irrelevant but commenting on it anyway?

Context. If you had read the rest of the post rather than only the first line, you'd understand what the point of the post was in the first place.
 
Context. If you had read the rest of the post rather than only the first line, you'd understand what the point of the post was in the first place.
The rest of that post didn't make a great deal of sense.

Your assertion that bitcoin would have to be "pegged to an actual currency" before it could become used as a currency is just that - an assertion. It's imaginable that if bitcoin became popular enough, then the role between bitcoin and fiat currencies might become reversed. That is, when paying for something with fiat currency, you might have to convert its price from bitcoin first.

This is not a possibility that I relish because the ownership of bitcoin is highly concentrated. However, as long as the current mentality of "we can always get another loan" persists, anything is possible.
 
The rest of that post didn't make a great deal of sense.

Then read for comprehension, rather than trying to find something to cherry-pick and complain about.

Your assertion that bitcoin would have to be "pegged to an actual currency" before it could become used as a currency is just that - an assertion.

Except of course that it's been supported heavily by the entire course of this thread, where the prospects of what it will take for bitcoin to become a currency have been quite thoroughly explored. You should go back and reread more than the first line of _those_ posts, as well.

It's imaginable that if bitcoin became popular enough, then the role between bitcoin and fiat currencies might become reversed. That is, when paying for something with fiat currency, you might have to convert its price from bitcoin first.

Sure, it's imaginable that this might happen. It's also imaginable that flying pink unicorns might come by and crap glitter on my front lawn, too, but I'm not going to spend a whole lot of effort considering it.
 
Sure, it's imaginable that this might happen. It's also imaginable that flying pink unicorns might come by and crap glitter on my front lawn, too, but I'm not going to spend a whole lot of effort considering it.
If you can't tell the difference between bitcoin and flying unicorns then you are the one who needs to read for comprehension.

Of course, you wouldn't dare consider the possibility that bitcoin might become a currency because that was claimed by michaelsuede, mhaze and Tippit.
 
Hahahaha!

I mean, it's...

hahahah!

Yeah. That one was massively ignorant of how economies work. Talk about cognitive bias. But I guess if you start from the viewpoint that fiat means it has no base value, then of course you end up in the ditch of ignorance.
 
The USD's value has plummeted 95% since its inception, by conservative measures. How does that not qualify as a collapse?

Then again, by some measures, the US standard of living is among the highest in the world.

From the 1930s up until 1980, the average American income (after taxes and inflation) tripled, which translated into higher living standards for the American population. Between 1949 and 1969, real median family income grew by 99.3%....By the 1990s, the average American standard of living was regarded as amongst the highest in the world.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_of_living_in_the_United_States
 
If you can't tell the difference between bitcoin and flying unicorns then you are the one who needs to read for comprehension.

Of course, you wouldn't dare consider the possibility that bitcoin might become a currency because that was claimed by michaelsuede, mhaze and Tippit.

So if michaelsuede, mhaze, mhaze, or Tippit make unfounded assertions, they're asking important questions. But if someone has legitimate concerns about the economic soundness of bitcoin, due both to expert testimony and general knowledge of economics, they're just being petty for the sake of being contrary? I don't know what you think that is, but it's not critical thinking.

You've made some good points in this thread, but you intersperse them with so many bald, unqualified assertions that it becomes difficult to take whatever point you're trying to make seriously. At least Meg has displayed a sense of humor and shown an interest in civil discourse, presenting some kind of references to back up her arguments, and actually read and understand what she is commenting on. And if she still doesn't agree with me, I can respect that.
 
So if michaelsuede, mhaze, mhaze, or Tippit make unfounded assertions, they're asking important questions.
I'm saying that the legitimacy or otherwise of the statements made by michaelsuede et al is irrelevant to some of the posters here. They treat any statement made by this trio as being proof that the exact opposite is true.

But if someone has legitimate concerns about the economic soundness of bitcoin, due both to expert testimony and general knowledge of economics, they're just being petty for the sake of being contrary?
Now you are implying that anybody who opposes the "kooky" trio do so "due both to expert testimony and general knowledge of economics" irrespective of whether they provide any evidence of that or not.

Some posters show critical thinking on this forum and others don't. I treat each poster on his or her merits.
 
TigerDirect processed $500,000 worth of bitcoin orders in its first three days of offering that option. http://bitcoinboard.net/tigerdirect-processes-500000-in-bitcoin-payments-in-3-days/

If they typically pay 3% for credit card transactions, they would have to pay $15,000 to process those orders.

If they are using BitPay's most expensive service, they pay $3000 flat rate per month. They've saved $12,000 already in the first three days.

According to the article, TigerDirect processes $2 Billion in orders per year. Which is about $5 million in orders per day. If they maintain this rate of approximately 3% of the orders being bitcoin, they will save $1,764,000 in a year.

Not bad. Not bad at all.

Especially considering TigerDirect ended their last fiscal year with a net loss of about three million.

Growing their bitcoin business by a few percentage points could put them back in the black.
 
I'm saying that the legitimacy or otherwise of the statements made by michaelsuede et al is irrelevant to some of the posters here. They treat any statement made by this trio as being proof that the exact opposite is true.

You've completely made this up inside your own mind. The actual conversational chain was:

meg said:
Is imminent fiat collapse anyone's argument? Who are you arguing with?
Almo said:
That was (one of) MichaelSuede's argument (s). You know, the guy who started this thread.
me said:
And mhaze (good riddance to bad rubbish), and Tippit. There are some others who pass through but those were the only three "fiat is dying" fantasists that immediately spring to mind.

Bitcoin's utility or lack thereof will have next-to-zero impact on fiat currencies, because for it (or any other digital payment system) to become commonly used, it's going to have to be pegged to an actual currency somewhere along the way. Right now we have payment processors (Bitpay, Coinbase) who are assuming the risk themselves of holding Bitcoin, but there's quite a bit of risk involved.

...Alternately, if you think of it a _different_, slightly more cynical way, there's almost no risk at all. Set up payment processor with angel/venture capital, skim as much as you can on transaction fees/membership fees off the top, and if Bitcoin crashes enough that you take a big hit, you've still got everything you've collected that _wasn't_ Bitcoin. You'd be rapidly converting BTC to USBGBPEURRMB all the while, of course, because you can't afford to _yourself_ get caught short on ability to push out money... but depending on how fast you moved the shells, you could keep it up for quite a long time and all that time you're collecting fees. Be sure you don't mix the fee pile and the funding pile though.

As you can see, your assertion is an utter and complete fantasy. Nobody has said anything of the kind -- nobody was even close to saying anything of the kind. Please at least try to respond to what people actually say, rather than what you imagine they had said.

The fallacy you're committing is called "strawman", for reference. Please keep it in mind in the future; avoiding those will make your arguments much more coherent and reflective of reality.
 
TigerDirect processed $500,000 worth of bitcoin orders in its first three days of offering that option. http://bitcoinboard.net/tigerdirect-processes-500000-in-bitcoin-payments-in-3-days/

I'm not even slightly surprised by this. TigerDirect just provided a way for people to cash out Bitcoin for something immediately useful to them -- new hardware. Correct me if I'm wrong here, but aren't they the first computer-parts store to even offer Bitcoin acceptance through a payment processor? Given the underlying Bitcoin demographic, it would have been a surprise if they _weren't_ immediately flooded with orders.

Be interesting to see how the volume looks after 3 months -- and possibly what the volume looks like in comparison to price fluctuations at the exchanges, though if there aren't any major ones there won't be anything to see. One of the oft-remarked-on objections to Bitcoin-as-currency here is that its deflationary nature is a disincentive to spend it; so if the price rises sharply, sales should drop off, and if the price _drops_ sharply, sales should increase. Can't see any of that in the short term though, of course.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom