Lizards Undergo Rapid Evolution After Introduction To A New Home

CFLarsen

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Aug 3, 2001
Messages
42,371
In 1971, biologists moved five adult pairs of Italian wall lizards from their home island of Pod Kopiste, in the South Adriatic Sea, to the neighboring island of Pod Mrcaru. Now, an international team of researchers has shown that introducing these small, green-backed lizards, Podarcis sicula, to a new environment caused them to undergo rapid and large-scale evolutionary changes.

“Striking differences in head size and shape, increased bite strength and the development of new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts were noted after only 36 years, which is an extremely short time scale,” says Duncan Irschick, a professor of biology at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. “These physical changes have occurred side-by-side with dramatic changes in population density and social structure.”
Source

Eat some veggies, Ken Ham.
 
I don't understand this. It seems to me that the lizards had a bigger and more reliable food source and so they grew. This is not so very surprising is it? In what sense is this evolution if the genetic material is identical. What am I missing?
 
I don't understand this. It seems to me that the lizards had a bigger and more reliable food source and so they grew. This is not so very surprising is it? In what sense is this evolution if the genetic material is identical. What am I missing?
You are missing the second part of the quote:
“Striking differences in head size and shape, increased bite strength and the development of new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts were noted after only 36 years, which is an extremely short time scale,” says Duncan Irschick, a professor of biology at the University of Massachusetts Amherst. “These physical changes have occurred side-by-side with dramatic changes in population density and social structure.”
And later in the article
Observed changes in head morphology were caused by adaptation to a different food source.
 
No I did not miss that, Reality Check. The DNA is identical to the original population: so it seems to me that big fat lizards are morphologically different from wee undernourished ones. But they have not mutated and there has been no demonstrable natural selection on this evidence. What happens to lizards who are really well fed from birth in lab?
 
You still miss it: They went from primarily meat eaters to primarily plant eaters.

That's a huge step, evolutionary wise. And in only 36 years.
 
It seems to me that that is what an omnivore would do if it had the chance.
 
No I did not miss that, Reality Check. The DNA is identical to the original population: so it seems to me that big fat lizards are morphologically different from wee undernourished ones. But they have not mutated and there has been no demonstrable natural selection on this evidence. What happens to lizards who are really well fed from birth in lab?
The article states:
Tail clips taken for DNA analysis confirmed that the Pod Mrcaru lizards were genetically identical to the source population on Pod Kopiste.
I don't think that this means that the lizards on the second island were clones of the ones on the original island. It means that they were identical as in a genetic fingerprint sense, not as in every bit of the DNA was identical.

Another point: The Pod Mrcaru lizards are not described as "big fat lizards" compared to the original Pod Kopiste lizards (nor is "wee undernourished" used for the original population). The only differences were "striking" (a scientific term for "we noticed it!") differences in head size and shape, increased bite strength and the development of new structures in the lizard’s digestive tracts.
 
Last edited:
Examination of the lizard’s digestive tracts revealed something even more surprising. Eating more plants caused the development of new structures called cecal valves, designed to slow the passage of food by creating fermentation chambers in the gut, where microbes can break down the difficult to digest portion of plants. Cecal valves, which were found in hatchlings, juveniles and adults on Pod Mrcaru, have never been reported for this species, including the source population on Pod Kopiste.

Arrgh.

As Fiona noted, these populations are genetically identical.

this seems like an adaptation/acclimitisation, which should only take one generation.

What is the difference between this and athletes undergoing altitude training?*

*There are further genetic differences so that I would never have the VO2 max capacity of an Andean Indian, but there also significant acclimitisations that my body would undergo should I start living at altitude.
 
Last edited:
Arrgh.
Quote:
Examination of the lizard’s digestive tracts revealed something even more surprising. Eating more plants caused the development of new structures called cecal valves, designed to slow the passage of food by creating fermentation chambers in the gut, where microbes can break down the difficult to digest portion of plants. Cecal valves, which were found in hatchlings, juveniles and adults on Pod Mrcaru, have never been reported for this species, including the source population on Pod Kopiste.

As Fiona noted, these populations are genetically identical.

this seems like an adaptation/acclimatisation, which should only take one generation.

What is the difference between this and athletes undergoing altitude training?*

*There are further genetic differences so that I would never have the VO2 max capacity of an Andean Indian, but there also significant acclimatizations that my body would undergo should I start living at altitude.

You need to read on:
“These structures actually occur in less than 1 percent of all known species of scaled reptiles,” says Irschick. “Our data shows that evolution of novel structures can occur on extremely short time scales. Cecal valve evolution probably went hand-in-hand with a novel association between the lizards on Pod Mrcaru and microorganisms called nematodes that break down cellulose, which were found in their hindguts.”

This is not a case of increased red cell counts in the blood due to acclimatizing to high altitudes. It is a case of novel structures evolving in these lizards.
 
Can't see it. Not all possibilities develop in the undernourished. That doesn't mean they wouldn't in the right conditions. Not all genetic potential is manifest. We know that undernourishment in childhood has long lasting effects on the development of the human so why not in lizards? If the genetic material is identical I do not see evolution in action. At least not as I understand the word
 
It seems to me that that is what an omnivore would do if it had the chance.

Not chance, but necessity. They suddenly moved from an environment with insects but few plants to one with plants but few insects.

Think about lions. They live where there's plenty of plant food. If plants provide a larger and more predictable food supply, why don't lions become herbivores?

Hmmmm.....? :)
 
Not chance, but necessity. They suddenly moved from an environment with insects but few plants to one with plants but few insects.

Think about lions. They live where there's plenty of plant food. If plants provide a larger and more predictable food supply, why don't lions become herbivores?

Hmmmm.....? :)

Because they are carnivores? Just a guess. :D
 
Not to tangent from actual evolutionary theory to Creationism this early in the thread, but since God created every species male and female, I've never seen any (and let my qualify my ignorance) or a decent explanation as to why Bdelloid rotifers or Whip-tailed lizards exist. The herbivore to carnivore to herbivore transitions are childs play compared to explaining my entire populations of some species are all female and parthenogenetic.
 
Current understanding of evolution includes the issue of how genes are expressed, not simply "changed". That appears to be a common factor in all life, given that even humans share much genetic similarity with lizards (we can start with simple morphological issues). The point is that how a given gene functions can rapidly be changed (much more rapidly than the gene itself) through changes in the triggers that activate the genes (paraphrased by me, excuse any technical omissions) and those triggers are more susceptible to rapid change.

ETA, there is a good article in the current issue of Scientific American, sciam.com, but it's not available online until next month or I would have put the link here.
 
Last edited:
I take this part to be evolution in action:

Examination of the lizard’s digestive tracts revealed something even more surprising. Eating more plants caused the development of new structures called cecal valves, designed to slow the passage of food by creating fermentation chambers in the gut, where microbes can break down the difficult to digest portion of plants. Cecal valves, which were found in hatchlings, juveniles and adults on Pod Mrcaru, have never been reported for this species, including the source population on Pod Kopiste.

Unless I misunderstand, and an individual lizard that never had cecal valves before can suddenly develop them after a change of diet.
 
Because they are carnivores? Just a guess. :D

So were the lizards in the beginning.

The reason why lions don't turn herbivorous is that they still have enough meat in their environment. If that disappears, they either adapt by eating plants, or become extinct.

Unless I misunderstand, and an individual lizard that never had cecal valves before can suddenly develop them after a change of diet.

Those that were able to adapt, yes. I'm sure there were a number who croaked on the way because they couldn't. :)
 
They compared sections of mitochondrial DNA to identify the lizards.

Rapid large-scale evolutionary divergence in morphology and performance
associated with exploitation of a different dietary resource.
Herrel A, Huyghe K, Vanhooydonck B, Backeljau T, Breugelmans K, Grbac I, Van
Damme R, Irschick DJ.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2008 Mar 25;105(12):4792-5. Epub 2008 Mar 14.

"Although the islet of Pod Mrcˇaru was originally
inhabited by another lacertid lizard species (Podarcis melisellensis),
repeated visits (twice yearly over the past three years, beginning in
2004) show that this species has become extinct on Pod Mrcˇaru.
Genetic mitochondrial DNA analyses indicate that the lizards
currently on Pod Mrcˇaru are indeed P. sicula and are genetically
indistinguishable from lizards from the source population."

"Two mitochondrial DNA fragments (12S rDNA and 16S rDNA) were
amplified by PCR...Sequences were edited and aligned with BioEdit software
(26). The MEGA v4 (27) was used to calculate pairwise Jukes–Cantor distances and to construct a neighbor-joining tree... "
 
I take this part to be evolution in action:



Unless I misunderstand, and an individual lizard that never had cecal valves before can suddenly develop them after a change of diet.

Sounds like a simple controlable experiment.

take some lizard eggs, from the meat eaters, give them the vegitarian diet, and see how many of the first generation (maybe second generation) develop these structures.

If it is evolution and not adaptation, then only a small proportion should. If it were simply the expression of a latent trait, then most should...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom