|
Welcome to the International Skeptics Forum, where we discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly but lively way. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest, which means you are missing out on discussing matters that are of interest to you. Please consider registering so you can gain full use of the forum features and interact with other Members. Registration is simple, fast and free! Click here to register today. |
16th August 2011, 10:20 AM | #1 |
Student
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 49
|
The JREF on ABC's Primetime Nightline!
Be sure to watch psychics put to the JREF test on ABC's Primetime Nightline Wednesday, 8/17 at 10pm EST!
The JREF is a big part of this "Beyond Belief" special on psychic abilities. Will someone win our Million Dollar Challenge? http://bit.ly/mXh7Hz |
16th August 2011, 02:31 PM | #2 |
Masterblazer
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Montreal, Quebec
Posts: 6,843
|
|
__________________
Almo! My Music Blog "No society ever collapsed because the poor had too much." — LeftySergeant "It may be that there is no body really at rest, to which the places and motions of others may be referred." –Issac Newton in the Principia |
|
16th August 2011, 03:26 PM | #3 |
Gentleman of leisure
Tagger
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Flying around in the sky
Posts: 28,092
|
Will the forum even get a mention?
|
16th August 2011, 06:52 PM | #4 |
Master Poster
Join Date: Dec 2008
Posts: 2,333
|
Someone applied and was tested for the MDC on this TV show? Really?
Ward |
__________________
~~Na eth'er aa, ammre' en ank'aar'eith, d'emner'aa-, asd'reng'aather, em'n'err-aae...~ - Alenara Al'Kher'aat, aged 347 |
|
17th August 2011, 03:09 AM | #5 |
Philosopher
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 6,106
|
Anyone record this to disc and send across the pond??
|
__________________
"I achieve these results through a mixture of magic,misdirection,suggestion and showmanship"-Derren Brown
|
|
17th August 2011, 10:05 AM | #6 |
Student
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 49
|
Here's a lengthy clip: http://abcnews.go.com/Nightline/vide...-test-14320969
|
17th August 2011, 07:12 PM | #7 |
Masterblazer
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Montreal, Quebec
Posts: 6,843
|
Part to first ad break... pretty good!
|
__________________
Almo! My Music Blog "No society ever collapsed because the poor had too much." — LeftySergeant "It may be that there is no body really at rest, to which the places and motions of others may be referred." –Issac Newton in the Principia |
|
17th August 2011, 07:26 PM | #8 |
Scheme Monkey
Join Date: Feb 2005
Posts: 1,045
|
The problem I'm seeing so far is that there was no mention as to whether the "applicants" agreed that the protocols would be reasonable tests of their abilities. Currently, the "out" I see them all having was "this isn't what I said I could do".
Except for van Praagh. They chewed him up pretty good for the length of the segment. |
__________________
It's your contention that being sane is living a sheltered life? -- thaiboxerken |
|
17th August 2011, 07:58 PM | #9 |
Wuse
Join Date: Jan 2007
Posts: 1,441
|
What a disgusting last segment.
|
__________________
“I don't even know how to count.” -- Sylvia BrowneThis is invisible.“We're playing for blood, the stake is EARTH.” -- L. Ron HubbardThis is invisible.“I don't feel strong.” -- Uri Geller
|
|
17th August 2011, 10:30 PM | #10 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Los Angeles, California
Posts: 3,105
|
I just finished watching part two (testing the palm reader and tarot card reader, and the living and dead test). I'm afraid that segment is going to leave lots of room for believers to cry foul. With the living and dead test, I don't remember them showing the guy claiming to be able to do such a thing. I think they should show the claimant making a very specific claim, and like the MDC, then have them agree to a protocol. With the palm reader, she was working with crude looking photo copies of hands--of course believers are going to say that's not the same as looking at a live hand, as the reader claimed.
Still, glad to see Randi and Banacek on TV doing their best (I'm guessing the producers didn't make it easy for them to make their case). eta: the consultant to Psychic Kids (or whatever that TV show is called): (paraphrasing) interviewer: were any of those kids traumatized (by their experiencing demons etc, and possibly encouraged by their parents)? consultant: the children I worked with were beautiful kids with high IQs wtf, didn't answer question |
17th August 2011, 11:46 PM | #11 |
Muse
Join Date: Oct 2010
Location: The Netherlands
Posts: 897
|
I second this. I can only watch segments, but they're not complete and stop quite abruptly. If I click on the video for the complete episode, it says I can't watch because I'm not in the US.
The first part about Van Praagh is also on youtube and complete, but not the other parts. I liked what I've seen so far though, not the usual "wow it's amazing what he can do" type of show. |
__________________
Why is everybody so skeptical here? |
|
18th August 2011, 08:09 AM | #12 |
Muse
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 834
|
|
18th August 2011, 08:19 AM | #13 |
Thinker
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 178
|
Thought that they didn't make it clear that it was Banacheck that "saw" the yellow school bus toy over his head .. If you didn't get that, you'd think it was a psychic with "powers." Also, the last interviewer was pathetic. When they talked about his dead mom, he melted, and wanted to believe... not much in the way of skeptical reporting. Thought Banacheck and Randi were fabulous. Just wish they were given more time to talk. (check the floor of the editing room) Overall, left an impression that it could be real .. not as definitive as I'd have liked.
|
18th August 2011, 08:33 AM | #14 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
I would be astonished if there wasn't some sort of positive recititation by the participants that the test they were about to take was fair (or perhaps even suggested by themselves!). A positive recitiation is more than them taking the test without an objection.
In the past, test subjects have been asked: Can you do this? If we give you pictures of hands rather than the hands themselves, and cover the targets' hands with mittens, can you still do it? Can you to find a picture of one deceased person from among a random collection of a dozen pictures in folders and envelopes? It is not necessary to say to the participants anything like, "You will not be allowed to complain after the test that the test is unfair." Rather, it is more important to get them on the record that the test appears to be fair and they feel they CAN succeed at it. Afterwards, they can cry foul all they want, but JREF can point out that before and during the exam, there were no cries of foul. |
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
18th August 2011, 08:58 AM | #15 |
Master Poster
Join Date: May 2002
Location: Wisconsin, USA
Posts: 2,424
|
I take exception to shows that juxtapose a "real" psychic with a magician doing the same trick, but fail to explain how the magician did it. This means, to a typical audience, that while the magician might be performing using mundane powers, and the psychic might be using supernormal ones, the opposite might be true, and we are given insufficient knowledge to distinguish.
I think it hurts the skeptic cause, and this show, while not the worst, was far from what it could have been. Too many stones were unturned. |
18th August 2011, 09:21 AM | #16 |
Homer Simpson Analogue
Join Date: Oct 2007
Location: Arizona
Posts: 2,044
|
It was great to see Randi and Banacheck on prime time TV. I just wish they would have put the skeptical segment on last - that ending part with Alison Dubois was just atrocious.
I thought it was hilarious that one of the "testees" was wearing a Power Balance bracelet. |
__________________
I do mind, the Dude minds. This will not stand, ya know, this aggression will not stand, man. - The Dude |
|
18th August 2011, 09:21 AM | #17 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
Very often, magicians don't do the same trick. They do BETTER tricks: more baffling, under seemingly greater controls, under more difficult conditions, and with fewer miscues. By comparsion, those who try to pass trickery off as supernatural powers are amateurs, and usually not very skilled amateurs at that.
It is important to point out a significant number of self-proclaimed psychics do NOT use trickery at all. Rather, they simply do not have the abilities that they think they have. When put to a test, their claimed abilities just don't show up. They may have deceived themselves, they do not consciously try to deceive anyone. |
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
18th August 2011, 09:25 AM | #18 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
|
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
18th August 2011, 11:06 AM | #19 |
King of the Pod People
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 25,628
|
My one complaint is that they never mentioned the fact that MDC applicants agree to the test protocols before the test is performed.
|
18th August 2011, 12:15 PM | #20 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 10,015
|
Considering all the other news magazine stories of psychic claims, this was probably the best one I've ever seen. ABC should get some kudos for it. Not to mention Sylvia Browne was mentioned in the same sentence with the word "infamous".
|
18th August 2011, 04:48 PM | #21 |
Critical Thinker
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 390
|
Banacek's statements on the scumbaggery of psychic detectives are excellent. Hopefully those few moments will help people from being manipulated and having their grief exploited.
|
18th August 2011, 06:10 PM | #22 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 10,293
|
For those who haven't seen the latest JREF announcement:
Randi Challenges Top "Psychics" After Nightline Episode |
__________________
As long as people believe in absurdities they will continue to commit atrocities. - Voltaire. |
|
19th August 2011, 01:13 AM | #23 |
Student
Join Date: Jul 2011
Posts: 28
|
Regarding that silly last segment with the incredulous reporter, I tried googling "abc news david wright". The very first link that pops up is his ABC News online bio which was last updated in 2008. I'd post the URL but apparently I cannot without having made 15 posts here first, but you can google it like I did.
The last line in that bio is "He and his wife, Victoria, live in Washington, D.C., with their daughter, Deanna." Isn't it interesting that the psychic mentioned that he had a daughter, and the reporter responded that actually he had 3. If ABC News hadn't been so lax in keeping these bios updated, that poor psychic may have been able to divine the correct number of daughters. |
19th August 2011, 01:43 AM | #24 |
Gentleman of leisure
Tagger
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Flying around in the sky
Posts: 28,092
|
Here is the link referred to in this post http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/story?id=127805
|
19th August 2011, 05:47 AM | #25 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
Three questions:
1. Am I right that Jamy Ian Swiss, though plainly present at some of the tests, was not identified in the show by name or by vocation? 2. Was it a coincidence that ABC used its commercial space to promote its own upcoming show, "The Sixth Sense?" 3. Can anyone independently confirm the probabilities? In particular, if you are given twelve independent chances to make a selection of a target from twelve possible selections, what are the chances you will select the target at least nine times? According to ABC, "The odds of winning by luck are about 1 in a billion" (although when I first saw the show, I thought the reporter said "1 in 5 billion"). Basically, if you had one chance to make a guess, you'd be expected to be right one out of twelve times (1/12). If you had to be right two times in a row, you'd be right (on average) one out of 144 times ((1/12)^2). If you had to be right nine times in a row, that would be about 1 out of about 5.16 billion times ((1/12)^9). But the contestant doesn't need to be right nine times in a row. He gets twelve chances, so up to three misses are allowed. Also, the contestant doesn't need to guess right exactly nine times; ten, eleven and twelve correct picks also count as successes. |
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
19th August 2011, 08:19 AM | #26 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 53,084
|
|
__________________
If I see somebody with a gun on a plane? I'll kill him. Lupus is Lupus tor central scrutineezer |
|
19th August 2011, 11:26 AM | #27 |
Stranded in Sub-Atomica
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 3,395
|
|
19th August 2011, 12:07 PM | #28 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 10,293
|
In the other thread where the show is being discussed, someone apparently got it to work from the UK: http://www.internationalskeptics.com...34#post7489734 |
19th August 2011, 03:39 PM | #29 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Los Angeles, California
Posts: 3,105
|
Quote:
|
22nd August 2011, 03:37 AM | #30 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 18,774
|
Yes, the probability is actually much higher, since you're actually looking at 12C9 rather than just (1/12)9. I make it about 1 in 30 million. You can use an online calculator like this one to calculate probabilities for problems like this (which incidentally seems to have a free online textbook attached to it for those who want to learn how it works).
You're right that allowing more than 9 correct picks could in principle increase his chances, but in this case the probabilities for 10, 11 or 12 correct are so low that they actually make very little difference to the overall result - 1 in 30.449 million for exactly 9 compared to 1 in 29.628 million for 9 or more. |
23rd August 2011, 01:56 PM | #31 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
|
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
23rd August 2011, 02:07 PM | #32 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
Also, in the past, subjects are given a chance to try to perform the feat, already knowing where the target is. It would not surprise me, for example, if the guy who tried to find the photograph of Elvis was, at some time prior to the test, shown a set of envelopes in which he saw or was told the envelope in which Elvis's picture rested. He may then have been asked whether he could detect that picture.
As a general rule, when people know where the target is, they report that their special abilities are working quite well, thank you, and the special abilities can indeed find the object they are looking for, whether it be water, a coin, or a picture of Elvis ... if they already know where it is. But perhaps this does not make for very interesting TV viewing. Practices that don't "count" for the million dollar challenge: who cares about them?? The interesting part, of course, is whether those special abilities can find the McGuffin if the contestant DOESN'T know where it is. So far, no one has been able to do it. |
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
23rd August 2011, 02:11 PM | #33 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 10,293
|
|
__________________
As long as people believe in absurdities they will continue to commit atrocities. - Voltaire. |
|
23rd August 2011, 02:23 PM | #34 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
I could have predicted you'd say that!
News Flash: Huffington Post headline (along with an unflattering photo) says: "James Van Praagh Gets $1 Million Offer To Prove Mental Powers." Unfortunately, the link to the story doesn't work. I wonder who out there has a million bucks to test supposed psychic abilities...? |
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
24th August 2011, 02:38 PM | #35 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Feb 2010
Posts: 10,293
|
|
__________________
As long as people believe in absurdities they will continue to commit atrocities. - Voltaire. |
|
24th August 2011, 03:24 PM | #36 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Mar 2005
Location: Los Angeles, California
Posts: 3,105
|
....
|
25th August 2011, 05:29 AM | #37 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Aug 2001
Posts: 12,984
|
|
__________________
Klaatu: I'm impatient with stupidity. My people have learned to live without it. Mr. Harley: I'm afraid my people haven't. I am very sorry. I wish it were otherwise. -- The Day The Earth Stood Still, screenplay by Edmund H. North "Don't you get me wrong. I only want to know." -- Judas in Jesus Christ Superstar, lyrics by Tim Rice |
|
Thread Tools | |
|
|