|
Welcome to the International Skeptics Forum, where we discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly but lively way. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest, which means you are missing out on discussing matters that are of interest to you. Please consider registering so you can gain full use of the forum features and interact with other Members. Registration is simple, fast and free! Click here to register today. |
26th July 2010, 04:52 AM | #241 |
Orthogonal Vector
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 53,184
|
|
__________________
Sufficiently advanced Woo is indistinguishable from Parody "There shall be no *poofing* in science" Paul C. Anagnostopoulos Force ***** on reasons back" Ben Franklin |
|
26th July 2010, 04:55 AM | #242 |
Orthogonal Vector
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 53,184
|
|
__________________
Sufficiently advanced Woo is indistinguishable from Parody "There shall be no *poofing* in science" Paul C. Anagnostopoulos Force ***** on reasons back" Ben Franklin |
|
26th July 2010, 05:00 AM | #243 |
Orthogonal Vector
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 53,184
|
They are blatantly incompatable. In one you explicitly state that AA is more effective, and in the later one you claim no one made this claim. You are being blatantly dishonest.
If you want to lie, you should at least lie about things that are not there for everyone to see your lies. |
__________________
Sufficiently advanced Woo is indistinguishable from Parody "There shall be no *poofing* in science" Paul C. Anagnostopoulos Force ***** on reasons back" Ben Franklin |
|
26th July 2010, 05:43 AM | #244 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
Perhaps I could have been clearer. That said, your lack of understanding is not really my problem.
But do you have these other stats? I am genuinely interested in what methods of recovery achieve success. |
26th July 2010, 09:32 AM | #245 |
a carbon based life-form
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 39,049
|
|
26th July 2010, 11:10 AM | #246 |
Graduate Poster
Join Date: Jan 2010
Posts: 1,357
|
|
26th July 2010, 01:46 PM | #247 |
Thinker
Join Date: Aug 2009
Posts: 246
|
Several controlled or double-blind studies have shown that out of a given group of problem drinkers, approximately 5% quit on their own - without any sort of program or treatment, they simply decided they'd had enough punishment.
This 5% number is significant, as it's exactly the same as the average quit rate produced by attending AA. (again, quit rate determined by those who initially attended AA by whatever means -court, self directed, family directed, treatment center, etc & were still sober 1 year later). The conclusion from data from AA's own triennial surveys combined with the studies that have been done (with some difficulty, as AA is not cooperative in providing data) over the years is that doing nothing - simply deciding one has had enough - is just as effective as going to AA and having religion shoved down one's throat.. Those people who start babbling about AA only suggesting are just fooling themselves (as well as fooling 100's of thousands of people every year, and the massive 12 step recovery business/treatment centers/insurance providers) - what people are told in AA in the big book & 12x12 is take our suggestions or die of alcholism - or die in prison - or die in an insane institution. These people being introduced to AA are lead to believe AA has a cure (or forced to attend by the legal system) are in an extremely vulnerable position. Coupling that emotive state with strong group pressure to 'accept our suggestions or die' (ie - go back and drink some more - reinforced by the group/peer 'suggestion' that to continue to drink is to die) reveals the lie about 'suggestions' quite completely. I personally have seen this occur 1000's of times at meetings I myself attended over a period of 21 years - this personal experience matches the studies (espescially those studies by George Valiant - a Trustee of AA Inc) exactly. All this is quite clear to those who examine the data critically - unless, of course, you've been cult brainwashed or religiously converted (AA's primary goal - as stated in the official AA material) is to make the member do gods will & help others to achieve sobriety - you won't hear 'stay sober & help others to achieve sobriety' anywhere in the big book (except where AA's big book & other material says that just being sober isn't good enough ) as a primary goal, unless it's connected to 'and do god's will'. |
26th July 2010, 03:14 PM | #248 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
You keep saying stuff like this and draw on the opinions of individuals withing the big book and elsewhere.
Why? They have never said, "my way or the highway" or similar and if they did it related to their personal views. I obviously have to repeat: Tradition three: The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking. The 12 steps are suggested (ch5, p59) If someone is telling you to do something else, it is their opinion. Any religion is individual. And no matter how you want to twist words, the fact remains: NOTHING IS COMPULSORY. And on the "do AA or die message" (or similar), are you suggesting that people do not die (every day) from alcoholism? If 9% can find relief within AA (with or withour religion) surely that is a good thing. |
26th July 2010, 03:21 PM | #249 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
26th July 2010, 07:57 PM | #250 |
Chief Cook & Bottle Washer
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 950
|
|
__________________
king of all that is pizza "You only find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out" - Warren Buffett "Gods don't write books, people do. Gods create Universes. When you refuse to study the Universe, but choose instead to study a book, you are studying the work of men, not God." -Brainache |
|
27th July 2010, 04:01 AM | #251 |
Orthogonal Vector
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 53,184
|
|
__________________
Sufficiently advanced Woo is indistinguishable from Parody "There shall be no *poofing* in science" Paul C. Anagnostopoulos Force ***** on reasons back" Ben Franklin |
|
27th July 2010, 04:06 AM | #252 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
27th July 2010, 04:07 AM | #253 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
Life saving, soul crushing.
A "help" group that tells me that I have a "disease", which is clearly not the case, that I can't do anything about it, which is clearly not the case, that I'm worthless, which varies with the individual, and that my only hope for salvation is to allow a nonsensical, imaginary being into my heard is not only deeply religious, but dangerous and harmful. |
27th July 2010, 04:09 AM | #254 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
27th July 2010, 04:16 AM | #255 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
[quote=Belz...;6164346]Life saving, soul crushing.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
[quote] and that my only hope for salvation is to allow a nonsensical, imaginary being into my heard is not only deeply religious, Wrong again. Salvation (whatever that is, is up to the individual), getting sober depends on making some effort to do so.
Quote:
|
27th July 2010, 04:18 AM | #256 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
27th July 2010, 04:30 AM | #257 |
Orthogonal Vector
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 53,184
|
|
__________________
Sufficiently advanced Woo is indistinguishable from Parody "There shall be no *poofing* in science" Paul C. Anagnostopoulos Force ***** on reasons back" Ben Franklin |
|
27th July 2010, 04:42 AM | #258 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
lol
Imagine that, agnostics "preaching" sobriety in this thread, and atheists and non alcoholics thinking its religion. Talk about confirmation bias! |
27th July 2010, 05:14 AM | #259 |
a carbon based life-form
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 39,049
|
|
27th July 2010, 05:18 AM | #260 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
27th July 2010, 08:35 AM | #261 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Jan 2005
Posts: 4,289
|
|
27th July 2010, 09:09 AM | #262 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
Don't make this personal. The point is that addiction is not a disease: it's a habit, one that is decidedly intentional.
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
27th July 2010, 09:10 AM | #263 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
27th July 2010, 09:11 AM | #264 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
27th July 2010, 06:19 PM | #265 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
Good point. You are correct, I don't know what happens at every group, and they do vary in line with their individual structures. What I do know is that everyone in AA has their own opinion and their own recovery. The steps and traditions outline the 'rules', of which there are none.
In your opinion, but the experts disagree with you. To a point. There is plenty that can be done, it is a matter of being prepared to do it. Powerless (to me) refers to what happens after the first drink. I cannot guarantee my behaviour. Not quite, the 12 steps suggest that a higher power can restore us to sanity. This is not abdication in the terms you put it. No-one makes anyone do anything. If they choose to believe that, that is just fine. By the way, it may be false, but how is it dangerous? Fair enough. But again, you are banging on about a god that does not come into a lot of AAs thinking and recovery. A power greater than myself - say, the group of drunks - is more powerful than me, and can help restore me to sanity (i.e. get sober). eta, I will try and look at you video tonight. Cheers |
27th July 2010, 06:44 PM | #266 |
Chief Cook & Bottle Washer
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 950
|
|
__________________
king of all that is pizza "You only find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out" - Warren Buffett "Gods don't write books, people do. Gods create Universes. When you refuse to study the Universe, but choose instead to study a book, you are studying the work of men, not God." -Brainache |
|
28th July 2010, 01:05 AM | #267 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
28th July 2010, 02:25 AM | #268 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
28th July 2010, 02:26 AM | #269 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
28th July 2010, 02:40 AM | #270 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
Why not run a whole stack of entertainers to support their point? I could show you some Billy Connelley that has a different perspective. Hmm, who to believe?
Oh! I know, maybe someone who is qualified to make a determination like the AMA, World Health Organisation et al and not some (supposed) psychologist who supports their view Maybe Penn and Teller don't think cancer is a disease either, they say they do in the video and draw direct comparisons - curiously the Health Organisations all over the world do think both cancer and alcoholism disease. Hmm, Penn and Teller don't. Who to believe? So, are they qualified to comment? Sure, just as much as any other lay person. But in their opening they make a point of outlining they know eff all about it. Does that mean they are correct and their opinion overrides that of the leading health organisations? Um...., no. I will watch Penn and Teller for entertainment, not the science of addiction and disease. Cheers. |
28th July 2010, 04:06 AM | #271 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
http://medical-dictionary.thefreedic...com/alcoholism
Quote:
Even the APA reckon it doesn't matter if one is religious or not. and http://www.medicinenet.com/alcohol_a...sm/article.htm
Quote:
http://www.ama-assn.org/ama1/pub/upl...atementuad.pdf
Quote:
|
28th July 2010, 06:58 AM | #272 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
You don't have a choice whether you have a disease or not. Alcoholism is a choice. Just like eating disorders. If you claim they are a disease then you remove responsability from yourself.
No wonder they seek a higher power... If Alcoholism is a disease then so is every hobby when it becomes addictive. The definition of disease becomes so vague as to be unusable and meaningless. |
28th July 2010, 04:08 PM | #273 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
You are half right here.
Alcoholism is not a choice, drinking is. One will rarely know of they are going to be an alcoholic until it is too late. Hobbies become obsessive, not addictive - the word addictive is being misused here. Hobbies are a mental obsession only. Addiction is the physical dependance coupled with the mental obsession. The physical dependance is the what moves it from (say) a mental disorder to a disease. I hope that helps clear things up. |
28th July 2010, 08:15 PM | #274 |
Chief Cook & Bottle Washer
Join Date: Jan 2008
Posts: 950
|
AA Alfie-
I am coming to the conclusion that (most) of the people in this thread that are arguing against AA don't have any real desire to learn about AA or how it really works (which is different for different people). I would like to direct any of the those that are sincerely interested in more info about AA and how it works read this thread I found on AA when I first joined the forum. |
__________________
king of all that is pizza "You only find out who is swimming naked when the tide goes out" - Warren Buffett "Gods don't write books, people do. Gods create Universes. When you refuse to study the Universe, but choose instead to study a book, you are studying the work of men, not God." -Brainache |
|
28th July 2010, 09:10 PM | #275 |
Self Assessed Dunning-Kruger Expert
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,178
|
Still catching up with this thread, so my apologies if I cover ground that has already been addressed.
As to the OP, why the insistence that AA is a religeous program? That it has some roots in Christianity is undeniable, as is the fact that there are certainly particular groups that are overtly evangelistic about their brand of religion, but AA as a whole is religiously neutral in that it neither favors nor disfavors any particular religion. To wit: my home group has explicitly decided to NOT use the Lord's Prayer as we wish to not offend or exclude anyone. Moreover, one of the fundamental precepts of AA is that if you don't like how AA is being implemented in a particular group, you are free to start your own! Want a group that avoids the 'G' word? Go ahead and make one. There's a group locally that does just that. Lastly (for this post), there is nothing about 'God' that need be supernatural (that's the basic point behind the 'doorknob' saying, it's not meant to be taken too literally). The part about reliance on a higher power is symbolically an acceptance of outside help. My higher power is in fact 'not me.' More on some specific points later |
__________________
GENERATION 3: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and kill the great-great-great-great-grandfather of the person you copied it from. Time travel experiment. |
|
28th July 2010, 10:36 PM | #276 |
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2009
Posts: 10,691
|
|
29th July 2010, 12:28 AM | #277 |
Graduate Poster
Join Date: Feb 2009
Posts: 1,548
|
I read the first couple of pages on this thread and the last couple, so forgive me if anyone has already covered the following:
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
It is likely, though debatable, that one or two of the twelve steps might actually be psychologically beneficial, but it is astounding that the APA still gives AA any credibility at all. Likewise, it is obvious that support groups can be beneficial, but the structural model of AA and it's derivatives offer nothing more than a support system--only with the added baggage of its religious tenets (and make no mistake, the 12 steps are clearly religious tenets. And for all that AA's rhetoric is that there are 'no rules', this is belied if you actually challenge any of the Steps). There is no sound Empirical Basis for most of the 12 steps in any psychological, psychiatric, or neurological system. Nearly all other 12 step programs are based almost entirely on AA's model. And the Judicial system DOES force people into these programs all the time, which amounts to State sanctioning of Religion. There are many reasons for Alcoholism, ranging from socio-psychological traumas, political-economic traumas, mere hedonistic inculcation, habituation, and neurological predilections, or a combination thereof. The AA model of Alcoholism prevention is not "Disease", as it purports to be, but "Sin". It is plausible that some forms of Alcoholism do fit into the "Disease" model, but even to apply that model across the board is a clear mistake--a trap that many in the Medical Community fall into. Still, insofar as some forms of Alcoholism may respond to Medical Therapy, a scientific approach of treating the underlying neurological causes instead of the symptoms (self-medicating with alcohol or other drugs) is a far better approach to treatment. Psychological and Psychiatric professionals can also help some "addicts" work through the underlying causes of their problems, such as dealing with depression, schizophrenia, and other issues directly. And other Medical professionals can help people who are often dealing with Chronic Pain issues by self-medicating. In some cases, the religiously inclined CAN respond better to help from religious programs, but only if their "addictions" aren't masking deeper problems. In many cases, "addiction" runs rampant in the politically and economically dispossessed and oppressed communities. In which case the best "cure" is political/economic enfranchisement and the curbing of Economic Exploitation. In conclusion: I am no expert, but I think it should be clear that the Religious and Disease models of addiction often obfuscate the fact that addictive patterns of behaviour are more often than not, SYMPTOMS of deeper problems, for which many people self-medicate. Personally, I think 12 Step programs are the worst approach, not simply because of the religious issue, but also because they rarely help people discover the underlying problem they are self-medicating for, instead MASKING the problem with Religious Rhetoric. Some of the most successful programs have been experimental programs in Europe with psychotropics such as Ibogaine, which gives people a chance to "break" their obsessive patterns of behaviour, which in turn gives people a chance to discover the underlying causes of their problems. My recommendations for reading materials includes: The Diseasing of America by Stanton Peele-- an excellent resource even if he does overstate his case a bit (clearly, the disease model may be appropriate in some cases where the cause might have a neurological basis). But first and foremost Peele dispels the conflation of the religious model with the disease model, and examines many of the problems with the disease model itself. I'm Dysfunctional, You're Dysfunctional by Wendy Kaminer-- which examines the self-help movement over-all from the Pseudoscience of 12 steps to New Age "therapies". GB EDIT: After going back and reading through the rest of the posts, I must offer Special Kudos to Tinyal for largely sticking to the Empirical Evidence that proves beyond a Reasonable Doubt that AA and its offshoots are inherently religious, not particularly successful (as far as actually helping addicts), and occasionally dangerous. The Sophistry, Conflation, and Obfuscation of deniers like AAAlfie is almost painful to behold. The reason people like AAAlfie claim AA is not religious, is because they want to peddle their pseudo-scientific religion as science (all the better to reap "Converts"), just as Intelligent Design is Creationism dressed up as Pseudo-science. Marplotsmakes some cogent points in his post on the last page, though I think his point regarding the "backpedalling on God" is a bit of an overstatement. Sobriety IS a key issue, but it doesn't overshadow the imposition of God in AA. The whole set up is based on Sin, Confession, and Absolution. One can fall off the wagon all the time ("One day at a time"), but as long as you show up, Confess your Sins, and Pray with your Brethren for Absolution, you're good to go--until the next time you fall off the wagon. I have sat in on meetings which had people who had been in and out for years. Their Lurid Confessions (the juicier the better) and renewed Vows would bring the loudest applause. To continue the repetition that the Steps and Rules are merely Suggestions is beyond specious, and beyond disingenuous; it is a LIE. As other posters have pointed out, the Steps ARE the program (God and all), and this is drummed into every AA Adherent. In the same way, the proposition that one can claim God is a Doorknob, is simply an Obfuscation that a Belief in God is a foundational requirement for the 12 Steps. |
__________________
"It is like a finger pointing at the moon. Pay no attention to the finger or you will miss all that heavenly glory."--Bruce Lee Non-theistic Pagan Agnostic, or Gnostic Agnostic--depending on the day of the week. Absence of evidence is not evidence of absence--Carl Sagan |
|
29th July 2010, 01:53 AM | #278 |
Self Assessed Dunning-Kruger Expert
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,178
|
Bits from the Boy Scouts of America Oath and Law
Quote:
The US Congressional Oath:
Quote:
I don't deny that AA has many of the characteristics of a religion, and it certainly borrows language and concepts from religion (Christianity in particular), but it fails to qualify as a religion in and of itself. I posit that one of the defining characteristics of a religion is that one cannot belong to more than one at a time. (I'll note that by this definition, certain modern movements like universalism aren't clearly religions either) |
__________________
GENERATION 3: The first time you see this, copy it into your sig on any forum and kill the great-great-great-great-grandfather of the person you copied it from. Time travel experiment. |
|
29th July 2010, 02:33 AM | #279 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
But alcoholism IS drinking. Look at me for instance: I have trouble staying away from food. Candy and chocolate, specifically. It's an addiction, to a degree, but I'll be damned if someone calls it a disease.
Quote:
|
29th July 2010, 02:35 AM | #280 |
Fiend God
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: In a post-fact world
Posts: 96,875
|
|
Thread Tools | |
|
|