The state of affairs in any particular field of science

fls

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 14, 2005
Messages
10,226
Reading the Shroud of Turin thread reminds me of a question that has a lot of relevance to many of our topics. How do you get an idea of the state of affairs in any particular field? How do you discover the general consensus in regards to a particular idea, and does 'general consensus' represent the largest minority, a rapidly diminishing majority (as in a paradigm shift), an overwhelming majority, or tiny vocal minority?

I'm looking for insights and ideas from others, and maybe gain some understanding of why some people seem to come up with odd results.

Linda
 
Nobody has time to read journal articles from every discipline. Therefore, I recommend Scientific American...

:)
 
How do you discover the general consensus in regards to a particular idea, and does 'general consensus' represent the largest minority, a rapidly diminishing majority (as in a paradigm shift), an overwhelming majority, or tiny vocal minority?
If you asked ten different epistemologists this same question, you'd get fifteen different answers.
 
The state of affairs in any particular field of science

I can state that as a member of a particular field of science, I have never had an affair.
 
I think you're asking an important question. I don't have a single answer, because my procedure is usually dependent on the alleged field of study.

If it's immunology, I probably have a good handle on any actual consensus papers, but if not, I'll ask my colleagues.

For medicine, I usually ask my wife and her colleagues. They ususally don't know about subjects outside their field, but can point me in the right direction. If there's a Cochrane, I'll favour it, but Cochrane doesn't cover a lot of subjects.

For anything else, I usually take a stab at some online communities that have participants in said field, and ask their opinion about their profession's take on the topic.
 
:)

I was curious as to what you would do.

Linda

Define field. Generaly running a search and seeing which papers have been cited the most times in the last couple of years should give you some idea.
 
The state of affairs in any particular field of science

I can state that as a member of a particular field of science, I have never had an affair.

You have to tell us which field so we know what to avoid. ;)

Nobody has time to read journal articles from every discipline. Therefore, I recommend Scientific American...

:)

I think you're asking an important question. I don't have a single answer, because my procedure is usually dependent on the alleged field of study.

If it's immunology, I probably have a good handle on any actual consensus papers, but if not, I'll ask my colleagues.

For medicine, I usually ask my wife and her colleagues. They ususally don't know about subjects outside their field, but can point me in the right direction. If there's a Cochrane, I'll favour it, but Cochrane doesn't cover a lot of subjects.

I also tend to survey mainstream sources.

For anything else, I usually take a stab at some online communities that have participants in said field, and ask their opinion about their profession's take on the topic.

How do you sort out whose opinion is reliable? As we all know, lots of people who don't know what they're talking about are content to speak authoritatively in these forums.

Define field.

Whatever it needs to be to make sense. :)

Generaly running a search and seeing which papers have been cited the most times in the last couple of years should give you some idea.

I hadn't really thought of that. Thanks.

So what do you do if you come across an idea that sounds intriguing, but isn't yet mainstream? Or those of you who are suspicious of mainstream sources, where do you look?

Linda
 
Last edited:
I was curious as to what you would do.
Try to ease the frustration of encountering an unsolvable problem by making an attempt at humor. If a consensus on this question emerges among the posters here, and we are able to identify it, we might try to dissect the process that produced it, as well as that by which we identified it, but I think we'd be attempting to capture analytically a process which takes place intuitively. How do you get an idea of the state of affairs in any particular field? How do you get an idea about anything? I'm not sure any amount of effort would produce a better answer than "it's just something you develop a feel for". I'd also be concerned that the entire undertaking seems to begin with some underlying assumptions having to do with a conflation of truth with authority, so even if there is a better answer, I'd be careful how I applied it.

Wish I could be of more help.
 
Try to ease the frustration of encountering an unsolvable problem by making an attempt at humor. If a consensus on this question emerges among the posters here, and we are able to identify it, we might try to dissect the process that produced it, as well as that by which we identified it, but I think we'd be attempting to capture analytically a process which takes place intuitively. How do you get an idea of the state of affairs in any particular field? How do you get an idea about anything? I'm not sure any amount of effort would produce a better answer than "it's just something you develop a feel for". I'd also be concerned that the entire undertaking seems to begin with some underlying assumptions having to do with a conflation of truth with authority, so even if there is a better answer, I'd be careful how I applied it.

Wish I could be of more help.

I think many (most? some?) of us recognize these sorts of problems and assumptions underlie the process. Since we haven't thrown up our hands in despair, I'm just wondering about what sort of personal strategies others are using to make an attempt. I wasn't thinking that the results would lead to some sort of prescription or go so far as to provide epistemological validity. My ambitions are more trivial than you're implying. :)

Linda
 
Last edited:
I also tend to survey mainstream sources...

...So what do you do if you come across an idea that sounds intriguing, but isn't yet mainstream? Or those of you who are suspicious of mainstream sources, where do you look?

Linda

I wasn't being facetious when I recommended SciAm. Outside of our particular jobs/areas, who amongst us is qualified to dispute particular articles?

The more general the publication, the easier to dispute articles, so we may have a fighting chance at disputing the Palookaville Post. However, even that's not a guarantee...
 
I wasn't being facetious when I recommended SciAm.

I didn't think you were. I was lumping it in with other mainstream sources, but I should have commented that it was very useful suggestion.

Outside of our particular jobs/areas, who amongst us is qualified to dispute particular articles?

The more general the publication, the easier to dispute articles, so we may have a fighting chance at disputing the Palookaville Post. However, even that's not a guarantee...

Especially since, in the right hands, most anything can be made to sound equally plausible or implausible.

Linda
 
In my field (Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care) there is an international consensus meeting once every five years. From that a consensus on science with treatment recommendations is produced and national expert groups then adapt it to fit with local practice.

Works well generally and if something important crops up midway between meetings the core group review it and issue a statement.
 
I'm looking for insights and ideas from others, and maybe gain some understanding of why some people seem to come up with odd results.

Find someone in the field that's smart, informed, and near the beginning of their career (so not too invested in any particular set of ideas) and ask them.
 
I didn't think you were. I was lumping it in with other mainstream sources, but I should have commented that it was very useful suggestion.

The problem with lumping anything, and calling something mainstream, is that there could be an implication of product inferiority. I was reacting more strongly to your claim that someone might be suspicious of 'mainstream' sources, including pubs like SciAm (and I keep listing it by name to distinguish between that and other fan mags like: Popular Science and Discover). I'm not sure that suspicion can always be justified.

It's related to something I was asking last year in another thread, mainly: what qualifications do many of us have to make serious comments on cutting-edge cosmology? I probably know more about physics than I do about any other academic discipline, yet I wouldn't dare to make to make too many authoritative statements regarding the high-end theoretical cosmology stuff.

Case in point (and here, SciAm provides a good example): I remember an issue a couple years back which talked about Loop Quantum Gravity. They're usually pretty good at pointing out when a hypothesis has an alternative. LQG is not universally accepted by the scientific community. However, it's not for me to pass judgement. I read the articles with incredible interest, but at the end of the day, reserve judgement... and wait for future articles! :D

Especially since, in the right hands, most anything can be made to sound equally plausible or implausible.

Linda

... this is true for non-scientific disciplines as well. My wife is a cop. You should hear her rant and rave about factual inaccuracies and downright lies in the local news. ;)
 
If there's a Cochrane, I'll favour it, but Cochrane doesn't cover a lot of subjects.

Uggh... The Cochrane Database is, generally speaking, the worst invention to come about in the field of "medical research" in a long time. I never 'metanalysis' I liked. This has produced, in my opinion, much of the confusing, retrospective, data-mining publication diarrhea that has served, in many cases, to do a better job of confusing clinicians and the lay public than actually clarifying important medical problems. You can't prove everything with a cobbled-together studies, especially post hoc and often disparate ones. Some see power in this methodology; I see dilution and confusion.

-Dr. Imago
 
The problem with lumping anything, and calling something mainstream, is that there could be an implication of product inferiority. I was reacting more strongly to your claim that someone might be suspicious of 'mainstream' sources, including pubs like SciAm (and I keep listing it by name to distinguish between that and other fan mags like: Popular Science and Discover). I'm not sure that suspicion can always be justified.

Whether or not it's justified, I just wanted to recognize that it's out there. So far, I don't think the people who have responded here take that perspective. But I am curious about what people who are suspicious do instead. I don't know how to get them to show up here, though. Maybe I need to start making inflammatory statements.

You can always trust mainstream ideas.

It's related to something I was asking last year in another thread, mainly: what qualifications do many of us have to make serious comments on cutting-edge cosmology? I probably know more about physics than I do about any other academic discipline, yet I wouldn't dare to make to make too many authoritative statements regarding the high-end theoretical cosmology stuff.

Case in point (and here, SciAm provides a good example): I remember an issue a couple years back which talked about Loop Quantum Gravity. They're usually pretty good at pointing out when a hypothesis has an alternative. LQG is not universally accepted by the scientific community. However, it's not for me to pass judgement. I read the articles with incredible interest, but at the end of the day, reserve judgement... and wait for future articles! :D

But you are able to tell from the articles which ideas you should reserve judgement on. I think. This is one of the things I am getting at.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom