Carl Weinberg: A financial crisis is inevitable in Japan

Puppycow

Penultimate Amazing
Joined
Jan 9, 2003
Messages
34,656
Location
Yokohama, Japan
After hearing Economist Carl Weinberg discuss Japan on a recent podcast, I'm worried.

Here's what he's saying about Japan:
Japan faces severe and intractable challenges in its public finances: The debt-to-GDP ratio can never fall! A financial crisis is inevitable, and it may break out soon. Fiscal stimulus will only bring the crisis sooner.

The debt-to-GDP ratio can never fall and interest rates can never rise here, it seems. It's unlikely that the ratio can even be prevented from growing. I don't see any way out other than inflation. But we haven't seen inflation here in ages. Everything is a race to the bottom. Lower wages, lower prices, lower wages, lower prices, rinse and repeat. Meanwhile tax reveunes cover less than half the government's budget. The BoJ can't raise interest rates because the government is too deeply in debt to pay any significant interest rate on its debt. Population is falling. Working age population is falling. Retired population is growing.

Is there any way out?

What would happen in a financial crisis and when will it come?
 
The debt-to-GDP ratio can never fall and interest rates can never rise here, it seems.

I'm deeply suspicious of any statement with "never" in it, and I'm doubly suspicious of this statement. Of course the debt-to-GDP ratio can fall; just cut government spending. Similarly, the national bank can raise interest rates any time it likes as long as it's willing to accept the consequences. These are political questions, not laws of physics. All it would really take is a Japanese PM with the stones to take the appropriate action.

While I agree that testicular fortitude has never been a major strength of Japanese politicians, if the alternative is a complete default on the debt or a total crash, that might change.
 
I'm deeply suspicious of any statement with "never" in it, and I'm doubly suspicious of this statement. Of course the debt-to-GDP ratio can fall; just cut government spending. Similarly, the national bank can raise interest rates any time it likes as long as it's willing to accept the consequences. These are political questions, not laws of physics. All it would really take is a Japanese PM with the stones to take the appropriate action.

While I agree that testicular fortitude has never been a major strength of Japanese politicians, if the alternative is a complete default on the debt or a total crash, that might change.

While in theory it is possible, it's almost unimaginable in practice.
Ever hear of a government slashing spending by 50% or doubling taxes?

I don't know if this is the kind of thing where pressure builds gradually and adjustmenst can be made gradually or if there's a tipping point where suddenly everything goes pear-shaped. The financial crisis in the US took most people by surprise. I'm worried that nothing will be done until there's a major crisis.
 
Last edited:
Working age population is falling. Retired population is growing.

Is there any way out?

Raise the retirement age significantly - reduces the retired population - raises the working population

Increase the working population by throwing open the national doors to young immigrants
 
Population is falling. Working age population is falling. Retired population is growing ...

I'm worried that nothing will be done until there's a major crisis.


I agree.

With the extremely low interest rates, I've considered buying property here. But then I ask myself, "Is Japan really a good long term investment?"

When I think about the demographics for more than 5 seconds, it's very hard for me to say "Yes."
 
While in theory it is possible, it's almost unimaginable in practice.
Ever hear of a government slashing spending by 50% or doubling taxes?

Yes. I believe, in fact, that the World Bank or some such NGO has enforced those sorts of measures on countries when their economy is otherwise sufficiently messed up that no lesser measure would suffice. Granted, these are usually banana-republic style countries where the entire GDP wouldn't buy a three course dinner in a good Manhattan restaurant, and it's a little more difficult to lean on Japan the way you would on Belize.


I don't know if this is the kind of thing where pressure builds gradually and adjustmenst can be made gradually or if there's a tipping point where suddenly everything goes pear-shaped.

Both, typically. For example, the government's interest rate will gradually increase as more and more lenders notice the debt-to-GDP ratio. As long as the government can make payments, this will just be gradually increasing pressure. But as soon as the government can't make payments and has to default, things will go pear-shaped.
 
The debt-to-GDP ratio can never fall and interest rates can never rise here, it seems. It's unlikely that the ratio can even be prevented from growing. I don't see any way out other than inflation.
The less dramatic way out is real economic growth. Japan has failed rather badly in achieving growth since the mid 1990s since its recoveries have been snuffed out by (i) premature tax increases (1997) or (ii) rapid appreciation of the yen (various times) or (iii) global economic slump (2008). However, the comment that there is no way out, ever, save for debt monetisation amounts to a claim that Japan can never get back to lasting income growth. It probably can; there are many precedents of economies "reinventing themselves" without requiring a WW2 Marshall Plan type of event, but growth-augmenting policies are the best, though non-trivial, option for its government.

The BoJ can't raise interest rates because the government is too deeply in debt to pay any significant interest rate on its debt.
Well it has no reason to raise interest rates as long as it has no inflation, no growth, and no currency collapse.

Population is falling. Working age population is falling. Retired population is growing.
All these things depress Japan's growth rate, which is what has resulted in government dis-saving and the increase in government debt, but they also increase its domestic private savings rate. A conuncrum about Japan is that while the government is deeply in debt, the private sector (corporations and households--particularly households--is hugely in surplus, and by a lot more than the government is in debt. This means that, overall, Japan is a big net creditor of the rest of the world, despite its government being a big net debtor. But because most of that government debt is held by Japanese holders, it is the Japanese private sector that the government is in debt to, not so much other countries (and Japan holds far more US governmemt debt than the US holds of Japanese government debt, for example).

There is significantly less danger of a financing crisis (foreigners dumping the yen) due to this than otherwise. Effectively Japan's government is in debt to its own citizens, and they would be the group who would either trigger a yen collapse/bond yield jump (via capital flight), OR who would continue to finance the government because from their point of view it is not nearly so risky to lend to it, particularly since they have such a high appetite to save/lend in the first place.
 
Japan has brought itself to this because it refuses to let people immigrate. They either needs to start pumping out kids or open the borders a lot more. I doubt that either will happen and it will be interesting to see where this goes.
 
Yes. I believe, in fact, that the World Bank or some such NGO has enforced those sorts of measures on countries when their economy is otherwise sufficiently messed up that no lesser measure would suffice.
It's the IMF that acts in this way, and it doesn't have the power to "force" a sovereign state to undertake such measures per se--but it can attach them as conditions for a loan of last resort, which a government approaches the Fund to ask for when private lenders have already decided to abandon it. Japan isn't anywhere near that position right now. The IMF and the OECD and others can't do much more than hand-wave about Japan's fiscal problems in the meantime, which they do by the way. But ratings agencies still don't tend to raise a red flag about Japan, just a white one with a red dot on it. Ratings agencies aren't infallible with early warnings, but a sovereign debt crisis occuring in a country rated AA is probably unprecedented.
 
Japan has brought itself to this because it refuses to let people immigrate. They either needs to start pumping out kids or open the borders a lot more. I doubt that either will happen and it will be interesting to see where this goes.
The population density of Japan is already pretty high; about 50% higher than the UK for example, and ten times as high as the US.
 
See my first post above. They can likely "muddle through" approximately indefinitely, and they will likely return to debt-reducing growth eventually. I don't expect any significant increase in immigration. No real idea on the fertility rate. Raising retirement age is more likely.
 
Last edited:
What would happen in a financial crisis [ . . . ]?
What would happen would be a widespread "Sell Japan" trade. The yen and the equity market would fall, and bond yields and the credit default swap spread would spike.

For comparison the JGB 5 year CDS is +0.69%. This compares with +0.21% (Germany), +0.23% (US), +0.54% (UK), +0.75% (Italy) and about +1.5% (Ireland and Greece).
 
See my first post above. They can likely "muddle through" approximately indefinitely, and they will likely return to debt-reducing growth eventually. I don't expect any significant increase in immigration. No real idea on the fertility rate. Raising retirement age is more likely.

Ok, I can buy that. Won't the the problem eventually get worse if their demographic trend continues though?

BTW I think the retirement age is going to go up in a lot of places.
 
The dependency ratio will get worse, yes. Unless there is an offsetting productivity increase (which is possible but won't be growing on trees) then income per person will fall, and either (i) people, particularly the retired, will be poorer, or (ii) they will run down private savings more, or (iii) the government will borrow more to support their income. If option (iii) dominates then the debt problem gets worse, but it's probably the less likely option.
 
Is there any way out?
It could shift the basis of taxation back to land, as it did in the Meiji period, and the period following WW2; in both instances it was able to sustain massive gains for prolonged periods of time. But, that doesn't enrich the greedy privileged class of landowners, so it would be a fight. Of course, this solution is common to pretty much all the world; as long as production is taxed and spent on services and infrastructure which act to increase land values, and there is no means in place of recouping that externality, the result is a massive transfer of wealth to idle hands. Obviously, such a scheme isn't sustainable over the long term.
 
What would happen would be a widespread "Sell Japan" trade. The yen and the equity market would fall, and bond yields and the credit default swap spread would spike.

For comparison the JGB 5 year CDS is +0.69%. This compares with +0.21% (Germany), +0.23% (US), +0.54% (UK), +0.75% (Italy) and about +1.5% (Ireland and Greece).

If they could somehow get the yen back to the 110s or 120s I think it would help.

IIRC, Italy has similar demographics and debt to Japan.
But ratings agencies still don't tend to raise a red flag about Japan, just a white one with a red dot on it. Ratings agencies aren't infallible with early warnings, but a sovereign debt crisis occuring in a country rated AA is probably unprecedented.

AIG was rated AAA. So were the upper tranches of mortgage-backed securities. Not countries, but rated a better risk that most countries by the same rating agencies. I think that "not infallible" is the understatement of the year. This is one of the things that Weinberg complained about in the podcast, saying that it's "unconscionable" that ratings agencies haven't already downgraded Japan's debt. Of course, he's just one economist, but his argument seems to make sense to me. However, your perspective also seems to make sense and it makes me feel better. Thanks. :)

Japan has brought itself to this because it refuses to let people immigrate. They either needs to start pumping out kids or open the borders a lot more. I doubt that either will happen and it will be interesting to see where this goes.

Well actually, I'm an immigrant to Japan. They do let people in who are likely to be a net positive for the economy. People have to have certain skills to be useful in the Japanese economy. Such as literacy in the Japanese language. A wide-open-door immigration policy would probably cause more problems than it would solve. For example this sort of thing.
 
Well actually, I'm an immigrant to Japan. They do let people in who are likely to be a net positive for the economy. People have to have certain skills to be useful in the Japanese economy. Such as literacy in the Japanese language. A wide-open-door immigration policy would probably cause more problems than it would solve. For example this sort of thing.

Yeah, I know a few other guys that have made the transition. But their overall rate is very low and they make it tough to get in. I'm sure it would cause cultural issues as you say although immigration generally is a good thing IMHO.

My biz partner is also married to a japanese lady and spends a lot of time over there.
 
Both, typically. For example, the government's interest rate will gradually increase as more and more lenders notice the debt-to-GDP ratio. As long as the government can make payments, this will just be gradually increasing pressure. But as soon as the government can't make payments and has to default, things will go pear-shaped.

If investors were rational individuals acting independently I think the government's interest rate might gradually increase. OTOH, if they behave like they did in the mortgage debt bubble, they will all go merrily along as long as they see that everyone else is doing it and when they see enough people get nervous and pull out then more people will get nervous and pull out and then even rational individuals acting independently will see that a mad rush for the exits is happening and so suddenly everything goes pear-shaped. The investor panic will be the most immediate reason why the government becomes unable to make payments.
 
The government's interest rate--rationally--is made up of (i) an inflation premium (compensation for the expected change in real value, or purchasing power, of principal, (ii) a real risk-free rate (compensation for postponing purchases), (iii) a bond risk premium (compensation for uncertainty about both of the foregoing) and (iv) a default risk premium.

One can make rational assessments of each of (i)-(iv) in order to arrive at a calculation of what the "fair" value bond yield should be, and it is the same principle as is involved in valuing the shares of a business--namely discounted cash-flow--except that there are different parameters involved to be analysed and estimated. Additionally there is a lot more transparency in respect of the available information about the factors that affect (i)-(iv) for a country like Japan than there is/was in respect of mortage credit derivatives. So while collective greed-fear cycles can happen in government bond markets just as they can anywhere, there is less reason to expect them.

An investor panic would not affect the government's ability to make payments; it would increase the cost to the government of issuing more debt. That could ultimately amount to the same thing though.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom