Specified Complexity the hallmark of Intelligent Design

Joined
Feb 1, 2009
Messages
647
In my personal search for truth (God) has led me through two decades of (mild) adventure and travel, most of it spiritual some of it via a jet plane on a flight plan vs. an spirit on an astral plane. I agree with much of established ID. We sorely need a standard theory. Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events? We can say that in addition to high improbability events and conformity to an independently given pattern should also exist (to lend credence to ID). When these two rudiments/situations are present, we have what ID proponents call “specified complexity” (SC). What is SC you say ? Lets use the example of a poker game. All deals of the cards is equally and highly improbable. Nevertheless if a guy across from you gets a royal flush every time you can bet this is not the result of chance but of design !

In the labors of Intelligent Design theorists we find that none of them appeals to the simple high improbability of an event or thing as a basis for a design inference (conclusions). Our own existence, for example has to do with the exceedingly improbable union of one specific sperm and a one in specific egg. Nevertheless, ID proponents wouldn’t say conception was intelligently designed.

A reader writing in to Dr William Craig (a Christian, ID apologist) used this example: Imagine a likely Universe that is a great deal larger than our own, in which there are only two small space asteroids in existence, but they are located on different ‘edges’ of the Universe. The likelihood of these two small rocks colliding is dreadfully improbable, but if it did theoretically happen, would that warrant a supernatural explanation?

If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...

With the disinformation on the web you could use this criteria to determine if a claim meets ID criteria, such that is. I hope that this clears up a bit of the mystery of ID.

; {>
 
Last edited:
If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity.
That is exactly right! Most I.D. proponents would like people to think that there is no third alternative: It must be either designed or random chance.

But, the very nature of the sciences of abiogenesis, evolution, and cosmology, etc. belie that false dichonomy: These are teams of scientists devoted to the empirical, physical behavior of things. It would not be very helpful to anyone if all they did was declare "Oh, well that's just all random chance.", would it?



ETA: And, of course, it wouldn't be helpful to anyone if the scientists declared "Oh, well it was all designed that way.", either. What is more helpful is understand how and why things work the way they do, as precisely as possible. And, sciences such as evolution and abiogenesis are able to do that for biological life forms.
 
Last edited:
That is exactly right! Most I.D. proponents would like people to think that there is no third alternative: It must be either designed or random chance.


There is also the "inconceivable" angle. If I can't conceive of a natural explanation, then it must be the handiwork of my choice of magical sky daddy. This is the entirety of the argument proffered by the OP.
 
I'm not sure you're quite correct about what a pattern is, and how what we think of as patterns can emerge without a plan.

Can you point to the rocks which have split apart to spell "Welcome to the Milky Way?" I have not yet seen them.
 
...
If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”
...


I ask you: If two rocks collide in space and spell out a welcome message, and no human is there to read it, is it really the work of a human-designed designer? Hmm?
 
I agree with much of established ID.
There isn't much of ID to agree with. As we shall see.

We sorely need a standard theory.
We have one. It's the Theory of Evolution. But you are going to go to all sorts of places that have nothing to do with ID or evolution. Right? Please don't disappoint us!

Nevertheless I will attempt to explain my beliefs and why I think ID is a credible idea.
Fire away.

How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe
Fweep! Foul!

How improbable, exactly? How finely tuned? Can you even calculate these numbers? What models are you using for your calculations? What criteria did you apply in selecting these models?

Continue.

could warrant belief in a God
Fweep! Foul!

What God? Why one God and not multiple gods and/or goddesses and/or other entities? If you selected the God of one of the major monotheistic religions, on what basis do you reject the other major monotheistic religions, the minor monotheistic religions, polytheistic religions, and general animism, pantheism, and spirituality? What properties does your God have? And how did you determine this?

Continue.

and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events?
Fweep! Foul!

You have yet to establish any degrees of probability for any events, much less that this degree is incomprehensible. We can comprehend some pretty darn big things.

Continue.

We can say that in addition to high improbability events
Fweep! Foul.

Not established.

Continue.

and conformity to an independently given pattern
Fweep! Foul.

Conformity in what way? Independently to what? Pattern of what?

Continue.

should also exist (to lend credence to ID). When these two rudiments/situations are present, we have what ID proponents call “specified complexity” (SC). What is SC you say ?
What is SC?

Lets use the example of a poker game. All deals of the cards is equally and highly improbable. Nevertheless if a guy across from you gets a royal flush every time you can bet this is not the result of chance but of design!
Fweep! Foul.

Did not address the question.

In the labors of Intelligent Design theorists we find that none of them appeals to the simple high improbability of an event or thing as a basis for a design inference (conclusions).
Fweep! Foul.

Yeah, that is precisley what they do. Also, they get their calculations of probabilities hopelessly wrong.

Continue.

Our own existence, for example has to do with the exceedingly improbable union of one specific sperm and a one in specific egg. Nevertheless, ID proponents wouldn’t say conception was intelligently designed.
Fweep! Foul.

They make this claim for the blood clotting cascade (demolished), the bacterial flagellum (demolished), the immune system (demolished), and the eye (demolished by Darwin over a century earlier). To claim that they wouldn't make some other equally absurd proposition is purely speculative.

Continue.

A reader writing in to Dr William Craig (a Christian, ID apologist) used this example: Imagine a likely Universe that is a great deal larger than our own, in which there are only two small space asteroids in existence, but they are located on different ‘edges’ of the Universe. The likelihood of these two small rocks colliding is dreadfully improbable, but if it did theoretically happen, would that warrant a supernatural explanation?
No.

If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”
Fweep! Foul.

That would suggest design in precisely the same way as your poker opponent drawing 2, 3, 7, 9 and Q for a given hand.

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...
Fweep! Foul.

No probabilities, high, low, or otherwise, have been established.

No patterns, dependent, independent, or otherwise, have been established.

With the disinformation on the web you could use this criteria to determine if a claim meets ID criteria, such that is.
What?

I hope that this clears up a bit of the mystery of ID.
That was, without question, the most incoherent argument for Intelligent Design that it has ever been my sorry experience to witness. Everyone in this room is now dumber for having listened to it. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
 
Last edited:
To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...

Good plan. Can you give us an example of "high improbability" that meets with "an independently given pattern". Of course, I'm talking about in natural phenomena, not royal flushes or mousetraps, which we know are designed.

Can you give us an example of something that most of us on JREF thinks developed by without direction, simply under the influence of natural law and random chance, but which has a very high improbability and an independently given pattern?
 
How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events?
1) what's finely-tuned about our universe?
2) it's a loaded question anyway, given we are here.
3) with regards to a similar question, the probability of abiogenesis, Dawkins gives an excellent explanation in the "Blind Watchmaker". It involves, a.o., that our mind isn't very suited to assess risk in evens with a very low probability. I can't cite details from it, I lent my copy to a Christian friend :). But I'd say, show the numbers.

We can say that in addition to high improbability events and conformity to an independently given pattern should also exist (to lend credence to ID). When these two rudiments/situations are present, we have what ID proponents call “specified complexity” (SC). What is SC you say ? Lets use the example of a poker game. All deals of the cards is equally and highly improbable. Nevertheless if a guy across from you gets a royal flush every time you can bet this is not the result of chance but of design !

4) Bolding mine - you misspelled "cdesign proponentsists".

5) Yes, if that guy had 10 flushes in a row, I'd also investigate if he'd stacked the deck. However, if he had only one flush, he's just lucky. AFAIK, we only have one universe.

6) In case of the poker game, we can calculate the numbers, on the assumption of a randomly shuffled deck. Specify the kind of poker game you want, and show the numbers. What's the precondition for the universe? Again, show the numbers and the reasoning for it.

In the labors of Intelligent Design theorists we find that none of them appeals to the simple high improbability of an event or thing as a basis for a design inference (conclusions). Our own existence, for example has to do with the exceedingly improbable union of one specific sperm and a one in specific egg. Nevertheless, ID proponents wouldn’t say conception was intelligently designed.
What's a "simple high improbability"? Where is your cutoff point?

A reader writing in to Dr William Craig (a Christian, ID apologist) used this example: Imagine a likely Universe that is a great deal larger than our own, in which there are only two small space asteroids in existence, but they are located on different ‘edges’ of the Universe. The likelihood of these two small rocks colliding is dreadfully improbable, but if it did theoretically happen, would that warrant a supernatural explanation?
I'm not very interested in Craig's imaginative worlds. We have this world to observe. He can't even keep up with basic set theory. But nevertheless: stick a number to "dreadfully improbable".

If the two rocks collided, you would deduce it was neither design nor chance as the best explanation. We should look to the third alternative ie physical necessity. Because gravitation acts over infinite distances, it is in fact, unavoidable that those two masses will eventually collide. However the thing that would suggest design would be if the rocks were to smash into pieces which then came together to spell “Welcome to the Milky Way.”
You're sure? Your whole argument rests on measures of probability. Show the numbers. Would it also be design in your opinion if they spelled "Craig sucks balls"?

To detect design look for high improbability conjoined with an independently given pattern. Thats all folks...
Again a paragraph with the word "improbability". I note the utter lack of numbers in your whole argument. Calculate!

With the disinformation on the web you could use this criteria to determine if a claim meets ID criteria, such that is. I hope that this clears up a bit of the mystery of ID.
I haven't seen any criterion. You're peddling with measures of probability, but you've thus far utterly failed to stick any number at all to any of your statements.

Go do your homework, calculate the numbers, and present the calculations here. Better be prepared well, your performance in the other thread didn't give the impression that math is your forte.

:popcorn1
 
I don't think that there's a distinct difference between design and chance anyway. If I throw an axe at the wall, and it leaves a dent, did I design the dent? If I spend ten years throwing axes at walls and learn how to produce any type of dent I want, do I design dents? What about damage done to the axe? Do I design that?

Confusion arises from trying to use vague words at the same time as logic.
 
You're sure? Your whole argument rests on measures of probability. Show the numbers. Would it also be design in your opinion if they spelled "Craig sucks balls"?
In Morse code... Backwards... In Swahili?

Go do your homework, calculate the numbers, and present the calculations here. Better be prepared well, your performance in the other thread didn't give the impression that math is your forte.
And remember to show your work!
 
Oh no, not the fine tuning/improbability nonsense again. :(

Douglas Adams said all that needs to be said:

Imagine a puddle waking up one morning and thinking, 'This is an interesting world I find myself in, an interesting hole I find myself in, fits me rather neatly, doesn't it? In fact it fits me staggeringly well, must have been made to have me in it!' This is such a powerful idea that as the sun rises in the sky and the air heats up and as, gradually, the puddle gets smaller and smaller, it's still frantically hanging on to the notion that everything's going to be alright, because this world was meant to have him in it, was built to have him in it; so the moment he disappears catches him rather by surprise. I think this may be something we need to be on the watch out for.
 
The universe being finely tuned was not really improbable. It happened so an after the fact probability is really 100%. Alot of people miss the true meaning of the Miller-Urey experiment. Essentially it showed that out of inorganic compounds the building blocks of life can arise. Again, much to the chagrin of IDiots, life wasn't a highly improbable outcome. As it happened, a probability put on after the fact is 100%.
 
sentient puddle.

ETA:
I see Pixel42 beat me to it.
 
Last edited:
How can an infinitesimally improbable event such as a finely-tuned Universe could warrant belief in a God and how about other incomprehensibly improbable events?

I heard the following on the radio, but here's a link to it.
In a recent interview for the Radio times, the great David Attenborough discussed his opposition to creationism and was asked why he didn't give "credit" to God for the design of living things. He replied:

"They always mean beautiful things like hummingbirds. I always reply by saying that I think of a little child in east Africa with a worm burrowing through his eyeball. The worm cannot live in any other way, except by burrowing through eyeballs. I find that hard to reconcile with the notion of a divine and benevolent creator."

So, what sort of god do you think it takes to design such a worm?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom