westprog
Philosopher
- Joined
- Dec 1, 2006
- Messages
- 8,928
I'll continue to use 'apologist' to describe these people, but I am willing to vary the verbage a bit - 'collaborator' and 'traitor' both seem apt.
As always, these people keep trying to change the subject away from the question on the table: Why do they regard religion as being exempt from skeptical scrutiny?
They have no honest answer to this question that they can face.
I was going to reply to this (and many others along the same lines) on the "coddle" thread, but that seems to have run off in all directions, and I wanted to deal with this specific point.
Let's first consider how a skeptic should approach the specific claims of, say, homeopathy. What is his approach? How does he deal with the issue?
It's fairly obvious. He deals with the science. He examines the scientific theory behind homeopathy, and finds that it's gibberish. He then examines the experimental evidence, and finds that all the double blind tests fail. It's fairly straightforward.
How does a skeptic then deal with the claims of religion? Well, when it's a claim like "The Earth is six thousand years old and all species were created independently" he follows exactly the same strategy. The claim is in the realm of science, and it is rebutted scientifically.
But what about the claim that the universe was created by an omnipotent, omniscient being? How should that claim be dealt with? Let's go to the science. What do the textbooks say? Nothing. Shelf after shelf on physics and cosmology have nothing to say about God. No physicist has claimed to have demonstrated the non-existence of God. Many physicists don't believe that a God exists. However, many do, and they seem to be doing exactly the same physics. I don't think the same could be said for biologists who believe in homeopathy.
So the skeptic has to move to another section of the library altogether. He can look in Philosophy, and he'll find plenty of stuff there. Neitzche will tell him that God is dead. He can make the arguments accordingly.
But what about the atheists who claim that the arguments are the same? They claim that rather than advancing a philosophical point of view, they are arging scientifically? They are doing exactly what the creationists do - conflating religion and science in a way designed to cause confusion.