StopSylviaBrowne - Montel: Anthony Urciuoli Jr. Reading

Another excellent job, Robert. This woman is just despicable, and, while all the work you do takes huge amounts of time and energy, you are making a huge difference. Kudos.

In other words, this insane guy says, 'You won't have anything to do with this girl.' ... And offed him.
"Offed him"? Psychic or not, what person with any amount of empathy or human compassion, would say this to parents about their missing son?

I was so glad to see you comment on this. I just winced when I read her statement. That comment is simply inexcusably cold, and horrendous even by Sylvia standards. What a terrible thing for grieving parents to hear. The woman's depth of callousness never ceases to astound and infuriate me.

Excellent work.
 
Another excellent article, Robert. :)

It feels as though the Browne dubunking is gathering momentum with more and more people doubting her, largely due to youtube, and, of course your fantastic site.
Hopefully the cancellation of Montel will finish off her TV career, but I wouldn't be suprised if some network or other approaches her for a 'Crossing Over With John Edward' style show.
 
Great article, Robert! I watched the video and it seemed to me that none of Tony's family was convinced by anything Sylvia said. I could be wrong, of course, but to me they did not look convinced at the story she spun about "Rudy" and "Cynthia" and the love triangle aspect. I'm glad that Lisa tried to get Sylvia to say something useful but of course Sylvia didn't. And telling them that they do indeed "have closure because he's on the Other Side and rings doorbells and phones and stuff" was just plain silly and dismissive of their pain. :(
 
Last edited:
Very nice article, RSL. It's hard to fathom how she could so callously and cruelly say their son was "offed."

I thought it was especially good that you included the contact info for anyone with information. I hope it will encourage other families of missing persons who have had readings with SB to come forward and talk to you, knowing that it will not only help expose SB but also be another avenue of publicity for them, any and all of which are so valuable.

I feel so bad for these families. There was a time I would have done the same, looked to psychics for answers if this had happened to me. Now I don't think I could run fast enough to get away.
 
It's great that you're finally writing these up, Robert. I've been waiting for them for a long time.

Speaking of which, aren't you forgetting to thank QG? I know the man bailed on us and left us with all the work, but still. :p
 
Another excellent job, Robert. This woman is just despicable, and, while all the work you do takes huge amounts of time and energy, you are making a huge difference. Kudos.
Thanks, Empress.

I was so glad to see you comment on this. I just winced when I read her statement. That comment is simply inexcusably cold, and horrendous even by Sylvia standards. What a terrible thing for grieving parents to hear. The woman's depth of callousness never ceases to astound and infuriate me.
It was just... unbelievable harsh.

I have never seen her use the phrase before. And I have to wonder, given the apparent racism that she has shown elsewhere, if she somehow thought it was somehow okay/appropriate to use the phrase to a family of Italian descent. I considered mentioning this in the article, but decided against it.

Another sad tale; excellent job RSL.
Thanks, Locknar.

Another excellent article, Robert. :)

It feels as though the Browne dubunking is gathering momentum with more and more people doubting her, largely due to youtube, and, of course your fantastic site.
Thanks, Cecily.

Hopefully the cancellation of Montel will finish off her TV career, but I wouldn't be suprised if some network or other approaches her for a 'Crossing Over With John Edward' style show.
I have heard hints that she may be appearing on other talk shows, and am in the process of putting together an article encouraging people to write letters to the shows involved, letting the producers know how they feel.

I can't imagine her having a Crossing Over style show without a Montel there to run interference for her. Her callousness, and frequent obliviousness to what is going on, would be too obvious. I'd think so, any way.

Great article, Robert!
Thanks, Minarvia!

I watched the video and it seemed to me that none of Tony's family was convinced by anything Sylvia said.
That's the way it seemed to me as well.

Very nice article, RSL. It's hard to fathom how she could so callously and cruelly say their son was "offed."
Thanks, ExM.

I thought it was especially good that you included the contact info for anyone with information.
I did that for the other missing person case on the site which is as yet unsolved. I plan to do it with each of them.

I hope it will encourage other families of missing persons who have had readings with SB to come forward and talk to you, knowing that it will not only help expose SB but also be another avenue of publicity for them, any and all of which are so valuable.
I hadn't thought of it as encouraging other families, although that may well be so. I just felt it was the right thing to do.

I feel so bad for these families. There was a time I would have done the same, looked to psychics for answers if this had happened to me. Now I don't think I could run fast enough to get away.
Funny what a year can do, isn't it? :)
 
Last edited:
In addition to the cruelty pointed out by RSL at the end of the article, she says it again at the end of this spectacularly useless comment about the location of the body:
Browne: It's really hard. If--if--if we were to take--OK, if we were to take a direct--let's say we take a thread or a--and let's say, and--and pull it directly from where he was to where the river was, directly to that part, that's where he would be. Now is it fairly far? Yes, but it doesn't matter. See, where a person is offed doesn't necessarily mean where they're...


Here's a picture of the area where his car was found, with the Spratt Park parking lot labelled. I don't know the exact location, only that it was near the park. Any line drawn directly from the car in any westward direction will lead directly to the river. She'd like us to think that she's talking about point 1, but her comment could lead us to point 2, 3 or an infnite number of other points. Not that it matters since she knows it's a river and the flow would probably carry the body elsewhere anyway.

Oh, and he's now ringing doorbells and making phone calls? Going to the other side makes you an 11-year-old prankster?

Another thing (this woman could be unconscious and still make me mad): So he'll never be found, but the family ought to pay a detective to look for his money. The family is talking about needing closure, and the best the Gruesome Twosome could come up with is "We've done shows about missing money".:jaw-dropp
 
At first, I was thinking it was a little odd since it wasn't proving her wrong, but that "offed" comment is telling. Sounds like she was a bit put out too, when it was suggested they won't have any closure, but yet, that's what she probably thought she was doing.

And I, too, liked the 'If You Can Help' section. I hope someone can. It also gives the article much more meaning. Very nice, indeed.
 
I can't imagine her having a Crossing Over style show without a Montel there to run interference for her. Her callousness, and frequent obviousness to what is going on, would be too obvious. I'd think so, any way.

Robert, I think you meant obliviousness here, and there's a fine example of it in this reading. Anthony, Sr. had just said "He says, 'Dad, I work seven days a week. My friend called me. I'm going to go shoot pool for an hour, and I'll be home.' " Sylvia, not a minute later, says "Now he may have told you that it was, you know, business or whatever, but it wasn't, it was from a female that supposedly was in trouble."

It shows what a poor cold reader she is - she doesn't even listen to her marks half the time.
 
I always wonder why there isn't a stronger reaction by the family when Sylvia is so flippant. I'd be livid if I went to someone for help (a therapist, for example) and they talked about my loved one being 'offed'! I'm sure their desperation for any speck of hope keeps them civil. Thanks for this, Robert.
 
She'd like us to think that she's talking about point 1, but her comment could lead us to point 2, 3 or an infnite number of other points. Not that it matters since she knows it's a river and the flow would probably carry the body elsewhere anyway.
I had considered pointing out this very thing. Perhaps I will add it in, along with your map image, thanks. But yes, it is a statement which - I think intentionally so- lends itself to a myriad of interpretations, thus opening up the widest possibility of claiming a "hit."

And I, too, liked the 'If You Can Help' section. I hope someone can. It also gives the article much more meaning. Very nice, indeed.
Thanks, KT.

Robert, I think you meant obliviousness here
Indeed. Typo fixed, thanks!

It shows what a poor cold reader she is - she doesn't even listen to her marks half the time.
Yup.

I always wonder why there isn't a stronger reaction by the family when Sylvia is so flippant. I'd be livid if I went to someone for help (a therapist, for example) and they talked about my loved one being 'offed'! I'm sure their desperation for any speck of hope keeps them civil.
IO wonder about this to, and one possible explanation is this: These people, whether they believe in Browne's abilities or not, are, above all, interested in getting their missing loved one's face on national television. And perhaps they know that if they let it show on their faces that they know or suspect that Browne is a fraud, the reading may never make it to the air. So they steel themselves to not react in that way.

Thanks for this, Robert.
Thank you, Kate.
 
IO wonder about this to, and one possible explanation is this: These people, whether they believe in Browne's abilities or not, are, above all, interested in getting their missing loved one's face on national television. And perhaps they know that if they let it show on their faces that they know or suspect that Browne is a fraud, the reading may never make it to the air. So they steel themselves to not react in that way.

That, and I'm sure certain facial reactions get edited out before the shows are aired.

This statement was appalling. Extreme even for Browne's usual lack of empathy. Cannot abide that woman.
 
Robert, I think you meant obliviousness here, and there's a fine example of it in this reading...
It shows what a poor cold reader she is - she doesn't even listen to her marks half the time.

Have you read the Skeptic in the Audience article? She was so oblivious to what as going on around her (at least when I saw her) that I'd wonder how she's able to listen and talk to the dead, given that she can barely comprehend what the living are saying to her most of the time.

I always wonder why there isn't a stronger reaction by the family when Sylvia is so flippant. I'd be livid if I went to someone for help (a therapist, for example) and they talked about my loved one being 'offed'! I'm sure their desperation for any speck of hope keeps them civil. Thanks for this, Robert.

When I saw her in person, I was also amazed at the civility of the audience. Long after I'd have exploded, they keep treating her with respect and reverence.

Just my guess but I'd think that since the vast majority of them believe in her, this gives her enormous leverage over them- she's holding them emotionally hostage. Also leads them to be completely oblivious to her behavior, like all the folks telling Robert how nice Sylvia is.

And who would you be comfortable giving someone a piece of their mind or airing their feelings in front of a group of complete strangers? With the episode presumably aired on national TV? With two somewhat powerful and intimidating celebrities involved, no less?

Psychologists talk about the "spiral of silence", as in the reluctance to speak out for a position when one is in a group of people with conflicting views to yours. Imagine being the only one to doubt a psychic in a group of people coming to see that psychic.

"Offed"...

I searched Lexis-Nex is for Sylvia Browne saying "offed" or "was offed" and found only this one instance since the transcripts begin. :mad: Thank goodness she didn't tell them "whacked" or I'd have killed her myself.

I also found it offensive and grating, the number of times she trots out "a female that was involved". What is up with these "females"?

And that she'd use a phrase like "playing around" when talking to grieving parents.:mad:

It could just be me but it occurred to me that she could have thought of "Rudy" because of then-mayor Guiliani but that's probably stretching it a bit too far.

That, and I'm sure certain facial reactions get edited out before the shows are aired.

This statement was appalling. Extreme even for Browne's usual lack of empathy. Cannot abide that woman.

They are. One thing that surprised me about my aired episode is how adeptly the true facial reactions were edited out.

But why are we surprised? She tells victims idiotic, offensive, bizzarre, callous and disgusting things all the time, whether telling someone their wife was killed by a serial killer who enjoyed taking pictures of it or telling someone their mother had gone "goofy" or "funny".

Edit: Also, for a psychic, she seems quite ignorant of the town of Poughkeepsie. She even had to cold-read the name of the Hudson River out of the family!

Reminds me of Groucho Marx asking a psychic "If you're so psychic, what's the capital of North Dakota?"
 
Last edited:
Edit: Also, for a psychic, she seems quite ignorant of the town of Poughkeepsie. She even had to cold-read the name of the Hudson River out of the family!

Well, obviously, that was due to the victim that was "offed" by "Rudy" being too busy ringing doorbells to remember what river he'd been dumped in. We can't expect poor Sylvia to come up with names of rivers without the victim's help, now can we? :rolleyes:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom