RandFan
Mormon Atheist
- Joined
- Dec 18, 2001
- Messages
- 60,135
I apologize but I honestly don't understand your complaint. You seem to be saying that you (GreNME) are right and I (RandFan) am wrong and that's that. In other words, you believe that a.) your assertion and b.) Gurdur's assertion is enough to establish that you are correct. Is that it? If so why? Is it because 2 against 1 establishes your assertion as fact?Your post that I was responding to was making assertions about the diagnostic process, was it not? My response was assuming that you were making such assertions, and was pointing out that two individuals so far have pointed out from separate perspectives (and separate capacities) that the diagnostic process is quite different than what you assert.
?Because they directly contradict what you were asserting as if it were fact.
In all honesty I find this very odd coming from someone who posts on the JREF forum. With all due respect. Contradiction is not argument. Please see argument clinic.
No, I'm serious. If you haven't watched then watch it. Then tell me why contradiction isn't of any significant value. Please forgive me for being condescending but this is rudimentary for anyone debating at the JREF forum.
But there is a real difference, I've made an argument for my position. I've not simply asserted something. My argument is based on skepticism and the scientific method.Since all you have done as well is make assertions (which you define as not arguments), I maintain that the authority I am placing to my posts is at least equal to yours.
Again, at the risk of being condesending.
Do you know what the scientific method is?
Do you know what skepticism is?
Do you know why this might be important as it relates to psychiatry?
I'm not sure what your anecdote is supposed to prove. I use anecdotes to illustrate points. You seem to think that your anecdote proves something. You've not made that clear. What do you think your anecdote proves and why? Do you understand the limits of anecdotal evidence?Again, your assertion is incorrect. The anecdotal diagnoses I referred to in my post happened between five and ten years ago (there are two distinct dates involved), and even then some of the tests were already decades old. You are simply making claims that are not based in fact.
Ok, but why are they incorrect? Don't you see that you are simply gainsaying?I am telling you that your assertions regarding what is involved in psychiatric diagnosis within this thread have thus far been incorrect.
I beg your forgiveness but I have to be honest here, this is a bit bizarre simply because I'm not used to having to point out such obvious mistakes in argument.
Gainsaying is not argument. Saing "no it's not" is not really an appropriate rebuttal. You are wrong is not an appropriate rebuttal in a skeptics forum.
I was not the one who started the appeal to authority. I only responded in kind.So, are we going to actually have a conversation where we clarify what our points are and work from there, or is this going to escalate into a contest of who can name the most textbook fallacies in others' posts and who can claim to have more friends in the field?
Yes, I would very much like to have a productive discussion. However, it is crucial to the discussion that we avoid fallacy. If I may and at the risk of patronizing, please take a moment to read the following.
Constructing a Logical Argument
I would very much appreciate if we could avoid fallacies like appeals to authority and special pleading. Please stick just to logical argument. And by all means call me out when I engage in fallacy. Being human I'm not above making mistakes. It's not a contest to list fallacies. It is just that valid logic isn't simply the best way to arrive at the truth it's that it's the best way to be confident that you have arrived at the truth.
If I have patronized then please accept my apology but like I told you before, I don't encounter this degree of fallacy here. Usually a few reminders is enough to get most sincere participants back on track.
Last edited: