Gold

diggy70

Scholar
Joined
May 6, 2008
Messages
90
Please Tell my why or why not to own gold??
Please real answers only. I don't want to hear any of this hoarding crap. Gold used to be tied to the dollar and the central banks still hold lots of gold!! Gold is up 400% in 7-8 years. please some one tell me why.
 
Please Tell my why or why not to own gold??
Please real answers only. I don't want to hear any of this hoarding crap. Gold used to be tied to the dollar and the central banks still hold lots of gold!! Gold is up 400% in 7-8 years. please some one tell me why.

Please, diggy, by all means, sink your life's savings into gold. It will always be worth something, after all. Perhaps not what you paid for it, but it's so pretty. Too bad you didn't think of this in 2001, but...

http://goldprice.org/30-year-gold-price-history.html

Seriously, what do you knw about the forces that cause gold to go up or down in price? Is there any intelligence to this choice, other than "look what it's done"? Treat it as coldly as you do any investment.
 
Ah, where is good old Dave. Telling people in February to get into silver 'cuz it was going to break $20.... and immediately starting slipping and is now trading at 16.50 to 17.00

Shadron's got the right advice. If you don't know the trade, stay out of it until you do. While gold has gone up in the long-term over the past several years, it's also gone down in the short-term, more than 12% since it touched the $1000 line. If you haven't got the money to lose, don't play around with it.
 
Shadron and Foolmewunz are right. Historic trends are very poor indicators of where something will go in the future. It's also possible that gold is in a bubble that will pop soon and you'll lose your shirt.

So, unless you've studied the gold market and understand why its at the price its at and where it will go, you don't need to get involved.
 
Please Tell my why or why not to own gold??
Please real answers only. I don't want to hear any of this hoarding crap. Gold used to be tied to the dollar and the central banks still hold lots of gold!! Gold is up 400% in 7-8 years. please some one tell me why.

Check to see how much it is "up" over the last 25 years. Then tell me if it is a good idea to own gold.
 
Please Tell my why or why not to own gold??
Please real answers only. I don't want to hear any of this hoarding crap. Gold used to be tied to the dollar and the central banks still hold lots of gold!! Gold is up 400% in 7-8 years. please some one tell me why.

Gold is up 200%, silver is up 150%, copper is up 200%, platinum is up 150%, zinc is up 200%, lead up, steel up, aluminum up, etc.

And oil is up 200%, wheat is up, soybeans are up, corn is up, rice is up ...



Or maybe it's just that the dollar is down 50%.
 
yep, over the last 25 years, gold has been a bad investment. But ,you also had a bull run in stocks from 1980 to 2002. We seem to be in a commodity bull market from 2000. I guess the question is, how long wil it last? Has it topped? Well, I dont think so.
There seems to be tons of short positions in around the 600-700 $ mark. If gold does not head down soon they will have to come in and cover their shorts at some point and this will move the price higher. My last point for gold is that the oil and gold ratio averages about 10:1 (gold : oil). This means oil is coming down or gold is going higher.
 
yep, over the last 25 years, gold has been a bad investment. But ,you also had a bull run in stocks from 1980 to 2002. We seem to be in a commodity bull market from 2000. I guess the question is, how long wil it last? Has it topped? Well, I dont think so.
There seems to be tons of short positions in around the 600-700 $ mark. If gold does not head down soon they will have to come in and cover their shorts at some point and this will move the price higher. My last point for gold is that the oil and gold ratio averages about 10:1 (gold : oil). This means oil is coming down or gold is going higher.

Timing the market, eh? That has worked well for soooooo many people. :rolleyes:
 
Yeah, bet on the ratios while you're at it, Diggy.

We have a word for people like that - "poor".

And who came up with the 10:1 ratio, please? That's some sound byte invented in around 2006. 1 oz:1 brl of light crude is much more accurately at 15:1 or 20:1. But it's been as low as 6:1, and as high as 32:1 in the past 20 years. In short.... THERE IS NO HISTORICAL RATIO.

This sort of BSSA (bulls**t statistical analysis) is the favorite blind spot of a client of mine. He looks for relationships. One year, about 2003, his container price from Prague to Charlotte was at the same price as a container from Hong Kong to Buenos Aires. The following year, he insisted that we had to adjust our pricing to make the two match, again. One is not related to the other. There was just a single year out of perhaps 50 when the prices were the same, but because he'd seen the relationship, he would not look any further. He spent 100,000 bucks of his company's money to go out for competitive bids on all lanes because he was sure that we were fiddling with the numbers just because a non-existing ratio didn't work.
 
Diggy70 what effect do you think a resolution in the Zimbabwe crisis will have on your gold investment?
 
Diggy70 what effect do you think a resolution in the Zimbabwe crisis will have on your gold investment?


If any zimbabwean bought gold before the hyperinflation, They at least hold thier buying power. 1 oz gold = 150-200 million zimbabwe dollar <about that amount> so if the country has any thing deflating, they can buy other peoples wealth for cheep, or at least eat.
 
Last edited:
If any zimbabwean bought gold before the hyperinflation, They at least hold thier buying power. 1 oz gold = 150-200 million zimbabwe dollar <about that amount> so if the country has any thing deflating, they can buy other peoples wealth for cheep, or at least eat.


The News if our friend. I think, perhaps, what he was alluding to had more to do with supply and demand.
 
If any zimbabwean bought gold before the hyperinflation, They at least hold thier buying power. 1 oz gold = 150-200 million zimbabwe dollar <about that amount> so if the country has any thing deflating, they can buy other peoples wealth for cheep, or at least eat.



In 1999 Zimbabwe produced 27 metric tonnes of gold. In 2006 it was down to 16 tonnes, in 2007 8 tonnes.
This is only around 1% of global production but still significant.

Essentially what I'm asking is if you know what if any effect the resumption of normal mining in Zimbabwe would have on the price of Gold. Also $1.00 us = approx $180,000,000.00 Zimbabwean dollars but that was a week ago, it should be well over that now. So one ounce of Gold shipped from Zimbabwe to America and changed for dollars then changed back to Zimbabwean dollars would be worth 170.28 Billion Zimbabwean dollars.
 
ok i think we all get that gold was a poor investment pre 2000. what about now,good time to buy?
whats going to happen to people whho buy in 2008?
Could this be like the 70s gold run.. I think the 10 year gold run was like 4000%.

hope any one who bought in the 80s sold , and didnt hold for 25 years. or at had least stop loss somewhere.
 
What your suggesting is to try to Time the Markets. Thats just a flat out bad idea in general. Mind you a some folks strike it rich writing books about how to do it.
 
What your suggesting is to try to Time the Markets. Thats just a flat out bad idea in general. Mind you a some folks strike it rich writing books about how to do it.

What I'm suggesting is that like our friend, Dave.... Diggy's missed the boat. The run up to Silver @ $20 and Gold @ $1000 was when to make the money AND THEN GET OUT.

By the time the small investors get into the game and you have hucksters pumping it as an investment, it's all over.
 
Gold is not an asset class. There is no reason why a lump of gold should add value. Sometimes it goes up in price. Buying gold following a massive bull market in metals (and most commodities) and on the basis of responses in internet forums probably isn't the surest way to clean up.
 
Note that the charts on that link do not correct for inflation. Take a look at this chart from the same site which does correct for inflation:

Inflation Adjusted Gold Price History.

The folks who bought gold in 1980-81 are still nowhere near recouping their investment.

But...but....but...How can that be? The gold bugs are always telling us that gold is a great hedge against inflation. :confused:

I guess it would be more accurate to say that gold is a great hedge against superior returns.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom