StopSylviaBrowne: Browne & "The Mentalizer"

I didnt see this show but did read a bit about this on the previous thread. It sounds like Sylvia was wrongly assuming Segev was promoting himself as a John Edward or van Praagh. If I were a fan, I would be either 1) wondering why, as a psychic, she did not know he was not doing anything supernatural (as he himself plainly states on his web site), or 2) if she was just going along with the show, essentially using her reputation to promote something she did not believe was valid, then I would have to question her integrity. Nice work, Robert!
 
Segev: Nothing is special about it. You really need to see it from up close. Watch it very closely as it happens

[...]

Segev: To the camera, so they can see how it happens!

[The spoon appears to bend even further.]

Browne: That's right. That's right. It's called kinetic energy.

Sylvia hasn't been doing very well with English, and now she's branching out into physics? I give her an "F" for FAIL.

Thanks for the article Robert. :)
 
I must say that Segev seems to be treading the fine line that Kreskin walked.

"Though I'm not a real psychic, only a psychic entertainer and as always I want everyone to know I don't have supernatural powers - - - my powers are so natural it's superb :-)"

Kreskin too used to make a point of saying that what he does is NOT supernatural or paranormal, but the part of pretending to have powers got to be bigger and bigger until now it seems maybe he's professing supernatural powers.

I understand that Segev probably wouldn't have been given air time on the Montel show if he made his disclaimer then, but as it is, most of the audience saw him as another psychic. Being new to the U.S. isn't an excuse, since he should know all about Uri Geller.

I hope that this incident and especially his interaction with you, Robert, will keep Segev from going to the "dark side". I hope learning how much easier it is to make money as a psychic than as a mentalist doesn't sway him to go that route.

Who knows, maybe this incident will encourage Segev to be more outspoken against those who make supernatural claims.
 
Well done as usual, Robert!

May the Light of Diogenes shine ever brighter through your efforts.
 
I must say that Segev seems to be treading the fine line that Kreskin walked.

"Though I'm not a real psychic, only a psychic entertainer and as always I want everyone to know I don't have supernatural powers - - - my powers are so natural it's superb :-)"

Kreskin too used to make a point of saying that what he does is NOT supernatural or paranormal, but the part of pretending to have powers got to be bigger and bigger until now it seems maybe he's professing supernatural powers.

What he means is that he doesn't have any supernatural powers. On the contrary, his powers are VERY natural. Never take claims by magicians litertally, as many of them try to keep themselves somewhat myterious. What matters is that he denies having powers.

Who knows, maybe this incident will encourage Segev to be more outspoken against those who make supernatural claims.

He's already been outspoken about this.


Great article, Robert.
 
Last edited:
What he means is that he doesn't have any supernatural powers. On the contrary, his powers are VERY natural. Never take claims by magicians litertally, as many of them try to keep themselves somewhat myterious. What matters is that he denies having powers.



He's already been outspoken about this.
I think you misread my comments, DJM. I know he is not claiming supernatural powers, and I know that in places other than his appearance on the Montel show he is outspoken on this point.

If I'm not mistaken, though, he said nothing on the Montel Show to inform viewers that Sylvia's comments about what he is doing were wrong. He did not deny supernatural powers on the Montel show, right?

(I understand there's a catch-22: if he had said something, it would not have made it on the air. If he disagreed to their urging him to behave himself toward Sylvia, he probably would never have been on at all.)

Again, I hope the allure of easy money doesn't get the better of him.
 
"Kinetic Energy"? I find those people insulting... They use words like "energy" and "metaphysics" without actually knowing what they mean, and now every time I utter those words people think I am affiliated with the New Age Nutjobs.
 
Kudos to Ehud for e-mailing back all the people to clarify his lack of supernatural skills. He could have just let it be and let these folks continue to believe. Of course they probably still do and think that Ehud actually does possess psychic powers and he just doesn't know it or is lying to them.
 
If I'm not mistaken, though, he said nothing on the Montel Show to inform viewers that Sylvia's comments about what he is doing were wrong. He did not deny supernatural powers on the Montel show, right?

(I understand there's a catch-22: if he had said something, it would not have made it on the air. If he disagreed to their urging him to behave himself toward Sylvia, he probably would never have been on at all.)

Again, I hope the allure of easy money doesn't get the better of him.

Segev was invited to do a mentalism routine, which is exactly what he did. Montel called him a mentalist, and even said the word "tricks" a few times. It's not his fault that Sylvia started with her pyschic nonsense, and he did make it very clear that what he does is illusions, when people asked him about that after the show. He was probably too busy concentrating on his routine and impress the viewers on his American TV debute, rather than pay attention to Sylvia's remarks. Not sure what easy money has to do with it.
 
I'm liking Ehud more and more.
Me too.

Excellent article, Robert. The quote from Segev was gold.
Thanks, Gr8!

I didnt see this show but did read a bit about this on the previous thread. It sounds like Sylvia was wrongly assuming Segev was promoting himself as a John Edward or van Praagh.
More like Geller, I'd think.

If I were a fan, I would be either 1) wondering why, as a psychic, she did not know he was not doing anything supernatural (as he himself plainly states on his web site), or 2) if she was just going along with the show, essentially using her reputation to promote something she did not believe was valid, then I would have to question her integrity.
Well put. Where were you when I was writing the article? :)

Nice work, Robert!
Thanks, ExM!

Sylvia hasn't been doing very well with English, and now she's branching out into physics? I give her an "F" for FAIL.
:D

Thanks for the article Robert. :)
Thanks, Slyjoe!

I must say that Segev seems to be treading the fine line that Kreskin walked.
It is a fine line, but I think that Segev is staying on the correct side of it.

"Though I'm not a real psychic, only a psychic entertainer and as always I want everyone to know I don't have supernatural powers - - - my powers are so natural it's superb :-)"
I think he is stating it as plainly as he can while still retaining at lease a wink and a nod towards the "mystery".

Kreskin too used to make a point of saying that what he does is NOT supernatural or paranormal, but the part of pretending to have powers got to be bigger and bigger until now it seems maybe he's professing supernatural powers.
Agreed.

I hope that this incident and especially his interaction with you, Robert, will keep Segev from going to the "dark side". I hope learning how much easier it is to make money as a psychic than as a mentalist doesn't sway him to go that route.
He does not strike me as being that type.

Who knows, maybe this incident will encourage Segev to be more outspoken against those who make supernatural claims.
I think he was pretty outspoken in his Phenomenon exit interview.

Well done as usual, Robert!
Thanks, Fnord!

Never take claims by magicians litertally, as many of them try to keep themselves somewhat myterious. What matters is that he denies having powers.
Agreed.

Great article, Robert.
Thanks, DJM! By the way, at the last minute before putting the article up, I noticed a misplaced apostrophe in the article's subtitle! :D

If I'm not mistaken, though, he said nothing on the Montel Show to inform viewers that Sylvia's comments about what he is doing were wrong. He did not deny supernatural powers on the Montel show, right?
He addressed that somewhat in his email to me.

"Kinetic Energy"? I find those people insulting... They use words like "energy" and "metaphysics" without actually knowing what they mean, and now every time I utter those words people think I am affiliated with the New Age Nutjobs.
Whatever you do, don't mention the word "Quantum"...
 
This is the only excerpt from a Williams show that I have actually enjoyed. At no point did I feel that Segev was pretending to have supernatural powers, but rather he seemed to be gently chiding Browne for her mendacity.
 
Segev was invited to do a mentalism routine, which is exactly what he did. Montel called him a mentalist, and even said the word "tricks" a few times.
I will watch it again to see if that's so. I'm sure Ehud corrected Montel at least once when he said he was a "mentalist" saying instead that he is "the mentalizer".

In the context, I would much rather see a magician repeat that these are illusions. The caption below his face said "able to perform amazing feats using his mind." Montel's intro said something about "mental power" IIRC.

That business about "he was always different--even as a child"--and "when did you notice you were different?" surely implies something other than a guy who decided to be a magician and learned sleight of hand and mentalist techniques. He spun it to be about how he didn't have a lot of friends, which treads that fine line again--not lying, but careful not to say anything incompatible with the paranormal interpretation.

Segev failed to correct several of Sylvia's comments ("He's really doing it" and "It's kinetic energy" and "that's proof that we're all connected"), so it's no surprise that a great number of Montel's audience members thought this was yet another "paranormal" demonstration.

Remember, some of these people even believe that overt magicians really have paranormal powers and are somehow deluded into thinking what they're doing are just illusions.

Again, I find it difficult to believe that he's so new to the U.S. that he didn't know (or didn't find out) about the kind of show he was appearing on and who the co-hosts were.

RSLancaster said:
JoeTheJuggler said:
If I'm not mistaken, though, he said nothing on the Montel Show to inform viewers that Sylvia's comments about what he is doing were wrong. He did not deny supernatural powers on the Montel show, right?
He addressed that somewhat in his email to me.
I appreciate that--and it shows again how very important your website is. I repeat, I hope you have a greater influence on him than Sylvia and Montel and their big bucks. I do hope you'll correspond with him more before he appears on Montel again.

By the way, is "The Friday Show with Sylvia" going to be something regular on Montel? It almost sounds like they're preparing a spin-off show where she is the host.
 
I will watch it again to see if that's so. I'm sure Ehud corrected Montel at least once when he said he was a "mentalist" saying instead that he is "the mentalizer".

In the context, I would much rather see a magician repeat that these are illusions. The caption below his face said "able to perform amazing feats using his mind." Montel's intro said something about "mental power" IIRC.

He said he's the Mentalizer because that's his stage name. He was there mostly for PR, that's the purpose of such appearances. You won't find many magicians/mentalists who say what they do is illusions before or during their act, as it would break the illusion. I think you are taking this way too seriously.

Thanks, DJM! By the way, at the last minute before putting the article up, I noticed a misplaced apostrophe in the article's subtitle! :D

I'm starting to think you got a real Master's Degree in English that you are hiding from us. ;)
 
Last edited:
At the risk of being a party-pooper, I can imagine supporters of Sylvia saying that since she was so taken in by this, that supports her since it demonstrates she has no other dealings with these kind of techniques. From the article I get the impression he did only sleight-of-hand. No actual mentalist tricks, like guessing a word chosen at random from a book, etc.

As for "wouldn't a psychic know these were sleight of hand tricks", are you saying that her spirit guide should've given her a heads-up on the situation?

But it's a nice light-hearted article. I liked Sylvia's inappropriate use of the phrase "kinetic energy".
 
This is the only excerpt from a Williams show that I have actually enjoyed.
Yes, Segev did a good job, despite Browne's nonsense. He's a very personable guy, and "sold" the routines very well.

In the context, I would much rather see a magician repeat that these are illusions.
That is ideal, sure. But given Segev's openness about it on his site, I find it hard to fault him for it, particularly give the time constraints he was working with.

I appreciate that--and it shows again how very important your website is. I repeat, I hope you have a greater influence on him than Sylvia and Montel and their big bucks.
I don't know that I have any influence on him at all. He was open and honest about the whole thing on his site from the day the show was first broadcast.

I do hope you'll correspond with him more before he appears on Montel again.
Given his very public statements about Browne, I'm not holding my breath waiting for his next Montel gig.

By the way, is "The Friday Show with Sylvia" going to be something regular on Montel? It almost sounds like they're preparing a spin-off show where she is the host.
If you'll notice, that particular episode was aired almost two years ago. I dont know if that format was ever tried again. Browne seemed to make for a pretty surly co-host.

I'm starting to think you got a real Master's Degree in English that you are hiding from us. ;)
If so, I'm hiding it from me too! :)

At the risk of being a party-pooper, I can imagine supporters of Sylvia saying that since she was so taken in by this, that supports her since it demonstrates she has no other dealings with these kind of techniques.
Some of them, certainly. But not all. This article, like most (if not all) on the site is not meant to be the "smoking gun" which should convince everyone. But I firmly believe (and my email tends to bear this out) that each article on the site is the "last straw" for some group of people. I'm hoping the same is true of this one. And each article adds to the site's momentum as well.

From the article I get the impression he did only sleight-of-hand. No actual mentalist tricks, like guessing a word chosen at random from a book, etc.
Well, I would categorize even the sleight-of-hand he did as "actual mentalist's tricks," given the way they were presented. But he did one final trick more along the lines of what you are talking about. It was rather rushed, so I didn't get the whole setup, but he had Williams "pick a word," and then showed a video which had been shot the previous week in which Segev showed the word appearing on a marquee in Times Square.

As for "wouldn't a psychic know these were sleight of hand tricks", are you saying that her spirit guide should've given her a heads-up on the situation?
She does not claim that all of her "psychic insights" come through "Francine." Browne promotes herself as an expert in all things paranormal. For instance, in her book "Secrets and Mysteries of the World," she pontificates on just about every woo concept you can think of.

But it's a nice light-hearted article.
Thanks!
 
Thumbs up on the story from me, too!

My reaction is the same as yours: Browne has a vested interest in encouraging people NOT to question things. If she took the position that another's "powers" ought to be critically analyzed, then she would tacitly be inviting people to critically analyze her performance, too.

Sad to say, Sylvia is not the only one with a vested interest in gullability. Many "mainstream" churches won't criticize cultish nonsense rationally, thinking that it would open up their own brands of supernaturalism to criticism. (And they're right; it would.) I am pleased to note, however, that there are also many mainstream churches that critically examine not only the supernatural beliefs of others, but their own as well. They hold to the moral principle that it is better to be more knowledgeable and less awe-struck than it is to be in a state of open-mouthed wonder due to sheer ignorance and gullibility.
 
As for "wouldn't a psychic know these were sleight of hand tricks", are you saying that her spirit guide should've given her a heads-up on the situation?

But it's a nice light-hearted article. I liked Sylvia's inappropriate use of the phrase "kinetic energy".

Just as a side note, as the token ex-minister thought I'd clarify that Sylvia has always maintained that Francine doesn't help her in the reading room at all. She claims to be psychic from birth, with no help from Francine whatsoever. "Direct communication" with her spirit guide, according to her, is a manifestation of her so-called psychic ability but it's only part of it. :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom