too angry to form a logical argument

Roma

Master Poster
Joined
Aug 6, 2008
Messages
2,073
I am trying to write a letter to Dr.T. the President of a hospital to rebut his conclusion in response to my request for an apology for the misdiagnosis of multiple personality disorder.

I was misdiagnosed a long time ago by Dr.R. the director of that hospital's psychiatric department when after being asked what I do under stress I replied "switch to auto pilot and keep going".

I wrote Dr.T. last October explaining the problems I have encountered and will continue to encounter because of that misdiagnosis and provided documentation to him proving that I did not have MPD and am perfectly sane.
Two of the world's most highly regarded experts provided letters on my behalf, a psychiatrist from Canada and the other a psychiatrist and professor from Harvard.

I also included documents from several other psychiatrists from John Hopkins, Berkley and Philadelphia. I wrote my letter with the help of my province's Liberal Party leader who is also a doctor who wrote the province's Apology Act and thought I should also receive an apology from the hospital for the misdiagnosis.

So today I received Dr.T.'s response, short and infuriating. He concluded that since multiple personality disorder was in the DSM III when I was given that diagnosis then I was not misdiagnosed.

I am trying to respond to Dr.T.'s conclusion but am too angry to think clearly. What the hell? There are hundreds of diagnosis in that DSM III book but that doesn't mean I have any of them.

How can I argue? I am completely mind boggled (not in the DSM III).

I'm not kidding, I can imagine myself a little old lady in a nursing home some day dealing with that misdiagnosis, kind of worries me.

I've read some of the logical arguments in this philosophy site, I'm sure you guys can think of something. Help , please. Thank-you
 
Last edited:
Is this physician your primary care provider?

Is the diagnosis preventing you from getting the assistance you feel you need?

I'm not being confrontational, I'm just wondering how the diagnosis affects your particular situation.

So today I received Dr.T.'s response, short and infuriating. He concluded that since multiple personality disorder was in the DSM III when I was given that diagnosis then I was not misdiagnosed.

I will say, that looks a little weak. He shouldn't be using DSM-III, DSM-IV was published in 1994 and has had several updates since that time. For one thing, the term "Multiple Personality Disorder" isn't used now. It should be "Dissasociative Identity Disorder." Anyway, klepto- and pyromania are also listed in the DSM. Just because something IS listed in the DSM doesn't mean it was the correct diagnosis in and of itself.

Sounds like you have one arrogant doctor there.
 
Last edited:
Dr.T. is the President of the St.B. General Hospital, a hospital that I will likely need to go to in this city if I get sick. There's not much choice.

My family doctor of 21 years quit last year but before he left he encouraged me to write that letter to Dr.T. and have all of my old hospital records sealed. Something Dr.T. said would be too much trouble. I don't have a family doctor now.

This diagnosis prevents me from being taken seriously by the staff at that hospital.
For example, every time I am sent to that hospital for test of any kind I am asked at registration "which personality I am".

All symptoms are immediately regarded as psychiatric. I went into premature labor with my second child and was sent to a private room with a security guard outside the door. The Head of psychiatry came with 5 med students because the nurses told him I was switching personalities. I expalined that the nurses were calling me by my middle name instead of my first name but the contractions were so painful I didn't bother to correct the nurses and would answer to whatever the hell name they wanted to call me.

I took a heart stress test and passed out cold on the floor at the second stage, it was recorded as "anxiety".

I broke my jaw and was given valium for a year before any proper x-rays were offered.
 
Last edited:
You don't need to talk to the doctor.

You need to talk to a lawyer, who needs to talk to the doctor. Good gravy, what an awful problem. And isn't it nice how it's self-perpetuating, and no one has to take any of your protests or arguments seriously because you're insane? So of course you get angry, but of course, that's a symptom of your illness, so of course they patronize you and use "calming methods" on you, when in truth you could be perfectly calm if they'd just stop treating you as if you're insane!

Augh, that's horrible. Yeah, get a lawyer. And have a hug.
 
I'll second the "talk to a lawyer" thing.

Even _if_ (ad absurdum) you were insane, what they're doing isn't any kind of sane treatment or attitude. Any kind of psychotherapy is based on listening what the patient has to say, and letting him feel safe and comfortable while he explores his problems and all. Attitudes along the lines of "bwahaha, and which personality are you today" are outright counter-productive, _if_ the purpose is to actually help him/her.

There's also the issue of confidentiality. Depending on how far they go (e.g., if they call you insane in front of other people from your town) they could even be breaking the law. But even if not, it's not the way to get patients open their heart and explore their problems. If you want to psychoanalyze someone and get them to explore their problems, you have to guarantee to them that it stays between you and them, not that they could just as well put it on posters outside.

Now it may sound like I'm treating you as insane, but I'm not. As I was saying, this is an "ad absurdum." If you actually were, they wouldn't (or shouldn't) act that way. Public ridicule is _not_ a way to treat mental problems, it's a way to create or deepen emotional or mental problems.

It seems to me like pure malice, and someone using their position to harrass.
 
You don't need to talk to the doctor.

You need to talk to a lawyer, who needs to talk to the doctor.

Augh, that's horrible. Yeah, get a lawyer. And have a hug.

I'm quoting Sling, because I can't say this any better.

Some senior medics have a god complex. All senior lawyers have.
Full house beats two pair.
 
Lawyer, definitely. Media involvement might also be worth exploring as this whole thing could definitely turn into a big embarrassment for the hospital. Make sure you're documenting your correspondence with this doctor as well.
 
I am trying to write a letter to Dr.T. the President of a hospital to rebut his conclusion in response to my request for an apology for the misdiagnosis of multiple personality disorder.

I was misdiagnosed a long time ago by Dr.R. the director of that hospital's psychiatric department when after being asked what I do under stress I replied "switch to auto pilot and keep going".

You need to be honest when dealing with this issue. You were not diagnosed as having MPD because you made an off-hand remark. If you were in a situation where you were undergoing evaluation by a psychiatrist, there was some reason(s) for others and/or you to think you may have a mental illness. If you don't recognize and deal with this aspect, when describing the situation to people with psychiatric experience, you will make it difficult to take what you say at face-value.

Instead, if you are upfront about any issues you have, it makes it easier to trust that what you are saying isn't coloured by denial and misinterpretation. Because here's the thing....even if the diagnosis is correct or you have some other psychiatric diagnosis, you were still treated inappropriately and unethically. It would not have been okay for the clerk to ask you which personality you were today, for a security guard to be posted, or for you to be offered valium and to fail to diagnose a broken jaw even if you had MPD. The problem isn't the misdiagnosis (sorta), it's what was done with that diagnosis. And it's important to get those issues addressed. It's bad enough that people encounter prejudice in regards to mental illness from the lay public, but ignorance should not be tolerated in a health care setting.

I wrote Dr.T. last October explaining the problems I have encountered and will continue to encounter because of that misdiagnosis and provided documentation to him proving that I did not have MPD and am perfectly sane.
Two of the world's most highly regarded experts provided letters on my behalf, a psychiatrist from Canada and the other a psychiatrist and professor from Harvard.

I also included documents from several other psychiatrists from John Hopkins, Berkley and Philadelphia. I wrote my letter with the help of my province's Liberal Party leader who is also a doctor who wrote the province's Apology Act and thought I should also receive an apology from the hospital for the misdiagnosis.

So today I received Dr.T.'s response, short and infuriating. He concluded that since multiple personality disorder was in the DSM III when I was given that diagnosis then I was not misdiagnosed.

I suspect that he was simply responding to the contents of your argument. I'm guessing that the letters/documents that you provided from other psychiatrists were not directed at confirming your sanity, but were directed towards the validity of MPD as a diagnosis. And I don't know how you documented that you were sane, but it is unreasonable to ask him to second-guess another physician's diagnosis well after the fact with inadequate information. Even if you can pass on a report from a current psychiatric exam, it doesn't really address whether or not the diagnosis was a reasonable consideration at the time. I wouldn't really expect him to address that aspect, since it is not something he can. What he could have addressed is any problems specific to St. B. that you encountered as a result of this label. But you may not have given him enough information to act upon. He can't act upon gossip among the radiology department support staff, for example.

I am trying to respond to Dr.T.'s conclusion but am too angry to think clearly. What the hell? There are hundreds of diagnosis in that DSM III book but that doesn't mean I have any of them.

Which is why I suspect that you were arguing against the condition and he was simply arguing in kind.

Why were you directing your letter to the president? Why do you want an apology? The conditions that you revealed in your other post are more egregious and they will not be solved when you receive your apology. If an apology is also important to you, then I understand your pursuit of the president. But you would benefit more from exploring some other avenues, I think.

I don't get the impression that you want to become a public figure, so I'm not sure media exposure would be useful. And I'm not sure what the story is, either. There isn't anything newsworthy about the fluidity of diagnoses or that health care workers like to gossip like everyone else. And without damages, what would interest a lawyer (unless you are wealthy and can afford to hire a lawyer to pursue a principle)?

I'm going to give you some specific suggestions in response to your other post. I'm an MD from Canada and I have some familiarity with the area you are located. Feel free to take this to PM.

Linda
 
Okay, here's the exact lette I wrote:

Dr. T
President and Chief Executive Officer
General Hospital

Winnipeg, Manitoba
R2H 2A6

Dear Dr.T

I write to specifically ask for an apology for the misdiagnosis of multiple personality disorder and consequent multiple personality disorder therapy I endured at the hands of Dr. R, the Former Director of Psychiatry at the St.B, and his staff under his direction.

In October 1986 a University of Manitoba Student Psych. Services counselor, (also his student at the time), arranged for me to bring in an unemployment insurance medical form to get my claim extended based upon stress. After only fifteen minutes in Dr. R’ office he diagnosed me as suffering from multiple personality disorder, he then put out his hand to welcome me to MPD therapy, I put out my hand with the unemployment insurance form in it, he signed it and my life was never the same again.

My family was destroyed from the inevitable false accusations of sexual and ritual abuse that follow a diagnosis of MPD. My parents, both teachers, took early retirement. My family disowned me. My 10 year-old daughter was placed in foster care and secluded from her entire family until she reached adulthood to “protect” her from “the Satanic cult” Dr. R informed CFS my family was involved in.

I could not complete my university degree because of the MPD therapy. I lost my home, lost my career, lost all of my friends, and nearly lost my life several times.

Today I am faced with this misdiagnosis every time I go to a hospital for any type of medical test so I am also asking for my hospital records to be sealed. I told my family doctor, Dr.E that I was going to include in my request for an apology an additional request for my hospital records to be sealed and he emphatically agreed with me.

I am attaching medical assessments written by two of the world’s most highly respected experts regarding their own opinions that I do not have MPD, nor should I ever have been diagnosed with or treated for MPD.

I believe I am owed an apology from the St.B because this misdiagnosis and the subsequent therapy based on this misdiagnosis has ruined not only my life but has had a devastating affect on every member of my family, particularly my daughter who suffered terribly in foster care for eight years.

I thank you for your time and look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

Ms. Roma Hart
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I already spent 11 years dragging a medical malpractice lawsuit through the legal system and had to see it Dismissed Due to Delay because I could not afford to keep it going.

I had a broken foot, that's what the unemployment insurance was for but it ran out. My "clever" girlfriend suggested I could get an extension based on stress, why not go up to the Student Psych Center and have one of their counsellors fill out the unemployment extension form for me. How easy could that be, I was a single mom going to university full time, going back to work in the evenings as a maid with a foot that still hurt so baddly wasn't very appealing, if I could just get that extension to let my foot heal a little more , well why not, stressed? yup that's me.

Problem was that Student Psych couldn't fill out the form, and the doctor I went too see was findig patients with MPD under every rock. A complete lunatic, he went to the States after leaving my home town, that's why almost every expert witness who provided me with those letters is from the States, the reputable psychiatrists HATE him there. But when the patients in the States started suing him my source of funding for my lawsuit dwindled.

I couldn't get justice, but the Manitoba Apology Act was finally passed and received Royal Accent last year so at least, I thought , I could get an apology.
 
Last edited:
Dr.T. is the President of the St.B. General Hospital, a hospital that I will likely need to go to in this city if I get sick. There's not much choice.

My family doctor of 21 years quit last year but before he left he encouraged me to write that letter to Dr.T. and have all of my old hospital records sealed. Something Dr.T. said would be too much trouble. I don't have a family doctor now.

Your family doctor should have helped you find a new doctor before he quit. You need to have family doctor that listens to you, because it sounds like you may need an advocate. I don't know what it's like trying to find a primary care doctor where you are right now. But you probably should make the effort before you run into another problem. You are a young enough woman that you can use the excuse that you need a pap test to get an appointment, right? Be upfront about the problems you've had - "I know I can get anxious or come across as a whiner, but I can still develop medical problems just like anyone else. I need someone who will listen and take me seriously, rather than considering 'anxiety' as the default diagnosis every time I develop a new problem."

This diagnosis prevents me from being taken seriously by the staff at that hospital.
For example, every time I am sent to that hospital for test of any kind I am asked at registration "which personality I am".

This is a PHIA issue. Facilities and health care professionals are governed by the Private Health Information Act. The clerk at the registration desk should not know that you have this diagnosis. Personal medical information can only be released on a need-to-know basis with your permission, so if the clerks know, then someone has violated PHIA. Realistically, MPD is a dramatic diagnosis and people like to gossip even if they're not supposed to. It may be that the word spread a long time ago and it is now common knowledge whose source is untraceable. However, if there is ongoing leakage, this can be addressed. The next time this happens, consider pursuing it. Get the clerk's name and ask how she knows that you have this diagnosis. It may be that the doctor has written in this information on the request form for the diagnostic test. I can't think of any test you could be having where this sort of information would be relevant, though. If that is the case, then complaints should be directed at the doctor. Make a specific complaint about information leakage to the department where it occurred - Registration, Radiology, Emergency, etc. Make a complaint to PHIA and involve the Ombudsman if necessary.

http://www.ombudsman.mb.ca/phia-faq.htm

If you can identify that it was the actions of a specific physician and discussion with that physician is not fruitful, complain to the College of Physicians and Surgeons. It is part of the duty of a physician to maintain confidentiality of the medical records.

If it's a matter of 'common knowledge', it's still reasonable to expect the facility to deal with issues of prejudice. Make a complaint to a supervisor if a clerk makes a smart-ass comment.

All symptoms are immediately regarded as psychiatric. I went into premature labor with my second child and was sent to a private room with a security guard outside the door.

That is odd. I don't see how a diagnosis of MPD leads to a security guard. I have to wonder what else is in your history that leads anyone to associate you with a security risk.

The Head of psychiatry came with 5 med students because the nurses told him I was switching personalities.

This isn't unreasonable. It is better to ask an expert to evaluate whether or not there is a concern than to expect a nurse to make that call. And St. B. is a teaching hospital after all.

I expalined that the nurses were calling me by my middle name instead of my first name but the contractions were so painful I didn't bother to correct the nurses and would answer to whatever the hell name they wanted to call me.

How did the nurses know that you were diagnosed with MPD, since this certainly isn't information that would be relevant for your care? If it was the result of looking through your medical record, then I think you have a good case for getting your records altered. If you will notice, on that PHIA link I gave above, it describes the process for getting your records altered. I would consider pursuing the possibility of having all references to that diagnosis expunged if you can document that it was made in error.

I took a heart stress test and passed out cold on the floor at the second stage, it was recorded as "anxiety".

This may not have been unreasonable. You haven't given enough information, but if you passed out during the stress test, they would have been able to determine whether it was due to a physical condition. It may be that you were given the diagnosis of anxiety because they were able to rule-out other causes under those conditions, not because they ignored information in favour of a prior diagnosis.

I broke my jaw and was given valium for a year before any proper x-rays were offered.

That's your problem right there. If you had asked for valium, then they would have taken x-rays in order to justify withholding a possible drug of abuse. :rolleyes:

I think you've made a pretty good case for trying to prevent this diagnosis from following you around. You may have better luck if you start lower - like writing to Medical Records at the hospital. And give PHIA a try, as well. It puts more of the onus on you than is deserved, but you seem willing to put in some effort. And you may be able to get some of the physicians that you identified in your OP to continue to advocate on your behalf.

Linda
 
Okay, here's the exact lette I wrote:

Dr. T
President and Chief Executive Officer
General Hospital

Winnipeg, Manitoba
R2H 2A6

Dear Dr.T

I write to specifically ask for an apology for the misdiagnosis of multiple personality disorder and consequent multiple personality disorder therapy I endured at the hands of Dr. R, the Former Director of Psychiatry at the St.B, and his staff under his direction.

In October 1986 a University of Manitoba Student Psych. Services counselor, (also his student at the time), arranged for me to bring in an unemployment insurance medical form to get my claim extended based upon stress. After only fifteen minutes in Dr. R’ office he diagnosed me as suffering from multiple personality disorder, he then put out his hand to welcome me to MPD therapy, I put out my hand with the unemployment insurance form in it, he signed it and my life was never the same again.

My family was destroyed from the inevitable false accusations of sexual and ritual abuse that follow a diagnosis of MPD. My parents, both teachers, took early retirement. My family disowned me. My 10 year-old daughter was placed in foster care and secluded from her entire family until she reached adulthood to “protect” her from “the Satanic cult” Dr. Colin Ross informed CFS my family was involved in.

I could not complete my university degree because of the MPD therapy. I lost my home, lost my career, lost all of my friends, and nearly lost my life several times.

Today I am faced with this misdiagnosis every time I go to a hospital for any type of medical test so I am also asking for my hospital records to be sealed. I told my family doctor, Dr.E that I was going to include in my request for an apology an additional request for my hospital records to be sealed and he emphatically agreed with me.

I am attaching medical assessments written by two of the world’s most highly respected experts regarding their own opinions that I do not have MPD, nor should I ever have been diagnosed with or treated for MPD.

I believe I am owed an apology from the St.B because this misdiagnosis and the subsequent therapy based on this misdiagnosis has ruined not only my life but has had a devastating affect on every member of my family, particularly my daughter who suffered terribly in foster care for eight years.

I thank you for your time and look forward to your response.

Sincerely,

Ms. Roma Hart

I can understand why you want and deserve an apology. I do not know what sort of difference it will make to you - only you can make that determination - but you need more than that.

I guessed that the psychiatrist you were talking about had left the province and therefore was out of the jurisdiction of the College, who would have been responsible for ensuring his practice.

I don't have any personal experience with the debacle that you describe. Obviously this is part of a larger problem that has received well-deserved condemnation, but that doesn't help you personally.

I strongly encourage you to continue trying to get your records sealed and/or changed. I don't know how useful it would be to try and work through Dr. T. if he has already shown that he is reluctant (a far more temperate word than he deserves). If you can, you need to identify people locally who can help you and advocate on your behalf. I would really hope that you can identify a physician or physicians who can help you navigate this. It really should be possible to get this changed, though. I have a few connections, but I think they are less useful than the ones you already have. If you want my help (such as it is), please PM me.

Linda
 
I always get dizzy when I run, ever since I was little, I told them that and they wouldn't stop the test so I eventually passed out. Nothing much showed up on the first level of the test so they thumbed through my file and decided it was anxiety, though I don't know what so scary about running on a tread mill.

The doctor told me my jaw pain was TMJ and all I needed were warm baths and to reduce my stress, hence the valium.

Security guard outside the door, I still don't know why. Maybe they were worried about a crazy MPD person roaming around the maternity ward.

During the years that I was in deep MPD therapy with Dr.R. his therapy techniques certainly did cause me to behave like a crazy person, especially with the ultra high drug experiments and several hours of hypnotherapy every week. You can rightly say that I was known, and apparently well remembered.
 
I already spent 11 years dragging a medical malpractice lawsuit through the legal system and had to see it Dismissed Due to Delay because I could not afford to keep it going.

I had a broken foot, that's what the unemployment insurance was for but it ran out. My "clever" girlfriend suggested I could get an extension based on stress, why not go up to the Student Psych Center and have one of their counsellors fill out the unemployment extension form for me. How easy could that be, I was a single mom going to university full time, going back to work in the evenings as a maid with a foot that still hurt so baddly wasn't very appealing, if I could just get that extension to let my foot heal a little more , well why not, stressed? yup that's me.

Problem was that Student Psych couldn't fill out the form, and the doctor I went too see was findig patients with MPD under every rock. A complete lunatic, he went to the States after leaving my home town, that's why almost every expert witness who provided me with those letters is from the States, the reputable psychiatrists HATE him there. But when the patients in the States started suing him my source of funding for my lawsuit dwindled.

I couldn't get justice, but the Manitoba Apology Act was finally passed and received Royal Accent last year so at least, I thought , I could get an apology.

I can't even begin to tell you how disgusted I am by this story. Okay, so maybe you shouldn't have agreed to the diagnosis when he first showed up, but really, how were you to know that it would lead to all this?!!

I would have expected that there would be a group of you locally that had been harmed by this. Is this not the case and you were on your own there?

Linda
 
I always get dizzy when I run, ever since I was little, I told them that and they wouldn't stop the test so I eventually passed out. Nothing much showed up on the first level of the test so they thumbed through my file and decided it was anxiety, though I don't know what so scary about running on a tread mill.

The doctor told me my jaw pain was TMJ and all I needed were warm baths and to reduce my stress, hence the valium.

I'm only being somewhat facetious when I say that if you had asked for valium, your doctor would have done all he could to avoid giving it to you (like doing some diagnostic tests). This is not the first time I've seen something like this.

Security guard outside the door, I still don't know why. Maybe they were worried about a crazy MPD person roaming around the maternity ward.

I bet that was due to your CFS history, not the MPD per se.

During the years that I was in deep MPD therapy with Dr.R. his therapy techniques certainly did cause me to behave like a crazy person, especially with the ultra high drug experiments and several hours of hypnotherapy every week. You can rightly say that I was known, and apparently well remembered.

You can't help that you are known, but you could stop others from finding out as easily. Is it worth your while picking a doctor who is affliated with a different hospital?

Linda
 
Would my CFS history be in my hospital records?

I know my hospital records are in the old CFS file.

I have an old file in several hospitals in this city, but the main file regarding the initial misdiagnosis and therapy for MPD is in the St.B.
I was hoping to use the letter from Dr.T to help me get rid of all of those file references about MPD that exist at the other hospitals.

The Pain Clinic at the HSC, the emergency ward at a hospital a couple blocks away from my home, the hospital where I had my follow-up outpatient jaw surgery. I planned to take Dr.T.'s letter to the patient reps at those hospitals to have the diagnosis of MPD taken off their files too.
 
You deserve an apology. But you are asking Dr. T. to generate a piece of evidence to be used against his hospital at trial. The only way I see an apology coming your way is either as part of a settlement or part of a judgment. In other words, call a lawyer.
 
You deserve an apology. But you are asking Dr. T. to generate a piece of evidence to be used against his hospital at trial. The only way I see an apology coming your way is either as part of a settlement or part of a judgment. In other words, call a lawyer.

The point of the Apology Act that Roma Hart referred to earlier was to specify that an apology can't be used as evidence. This is supposed to remove a barrier towards obtaining an official apology.

What do you think the hospital is liable for?

Linda
 
Would my CFS history be in my hospital records?

They could be, especially if they were called in at any point where you were using hospital services (ER, inpatient, outpatient program held in the hospital, doctor visits, etc.). The notes of the hospital social workers will be part of your medical record and they would include that information (the social worker would get that info from CFS). Social workers are involved in many departments - particularly psychiatry.

You have the right to look at your records. You should go through them and document where the MPD diagnosis shows up, anyway.

I know my hospital records are in the old CFS file.

I have an old file in several hospitals in this city, but the main file regarding the initial misdiagnosis and therapy for MPD is in the St.B.
I was hoping to use the letter from Dr.T to help me get rid of all of those file references about MPD that exist at the other hospitals.

The Pain Clinic at the HSC, the emergency ward at a hospital a couple blocks away from my home, the hospital where I had my follow-up outpatient jaw surgery. I planned to take Dr.T.'s letter to the patient reps at those hospitals to have the diagnosis of MPD taken off their files too.

Ah, that makes sense.

Linda
 
Last edited:
The point of the Apology Act that Roma Hart referred to earlier was to specify that an apology can't be used as evidence. This is supposed to remove a barrier towards obtaining an official apology.
Oh, then never mind. Thank you.

What do you think the hospital is liable for?
I have no way of knowing what the hospital is liable for, but it sure looks like there's a possibility of a negligence action here. I don't know if it would fall under the label of "malpractice" or not. But the point is less about the hospital being liable than it is about the hospital being sued. Which (given my ignorance about the Apology Act) seemed an awful lot more likely with the apology than without. But with the Apology Act, yes, that makes it different, and hopefully better.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom