Evidence that 911 Truth is seen as a lunatic fringe in the engineering community...

1337m4n

Alphanumeric Anonymous Stick Man
Joined
May 10, 2007
Messages
3,510
...from AE911Truth's own members!

Yes, I was reading through AE911Truth's members statements, and many of them indicate that they receive little to no respect or acknowledgment from their peers.

Here are quotes from AE911Truth's own members, with bolding on the statements relevant to this thread:

Nelson L. Johnson said:
By 9/12 I was convinced that there was something "fishy" about the "collapse" of the WTC. I learned about progressive collapse from my engineering professors at Columbia, and I found it hard to imagine that the twin towers could have failed in that way. They were specifically designed to resist impact and load applied by the collision of a Boeing 707 jet. The buildings appeared to have been destroyed by an engineered demolition. When I articulated my suspicions, however, I was met with derision. I have continued, however, in my conviction that the buildings were intentionally destroyed.

Richard Paul Sheridan said:
Only a controlled demolition would have cause the towers to come down in an almost perfect vertical fall.

Only demolition would have caused window glass to be shot out hundreds of feet horizontally.

It is a shame on the engineering profession that the ASCE hasn't challenged th official government position on 9/11.

Christopher E. Martini said:
Since the Oklahoma bombing I lost faith in getting the truth from nat'l. media and our gov. I felt strongly when the WTC fell that it was impossible (and argued with colleagues for years), with my knowledge/ understanding of alloy and structural steels. Then heard later another building fell but no one talked about it... Why? Then the Pentagon and PA... TV reports explained the alloy steel and titanium in landing gear and jet engines vaporized because they hit so hard... Bull, these metals do not vaporize no matter they were traveling at 500mph or 1000mph... So, where are they? No one answers... Letters to congressman and the local TV investigators gets you no response or something unrelated..... why? I'm glad someone has put this site together, finally, people who see the same things I've seen and been scorned for all these years.

Jeffrey A. Miller said:
I knew what I was viewing as I saw it live on TV. I heard misinformation coming from overconfident bystanders right in live-feeds. To much like Vegas hotels famously imploded. No stacks of flooring, just dust and molten steel.

Horrific. It has taken some time to find this organization with whom to vent publicly and properly.

Kevin Ryan said:
I was fired by Underwriters Laboratories for sending a letter to an NIST scientist pointing out inconsistencies in the NIST WTC report, and asking for clarification.

Steve Bishop said:
There are many inconsistencies between the official explanation and the facts. Here are some observations.

1) The lateral ejection of 20 ton steel beams hundreds of feet from a building--some reportedly in clean even lengths.

2) The beams were ejected in absolutely symmetrical patterns.
(see http://911research.wtc7.net/wtc/analysis/collapses/mushrooming.html)

3) The manner and speed of collapse were suspect. WTC1, WTC2, & WTC7 did not topple over as you might expect from a building weakened unevenly due to fire.

4) The mass of a fully loaded 767 with fuel would be less than 1/10 of one percent of the above-ground mass of one of the twin towers.

5) A variety of dust samples have proven the existence of iron-rich microspheres commonly produced by thermate reactions (explosives). In fact, the existence of these spheres has even been documented by the government.

Some people may say that it is not likely or highly improbable for the trade center towers to have been wired with explosives due to the difficulty involved. This reasoning is used to dismiss any possibility of this scenario actually having occurred without considering the real evidence. Please find out the facts yourself. Don't let the so-called “experts” (PhD or otherwise) and network television make up your mind for you. Attempt to understand and evaluate them yourself. Do your best to critically evaluate their statements to understand who has credibility and who doesn't. It is very important to consult experts, in print and on video, but do not let them make up your mind for you. Find out who is trustworthy and well-grounded in scientific principles, such as the founder of this group, Richard Gage and many others in the truth movement. Thank you.

These quotes would seem to indicate that the vast majority of the engineering community does not exactly see eye-to-eye with the AE911Truth.

Couple that with the dismal failure that AE911Truth suffered at the AIA convention, and the fact that Ron Paul's campaign failed miserably, and you've got a pretty solid case for what I've been saying all along: the Truth Movement is seen by the general public as a lunatic fringe group.

The fact that Truthers continue to deny that the public sees them this way just goes to show that they are, well, in denial.
 
It can't be that. It has to be the biggest CIA operation in the history of ever to hide the groundswell of public opinion and discredit the "truth" movement. It has to be a conspiracy at least ten times the size of the 9/11 conspiracy itself to keep the conspiracy under wraps. Besides, all the members of AIA are disinfo.
</truthist>
 
I can't prove what's in their own minds, but amongst truthers (especially ones such as these), there seems to be many pseudo-Galileos.

Pseudoscientists also love the "Galileo Argument." This consists of the pseudoscientist comparing himself to Galileo, and saying that just as the pseudoscientist is believed to be wrong, so Galileo was thought wrong by his contemporaries therefore the pseudoscientist must be right too, just as Galileo was. Clearly the conclusion does not follow! Moreover, Galileo's ideas were tested, verified, and accepted promptly by his scientific colleagues. The rejection came from the established religion which favored the pseudoscience that Galileo's findings contradicted.

http://www.quackwatch.com/01QuackeryRelatedTopics/pseudo.html
 
...from AE911Truth's own members!

Yes, I was reading through AE911Truth's members statements, and many of them indicate that they receive little to no respect or acknowledgment from their peers.

Here are quotes from AE911Truth's own members, with bolding on the statements relevant to this thread:













These quotes would seem to indicate that the vast majority of the engineering community does not exactly see eye-to-eye with the AE911Truth.

Couple that with the dismal failure that AE911Truth suffered at the AIA convention, and the fact that Ron Paul's campaign failed miserably, and you've got a pretty solid case for what I've been saying all along: the Truth Movement is seen by the general public as a lunatic fringe group.

The fact that Truthers continue to deny that the public sees them this way just goes to show that they are, well, in denial.


6 quotes out of 384 members:rolleyes:

You even included the brave patriot Kevin Ryan and we all know how unfairly he was treated.
 
6 quotes out of 384 members:rolleyes:

You even included the brave patriot Kevin Ryan and we all know how unfairly he was treated.

Interesting that you're not this interested in the actual numbers when it comes to tallying family members seeking a new investigation, and instead just make vague statements that imply a much larger number than you know to be true.
 
Last edited:
6 quotes out of 384 members:rolleyes:

You even included the brave patriot Kevin Ryan and we all know how unfairly he was treated.

Hahahahahahahahahahahahahaha

"Hay guys, I like to lie about what other people said, pretend to be more important than some idiot testing water, and play with my friend the scarecrow. Don't fire me"

I would insult you, but that would be against the forum rules.
 
Interesting that you're not this interested in the actual numbers when it comes to tallying family members seeking a new investigation, and instead just make vague statements that imply a much larger number than you know to be true.


How many would that be? I've heard numbers like 6. The families in NYC have good reason to be angry about things related to 9/11, mostly about heath care for the first responders. As far as I can tell, none of the anger involves man-made demolition at WTC or something other than 4 hijacked civilian jets causing all the damage.

I live in Staten Island, NYC, the county that apparently has the most survivors and families of victims of 9/11 anywhere. I know a few of these people and have met uncounted numbers of others and I happen to know two doctors that have been on contract with FDNY for 9/11-related mental heath counseling.

The "Truth Movement" is invisible here.

The handful of first-responders and survivors that admit hearing of the "Truth Movement" think it's sick, funny, or both.
 
A very nice collection of quotes. Hardly surprising, but good to see them admitting it themselves.

That's the beauty of being a conspiracy theorist: ANYTHING is confirmation of your beliefs. If 99% of the engineering community thinks you're a kook, then that's PROOF that the conspiracy is even bigger than we thought!!!
 
theauthor you are in some SERIOUS denial. For a movement that supposedly has rock-solid evidence of inside job and views the collapses as so suspicious that anybody can see through it, it sure is seriously ignored by peers.

From your posts it's obvious you have cleverly rationalized that fact away pretty well, what with your disinfo accusations and all, but this makes normal people at least think twice.
 
...I live in Staten Island, NYC, the county that apparently has the most survivors and families of victims of 9/11 anywhere. I know a few of these people and have met uncounted numbers of others and I happen to know two doctors that have been on contract with FDNY for 9/11-related mental heath counseling.

The "Truth Movement" is invisible here.

The "Truth Movement" is largely invisible everywhere. In the 6+ years since 9/11/2001, the only real-world evidence I've ever personally encountered for its very existence is a "9/11 was an inside job" sticker I saw on one idiot's car. Not one person I've ever met has ever mentioned the "Truth Movement" or any of its many nutty (and often self-contradictory) claims.

I daresay this also applies to the engineering community at large. I'm in aerospace, and not one engineer I've ever met has brought up conspiracy claims. I suppose the civil engineering community naturally has a greater awareness of it, though clearly the vast majority have no truck with such claims.

The handful of first-responders and survivors that admit hearing of the "Truth Movement" think it's sick, funny, or both.

As a (volunteer) firefighter/EMT, I'd agree both with the general lack of awareness of the "truth movement" and its claims, and the disdain with which they are treated. I once raised the topic with a USAR guy who was at the Pentagon that day. He just rolled his eyes.

But I stand by my offer to chip in for transportation for any TM member who wants to confront an FDNY firefighter with such claims. As long as I get to be there with popcorn.
 
Last edited:
theauthor said:
6 quotes out of 384 members

Wow PDoh, you sure got me. There are 6 quotes from people who all admit to being ridiculed and looked down upon by the rest of the architectural and engineering community. Say why does AE911Truth have only 384 members, anyway? I could've sworn that the total number of architects and engineers in the United States was in the millions. Good thing they informed so many architects when they went to the AIA convention, right? Oh wait, they bombed there.

You even included the brave patriot Kevin Ryan and we all know how unfairly he was treated.

"brave patriot"

What loaded language. Kevin Ryan has done nothing brave or patriotic, unless you count filing lawsuits against companies that fire morons to be brave and patriotic. Most companies fire morons, you know. It's necessary to keep the economy running. If you were an employer you would probably fire morons as well.
 
These quotes would seem to indicate that the vast majority of the engineering community does not exactly see eye-to-eye with the AE911Truth.

Ah but Doug Plumb of AE911 has an explanation for that!

From a Toronto 911 truth e-mail:

No one in engineering seriously thinks those buildings went down like that naturally by now IMO. They think they are on the winning team because they have been told so. They think they will get to be dictators in the new world so they shut up.

Yup, the engineers of the world are all silent because they are looking for a cabinet position in the NWO world government!


 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom