Stop Sylvia Browne - Email: "My Sister Margaret and Me"

Robert, a typo for you.

"Browne's having incorrectly told them that they, or a lived one, was going to live a certain length of time."

'loved', shirley?

Although I had to read that sentence about 5 times, each time knowing there was something wrong, and not being able to put my finger on it...

The way that woman brazenly pulls stuff out of her donkey, then attributes it to 'her psychic powers' never fails to amaze* me. Does she not realise what she is saying? Or to whom? Keep her feet to the fire, Robert, Amazing work.

*annoy/repel/astound/induce vomit in/incite violence in - delete as appropriate.
 
People can foolishly ignore a doctor's warning, since Browne told them they would live a long life.

You could put that in bold in your article. So much for "what harm does it?" and "for entertainment only". Very entertaining, indeed. :mad:
 
Same sentence, another little fix - Should be: "...Browne's having incorrectly told them that they, or a loved one, were going to live a certain length of time."

Another good point this article brings up is that in this instance Sylvia was nice, she agreed to read for someone spontaneously at no charge, she appeared to hold the picture and really care, from the way the e-mail is worded...and yet she was wrong and this article shows how badly her being wrong can hurt, regardless of how kindly it's presented.

I believe some people may be reluctant to come forward because they were treated nicely by Sylvia, so even though her false readings/false everything may have done some damage in their life, they're conflicted about it. That, as you know, was partly the case with me for awhile.

Great article, RSL.
 
Hey Robert,

As always, a great piece of work! Well done.

I was just checking your FAQ out and it could stand to be updated :)

Especially the following bits:

www.stopsylviabrowne.com said:
Q: Have you ever met her?

A: As of this writing (November of 2006), no, I have not.

Q: Have you ever read any of her books?

A: As of this writing (November of 2006), I have read one (Adventures of a Psychic) and am in the process of reading another (Prophecy). I have over a dozen more on my shelf.

I intend to read, and comment on, as many of her books as possible in the course of my research.
 
You know, Sylvia could really do with learning those three simple words:

"I don't know"
 
Nice story, Robert, but either I'm missing something or you left a significant piece out.

The email ends with Sylvia telling Peter that Margaret will live a long life, followed by the captioned photo of both of them. You then move directly into your analysis. Did Peter not explicitly say something about when Margaret died? It is clear that she did, but the direct information comes from you and not Peter.
 
Garrette said:
Nice story, Robert, but either I'm missing something or you left a significant piece out.

The email ends with Sylvia telling Peter that Margaret will live a long life, followed by the captioned photo of both of them. You then move directly into your analysis. Did Peter not explicitly say something about when Margaret died? It is clear that she did, but the direct information comes from you and not Peter.


Perhaps you missed the caption under the photo, which mentions her date of death.
 
Last edited:
Just picturing a "psychic" walk into a limo seems wrong on SO many levels. Kind of like how peter poppoff or other preachers take peoples money, and then drive off in their cadillac and go to their million dollar homes.

Sad story, but hopefully it will reach other people and expose this charlatan.
 
I can understand the reasoning behind the attitude of 'what's the harm?' but it still screams of not being able to see the big picture. Thanks for the article and thanks to Peter; he also has my condolences.
 
This Witch said almost the exact same thing to me, and I can totally relate to the authors letter.

At the Atlantic City John Edward/Sylvia Browne lecture in October 2006, I was back stage with Sylvias son Paul and John Edward, standing by her wheelchair, and when she came off stage Paul told her that I needed to ask her a question.

Now, I never had any reason to ever ask Sylvia anything as a psychic, but my best friend had been diagnosed with Lymphoma in July of 06, and wasn't doing well at all. His partner called me and asked me to ask Sylvia what the outcome would be so they could prepare themselves. I really didn't want to ask this question because I knew what the answer would be, but decided to go ahead, knowing that Sylvia would say he has xxx months to live.

So, I told Sylvia that Chris was in stage 4 Lymphoma, and it didn't look like he would make it much longer. Sylvia then tells me it's going to be very rough and very painful for him,but the Cancer will go away and he's going to live a long time.

Needless to say I was very surprised, especially since I had been spending days at the hospital with him and knew exactly what the prognosis was.

Chris died January 31, 2007, had become paralyzed from the neck down due to the Cancer, could barely speak, and I kept thinking about that callous witch Sylvia Browne and how she said he'd make it just fine.

Luckily I did not tell my friend what she told me, instead telling them that there was a small chance but it didn't look good.

Now, I know that Sylvia and her staff would say that he is on the Other Side and is just fine, thus claiming that Sylvia was correct in one aspect, but right then and there I knew she was lying and had just pulled that out of her .........and that was the final straw with my relationship with Sylvia and her front of a church.

Rob
 
Perhaps you missed the caption under the photo, which mentions her date of death.
Oh, sure. Just because I'm the one who made the mistake you feel justified in putting the blame on me. Geez, you skeptics....

Sorry, Robert.

Seriously, though, even though I see now what I missed, I think your analysis would be clearer if you put a quick timeline:

1999: Sylvia says Margaret will beat the cancer and live a long time

2002: Margaret dies of cancer
 
Yet another, in a seemingly endless number, story where SB doles out wrong advice/information with potentially live impacting results. How sad.
 
Not wanting to play skeptical skeptic, but the picture looks slightly odd, like it was combined in photoshop from a head shot and a second picture of a young lady. The person isn't trying to set you up, I hope? You are usually rigorous in your checking up on stories, so I assume it all checked out before you put it up. Sorry, the photo just doesn't look right.

Basilio
 
Not wanting to play skeptical skeptic, but the picture looks slightly odd, like it was combined in photoshop from a head shot and a second picture of a young lady. The person isn't trying to set you up, I hope? You are usually rigorous in your checking up on stories, so I assume it all checked out before you put it up. Sorry, the photo just doesn't look right.

Basilio

You are right regarding the photo. Compared to the woman's photo, the man's picture has a higher black level, has a different lighting and also seems to be a scan from a printed magazine, there's distinct moiré visible. The scaling is a bit off, too. I'm sure Robert does some checking before putting people's photographs online, and maybe the email author mailed that composition because there was no good picture of him together with his sister.
 
Great article, Robert! I'm always excited when I see a post for a new article here.

Seriously, though, even though I see now what I missed, I think your analysis would be clearer if you put a quick timeline:

1999: Sylvia says Margaret will beat the cancer and live a long time

2002: Margaret dies of cancer

I agree. Somehow make her error a bit more obvious for the attention-impaired? (Me included)

Thanks again, Robert.
 
Not wanting to play skeptical skeptic, but the picture looks slightly odd, like it was combined in photoshop from a head shot and a second picture of a young lady. The person isn't trying to set you up, I hope? You are usually rigorous in your checking up on stories, so I assume it all checked out before you put it up. Sorry, the photo just doesn't look right.

Basilio

Yes, even before reading these posts that was my thought also. In fact, I thought it was a Photoshopped Lou Ferrigno at first.
 
Robert, a typo for you.
Fixed, thanks!

The way that woman brazenly pulls stuff out of her donkey, then attributes it to 'her psychic powers' never fails to amaze* me. Does she not realise what she is saying? Or to whom? Keep her feet to the fire, Robert, Amazing work.
Thanks, Soma.

You could put that in bold in your article. So much for "what harm does it?" and "for entertainment only". Very entertaining, indeed. :mad:
Agreed.

Same sentence, another little fix
Fixed, thanks!

Great article, RSL.
Thanks, ex-m!

Hey Robert,

As always, a great piece of work! Well done.
Thanks, Octavo.

I was just checking your FAQ out and it could stand to be updated :)
Yes, it has been on my to-do list for some thime.

You know, Sylvia could really do with learning those three simple words:

"I don't know"
Actually, they should be all she ever says.

Sad story, but hopefully it will reach other people and expose this charlatan.
That's the hope.

Thanks for the article and thanks to Peter; he also has my condolences.
You're welcome, KT.

This Witch said almost the exact same thing to me, and I can totally relate to the authors letter.
Rob, thanks for sharing that. My condolences on the loss of your friend. Would it be all right with you if I put that story up on the site? If so, please send it to me in an email (just cut/paste it is fine) and it will go on the to-do list.

Seriously, though, even though I see now what I missed, I think your analysis would be clearer if you put a quick timeline:

1999: Sylvia says Margaret will beat the cancer and live a long time

2002: Margaret dies of cancer
Um, not to correct you or anything, but Browne said that in 2001, not 1999.

I will consider putting in a timeline, or at least highlighting the dates within the email.

Yet another, in a seemingly endless number, story where SB doles out wrong advice/information with potentially live impacting results. How sad.
Very.

Sorry, the photo just doesn't look right.
For reasons I won't go into, I am pretty comfortable with the story's authenticity.

The oddness of the photo is largely a result of what I did to it in order to make it large enough for the article. The image which was sent to me was a small digital photo OF a framed photo, perhaps on Peter's desk or mantle. It was a little angled (perhaps to avoid relecting the flash in the glass of the frame), and looked as though it may have been taken with a camera phone.

I took that image, cropped it a bit, tried to compensate for the angle, and enlarged it somewhat to make it fit the size I normally use for images in the articles.

So, the image you see in the article is my amateurishly enhanced version of a low-quality digital photo of a photograph in a frame. Thus the artifacts and such which makes it look odd. I have asked Peter if he can supply me with a better copy. We'll see.

I'm sure Robert does some checking before putting people's photographs online, and maybe the email author mailed that composition because there was no good picture of him together with his sister.
See above.

Great article, Robert! I'm always excited when I see a post for a new article here.
Thanks, Chimera.

Yes, even before reading these posts that was my thought also. In fact, I thought it was a Photoshopped Lou Ferrigno at first.
Well, I did have to work hard to take out the green skin...

I understand and appreciate everyone's concern about the pic. I'll see what I can do.
 
Last edited:
RSLancaster said:
Um, not to correct you or anything, but Browne said that in 2001, not 1999.
Then there are further problems.

In the email, Peter says this: I showed Sylvia a picture of my 33-year-old sister and said,

The photo caption says this: In loving Memory of Margaret [last name]: September 2nd 1966 - June 16th 2002

I don't have an advanced degree, but I fairly certain that 1966 + 33 = 1999.

RSLancaster said:
I will consider putting in a timeline, or at least highlighting the dates within the email.
Okay. Thanks.
 
For reasons I won't go into, I am pretty comfortable with the story's authenticity.

The oddness of the photo is largely a result of what I did to it in order to make it large enough for the article. The image which was sent to me was a small digital photo OF a framed photo, perhaps on Peter's desk or mantle. It was a little angled (perhaps to avoid relecting the flash in the glass of the frame), and looked as though it may have been taken with a camera phone.

I took that image, cropped it a bit, tried to compensate for the angle, and enlarged it somewhat to make it fit the size I normally use for images in the articles.

So, the image you see in the article is my amateurishly enhanced version of a low-quality digital photo of a photograph in a frame. Thus the artifacts and such which makes it look odd. I have asked Peter if he can supply me with a better copy. We'll see.

Thanks for the information, Robert. Does that mean that the original, framed photograph was a Photoshop job already?

I certainly don't doubt your trust in the story's authenticity, and I hope I don't come across as a know-it-all, but that photograph looks 100% photoshopped to me. And I am not referring to your cropping and skewing the picture to distort it, but the light, the black levels and what I consider Moiré, they are just wrong. *confused*

I am fully aware this might be trivial in the big picture, but it caught my attention.

More importantly, if you need a minion doing such jobs like enhancing pictures for your site, send me a PM. I'm doing stuff like this for a living and would be glad to help you out and save your time for other things to do. :wackynotworthy:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom