Split Thread The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution

Cain

Straussian
Joined
May 31, 2002
Messages
15,608
Location
Los Angeles
Here's the problem: The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution.

I forget the numbers, but I recall reading an article saying Senate Republicans represents one-hundred X number of million people, and Democrats, who were in the minority at the time, represented 200 X number of million people (upper 100 million vs. lower 200 million). That's crazy.

I am not necessarily philosophically opposed to the idea of filibustering, but the Republican "majority" was an illusion, and we need to apply democratic principles of one person, one vote to the Senate.

Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Gaspode
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Here's the problem: The Senate is a highly undemocratic institution.

Absolutely correct. That's the way it's supposed to be.

The USA is NOT a democracy -- it is a REPUBLIC. It deliberately created a balance between proportional representation (in the House of Representatives) and one where each state of the Union has the same number of senators (the Senate).

The idea of this bicameral legistlature is to let the majority have more power while not allowing it to overwhelm the minority. The senate is there precisely to make sure the larger (in terms of population) states of the union do not overwhelm the smaller, less populous ones.

Right now the less populous, more rural states tend to be Republican, and the large, more populous ones tend to be democratic. In the past, the smaller states used to be Democratic, while the more populous, larger states tended to be Republican.

In neither case should the senate have been changed just to make it "more democratic" and not "crazily out of touch with the will of the people". All such statements really mean is, "let the current majority overwhelm the current minority! I don't care, because right now the majority I LIKE happens to be in power!"
 
Absolutely correct. That's the way it's supposed to be.

The USA is NOT a democracy -- it is a REPUBLIC. It deliberately created a balance between proportional representation (in the House of Representatives) and one where each state of the Union has the same number of senators (the Senate).

The idea of this bicameral legistlature is to let the majority have more power while not allowing it to overwhelm the minority. The senate is there precisely to make sure the larger (in terms of population) states of the union do not overwhelm the smaller, less populous ones.

Right now the less populous, more rural states tend to be Republican, and the large, more populous ones tend to be democratic. In the past, the smaller states used to be Democratic, while the more populous, larger states tended to be Republican.

In neither case should the senate have been changed just to make it "more democratic" and not "crazily out of touch with the will of the people". All such statements really mean is, "let the current majority overwhelm the current minority! I don't care, because right now the majority I LIKE happens to be in power!"

Oh noes, the smaller states will be overwhelmed! Heavens to Betsy!

The idea that democracy has to be inefficient to be good is silly. Furthermore, the idea that it should be so based on geography is even dumber. The government is made for the people, not invisible entities called States. And thanks for reading my mind.
 
Absolutely correct. That's the way it's supposed to be.

The USA is NOT a democracy -- it is a REPUBLIC.

Oh God, it's you. Of course you believe such nonsense. After all, it's the natural right of the "Chosen People" to oppress the Palestinian hordes.

Your argument -- such as it is -- is not only a non sequitur, it's not very good. I don't think you know what a republic is. Supposing our Senate was a more democratic -- and dare I say "civilized" institution -- would we somehow be less of a republic? Would the republic be under threat? Was the 17th Amendment a threat to republicanism? Do you even know what a republic is?

It deliberately created a balance between proportional representation (in the House of Representatives) and one where each state of the Union has the same number of senators (the Senate).

The idea of this bicameral legistlature is to let the majority have more power while not allowing it to overwhelm the minority. The senate is there precisely to make sure the larger (in terms of population) states of the union do not overwhelm the smaller, less populous ones.

Do you know why? The U.S. Constitution is not some grand philosophical document from on high? It was borne out of political compromises from the time, and in the case of our bicameral legislature, the "Great Compromise." There were other compromises: ending the slave trade in 1808 for no export tax. Counting blacks as 3/5 of a person for census purposes. Stop your foolishness.


Right now the less populous, more rural states tend to be Republican, and the large, more populous ones tend to be democratic. In the past, the smaller states used to be Democratic, while the more populous, larger states tended to be Republican.

How is this at all relevant or meaningful? Who cares about the political parties?

[quote[In neither case should the senate have been changed just to make it "more democratic" and not "crazily out of touch with the will of the people". All such statements really mean is, "let the current majority overwhelm the current minority! I don't care, because right now the majority I LIKE happens to be in power!"[/QUOTE]

Total B.S.

I would like to know why conservatives are enamored with being ruled by a minority.
 
Man, Washinton ,Jefferson, and the rest of the founding fathers were DUMB.
We need to get rid of the Consitution, and have a new one written by a group of Cool,Hip, Internet Revolutionaries.
 
The Constitution seems to say otherwise.


TSuka Buddha seems to want an overwhelmingly powerful federal government. Maybe why he seems to dislike the Constituion is because it would get in the way of the political and economic agenda he wants.
 
Man, Washinton ,Jefferson, and the rest of the founding fathers were DUMB. We need to get rid of the Consitution, and have a new one written by a group of Cool,Hip, Internet Revolutionaries.

Weak sarcasm coupled with a weaker argument -- or what I expect from you.

You want to cast the debate in other terms: The founding fathers are DUMB. We need to replace the Constitution with "Internet Revolutions." Try to engage the arguments at hand, if you can. Madison, the "Father of the Constitution," originally proposed a bicameral legislature based on population. Politicians then were still politicians, often motivated by self-interest (despite the lies your teacher told you).

The character of the country has changed since the late 1700s. Indeed, it changed quite some time ago when Lincoln, "the Father of the Republican Party" as John McCain likes to say, won the Civil War. This IS the United States.
 
Weak sarcasm coupled with a weaker argument -- or what I expect from you.

You want to cast the debate in other terms: The founding fathers are DUMB. We need to replace the Constitution with "Internet Revolutions." Try to engage the arguments at hand, if you can. Madison, the "Father of the Constitution," originally proposed a bicameral legislature based on population. Politicians then were still politicians, often motivated by self-interest (despite the lies your teacher told you).

The character of the country has changed since the late 1700s. Indeed, it changed quite some time ago when Lincoln, "the Father of the Republican Party" as John McCain likes to say, won the Civil War. This IS the United States.
And as such, the controls in the legislature help, in conjunction with the Judicial branch, prevent the "Tyranny of the Majority" by helping protect the Rights of EVERYBODY, not just the plurality
 
but the Republican "majority" was an illusion
Regardless of the number of people represented, each Senator's vote is worth the same. As the Republicans, at one time, had the majority of those votes, the had the majority. In reality.

You may not like it, but reality doean't really care about our feelings.
 
And as such...

And as such what? What's your jumping off point? Suppose we transform the Senate into a democratic institution, is the threat of tyranny more likely? You seem to be blabbing about a different type of majoritarian tyranny, one that lacks even the basic dignity of drawing its authority from the people. Your tyranny of the many is the tyranny of smaller states. In a republic, the people are sovereign.

What's amusing is that we can easily re-write this story in conservative terms, extolling virtues of excellence, and merit. You have big states and small states. Why? In some cases because some states are just better than others. A lot of people prefer to live in America than pick-some-dumb-third-world country because, well, America is better. America's the best. Similarly, a lot of people choose to live in New York and California because they're dreamers and they want to make something of themselves. They want to succeed. Yet, in America, right now, tax dollars flow from the populous states to the not-so-populous states. You're taking our tax dollars for dumb pet projects and stupid Homeland Security protocols (as if any self-respecting terrorist is going to attack ****in' Wyoming).

Upchurch wrote:
Regardless of the number of people represented, each Senator's vote is worth the same.

I suppose you're trying to make some show of intellectual independence, but you're looking uncharacteristically foolish. Yes, each Senator has an equal vote even though some represent lots of people while others represent relatively few people. That's, um, the thrust of my the moral argument -- that this state of affairs is unjust.

As the Republicans, at one time, had the majority of those votes, the had the majority. In reality. You may not like it, but reality doean't really care about our feelings.

I hope you didn't scratch yourself too bad from falling flat on your face with this one.
I suppose we could go back to census data when three-fifths was still in effect and claim the "reality" is that government only recognizes X number of blacks. We may not like it, but we can't deny that reality. OoooooK. :rolleyes: The trouble is you're not making a relevant moral argument, and what's doubly insulting you're claiming to offer some reality-sensitive observation.

The whole point is that if you have, say, 55 Republicans representing 170 million people and 45 Democrats representing 220 million people, then there's a moral disconnect. I'm interested in learning how such an institution helps stave off tyranny.
 
The whole point is that if you have, say, 55 Republicans representing 170 million people and 45 Democrats representing 220 million people, then there's a moral disconnect. I'm interested in learning how such an institution helps stave off tyranny.

Fortunately, that's not the case. We have 100 senators (of some mixture of political parties) representing 50 states. Two senators per state seems balanced to me.
 
The whole point is that if you have, say, 55 Republicans representing 170 million people and 45 Democrats representing 220 million people, then there's a moral disconnect. I'm interested in learning how such an institution helps stave off tyranny.
You have that with the House. The number of House seats are based on state population because the House was set up to be the people's representatives. The Senate was not even an elected body until the 17th Amendment was ratified 1n 1913, Senators were appointed by State legislatures, because it was envisioned as a deliberative body that acted as a brake on rash action from the House. It is now an elective office BUT it is still supposed to be a deliberative body. You have your proportionate representation in the House and you have a check in place in the Senate to protect the smaller states from their minority status in the House.
 
Last edited:
Fortunately, that's not the case. We have 100 senators (of some mixture of political parties) representing 50 states. Two senators per state seems balanced to me.

Oh, it "seems balanced" to "jsfisher" -- what in holy god **** was I thinking. Yeah, 100, a nice round number. Jesus, it all makes perfect sense now.

Texas wrote:
You have that with the House. The number of House seats are based on state population because the House was set up to be the people's representatives. The Senate was not even an elected body until the 17th Amendment was ratified 1n 1913, Senators were appointed by State legislatures, because it was envisioned as a deliberative body that acted as a brake on rash action from the House.

And the progressives from early in the last century thought they were SOOOOO much smarter than the DUMB founding fathers. Dudalb, your fatuous aside now recalls what Douglas said to Lincoln in those famous debates:

Surely, Mr. Lincoln is a wiser man than those who framed the Government. Washington did not believe, nor did his compatriots, that the local laws and domestic institutions...

Returning to our normal programming, the argument seems to be that this "deliberative body" serves as a check against its representative counterpart (which is restless and unthinking, like the masses):

It is now an elective office BUT it is still supposed to be a deliberative body. You have your proportionate representation in the House and you have a check in place in the Senate to protect the smaller states from their minority status in the House.

The House of Representatives is also ********. It's not representative because the vast majority of those districts are comically gerrymandered. Politicians are choosing voters, rather than voters choosing politicians. We have, what, two dozen competitive elections in a given year?

I'm interested in learning what sort of protections has the Senate been responsible for? Can you point to any examples?

I do wonder if Republicans would be in favor of an affirmative action-quota-style legislature to protect racial minorities -- actual people, not imaginaries -- for the all too real oppression they have historically experienced. We allot a certain number of seats to blacks, latinos, and Native Americans. This need not be representative -- we can give 54% of the seats to Native Americans. The Senate is already arbitrary enough, despite magical numbers like "100."

For some reason I think conservatives would immediately dismiss that idea out of hand. Maybe a few will concede that it would have once been a good idea, but not now in 2009.

If we are wedded to this idea of a deliberative body, then maybe we should seriously reconsider the Founding Fathers' original intention of not having the Senate elected by the people. We need to insulate this Patrician institution from the rabble; if our leaders are held accountable to hoi polloi rather than their own noble conscience, you're going to have lowest common denominator politics.

Upchurch.

Yeah, whatever. The sad fact -- the reality -- is that there is no decent argument for the Senate in its present form.

ETA: Open question- I really want to know what the large states are going to do to oppress the small states. What are your specific fears?
 
Last edited:
Oh, it "seems balanced" to "jsfisher" -- what in holy god **** was I thinking. Yeah, 100, a nice round number. Jesus, it all makes perfect sense now.

I have no idea what you were thinking, but I am glad I could be of service untangling the mystery for you of why the US has a senate. A lot of people get confused simply because they want it to be something it isn't.

You're welcome, by the way.
 
Last edited:
ETA: Open question- I really want to know what the large states are going to do to oppress the small states. What are your specific fears?

Excellent question hidden behind that straw man you erected. Maybe you'd consider starting a new thread with just such a question so as to not derail this one.
 
I live in a state where the majority was able to dominate the minority through ballot measures (aka elected representatives being too chicken to do their job so they hand it to the mobs), precisely the thing the constitution wanted to prevent

it SUCKS

Run away democracy is exactly the same as mob rule, not a happy way to live when you fall out of favor with the conformist drones
 
Man, Washinton ,Jefferson, and the rest of the founding fathers were DUMB.
We need to get rid of the Consitution, and have a new one written by a group of Cool,Hip, Internet Revolutionaries.

OMG LOLZ. Yay for a completely irrational argument.

And Jefferson wasn't even there and only argued for the Bill of Rights to be added.

TSuka Buddha seems to want an overwhelmingly powerful federal government. Maybe why he seems to dislike the Constituion is because it would get in the way of the political and economic agenda he wants.

No, I prefer a unitarian, unicameral government with proportional representation. And I don't see how that would help my political agenda, seeing as I am by far a minority in the things I care about (Gay marriage, health care, education, energy), and the economy is of the things I don't care much about seeing as I don't have an agenda to speak of.

I just like my governmental philosophy to be based on some premises, and not just hodge-podged together with what they had at the time and however they could get people to agree to it and then worshiping that as a new Revelation from the Lord.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom