Help with defining a point - light cones

ozziemate

Graduate Poster
Joined
Sep 12, 2008
Messages
1,240
Hi Guys, Gals
I am confused which is not that uncommon when it comes to physics and I am struggling to understand something.

Along the road to this understanding I need to know how science describes the central point on the light cone diagram shown below.

Originally I would have assumed it to be t=0 but I have since been told that 't' can be an arbitary choice. So obviously I need to look again at this issue.

So when looking at the cones we have a "Hyper surface of the present" and I wished to know in physics and math what symbol, character or math set would be used to decribe that point , as if you were using it in other formulations or descriptions.

lightc.png

image courtecy of wiki images

If I wanted to talk about this hyper surface of the present in a SRT gedanken how would I abreviate it?

Thanks in advance...Ozziemate
 
If I wanted to talk about this hyper surface of the present in a SRT gedanken how would I abreviate it?

Thanks in advance...Ozziemate

I generally just call it 'Steven'. You can shorten that to 'Steve', if it's easier for your experiment.
 
I generally just call it 'Steven'. You can shorten that to 'Steve', if it's easier for your experiment.

I think tSteven looks much more scientific.

Edit: Or rather, since its a co-ordinate in 4-D space-time:
(xSteven,ySteven,zSteven,tSteven)
 
Last edited:
The central point is simply any point in space time. The surface is Steven.

When looking at the light cone diagram it suggest that the point I am refering to must occur between past and future, is that correct.
From a laymans perspective to call this point 'Steven" certainly suggest scientist have a sense of humour, why not call it Number 5 instead? [refering to the movie No.5]

a quick google and no reference, any ideas how to confirm your response as valid? and not a bad attempt at humor?
 
The (hyper) surface is Steven.

The point does indeed have a past and a future, but it can still be any point, not merely the immediate present since all points in spacetime can be described by that same diagram. The top cone is the set of all points that can have knowledge of what happened at that central point. The lower cone is the set of all points that can influence that central point.
 
The (hyper) surface is Steven.

The point does indeed have a past and a future, but it can still be any point, not merely the immediate present since all points in spacetime can be described by that same diagram. The top cone is the set of all points that can have knowledge of what happened at that central point. The lower cone is the set of all points that can influence that central point.
ok I will drop the cynicism for a bit and ask:

If the surface is called Steven and it is indicative of the present moment what would that moment in time be called [apart from NOW]
If I am not interested in describing an event in the future and I am not interested in describing an event in the past in what way would I do so in mathematics that clearly anchors our point to the present? any?
Is there and clear way to show that you are talking about the hyperspace of the present in mathematics?
and if we drop reference to the diagram and refer in more general terms?
 
Last edited:
The central point is simply any point in space time. The surface is Steven.

The (hyper) surface is Steven.

The point does indeed have a past and a future, but it can still be any point, not merely the immediate present since all points in spacetime can be described by that same diagram. The top cone is the set of all points that can have knowledge of what happened at that central point. The lower cone is the set of all points that can influence that central point.

Thanks for the clarification, RY. I'd slightly misremembered the terminology.
 
Is there and clear way to show that you are talking about the hyperspace of the present in mathematics?
and if we drop reference to the diagram and refer in more general terms?

If you have a case where time matters, you just state the time.
 
I'm not sure I know what I'm talking about here but anyway....

The point is any event in space-time, the past lightcone contains any event that can possibly affect the event at the point and the future lightcone contains any event that can possibly be affected by the event at the point.

Any event outside of both lightcones cannot affect or be affected by the event at the point.

The way I've imagined it (and please tell me if this is wrong somone) in 3d instead of a cone it's a sphere that expands from an event at the speed of light and as an observer you cannot observe or be affected by the event until you are inside the sphere.
 
I am just wanting to qualify the current approach to time I guess.

You will probably say anything you want it to be...
however if that is the case then I am going to have to provide my own anchour and definitions accordingly.
And when someone askes why I did that I can explain by refering to all the posts that have said it as science holds it.

So Steven its the term and there is no anchour to the present moment when ever that present moment occurs in the ime line.

in other words [T=0 ] = [t= what ever you want it to be]
or something like that...

I must admit I am puzzled by the approach used. but will just have to accept it.
 
When I see t=0 at the center, it's not so much that "t" is arbitrary, but that 0 is arbitrary. t=0 at whatever point your observations begin.
 
You're trying to establish if there's some kind of direct Steven / time ratio?
actually no, but it's a good thought....
no ...what I am trying to do is be able to distinguish between events that are yet to happen and events that have happend in the past


Say I want to discuss an event that will happen at t= 12:01 am and make reference to the fact that I am at t=0 when doing so...

when predicting an event or forcasting an event how do you anchour th emoment of the forcast yet show the forcast with out confusion.

ie
t=now
t= future 120 minutes
 
Last edited:
Hi Guys, Gals
I am confused which is not that uncommon when it comes to physics and I am struggling to understand something.

Along the road to this understanding I need to know how science describes the central point on the light cone diagram shown below.
The observer (as in the actual label in the diagram) or "the current spacetime position of the observer".

Originally I would have assumed it to be t=0 but I have since been told that 't' can be an arbitary choice. So obviously I need to look again at this issue.

So when looking at the cones we have a "Hyper surface of the present" and I wished to know in physics and math what symbol, character or math set would be used to decribe that point , as if you were using it in other formulations or descriptions.

http://zeropointtheory.com/images/stories/images/lightc.png
image courtecy of wiki images

If I wanted to talk about this hyper surface of the present in a SRT gedanken how would I abreviate it?

Thanks in advance...Ozziemate
There is no "symbol, character or math set" that I know of used to commonly represent the hypersurface of the present.
I suggest "hypersurface of the present (HSP)" would be a good definition of a three letter acronym to shorten the phrase.

SRT tends to talk about the observer and the HSP is not relevant in that case. The HSP would be relevant in a gedanken experiment involving multiple observers.
 
actually no, but it's a good thought....
no ...what I am trying to do is be able to distinguish between events that are yet to happen and events that have happend in the past


Say I want to discuss an event that will happen at t= 12:01 am and make reference to the fact that I am at t=0 when doing so...

when predicting an event or forcasting an event how do you anchour th emoment of the forcast yet show the forcast with out confusion.

ie
t=now
t= future 120 minutes
That is exactly how you would refer to a future time in an observer's reference frame. More generally:
t=t1 is the time at t1 for the observer.
t=t2 where t2 > t1 is a future time for the observer.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom