Super Brain, Daniel Tammet. How is this possible?

Zeuzzz

Banned
Joined
Dec 26, 2007
Messages
5,211
(parts two and three of this documentary also available on youtube)

This guy is amazing. I dont have a clue how he does what he does, and neither do any mathematicians or scientists apparently. He has one of the fastest learning and most mysterious brains in the world, which works by finding patterns in pictures he visualises and reading the numerical answer from the image he forms. He holds the European record for reciting pi to 22,514 digits in five hours, and he apparently does this by visualizing a landscape he is moving over and reads off what the next digit will be from the his mental imagery. He also is fluent in seven languages, and can learn a new one in a week or so. Daniel is effectively what you get when you cross the abilities of a savant with the abilities of a synesthete. A very unique case. Unlike many other people with similar abilities he is able to explain how he does what he does, most people with these abilities are severely socially handicapped and cannot describe what is going on inside of their head.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_Tammet
Synaesthesia

Experiencing numbers as colors or sensations is a well-documented form of synaesthesia, but the detail and specificity of Tammet's mental imagery of numbers is unusual. In his mind, he says, each integer up to 10,000 has its own unique shape, color, texture and feel. He can intuitively "see" results of calculations as synesthesic landscapes without using conscious mental effort, and that he can "sense" whether a number is prime or composite. He has described his visual image of 289 as particularly ugly, 333 as particularly attractive, and pi as beautiful. 6 apparently has no distinct image.[1][2] Tammet not only verbally describes these visions, but has also created artwork: a watercolor painting of Pi.

Tammet was the subject of a documentary in the UK entitled The Boy With The Incredible Brain, which was first broadcast on the British television channel Five on 23 May 2005.[3] The documentary showed highlights of his pi recitation feat, studying the Icelandic language in one week and his meeting with Kim Peek, a world famous savant. In one moment of the show, Peek hugged Tammet and told him, "Some day you will be as great as I am," to which Tammet replied that "that was a wonderful compliment, what an aspiration to have."

[edit] Pi

Tammet holds the European record for reciting pi to 22,514 digits in five hours and nine minutes.[4] This sponsored charity challenge was held in aid of the National Society for Epilepsy (NSE) on “Pi Day”, 14 March 2004, at the Museum of the History of Science, Oxford, UK.[5] The NSE was chosen to benefit from this event because of Tammet's experience with epilepsy as a young child. Professor Allan Snyder at the Australian National University said of Tammet: "Savants can't usually tell us how they do what they do. It just comes to them. Daniel can. He describes what he sees in his head. That's why he's exciting. He could be the 'Rosetta Stone'."[6]

[edit] Language abilities

Tammet claims to speak eleven languages including English, French, Finnish, German, Spanish, Lithuanian, Romanian, Estonian, Icelandic, Welsh and Esperanto.

He particularly likes Estonian, because it is rich in vowels. Tammet is creating a new language called Mänti. Mänti has many features related to Finnish and Estonian, both of which are Finno-Ugric languages. Some sources credit Tammet as creating the Uusisuom and Lapsi languages as well.[7]

Tammet is capable of learning new languages very quickly. To prove this for a Channel Five documentary, Tammet was challenged to learn Icelandic in one week. Seven days later he appeared on Icelandic television conversing in Icelandic, with his Icelandic language instructor saying it was "not human" and "genius!". Segments of the interview showing Tammet responding to questions in Icelandic were televised on the 28 January 2007 edition of the CBS news magazine, 60 Minutes.[2]


Anyone have any idea about how he's able to do all this? I'm curious as to what physically is happening, how his synesthesia relates to his savant abilities to create his brain the way it is.
 
Last edited:
Amazing I agree. I wonder if, without this publicity, he could have applied for the MDC saying that he received pi to 25,000 places telepathically? Would he then do the "impossible" by reciting pi correctly to this number of places and walked away with the $1million?
 
I have just watched the whole doco, and Tammet would make the X-Men easily.

The only jarring moment was when he went to Las Vegas to see if he could win at blackjack counting cards. He couldn't, but the voiceover said that he then decided to trust his "intuition". He split two sevens against the dealer's ten (usually a bad bet). He drew another seven, split it and went on to draw three 21s. Pure dumb luck, that's all.

But leaving that alone, he has to be one of the most amazing people alive, and his talent is inexplicable.
 
Thanks for that godofpie. I thought I had seen something about him here before (must use search.....).
 
(parts two and three of this documentary also available on youtube)

Anyone have any idea about how he's able to do all this? I'm curious as to what physically is happening, how his synesthesia relates to his savant abilities to create his brain the way it is.

I don't know if this is the same doco I saw about Daniel as I can't get youtube at work.

In the doco I saw he describes that the he associates numbers with emotions and feelings, making his mathematical abilities almost like instinct. When he thinks about an equation the resulting numbers come to him as emotions. He was also able to learn Icelandic in a week, though he did have some problems with the accent on words.
 
I don't know if this is the same doco I saw about Daniel as I can't get youtube at work.

In the doco I saw he describes that the he associates numbers with emotions and feelings, making his mathematical abilities almost like instinct. When he thinks about an equation the resulting numbers come to him as emotions. He was also able to learn Icelandic in a week, though he did have some problems with the accent on words.


Yeah that sounds like the same docu. His synesthesia is unlike anyone elses, he combines every one of his senses with numbers. Most synesthetes only combine two or three, such as hearing notes as colors, or taste with smell. He has a distinct picture of every number up to 10,000, and to him numbers can be represented by emotions, visual pictures, sounds, movement, smell, taste, touch and texture(probably more). heres a direct link if that ones not working; http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Pt5VCj75X5g
 
Last edited:
I saw the documentary about him on the Discovery Channel a couple of years ago. I assume it's the same one.

Tammet has a book out. I believe it's called "Born On a Blue Day". My father-in-law gave it to me but I haven't had a chance to read it yet.
 
Amazing I agree. I wonder if, without this publicity, he could have applied for the MDC saying that he received pi to 25,000 places telepathically? Would he then do the "impossible" by reciting pi correctly to this number of places and walked away with the $1million?
Definitely not. There's no reason to allow the use of a number that's been agreed on in advance in a telepathy test. I would design the protocol to use a random number that's given to the sender at the last minute. If the person who claims to be able to receive numbers telepathically is able to get a 6-digit random number correct, that's definitely better evidence of telepathy then if he's able to get 25K decimals of pi right.

Since I'm talking about bad testing protocols...the task this guy was given at the beginning of the youtube clip is ridiculous. Most people can learn to do division in their head, but more importantly, the algorithm is such that it isn't any more difficult to get 100 decimals right than to get 3 decimals right. It's impressive that he does it so fast, but it doesn't prove that he has any "savant" skills.
 
Definitely not. There's no reason to allow the use of a number that's been agreed on in advance in a telepathy test. I would design the protocol to use a random number that's given to the sender at the last minute. If the person who claims to be able to receive numbers telepathically is able to get a 6-digit random number correct, that's definitely better evidence of telepathy then if he's able to get 25K decimals of pi right.

Since I'm talking about bad testing protocols...the task this guy was given at the beginning of the youtube clip is ridiculous. Most people can learn to do division in their head, but more importantly, the algorithm is such that it isn't any more difficult to get 100 decimals right than to get 3 decimals right. It's impressive that he does it so fast, but it doesn't prove that he has any "savant" skills.
No, learning a language in a week proves he has savant skills.

It's not superhuman, it's the very edge of human capacity.
 
Since I'm talking about bad testing protocols...the task this guy was given at the beginning of the youtube clip is ridiculous. Most people can learn to do division in their head, but more importantly, the algorithm is such that it isn't any more difficult to get 100 decimals right than to get 3 decimals right. It's impressive that he does it so fast, but it doesn't prove that he has any "savant" skills.
I agree this division test is no more difficult than playing many chess games blindfolded. Many persons can do that. What is needed is a good "photographic" memory.

For division you do the calculation in your mind as you would do it with a pen and a piece of paper.
 
No, learning a language in a week proves he has savant skills.
Does it really? I don't know what would happen if someone with a talent for languages in (say) the top 1.0% but not the top 0.5%, was to spend a week doing nothing but studying a new language, with a skilled teacher around the whole time. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the result looked a lot like what we saw or even better. I'm tempted to try to study a new language myself just to find out. :)

I agree this division test is no more difficult than playing many chess games blindfolded. Many persons can do that. What is needed is a good "photographic" memory.

For division you do the calculation in your mind as you would do it with a pen and a piece of paper.
It's not at all that difficult. If you do it with a pen and paper you'll see that you only have to memorize a small amount of information at each step, and you only have to remember it until you've completed that step. So I'd rather compare it with memorizing the first 6 moves or so of a chess game from a newspaper, and then repeating it many times with no requirement that you remember anything but the last game at any time.

I can divide those numbers in my head too, but nowhere near as fast as him. (I think most people who can do it on paper can learn to do it in their head with just a little bit of practice). So they really gave him a ridiculous task, but at least he solved it with an impressive speed.

Don't get me wrong guys. I'm very impressed by this guy. I'm just not very impressed by the people who tested him.
 
Being a savant isn't about doing something that nobody else can learn to do is it? It's about having an isolated skill which is marked contrast to the person's overall limitations (savants have developmental disorders, often but not always autism).
 
Last edited:
Being a savant isn't about doing something that nobody else can learn to do is it? It's about having an isolated skill which is marked contrast to the person's overall limitations (savants have developmental disorders, often but not always autism).

You're thinking of "The idiot savant."

Yes, it's about being a wise person.

–noun, plural sa·vants /sæˈvɑnts, ˈsævənts; Fr. saˈvɑ̃/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[sa-vahnts, sav-uhnts; Fr. sa-vahn] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation.
a person of profound or extensive learning; learned scholar.
 
Does it really? I don't know what would happen if someone with a talent for languages in (say) the top 1.0% but not the top 0.5%, was to spend a week doing nothing but studying a new language, with a skilled teacher around the whole time. I wouldn't be at all surprised if the result looked a lot like what we saw or even better. I'm tempted to try to study a new language myself just to find out. :).

You seriously think you could learn a new language in a week? IIRC they chose Icelandic because of the complexity of the language. Daniel was also able to speak 'conversational' not 'school room' Icelandic after the week. I have read that the more languages a person knows, the quicker they can pick up a new one, however I still think a week is fairly impressive.
 
It's virtually impossible. There are things called language immersion courses. They run on the order of 8 weeks. They are 100% studying of that language to the level where using native languages is not allowed to the students.

This brings you from a low-moderate level of knowledge to a moderate-high level.

To go from the 'no knowledge level' to the moderate-conversationally fluent level in a week is NOT a simple task, even for the top 1%.
 
You're thinking of "The idiot savant."

Yes, it's about being a wise person.

–noun, plural sa·vants /sæˈvɑnts, ˈsævənts; Fr. saˈvɑ̃/ Pronunciation Key - Show Spelled Pronunciation[sa-vahnts, sav-uhnts; Fr. sa-vahn] Pronunciation Key - Show IPA Pronunciation.
a person of profound or extensive learning; learned scholar.

I was talking about the meaning of savant as in savant syndrome (which includes autistic savants). Which you may have noticed seems to be the topic of the thread...
 
I was talking about the meaning of savant as in savant syndrome (which includes autistic savants). Which you may have noticed seems to be the topic of the thread...
Synesthesia is hardly a 'developmental disorder' any more than epilepsy is. It can in no way, shape, or form be compared to autism. Tammet merely proposed with "Savant Syndrome" that people who apparently process things differently, cognitively, are capable of learning in different ways than 'normal' people, which can lead to radically different learning times. I'm not sure there's much evidence for this theory besides selection bias (Hey look, we tend to notice people who are different AND can do amazing things over the people who, well, can't). Might be worth exploring, if we ever get around to determining what's a 'cognitive difference' is and what an 'unusual capacity' is.

The fact that you've decided to lump Synesthesia into developmental disorder is... bizarre. You seem to be utterly misunderstanding everything here.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom