Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

westprog

Philosopher
Joined
Dec 1, 2006
Messages
8,928
I'll continue to use 'apologist' to describe these people, but I am willing to vary the verbage a bit - 'collaborator' and 'traitor' both seem apt.

As always, these people keep trying to change the subject away from the question on the table: Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?

They have no honest answer to this question that they can face.


I was going to reply to this (and many others along the same lines) on the "coddle" thread, but that seems to have run off in all directions, and I wanted to deal with this specific point.

Let's first consider how a skeptic should approach the specific claims of, say, homeopathy. What is his approach? How does he deal with the issue?

It's fairly obvious. He deals with the science. He examines the scientific theory behind homeopathy, and finds that it's gibberish. He then examines the experimental evidence, and finds that all the double blind tests fail. It's fairly straightforward.

How does a skeptic then deal with the claims of religion? Well, when it's a claim like "The Earth is six thousand years old and all species were created independently" he follows exactly the same strategy. The claim is in the realm of science, and it is rebutted scientifically.

But what about the claim that the universe was created by an omnipotent, omniscient being? How should that claim be dealt with? Let's go to the science. What do the textbooks say? Nothing. Shelf after shelf on physics and cosmology have nothing to say about God. No physicist has claimed to have demonstrated the non-existence of God. Many physicists don't believe that a God exists. However, many do, and they seem to be doing exactly the same physics. I don't think the same could be said for biologists who believe in homeopathy.

So the skeptic has to move to another section of the library altogether. He can look in Philosophy, and he'll find plenty of stuff there. Neitzche will tell him that God is dead. He can make the arguments accordingly.

But what about the atheists who claim that the arguments are the same? They claim that rather than advancing a philosophical point of view, they are arging scientifically? They are doing exactly what the creationists do - conflating religion and science in a way designed to cause confusion.
 
The scientists Stephen Jay Gould came up with the term NOMA - Non Overlapping Magisteria

He felt that Science could answer questions about the material world - and Religion was meant for morality and ethics. It was a breach to jump into either one using the other magisteria - like when the Creationists say that the earth is 6,000 years old. Or if a scientists says science proves God does not exist.

In those cases - once the breach is made - the particular Magisteria can then counter it. The scientists can then take on the Creationists because they've overstepped the bounds and are now making scientific claims.
 
Last edited:
Ah, a terrible argument. Aside from H. L. Mencken's - and Epicurus' logical argument from evil that the god you propose is actually logically impossible, science doesn't have to answer the question of whether there is a god or not. The god hypothesis is so open to manipulation to fit any new evidence that it can't possibly be refuted by scientific evidence. What science, reason and skepticism do do to the god hypothesis is show that it as faulty as a hypothesis that the universe is secretly controlled by leprechauns who report to dragons in people's in garages and who are administered by an invisible pink unicorn. Go ahead and feel insulted that I'm comparing god to something so absurd, but the god hypothesis is equally untenable and unfalsifiable. If you dismiss one because it's silly, groundless, and impossible to either support or refute, you must dismiss the other.
 
Last edited:
Religion is exempt from skeptical scrutiny because religion is popular and skeptical scrutiny is unpopular.
 
Religion is exempt from skeptical scrutiny because religion is popular and skeptical scrutiny is unpopular.

Just wondering - is there a law somewhere saying people can't be skeptical about religions? Seems like every thread here shows religions aren't exempt.
 
Skeptical scrutiny raises questions about the foundations of faith.
It's uncomfortable to think too deeply about these questions, as it can create doubt about the faith so firmly held as immutable.
Makes the apologist uncomfortable, which makes him angry at having to think about these things at all, and he'll retreat to the "we'll all find it out at the end, so why consider it now" if he's somewhat tolerant of differing views.
"You're going to Hell" is the other response.. possibly as in the past, "And I'll send you there!" which is considered a faux pas in many advanced countries.. Not the US of course, where the sentiment can still be wished, if not acted on.
 
In many religions, including the major ones, faith is considered an outmost virtue, being a strong mental devotion to a religion or a God. Doubt is generally viewed as the enemy of faith, which would make doubt a negative concept when it comes to the religion. Doubt is a essential part of skeptical scrutiny. Thus, many religious refuse to apply that method to their religion, since it will inherently harm their faith.

There are, of course, exceptions. My view of faith and religion has more in common with those. Faith should be challenged with doubt, so doubt is not in itself an enemy of faith any more than scientific testing is the enemy of scientific theories.

Still, skeptical scrutiny is a tool. We apply it to what we want. Sometimes we think it's neat, sometimes we don't. To some, it serves a purpose in itself, to others it does not.

ETA: I see I Ratant beat me to some of these points, so you now get to hear them in stereo with different backdrops. Enjoy. ;)
 
Last edited:
Ah, a terrible argument. Aside from H. L. Mencken's - and Epicurus' logical argument from evil that the god you propose is actually logically impossible, science doesn't have to answer the question of whether there is a god or not. The god hypothesis is so open to manipulation to fit any new evidence that it can't possibly be refuted by scientific evidence. What science, reason and skepticism do do to the god hypothesis is show that it as faulty as a hypothesis that the universe is secretly controlled by leprechauns who report to dragons in people's in garages and who are administered by an invisible pink unicorn. Go ahead and feel insulted that I'm comparing god to something so absurd, but the god hypothesis is equally untenable and unfalsifiable. If you dismiss one because it's silly, groundless, and impossible to either support or refute, you must dismiss the other.

If it's impossible to refute, then it has nothing to do with science. Science doesn't have anything to say about the God Hypothesis, and claiming that it does is to do Bad Science. Pointing out Bad Science is one of the virtues of this particular forum, and it should be done whatever the proponents beliefs.
 
I was going to reply to this (and many others along the same lines) on the "coddle" thread, but that seems to have run off in all directions, and I wanted to deal with this specific point.

Let's first consider how a skeptic should approach the specific claims of, say, homeopathy. What is his approach? How does he deal with the issue?

It's fairly obvious. He deals with the science. He examines the scientific theory behind homeopathy, and finds that it's gibberish. He then examines the experimental evidence, and finds that all the double blind tests fail. It's fairly straightforward.

How does a skeptic then deal with the claims of religion? Well, when it's a claim like "The Earth is six thousand years old and all species were created independently" he follows exactly the same strategy. The claim is in the realm of science, and it is rebutted scientifically.

But what about the claim that the universe was created by an omnipotent, omniscient being? How should that claim be dealt with? Let's go to the science. What do the textbooks say? Nothing. Shelf after shelf on physics and cosmology have nothing to say about God. No physicist has claimed to have demonstrated the non-existence of God. Many physicists don't believe that a God exists. However, many do, and they seem to be doing exactly the same physics. I don't think the same could be said for biologists who believe in homeopathy.

So the skeptic has to move to another section of the library altogether. He can look in Philosophy, and he'll find plenty of stuff there. Neitzche will tell him that God is dead. He can make the arguments accordingly.

But what about the atheists who claim that the arguments are the same? They claim that rather than advancing a philosophical point of view, they are arging scientifically? They are doing exactly what the creationists do - conflating religion and science in a way designed to cause confusion.

Which relgion does not make a claim about the world we live in?
 
Ah, a terrible argument. Aside from H. L. Mencken's - and Epicurus' logical argument from evil that the god you propose is actually logically impossible, science doesn't have to answer the question of whether there is a god or not. The god hypothesis is so open to manipulation to fit any new evidence that it can't possibly be refuted by scientific evidence. What science, reason and skepticism do do to the god hypothesis is show that it as faulty as a hypothesis that the universe is secretly controlled by leprechauns who report to dragons in people's in garages and who are administered by an invisible pink unicorn. Go ahead and feel insulted that I'm comparing god to something so absurd, but the god hypothesis is equally untenable and unfalsifiable. If you dismiss one because it's silly, groundless, and impossible to either support or refute, you must dismiss the other.

If it's impossible to refute, then it has nothing to do with science. Science doesn't have anything to say about the God Hypothesis, and claiming that it does is to do Bad Science. Pointing out Bad Science is one of the virtues of this particular forum, and it should be done whatever the proponents beliefs.

When religious propositions spill over into the scientific realm, then they can be rebutted using science. It's very clear when that happens. When religious claims are disputed using actual scientific reference, that makes sense. When they are disputed with arm-waving assertions that "science helps us to realise" then that's Bad Science.

I have no objection to atheists arguing for their beliefs. It's a good idea. It's a good forum for it. But they have to use the right tools for the job.
 
If it's impossible to refute, then it has nothing to do with science. Science doesn't have anything to say about the God Hypothesis, and claiming that it does is to do Bad Science. Pointing out Bad Science is one of the virtues of this particular forum, and it should be done whatever the proponents beliefs.

Oh, what a fun lie.

The current incarnation of the god hypothesis makes few if any material claims, few if any predictions, and is unfalsifiable precisely because science has attacked it with a hatchet for thousands of years. Does god make the sun shine? No, that's nuclear fusion. Does god cause disease? No, viruses, prions, bacteria, and other material causes do. Does god make things fall? No, that's gravity. At every turn for thousands of years, whenever god was counted as the cause for some mysterious phenomena, that hypothesis has been proven wrong.

What science has shown is that there is no god in our universe. Our universe is made of material things that interact with other material things. It's remotely possible that there's an invisible, intangible, silent, odorless god who does nothing and cannot be detected, but that isn't what religious people tend to claim exists. God does not answer prayers - that is a scientific fact. God did not create extant species - also a fact. Anything anyone might say about a god who actually does something is false. Anything that might say which is unfalsifiable is, by definition, utter nonsense.

If religious people want to muck about with claims that imply nothing, make no predictions, and cannot be disproved, they can go to the park and play in the sand box with the other toddlers.
 
Last edited:
Which religion does not make a claim about the world we live in?

If the claims can be scientifically addressed, go for it.

Claims that their is an original creator are not scientific in nature, and cannot be rebutted scientifically.
 
If the claims can be scientifically addressed, go for it.

Claims that their is an original creator are not scientific in nature, and cannot be rebutted scientifically.

If something cannot be rebutted scientifically, it cannot be rebutted at all. If you claim there's a god who runs everything and you say that claim is unassailable to reason, then I would counter and claim that god is a lemur inside the heart of Saturn. My stupid proposition is just as valid as your stupid proposition.

Once you entertain unscientific claims, you cannot distinguish between them.
 
Last edited:
...snip...

Claims that their is an original creator are not scientific in nature, and cannot be rebutted scientifically.

Yes they are since they make a claim about how reality came about and therefore those claims can in principle be tested.

However that is in fact being very charitable towards such an apparent claim because there is the little nub that many of those making such a claim forget. Which is they need to define exactly what they mean by "original creator" otherwise all they are doing is making marks on a piece of paper so to speak and not actually saying anything.
 
westprog said:
Claims that their is an original creator are not scientific in nature, and cannot be rebutted scientifically.

This is just funny. Of course it’s not scientific, thus science it’s not even interested in the claim in the first place. The relevant question seems to be: why make such a claim in the first place, what good does it do? What’s the point of claiming there’s some kind of original creator? If there were some kind of creator – which is extremely doubtful – what good does it do; it’s not like we could make any use of that conviction. :rolleyes:
 
Oh, what a fun lie.

I knew that questioning deeply held personal beliefs would upset people. I look forward to more of the same.

The current incarnation of the god hypothesis makes few if any material claims, few if any predictions, and is unfalsifiable precisely because science has attacked it with a hatchet for thousands of years. Does god make the sun shine? No, that's nuclear fusion. Does god cause disease? No, viruses, prions, bacteria, and other material causes do. Does god make things fall? No, that's gravity. At every turn for thousands of years, whenever god was counted as the cause for some mysterious phenomena, that hypothesis has been proven wrong.

That seems a fairly clear example of the extrapolation fallacy.

The point is not that science hasn't come up with an explanation for the purpose of the universe is that it isn't a scientific matter.

That science and religion have become disentangled is a good thing. The Good Scientist should support this, rather than getting re-entangled.

What science has shown is that there is no god in our universe.

Which is similarly the claim of most modern religions, which regard God as external and additional to the universe.

Our universe is made of material things that interact with other material things. It's remotely possible that there's an invisible, intangible, silent, odorless god who does nothing and cannot be detected, but that isn't what religious people tend to claim exists. God does not answer prayers - that is a scientific fact. God did not create extant species - also a fact. Anything anyone might say about a god who actually does something is false. Anything that might say which is unfalsifiable is, by definition, utter nonsense.

Anything that is unfalsifiable is nonsense? Is that the claim? Just want to be sure.

If religious people want to muck about with claims that imply nothing, make no predictions, and cannot be disproved, they can go to the park and play in the sand box with the other toddlers.

You know, there might be people out there who'll be convinced by the abusive posts, but I think that it's mainly playing to the home supporters.
 
A christian skeptic said:
The scientists Stephen Jay Gould came up with the term NOMA - Non Overlapping Magisteria

He felt that Science could answer questions about the material world - and Religion was meant for morality and ethics. It was a breach to jump into either one using the other magisteria - like when the Creationists say that the earth is 6,000 years old. Or if a scientists says science proves God does not exist.

In those cases - once the breach is made - the particular Magisteria can then counter it. The scientists can then take on the Creationists because they've overstepped the bounds and are now making scientific claims..

Did Jesus have a father or not? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

Did Jesus rise from the dead? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

Did Jesus turn water into wine? This is a scientific question, not a philosophical one.

ACS, what do you think the answer is to these questions?

Westprog, why do you feel the universe needs a 'meaning' or a purpose? What is the non-scientific meaning of thunder?
 
Last edited:
This is just funny. Of course it’s not scientific, thus science it’s not even interested in the claim in the first place. The relevant question seems to be: why make such a claim in the first place, what good does it do? What’s the point of claiming there’s some kind of original creator? If there were some kind of creator – which is extremely doubtful – what good does it do; it’s not like we could make any use of that conviction. :rolleyes:

I have to disagree with you - if the terms can be defined then it could be a scientific claim.

However a claim such as "which regard God as external and additional to the universe" is of course nothing more than an example how in English you can make up sentences that appear to be sentences but are in fact meaningless or indeed just nonsense.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom