"Expelled" now in legal trouble - will it make it to theaters?

MattusMaximus

Intellectual Gladiator
Joined
Jan 26, 2006
Messages
15,948
It looks like there's been a copyright lawsuit filed against the makers of "Expelled", and the film may never reach theaters as a result. Read all about it on the Panda's Thumb blog...

Will the public ever see Expelled?

I was wondering how long it would take for the other shoe to drop regarding the CG cell footage. And damn did that sucker DROP!!!

Of course, just watch Ben Stein et al start whining and moaning about how this is just all part of the “Darwinist conspiracy”. Pathetic whiny babies.
 
I had the same reaction as one of the posters in blog you linked to.

Is this going to give the movie a bump from the controversy?

I had no idea what the copyright suit was about, but a lot of the posters on that site seemed to know a lot about what was going on here.

Is there a quick summary about the basis for the suit of the history of the dispute some place?
 
I had the same reaction as one of the posters in blog you linked to.

Is this going to give the movie a bump from the controversy?


I thought about that too, but I think the only people it would sway are those who are firmly in the "Expelled" camp already. They'll likely just moan and whine about it being part of the "Darwinist conspiracy". :rolleyes:


I had no idea what the copyright suit was about, but a lot of the posters on that site seemed to know a lot about what was going on here.

Is there a quick summary about the basis for the suit of the history of the dispute some place?


It's about some footage that appears in "Expelled" - basically, this footage is a computer-generated ripoff of practically identical footage from Harvard University / XVIVO's "Inner Life" video. The ripoff is such a ripoff that the creationists made exactly the same mistakes as in the original.

For more details, here is a copy of the actual letter sent to the "Expelled" people concerning the lawsuit just today...

http://www.ncseweb.org/resources/articles/EXPELLED-Letter.pdf

When news of the contents of the movie during screenings began to come out, including contents of give-away DVDs at these screenings, there was almost immediate speculation that this very issue could lead to a copyright lawsuit.

And here we are...
 
How are you an extra in a documentary(yeah yeah, i know it really isn't, but they claim it is)
 
How are you an extra in a documentary(yeah yeah, i know it really isn't, but they claim it is)

They were dramatizing some scholastic event from Ben Stein's past at a college in SoCal, so he got to be a college student in the background. It's like those reenactments they do in america's most wanted. :)
Actually my buddy met Ben Stein while he was there. Apparently Ben wanted to meet my friend's female friend. He wanted to get her number to help her with her acting career. Although my friend claims Ben was totally non-creepy about it, and that Ben actually honestly wanted to help....but it seems so sleazy. I'm suspicious. And why didn't Ben want to help my friend? Weird
 
Last edited:
I actually hope it does make it to theaters, just so the makers of this tripe can't scream than Big Science is trying to surpress them. I am pretty much convinced this film will just be preaching to the choir anyway,and making some kind of matyr out of them is just playing into their hands.
 
I actually hope it does make it to theaters, just so the makers of this tripe can't scream than Big Science is trying to surpress them. I am pretty much convinced this film will just be preaching to the choir anyway,and making some kind of matyr out of them is just playing into their hands.


Yes, this is a concern I've seen expressed elsewhere. Of course, I think perhaps the most positive outcome would be that the film comes out (so the IDCs cannot scream "persecution!"), it flops in the theaters, AND that the producers get sued for big $$$ for copyright infringment AND that they lose the case badly.

If a lawsuit goes forth, it looks like the creationists could get creamed badly. For more info on this, check out this link to the Panda's Thumb blog...

Wesley Elsberry: “Expelled” exposed

As stated there, it could be that Premise Media (the group behind "Expelled") could inadvertently take down the entire IDC movement (well, the Disco Institute maybe) by exposing their hypocrisy & lies in open court in a case that would cost them huge money. It would show to the movement's financial backers that, without a doubt, the Disco Institute leaders of ID are a bunch of incompetent boobs.

It would be, as Elsberry states, "a completely self-inflicted wound."

I'm going to be eagerly watching the outcome of these events! :D
 
Last edited:
They were dramatizing some scholastic event from Ben Stein's past at a college in SoCal, so he got to be a college student in the background. It's like those reenactments they do in america's most wanted. :)
Actually my buddy met Ben Stein while he was there. Apparently Ben wanted to meet my friend's female friend. He wanted to get her number to help her with her acting career. Although my friend claims Ben was totally non-creepy about it, and that Ben actually honestly wanted to help....but it seems so sleazy. I'm suspicious. And why didn't Ben want to help my friend? Weird

If Ben likes to spread his genetic information as widely as possible then you neo-Darwinists should be patting him on the back and buying him a beer.
 
If Ben likes to spread his genetic information as widely as possible then you neo-Darwinists should be patting him on the back and buying him a beer.
Ben probably neglects to mention that it was evolutionary biologists, and NOT the intelligent design folks who made those molecular discoveries, in the first place.

And, it is also the evolutionary biologists, NOT the creationists, who are unraveling how those systems developed, as well. Creationism adds nothing to our understanding of the inner workings of cells and such. But, evolution yields dividends of information and understanding.
 
How are you an extra in a documentary(yeah yeah, i know it really isn't, but they claim it is)
See the thread about Scientific American's review of the film - it includes info about the scene zosima is talking about (or a similar one at another college).:)
 
Ben probably neglects to mention that it was evolutionary biologists, and NOT the intelligent design folks who made those molecular discoveries, in the first place.
Well that's hardly surprising seeing as pretty much all biologists in the last century or more have been taught to be evolutionary biologists.
Did the evolution part in any way help them to make those molecular discoveries? Or would biologists with non-evolutionary beliefs have had just as good a chance in the same circumstances?

And, it is also the evolutionary biologists, NOT the creationists, who are unraveling how those systems developed, as well. Creationism adds nothing to our understanding of the inner workings of cells and such. But, evolution yields dividends of information and understanding.
Hardly surprising again, seeing as ID/Creationists are basically not allowed into mainstream biology - where the vast majority of funding is - .. unless they make sure they shut up.

BTW, I was being light-hearted with my Ben Stein comment.
 
Last edited:
If Ben likes to spread his genetic information as widely as possible then you neo-Darwinists should be patting him on the back and buying him a beer.

I think plumjam was making a meta-comment in response to my suggestion that Ben may have been hitting on a girl at least 20 years younger than himself. But even if Ben performatively proves our theory while verbally denies it, I'd hate to imagine a future with a lot of little Bens running around. People who believe in evolution could only imagine that as a bad thing for the entire species.
 
"Hardly surprising again, seeing as ID/Creationists are basically not allowed into mainstream biology - where the vast majority of funding is - .. unless they make sure they shut up.'

Nor are witchdoctors admitted into most hospitals (I burned you, bible boy)))))))
 
Well that's hardly surprising seeing as pretty much all biologists in the last century or more have been taught to be evolutionary biologists.
Did the evolution part in any way help them to make those molecular discoveries? Or would biologists with non-evolutionary beliefs have had just as good a chance in the same circumstances?

If they followed the scientific methods, they certainly could have made them. The problem is that people who reject scientific evidence tend not to properly follow the methods, or do not follow them in a comprehensive manner. Several members of the ID movement exemplify this problem.

Hardly surprising again, seeing as ID/Creationists are basically not allowed into mainstream biology - where the vast majority of funding is - .. unless they make sure they shut up.

This is just false. Behe is in "mainstream biology", as would anyone be if they simply do actual research. Francis Collins is a "creationist" in a general sense in that he is a Theist and believes a God made the universe, but he follows the scientific methods when he does his science. That is all that is required.

What is not allowed is for someone to take the position that we will never find a particular answer to a particular question, claim "the designer did it", give up researching the topic, and focus on teleological explanations and not mechanistic ones. If you try to publish papers on teleology in journals that deal with mechanics, it is surely not unexpected that they aren't interested. If you fail to publish papers and do research on mechanics, and focus on teleology, it is certainly not unexpected that you would be told to find new work.

That is not telling someone to "shut up", its simply telling them to do the work of science if they claim to be a scientist. If they don't want to play be the rules, they can find something else to do.
 
Well that's hardly surprising seeing as pretty much all biologists in the last century or more have been taught to be evolutionary biologists.
Did the evolution part in any way help them to make those molecular discoveries? Or would biologists with non-evolutionary beliefs have had just as good a chance in the same circumstances?

I wondered the same thing a bit. It is a tricky question to answer I think. One of the fundamental ideas that underlies most biological research is that organisms have a mechanism for passing on traits and evolving. A biologist investigating those mechanisms could theoretically have some other model in mind than an evolutionary one for how species came to be and still be doing biological research.

I was an electrical engineer for thirty years. Could I have designed circuits if I didn't think that electrons existed. Yes, actually. For most of the time underlying physics were just modeled with simple mathematical constructs that didn't necessarily imply anything about the underlying science.

Still, it gets tricky. Could I have done physics research and not believed in the electron? Again I think the answer is yes, but it would have been much harder to direct experiments in useful directions if I didn't believe in one of the basic ideas that underlaid all modern thinking about nature of matter.

As a practical matter, not believing in evolution for a biologist would be such a contrived view that it is hard to imagine biologists that are doing useful research that don't believe in biology from my perspective but it seems like it is possible for some kinds of research.


Hardly surprising again, seeing as ID/Creationists are basically not allowed into mainstream biology - where the vast majority of funding is - .. unless they make sure they shut up.

BTW, I was being light-hearted with my Ben Stein comment.

This also seems a little tricky to me. When generations of established science point one way isn't it reasonable that research money be withheld from individuals that reject the basic science? You seem to be seeing this as some sort of conspiracy to prevent the rise of intelligent design. I suppose it is in the same sense that there is some sort of conspiracy to direct research in directions that seem to be suggested by the evidence instead of in directions suggested by what some people want to believe.

Intelligent design is not a basis for research. By its very nature it is an untestable theory. The idea that some theoretical entity or entities (probably supernatural), created life as we know is untestable and it suggests that research into the actual mechanisms that control and create life are useless because this entity(ies) just acted in mysterious unknowable ways and we just need to accept that.
 
Well that's hardly surprising seeing as pretty much all biologists in the last century or more have been taught to be evolutionary biologists.
Did the evolution part in any way help them to make those molecular discoveries? Or would biologists with non-evolutionary beliefs have had just as good a chance in the same circumstances?
Yes to the first and no to the second

One specific example is that in the idea evolution allows scientists to quantify relatedness and thus understand exactly how animal models can apply to humans. Which is fundamental to about any application of biotechnology to human benefit.

In general evolution provides the framework that ties all biology together. You might as well ask if physicists could have made the same accomplishments without the theories of Newton,Gauss,Maxwell,Einstein,Feynmann.... If they just ran experiments, but believed there was no theory tying everything together other than God's Design. The point is that evolution helps scientists figure out where to look, what experiments to run, and how to interpret those results. So no virtually none of that work could have been done without evolution.

Do you think its just coincidence that virtually all biologists believe in evolution? Do you think they're the one's arguing most vigorously for the teaching of evolution because they don't know what they're talking about? Do you think its some sort of anti-religious conspiracy? Or could it be possible that the more they learn about biology the more evidence they see for evolution?


BTW, I was being light-hearted with my Ben Stein comment.
I got it. So, at least someone got the joke. :)
 
Did the evolution part in any way help them to make those molecular discoveries? Or would biologists with non-evolutionary beliefs have had just as good a chance in the same circumstances?
It was Evolution that got us examining cellular microbiology, in the first place. If everyone was satisfied with "goddidit", it would severely reduce the chance of any of these discoveries getting made, at all.

Some more specific examples:
* Modeling organelles as "evolved symbiotic entities" has helped us test predictions about their behavior, some of which might even be in those animations.
* Stem cells were discovered, in part, by theorizing evolutionary origins of cell differentiation, after such behavior was observed in tumor growths.
Etc.

Has Creationism ever helped us make any new discoveries about life?

Hardly surprising again, seeing as ID/Creationists are basically not allowed into mainstream biology - where the vast majority of funding is - .. unless they make sure they shut up.
When ID/Creationists are capable of developing a testable theory, I am sure mainstream biologists would grant them some funds.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom