|
Welcome to the International Skeptics Forum, where we discuss skepticism, critical thinking, the paranormal and science in a friendly but lively way. You are currently viewing the forum as a guest, which means you are missing out on discussing matters that are of interest to you. Please consider registering so you can gain full use of the forum features and interact with other Members. Registration is simple, fast and free! Click here to register today. |
28th December 2011, 01:34 PM | #1 |
Thinker
Join Date: Aug 2005
Posts: 217
|
Can someone explain "Life of Pi" to me?
I read it a couple of years ago. It was quite good taken literally, until it all went a bit weird near the end with him talking to himself or something (can't really remember now).
I remember reading the tagline "It'll make you believe in God", which intrigued me, but I found nothing revelationary at all that I remember. There was the initial section about him investigating three religions which was fine, but seemed irrelevant to what followed. Then there was the whole tiger, zebra boat thing, a weird island and then the wierd delusional bit. Then at the end he's rescued and it's suggested that it's all an allegory and there's an alternate story with real people, but either could be true, and that's like God for some reason. Now I'm notoriously bad at interpreting allegorical stuff, my mind seems to be too literal to see it, so I'd be grateful if someone could explain the amazing truth that will make me believe in God, and also what the island and weird talking to himself bits were about. The most meaning I could get from it was "Some people prefer made up stories because they're more exciting than reality, so they prefer the idea of God to a meaningless universe" ? |
__________________
Are you a JREF Folder? |
|
28th December 2011, 08:06 PM | #2 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Way way north of Diddy Wah Diddy
Posts: 36,113
|
I had a bit the same problem, and it seemed to me that the basic message was that as long as the end result is the same you can't argue the belief that got you there, or perhaps a kind of corruption of the pragmatic maxim, that two stories that end up at the same point are equivalent, so why not pick the one you like. A nicely written book that I ended up finding very annoying.
|
__________________
Like many humorless and indignant people, he is hard on everybody but himself, and does not perceive it when he fails his own ideal (Molière) A pedant is a man who studies a vacuum through instruments that allow him to draw cross-sections of the details (John Ciardi) |
|
28th December 2011, 08:33 PM | #3 |
Guest
Join Date: Sep 2006
Posts: 17,252
|
Yeah I got about halfway though it - What ever brilliance of literature this book is - It was sailing way over my head
|
28th December 2011, 08:42 PM | #4 |
Philosophile
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Osaka, Japan
Posts: 35,981
|
Well, I think...
The story itself is supposed to be very interesting and exciting. We basically go along with the story for the most part because despite being a bit improbable, if you don't suspend your disbelief willingly, it sort of works. Then there's that bit at the island which is just weird... I didn't understand any of that except perhaps to throw our original sense of belief for another loop. Then when Pi is picked up by the Japanese ship he is told a far more rational story. That there had been no animals at all and it was just other survivors including his mum and the cook on the boat and not those animals. I think... he's trying to say that when there are two possible stories, choose the best one. And in this case, according to his own belief, the best story seems to be to believe in God. Bear in mind my caveats there are to with what I think the authors beliefs are not that I subscribe to the idea that a world explained by the existence of God and magic is better than a world described mechanistically. I just think that maybe the author was going for that. |
__________________
Слава Україні! **** Putin! |
|
28th December 2011, 11:11 PM | #5 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 4,107
|
I read it about 18 months ago and thought it was a remarkable work. I didn't recall any claim about believing in God, so I dug it out. My copy (published by Canongate in the UK) makes no such claim on the front or back cover. There is a quote from the NY Times book review on the back cover saying "[It] could renew your faith..." but goes on "...in the ability of novelists to invest even the most outrageous scenario with plausible life".
Inside, there's a couple of pages of high praise from various sources, which includes the Scotsman newspaper's "Impressive enough to make you, as the old man said, believe in God". I don't catch the 'as the old man said' allusion, but it isn't claiming that reading Pi will make you believe in god through the story, at most it's saying that Martel's work is that wondrous that you might (as, perhaps, with a sunset or mountain range) ascribe the existence of such a talent to the work of a higher power. Let's not forget that this book won the Booker prize in 2002. Not that I rate every film that won an oscar, but appreciators of the art of novel writing rate this book. Here in a largely scientific, rationalist forum a work of magical storytelling that leaves you with more questions than it answers is perhaps bound to meet with objections. Art (which includes literature) is not science, but science isn't (no, really, it isn't) all. As so often here, I'm reminded of Charles Babbage. I'll let Simon Singh pick up the story: Babbage had spent many years studying death rates, so he was annoyed when he read a verse from Alfred Tennyson's poem The Vision of Sin which contained the lines: "Every moment dies a man, Every moment one is born." Being a keen statistician, Babbage took exception to the line because it implied that the population of the world was static, when in fact it was increasing. He wrote to Tennyson and offered him a correction to his "otherwise beautiful" poem: "I would suggest that in the next edition of your poem you have it read - 'Every moment dies a man, Every moment one and a sixteenth is born.'" |
22nd December 2012, 08:40 PM | #6 |
Critical Thinker
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 311
|
Life of Pi: The poem or the truth?
I just saw the movie and googling after seeing it found this (in here (Spoiler beware, if you have not read the book or seen the movie do not visit the link): http://www.gradesaver.com/life-of-pi...-guide/quotes/ ):
This passage is the last paragraph of Life of Pi. It is an appropriate ending, because it essentially represents Mr. Okamoto accepting Pi's first story, and by extension, accepting God. Funnly, I an Ignostic, prefer the first story.... while my girlfriend, a believer (which does not like organized religion but does believe in the christian God) says that, to stay faithful with the truth, one must disregard the first story and accept only the second... |
__________________
All authority of any kind, especially in the field of thought and understanding, is the most destructive, evil thing. Leaders destroy the followers and followers destroy the leaders. You have to be your own teacher and your own disciple. You have to question everything that man has accepted as valuable, as necessary. |
|
23rd December 2012, 02:24 AM | #7 |
Muse
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 920
|
I picked up the book for no other reason than its mention in Katawa Shoujo. I thought the story was well-written, but the author's message was wishy-washy, immature, and a bit smug. Almost stopped reading entirely at the ridiculous "atheist deathbed conversion" line, but ended up continuing and skimming through the rest.
Embracing ignorance, faith for the sake of faith, your brain is god, etc. It's the philosophy of someone who has just broken out of an angsty phase, but hasn't actually progressed beyond it. |
23rd December 2012, 04:28 AM | #8 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
I started a thread on this question, but it got bogged down with pettifogging.
I went to this movie expecting to see some attempt to "prove God", as the visitor says to Pi early on. What I saw was Pi surviving. Big deal. Ship sinks, all the animals except one eventually die, and Pi's family and the crew die as well. Nice god you got there. I also found his multi-disciplinary attitude amusing. |
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
23rd December 2012, 04:52 AM | #9 |
Non credunt, semper verificare
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Sigil, the city of doors
Posts: 14,571
|
I have actually a different take on this.
|
23rd December 2012, 04:56 AM | #10 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
My issue is they come right out and say "And prove God" in the movie. Pi does the standard dodge there, but it's out there and some folks will come away saying, "Yeah, it did" without thinking. (This is fallout from a debate I'm having with a fundy over this elsewhere, so it may sound disjointed, with good reason.)
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
23rd December 2012, 01:15 PM | #11 |
Thinker
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 203
|
I've yet to see the movie, but did read the book 4 or 5 years ago.
The whole god-bothering thing completely passed me by. Pi is Richard Parker, the other animals being those people that made it into the lifeboat, too. The choice that is explicitly not given is that Pi, rather than being blessed by god(s) to survive his ordeal, has been the ultimate survivor without any divine intervention. He wasn't 'allowed' to survive, he just did, by the all that was within him to do so. Isn't it a much 'better' story to pretend that fluffy-wuffy Pi isn't the deluded predator inside us all? |
__________________
- CTB " ...in the land of the blind the one-eyed man is not king, for he can never get folks to see things his way." |
|
23rd December 2012, 01:53 PM | #12 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
23rd December 2012, 05:21 PM | #13 |
Philosophile
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Osaka, Japan
Posts: 35,981
|
|
23rd December 2012, 05:39 PM | #14 |
Thinker
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 203
|
|
__________________
- CTB " ...in the land of the blind the one-eyed man is not king, for he can never get folks to see things his way." |
|
23rd December 2012, 05:40 PM | #15 |
Atheist Tergiversator
Join Date: Jun 2007
Location: New Jersey
Posts: 3,103
|
Is it true the movie is 3.14 hours long?
|
__________________
"One of the hardest parts of being an active skeptic - of anything - is knowing when to cut your losses, and then doing so." -Phil Plait |
|
23rd December 2012, 05:52 PM | #16 |
Sorcerer Supreme
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Austin, Texas
Posts: 7,905
|
I'm not a fundy nor even a theist but I gush over this film. Taken purely as an adventure story with a subplot about the question of gods' existence, it's a masterful work of art and a thrilling cinematic experience. I'm interested in knowing about these plot holes you're certain you've discovered. Let's discuss them, if you're game.
|
__________________
"I'm 'willing to admit' any fact that can be shown to be evidential and certain." -- Vortigern99 "When the power of love overcomes the love of power the world will know peace." -- Jimi Hendrix |
|
23rd December 2012, 05:55 PM | #17 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
23rd December 2012, 05:57 PM | #18 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
23rd December 2012, 06:02 PM | #19 |
Philosophile
Join Date: Dec 2009
Location: Osaka, Japan
Posts: 35,981
|
|
23rd December 2012, 06:49 PM | #20 |
Critical Thinker
Join Date: Dec 2012
Posts: 462
|
Never read the book but saw the movie.
I think the movie was more about mental health when faced with traumatic experiences. Pi couldn't deal with what he witnessed, and what he did. So his mind conjured up the images of animals to help preserve (what was left of) his sanity. The rest of the boat story deals with him wrestling the new animal he's unleashed. BTW If you've seen the movie you might recall Richard Parker symbolically jumping out from underneath Pi's crotch, right as the hyena is attacking the orangutan. |
23rd December 2012, 07:53 PM | #21 |
Muse
Join Date: Mar 2009
Posts: 787
|
Inversely, I have read the book but not seen the movie. The book was awful, so I have no desire to see the movie.
The book doesn't seek to "prove" that God exists. It simply tries to posit that, in the complete absence of any evidence on either side, it's better to believe than to not believe, because it makes a better story. Sadly, that deeply annoyed me. I would prefer to believe in fairies, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster (may His Noodles be praised), but I will wait until I have a reasonable shot at the actual truth. |
23rd December 2012, 08:41 PM | #22 |
Philosopher
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 5,449
|
I see what you did there..
I read the book about 10 years ago on a trip through Thailand when all the hippies were raving about it. I liked it, for sure, right up until the end. OK the sargassum island was stretching however I refrained from admitting to anyone that I didn't "get it" in that the book was supposed to be some sort of life changing insight into metaphysics and religion. I just liked it as a story, I like tigers. Yea, I'm shallow. Maybe the book was suggesting that it doesn't matter what you believe as long as it brings you comfort ? |
24th December 2012, 01:40 AM | #23 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Nov 2002
Location: Sir Fynwy
Posts: 37,582
|
|
24th December 2012, 05:09 AM | #24 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
That's what bugged me. "You'll finally see proof of God!" from a person who was bugging me to read the book, hoping it would "cure my atheism". Sadly for him, I wasn't impressed.
Quote:
BTW, ever wonder about the tiger and the baboon being under the cover together without fighting?
Quote:
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
24th December 2012, 06:04 AM | #25 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,054
|
Thanks a lot.
I had no interest in this movie or the book. Now I want to see it. |
24th December 2012, 06:13 AM | #26 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
24th December 2012, 06:54 AM | #27 |
Illuminator
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 4,054
|
|
24th December 2012, 08:50 AM | #28 |
NWO Litter Technician
Join Date: May 2004
Location: Looks like Finland. Smells like Finland. Quacks like Finland. Where the hell am I?
Posts: 15,161
|
I saw the trailer for this last week when we went to see The Hobbit. I think it was the first time I almost died of boredom while watching a movie trailer.
|
__________________
When I was a kid I used to pray every night for a new bicycle. Then I realised that the Lord, in his wisdom, doesn't work that way. I just stole one and asked Him to forgive me. - Emo Philips
|
|
24th December 2012, 12:11 PM | #29 |
Muse
Join Date: Dec 2010
Posts: 617
|
i watched the movie a couple of weeks ago. very powerful visually, but that's about it, therefore i don't think i would enjoy the book as much.
at the beginning of the movie pi looks into different religions looking beyond the story each one tells to focus on the final message. for this reason i interpret the ending as if the real miracle was the kid surviving for so many months as a castaway and the writer (and viewer) believe the version of the story he's prepared to believe. when pi ends telling both stories and asks the writer which one he believes, the writer is practically trapped because he never got the choice of not believing either one and pi concludes "so it goes with god". maybe i'm wrong and i'm missing the whole point, but that's how i saw it. cheers |
24th December 2012, 12:36 PM | #30 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 32,635
|
Maybe the message is that faith and delusion are the same.
|
__________________
1. He'd never do that. 2. Okay but he's not currently doing it. 3. Okay but he's not currently technically doing it. 4. Okay but everyone does it. 5. He's doing it, we can't stop him, no point in complaining about it. 6. We all knew he was going to do it which... makes it okay somehow. 7. It's perfectly fine that's he's doing it. |
|
24th December 2012, 12:47 PM | #31 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
24th December 2012, 02:09 PM | #32 |
Philosopher
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 5,449
|
Wow, that must have been a cool gig. Right after reading the book I went to this place. That was before it became controversial and of course I got a completely different story about the origins and purpose of the place than anything I've subsequently read online.
While posing with the tiger I was thinking of myself spending time with it on a lifeboat. I believe in beer too |
24th December 2012, 02:13 PM | #33 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
24th December 2012, 04:52 PM | #34 |
Penultimate Amazing
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Way way north of Diddy Wah Diddy
Posts: 36,113
|
That certainly is one of the possible messages one can get from the book. I have not seen (and am in no hurry to see) the movie, but the book leaves a good deal of room for an interpretation, not so much that we should use the wrong side of Ockham's razor, but that this is what religion does.
|
__________________
Like many humorless and indignant people, he is hard on everybody but himself, and does not perceive it when he fails his own ideal (Molière) A pedant is a man who studies a vacuum through instruments that allow him to draw cross-sections of the details (John Ciardi) |
|
25th December 2012, 04:16 PM | #35 |
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 58,581
|
Guy on a lifeboat can't handle the truth, hallucinates a lot.
|
25th December 2012, 04:19 PM | #36 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
25th December 2012, 09:54 PM | #37 |
Critical Thinker
Join Date: Apr 2011
Posts: 311
|
|
__________________
All authority of any kind, especially in the field of thought and understanding, is the most destructive, evil thing. Leaders destroy the followers and followers destroy the leaders. You have to be your own teacher and your own disciple. You have to question everything that man has accepted as valuable, as necessary. |
|
26th December 2012, 04:33 AM | #38 |
121.92-meter mutant fire-breathing lizard-thingy
Join Date: Nov 2009
Location: Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Posts: 42,180
|
I sometimes think the second version was bolted on to end of that story because the author thought a pure fantasy story wouldn't sell.
|
__________________
Guns that are instantly available for use are instantly available for misuse. World War II Diplomatic and Political Resources Hyperwar, WWII Military History Buying conspiracy books is a voluntary tax on stupid. |
|
26th December 2012, 04:34 PM | #39 |
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 58,581
|
|
26th December 2012, 04:36 PM | #40 |
Banned
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 58,581
|
Last hallucination before the whole thing recirculates is Jack Nicholson in a Marine uniform and Joker make-up screaming " You want the truth!!? You can't handle the truth!!!) Fade to Black.
Pi wakes up back on the ship. Hears an alarm........... Re-enters the Twilo Zone. Eats walnuts as he waits in his lifeboat. Not alone. VERY not alone................Fade to black with blood red trailing down from the top........ |
Thread Tools | |
|
|