Another loss

Please note, however, that most of the wacky quotes in the article aren't from the "newly convinced" scientist. It sounds like this guy hasn't exactly "drank the Kool-aid." He says that he now believes there is a 60% chance of an intelligence designer based on that lack of certain chemical signatures in very old rocks.

He goes on to say:

"About 40% of me still has guarded hope that we will still be able to show how life evolved spontaneously according to the laws of normal physics and chemistry," he said. "I still believe, even though God appears to have specially created the first life, I still believe that I can powerfully defend … that pretty much all the rest of life still evolved."

This isn't exactly a loss to science here. It sounds like he is more than open to changing his view as he encounters more evidence.

He is strongly behind evolution...this is far from prattle about "irreducible complexity."
 
Here's a new twist:
The creation model stands apart from the "intelligent design" movement, which rightly has been assessed to be nonscientific, he said.

Even the creationists are trying to ditch the ID label now...
 
"I still believe, even though God appears to have specially created the first life, I still believe that I can powerfully defend … that pretty much all the rest of life still evolved."

I'd like this guy to start giving followup lectures to Discovery Institute audiences. I suspect he could convincingly stand up and say, "Ben Stein, Bill Dembski, and Michael Behe, you are contemptible frauds for trying to cram your bogus flagellum/design/complexity arguments into science curricula." And they can't accuse him of being a blinkered atheist trying to kick God out of science, since he's obviously willing to bring God into science.

Seriously, if the creationists' propaganda wing followed this guy, they'd be retreating from "Cat's dont evolve into dogz an why R there still apez" to "Darwin and modern science was are totally right about common descent and the origin of species by variation and natural selection, but abiogenesis isn't well understood." That'd be fine with me. I'd disagree with the God inference, obviously, but I wouldn't be worried about this view nucleating a move towards anti-intellectual theocracy.
 
Last edited:
Here's a new twist:


Even the creationists are trying to ditch the ID label now...

That's an old schizm. There's been hostility between the professional CSers and the professional IDers since day one.

To CSers, the whole point is to get Biblical teaching into the public school system, and they consider ID to be a pointless exercise.
 
Scientists: We've found creator's tracks
http://www.avpress.com/n/25/0425_s1.hts

"For 50 years, the best scientific minds on the planet have tried to show where the first cells came from and we failed miserably to demonstrate that. … If you try hard for 50 years and fail to show something, that's pretty strong evidence - the old theory of a prebiotic soup now appears to be kaput."

Compare with:

" . . .on May 15, 1953, a University of Chicago graduate student, Stanley Miller, published a landmark two-page paper in Science magazine. He considered if amino acids could be made from what was known about the early Earth's atmosphere. Could the building blocks of life be cooked up?

"Miller began his paper:

"The idea that the organic compounds that serve as the basis of life were formed when the earth had an atmosphere of methane, ammonia, water and hydrogen instead of carbon dioxide, nitrogen, oxygen and water was suggested by Oparin and has been given emphasis by Urey and Bernal. In order to test this hypothesis..."

"When Miller first presented his experimental findings to a large seminar, it is reported that at one point, Enrico Fermi politely asked if it was known whether this kind of process could have actually taken place on the primitive Earth. Harold Urey, Stanley's research advisor, immediately replied, saying 'If God did not do it this way, then he missed a good bet'. The seminar ended amid the laughter and, as the attendees filed out, some congratulated Stanley on his results."

"No single experiment, according to Carl Sagan, has done more to convince scientists that life is 'likely abundant in the cosmos' . . ."

See http://www.astrobio.net/news/modules.php?op=modload&name=News&file=article&sid=461
 
A creation model derived from the Bible would include a universe that emerges from a "singularity beginning" - that is, a moment when space, time, matter and energy come into being where none previously existed.

"What is unique about the Bible (among creation stories) is that it speaks about God acting independent of space and time," Ross said.

That universe then would be expected to continually expand and cool over time, he said, adding that all three of those elements describe the universe as observed and explained by modern scientific exploration.

"For thousands of years the Bible was the only text out there speaking of a continually expanding universe," he said.

That is a HUGE leap, from the bible stating that "God "Poofed" the universe into being" to ===> "The "poof" is the big bang" to ===> "Since the big bang lead to expansion the bible must have been directly talking about "a continually expanding universe", and this lends credence to the bible, because it knew about the expansion of the universe so long ago! OMG!".

What trash.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom