What if you're wrong?

Robert Oz

Graduate Poster
Joined
Dec 3, 2007
Messages
1,455
Atheists and agnostics are often asked by the religious, 'What if you're wrong?' in regards to God's existence. I believe Bertrand Russell, when asked what he would say to God if he faced him in the after-life, responded with something along the lines of 'There wasn't enough evidence'.

The religious seem to think that the question doesn't apply to them, but, assuming a god exists, choosing the wrong religion could result in the same fiery torment that would be in store for atheists and agnostics.

So, to the religious folk who frequent this forum and believe atheists and agnostics will go to hell once they die:

What if you're wrong? What will you say to the real god when you face him/her/it in the after-life?
 
They will say the same thing that everyone else says after death.
Nothing.
 
Why would it matter what I said?

I never yet convinced a believer that my atheist stance was morally justifiable.
What chance would I have changing the mind of an entity smart enough to create a universe?

If ever there was a time to STFU , that would seem to be it.
 
I will stand tall and say,

"Homage to thee, O Great God, Lord of Ma'at, I have come to thee, O my Lord, that I may behold thy beneficence. I know thee, and I know thy name, and the names of the Forty-Two who live with thee in the Hall of Ma'at, who keep ward over sinners, and feed upon their blood on the day of estimating characters before Un-Nefer ... Behold, I have come to thee, and I have brought ma'at to thee. I have destroyed sin for thee. I have not sinned against men. I have not oppressed my kinsfolk. I have done no wrong in the place of truth. I have not known worthless folk. I have not wrought evil. I have not defrauded the oppressed one of his goods. I have not done the things that the gods abominate. I have not vilified a servant to his master. I have not caused pain. I have not let any man hunger. I have made no one to weep. I have not committed murder. I have not commanded any to commit murder for me. I have inflicted pain on no man. I have not defrauded the temples of their oblations. I have not purloined the cakes of the gods. I have not stolen the offerings to the spirits of the dead. I have not committed fornication. I have not polluted myself in the holy places of the god of my city. I have not diminished from the bushel. I did not take from or add to the acre-measure. I did not encroach on the fields of others. I have not added to the weights of the scales. I have not misread the pointer of the scales. I have not taken milk from the mouths of children. I have not driven cattle from their pastures. I have not snared the birds of the gods. I have not caught fish with fish of their kind. I have not stopped water when it should flow. I have not cut the dam of a canal. I have not extinguished a fire when it should burn. I have not altered the times of the chosen meat offerings. I have not turned away the cattle intended for offerings. I have not repulsed the god at his appearances. I am pure. I am pure. I am pure. I am pure...."
 
I try to live my life in pretty much the same way as I did when I was a christian - except for the praying etc. If the god I believed in then exists, then I don't think he would hold it against me that I don't believe in him as long as I am trying to live a good life. If some other sort of god exists, then I would have been going to hell anyway.
 
The OP is addressed to theists and I must admit I would like to hear from them. It is true that it is a question often put to atheists but the question must be at least as important to those who believe in a jealous god
 
I'd probably say something like:

"Oh F***"


(Why not, I'd be likely to be headed for hell anyhow :D )
 
Atheists and agnostics are often asked by the religious, 'What if you're wrong?' in regards to God's existence. I believe Bertrand Russell, when asked what he would say to God if he faced him in the after-life, responded with something along the lines of 'There wasn't enough evidence'.

The religious seem to think that the question doesn't apply to them, but, assuming a god exists, choosing the wrong religion could result in the same fiery torment that would be in store for atheists and agnostics.

So, to the religious folk who frequent this forum and believe atheists and agnostics will go to hell once they die:

What if you're wrong? What will you say to the real god when you face him/her/it in the after-life?

My best friend believes I will "face Him" at the end. He does it out of love and concern for my "immortal soul" so I don't mind. He also only expresses this belief when we get into serious religious discussion.

I think, were I religious, and turned out to have chosen wrongly, and I had a chance to say anything, I might say, "But I tried so hard."
 
I ask, "Don't you hope that you are wrong?"

Because, see, if you're right, then that means reality is ruled by a psychopathic god who intends to torture for ever and ever almost everybody who ever lived simply because they refused to believe in him, or to do the odd things he says.

And wouldn't that be, or isn't that, a horrible, horrible situation?
 
Why would it matter what I said?

I never yet convinced a believer that my atheist stance was morally justifiable.
What chance would I have changing the mind of an entity smart enough to create a universe?

If ever there was a time to STFU , that would seem to be it.

Just a nitpick, an entity able to create the universe would not necessary be smart, only have the correct tool, the will to do it, and a big but finite amount of energy. I never understood why people keep ascribing it the tag "smart" as there is no display of smartness involved. It could be pure reflex or instinct without even a single drop of intelligence involved.

For what it matters, it could be that you meet after death a completely retard idiot god, dancing at the sound of an insane flute music(i.e. Azatoth).
 
Last edited:
I will stand tall and say,

"Homage to thee, O Great God, Lord of Ma'at, I have come to thee, O my Lord, that I may behold thy beneficence. I know thee, and I know thy name, and the names of the Forty-Two who live with thee in the Hall of Ma'at, who keep ward over sinners, and feed upon their blood on the day of estimating characters before Un-Nefer ... Behold, I have come to thee, and I have brought ma'at to thee. I have destroyed sin for thee. I have not sinned against men. I have not oppressed my kinsfolk. I have done no wrong in the place of truth. I have not known worthless folk. I have not wrought evil. I have not defrauded the oppressed one of his goods. I have not done the things that the gods abominate. I have not vilified a servant to his master. I have not caused pain. I have not let any man hunger. I have made no one to weep. I have not committed murder. I have not commanded any to commit murder for me. I have inflicted pain on no man. I have not defrauded the temples of their oblations. I have not purloined the cakes of the gods. I have not stolen the offerings to the spirits of the dead. I have not committed fornication. I have not polluted myself in the holy places of the god of my city. I have not diminished from the bushel. I did not take from or add to the acre-measure. I did not encroach on the fields of others. I have not added to the weights of the scales. I have not misread the pointer of the scales. I have not taken milk from the mouths of children. I have not driven cattle from their pastures. I have not snared the birds of the gods. I have not caught fish with fish of their kind. I have not stopped water when it should flow. I have not cut the dam of a canal. I have not extinguished a fire when it should burn. I have not altered the times of the chosen meat offerings. I have not turned away the cattle intended for offerings. I have not repulsed the god at his appearances. I am pure. I am pure. I am pure. I am pure...."
Gosh what would you say to the Gods if you did do all of these things? Uh nobodys perfect?
 
In that case, I guess the apropriate phrase would be, "bite me!" :p

I mean, it would be about to happen anyway :p
 
"I don't know how things turned out in the rest of the universe, but in that little corner called Earth I don't think we got to see your best work. Would you like some advice on how you might do a better job next time?"
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom