Identification of the Toshiba radio from PA103

Rolfe

Adult human female
Joined
Sep 11, 2003
Messages
55,386
Location
NT 150 511
Staring with this post in the MST-13 timer thread, the subject of the radio in which the bomb was housed was raised.

Random thought on the 'red circle' photo that might well be going a bit too far "CT".

Hayes examines 12th May a bag of cloth containing debris, he notes that he finds fragments of plastic consistent with a radio, and fragments of what turn out to be the manual for a radio.

Was it ever established that the fragments of paper he found were from the SAME manual found elsewhere almost intact which was ultimately used to specify the exact make of radio?

The investigators were unable to specify the exact radio from the pieces of radio, they relied on the manual to do that, only if there were bits of manual found from two seperate manuals how reliable is that identification? The exact model is kind of important to the case as the one they claim it is was sold exclusively (almost) in Libya, other similar radios were not and were sold elsewhere.


This is a separate topic, really, and very interesting in its own right, so I thought it could do with a new thread. A few basic points.

Khreesat was using (among other things) Toshiba Bombeat radio-cassette reconders to make his bombs in Neuss, however the only one that was recovered used a mono radio. Abu Talb, I believe, said the PFLP-GC never used stereo models, I think because there wasn't so much room for the explosives.

After Lockerbie, bits of a radio-cassette player began to be discovered, and a small piece of printed circuit board found blasted into the luggage container was identified as part of Toshiba Bombeat - but a stereo model.

Exact identity of the model depended on parts of the manual which were apparently packed with the bomb radio, and enough of which were recovered to identify it. One version does this entirely from very small scraps that were blasted into parts of the clothes in the bomb suitcase, but in another version the nearly-intact manual, or at least a page of it, was recovered many miles away in Northumberland. How a page-sized part of a paper manual could have survived that explosion is unclear.

Various conclusions seem to be drawn as to the exact identity of the radio, and sometimes it's white but then there's black plastic as well. In the end it is decided that it's part of a batch that was only supplied to Libya - another solid brick in the wall incriminating Libya.

I'd like to figure out how well-founded the conclusion about the radio being the model it was said to be, and traceable to Libya, actually is. Sorry, some people might have to re-post some stuff.

Here's the relevant part from the court judgement, which presumably summarises the salient points the prosecution relied on.

Within many of these items there were found fragments of what appeared to be parts of the primary suitcase, and also fragments of what appeared to have been a radio cassette player. Other similar fragments were found in clothing which from their charred appearance were considered to have been contained in the primary suitcase. In addition, when examining a data plate which had been attached to AVE 4041, Mr Claiden recovered a piece of debris which appeared to be a small piece of circuit board. The number of fragments associated with the clothing in close contact with the explosion and the extent of the shattering of these fragments indicated that the explosive charge had in all probability been located within the radio. It was known at that time that in October 1988 the West German police had recovered a Toshiba radio cassette player which had been modified to form an improvised explosive device. Mr Feraday visited West Germany to examine this device, and ascertained that the fragments in his possession and in particular the piece of circuit board recovered by Mr Claiden did not originate from the same model. However, he considered that there was a sufficient similarity to make it worth investigating other models of Toshiba players. It was found that there were seven models in which the printed circuit board bore precisely the same characteristics as the fragments. Subsequently, when the blast damaged clothing was examined in detail there were found embedded in two different Slalom brand shirts, a Babygro, and a pair of tartan checked trousers, fragments of paper which on examination proved to be from an owner’s manual for a Toshiba RT-SF 16 BomBeat radio cassette player. All the other fragments thought to have originated from the radio containing the explosive were consistent with having come from an RT-SF 16. Other fragments of plastic associated with the radio were found in other items of clothing considered to have been in the primary suitcase, namely a white T-shirt, cream pyjamas, a herringbone jacket, and brown herringbone trousers, as well as in the four items in which the fragments of paper were found. The conclusion reached by the forensic scientists was that the nature of the fragments and their distribution left no doubt that the explosive charge was contained within the Toshiba radio, and we agree with that conclusion. Having regard to the presence of fragments of an RT-SF 16 owner’s manual, we also accept that it was that model of Toshiba radio that was involved.


Rolfe.
 
I've been slow to come around on the radio itself issue. This thread would be a good spot to to discuss the radio model and what it means for the case.

On the white plastic I had this jotted down
AG/145 – IED fragment
A piece of circuit board, pivotal to establishing the model of radio used for the bomb, found inside AG/117. The defense raised some questions to Allan Feraday about how it could deflect there naturally. Feraday on mis-diagnosing the radio case color (finally decided as black): “I thought we'd probably got a white case, because I'd got white fragments with that AG/145 fragment.”

AG/117 is a burnt information plate riveted to the outside of cargo container AVE4041. There's some controversy as well on how these fragments would get inside there. And then they're the wrong colored plastic? Very confusing... I'll come back later.
 
I'm just copying over a couple of Buncrana's posts from the other thread.

Well, manual intact or not, Feraday had reached completely different conclusions.

de Braeckeleer said:
In a Letter titled “Lockerbie inquiries”, addressed to Detective Chief Superintendent Orr on 3rd February 1989, Feraday wrote the following:

“I have compared some fragments of electronic circuit board recovered at Lockerbie (Longtown) and marked as item AG/145 with various radio/cassette tape recorders. I am completely satisfied that these fragments originate from a Toshiba brand radio stereo cassette recorder types RT-8016 or RT-8026. These fragments are shattered in a manner consistent with their intimate involvement in a violent explosion, and I therefore conclude that the bomb was concealed in the aforementioned Toshiba type portable radio/cassette player.

The Toshiba RT-8016 and RT-8026 are visually similar and differ only in that the 8026 has a 3 band graphics equaliser on its front panel. Both sets measure 16 and a half inches by 5 and a half inches by 4 inches. The set used in the bomb possessed a white plastics case.”


Toshiba RT-8016 - http://www.shizaudio.ru/audio/./data/media/19/Toshiba_RT-8016.jpg

Toshiba RT-SF16 - http://www.shizaudio.ru/audio/./data/media/19/Toshiba_RT-SF16.jpg


And yet according to the Crown Office themselves,

*Also embedded within that same clothing fragment were pieces of a Toshiba RT-SF 16 radio cassette recorder owner's manual. Separately, another fragment of the owner's manual was found on 22 December 1988 in Morpeth, Northumberland;

*The fragments of the owner's manual recovered from the grey Slalom shirt by the forensic scientists were found to have come from parts of the same page of the same manual, close to one another."


http://www.copfs.gov.uk/News/Releases/2010/01/08115853

So, are they saying that this was one and the same manual? Some of it was embedded by the initial explosion into the shirt collar, while some of it was found in Northumberland virtually, according to the Horton's, unscathed? Surely not.


Rolfe.
 
According to the court judgement, the bits of radio manual used to make the identification were small scraps recovered from four different items of cloth found on the ground. The paper seemed to have been blasted into the fabric by the explosion. This is just about credible, assuming the scraps were propelled into the cloth by something hard, which also shielded them as they moved at great speed away from the centre of the explosion. What is less credible is that enough remained to determine exactly which model of radio the manual referred to, given the amount of standard, repeated text on most of these things.

However, Mrs. Horton's find is different. She said she handed in a fairly substantial piece of paper to the police, either the intact manual or an intact page (possibly the cover?). She found this in her garden, the day after the crash. Her gripe was that at the time of the trial she was asked to confirm the identity of that exhibit, and she believed it had been tampered with - she said it was damaged and burned, which it hadn't been when she picked it up. The police line was that it had been damaged during forensic testing.

This is weird. First, while it's just conceivable that small scraps might have survived embedded in the cloth, as described, the chances of the intact manual or even an intact page surviving that explosion are lower than the proverbial snowball in hell. Second, if there were four separate punched-out scraps recovered, how exactly could the manual or even a page of it be recovered virtually intact?

Caustic Logic made an interesting suggestion. Suppose Mrs. Horton picked up some random piece of litter from her garden 60 or 70 miles away. Maybe it was a manual for a radio or something like that, they're not exactly uncommon. Maybe it was something that came down from PA103, or maybe not. But it can't have been something that was inches from that explosion! She didn't photocopy it, did she even take a note of what was written on it? She just handed it in.

Is it possible that during the investigation a page of the manual the authorities wanted it to be was substituted for whatever she handed in? And singed a bit to make it look as if it had indeed been near the explosion?

I'd have thought that would have been shot down in court - that it would be obvious such a large piece couldn't survive. And indeed the court doesn't seem to have relied on it for identification. But then we have the Crown Office even NOW declaring that Mrs. Horton's page was indeed the same manual.

I'm also intrigued by the comment that the compacted fragments found in the shirt (five leaves compacted together) came from the same page. How could that happen? I'd have assumed these leaves would have been consecutive pages. Did the hard object flying off the explosion fold and corrugate one page then?

It's all very peculiar.

Rolfe.
 
Sorry, I meant to move those posts I made yesterday into this thread earlier. Thanks Rolfe.

I must admit, the Toshiba radio and the inconsistencies surrounding it's discovery and identification, is something I haven't looked at too much. Not because I'd never heard or thought of it's significance, but simply because of the sheer amount of reading, double-checking and learning process that is involved in some of the other aspects of the 103 bombing, investigation and trial.

Are the scraps identified by Hayes/Feraday part of one and the same manual of a relatively undamaged page found in Northumberland? It would seem that that is the position of both the prosecution and the Crown Office themselves. The scorched, compacted pieces as shown in the prosecutions production PP8932 claimed to wrapped around the bomb, also allowed one full page to escape from the initial Toshiba bomb, out of the suitcase, exit the baggage container and make it's way 60miles and 31,000 feet almost unscathed.

Surely, if not a piece of the same apparent manual, then why would it be presented in court? It was Libya who had (just like the timer fragment) made a specific order of these models of Toshiba, and therefore could not be a manual of UK model. So this sheet of the manual discovered by Mrs Horton, must've been of the model RT-SF16. However, as she herself claimed at Zeist, it had been severly damaged since she had found it, and it was now almost unrecognizable.

Link to the Horton's story - http://www.sundaysun.co.uk/news/north-east-news/2008/08/31/lockerbie-evidence-called-into-question-79310-21640187/
 
Last edited:
Oh, thanks, I hadn't seen that. So the Hortons were finding quite a bit of debris from the crash, because of the high wind - Christmas cards and so on. This sets the scene a bit better. And among this stuff was ....

.... part of a radio cassette manual with the word Toshiba clearly visible.

She later gave evidence at the trial of the Libyan man accused of the terrorist attack, but the evidence bag she was shown contained several pieces of paper.

She said: “It was in one piece when I found it but in the bag there were several pieces and the name Toshiba was only just discernable by then.

“When I found the piece of paper it was more or less intact, a bit tatty round the edges, but it definitely had Toshiba written across it.”


"part of a radio cassette manual with the word Toshiba clearly visible." How on earth is that supposed to have survived that explosion? Supposedly being right beside the radio when it exploded. It's ridiculous.

As others have said, radio-cassette players were common Christmas presents. It's perfectly possible there could have been others, boxed with their manuals, on that plane. Far enough away from the bomb to escape incineration and come down along with Christmas cards.

Mrs. Horton doesn't know the exact model number the piece she found referred to. She only knows it said "Toshiba". (God, the things were everywhere at that time! "Hey, Tosh, got a Toshiba?" was one of the most irritating adverts of all time.) And it sounds as if "Toshiba" was about all that was left legible by the time of the trial.

Suppose you have a bit of a random Toshiba manual that came down in Northumberland with the Christmas cards. And you want a particular Toshiba model, that was only supplied to Libya, to be implicated in this bombing. Maybe you do get a manual for the model in question and substitute a page of that for Mrs. Horton's page. Then you damage it a bit, partly to make it more plausible it was close to the explosion, and partly to obscure anything else she might have remembered about it that might lead to a suspicion it wasn't the same bit of paper.

It's at least as plausible a story as the idea that the same manual simultaneously had a few small scraps blasted hard into some of the clothes that were around the bomb, and yet at the same time one page survived "almost intact" to be blown over 60 miles in a 90mph gale, and come down just "a bit tatty round the edges".

Never mind how the fibreglass timer fragment couldn't have survived the explosion, how did a sheet of paper pull off that trick?

Rolfe.
 
Buncrana said:
.... the sheer amount of reading, double-checking and learning process that is involved in some of the other aspects of the 103 bombing, investigation and trial.


Indeed, that is an important point. Consider the disadvantage Megrahi was under. He didn't just have a team of prosecution lawyers ranges against him, he had a huge investigation effort - Scottish and English and FBI and everything - all dedicated to constructing a case against him.

This happens quite a lot. The police get an idea into their heads and run with it.They work with the prosecution to try to prove the case in court. The defence team have to make them prove it, or else the case falls. Theoretically. The defence team aren't just expected to be legal defence, they pretty much have to be their own detectives to try to find out how the police have got it wrong. Sometimes, though, this does lead to a miscarriage of justice.

This was a particularly hard one, because of the sheer complexity and amount of evidence to make sense of. Also, it's far harder to figure things out if the investigators are falsifying evidence, as might have been the case. Did Megrahi's defence team have a realistic chance of figuring out the flaws in the prosecution, in the time available?

I don't think so. I think they concentrated on the most obvious things, like the Gauci identification, and on trying to make the prosecution prove their case rather than on explaining what Megrahi was really up to with that coded passport that day. Nobody really predicted the Internet would give many people who are just interested the chance to look in detail at the evidence, at their leisure, and chew over the snags.

Rolfe.
 
Okay, on the radio model, the first I heard of a significance vis-a-vis guilt was from R. Marquise:
It was a senior Libyan official who had ordered the majority of all the Toshiba radios similar to that which carried the bomb. This official also talked in 1986 about putting a bag on a British or American flight from Malta. Ask why?
http://www.victimsofpanamflight103.org/node/99

The second part is the clue I need to name the official. The source for that is Giaka. As I just typed up elsewhere, as part of Giaka's qualifications as star witness:
- Long-standing friendship with Said Rashid, head of the operations section, JSO (also involved, allegedly, in timer acquisition and other wickedness)
...
– Was asked by Said Rashid, in 1986, to write a report on whether a bomb cold be put on a British plane - had someone else look, who said yeah so he wrote the report saying so. The upper levels mulled the idea over...

- Turned said report in via his boss, “Lockerbie bomber” Megrahi, who definitely saw it. Megrahi later mentioned the idea back to Giaka and said “don’t rush things.”

mostly I got that info from the Opinion of the Court.

Okay, so it was Said Rashid, head of JSO operations section, who made some major order for the RT-SF16 model, to make sure people would guess it was probably theirs if they found one, then packed it with the highly unique identifiable timers he bought, apparently way too little explosive, and had it set to all blow up over land and leave the clues everywhere?

Does anyone happen to know what basis Mr. Marquise might have for claiming the JSO cornered the market on that model? Feraday?

ETA:
Lord Boyd dealt with each piece of evidence, as follows:
_. Toshiba radio cassette fragment:
"evidence was obtained from Toshiba [by DERA's Alan Feraday] which showed that during October 1988 20,000 black Toshiba RT-SF 16 radio cassettes, the type used in the Pan Am bomb, were shipped to Libya. Of the total world-wide sales of that model 76% were sold to the General Electric Company's subsidiary in Libya, whose chairman was Said Rashid.[information added]"
http://intergritynews.wetpaint.com/...an+a.k.a+Lex+Coleman+Reporter,+Talk+Show+Host
 
Last edited:
Oh, thanks, I hadn't seen that. So the Hortons were finding quite a bit of debris from the crash, because of the high wind - Christmas cards and so on. This sets the scene a bit better. And among this stuff was ....


"part of a radio cassette manual with the word Toshiba clearly visible." How on earth is that supposed to have survived that explosion? Supposedly being right beside the radio when it exploded. It's ridiculous.

As others have said, radio-cassette players were common Christmas presents. It's perfectly possible there could have been others, boxed with their manuals, on that plane. Far enough away from the bomb to escape incineration and come down along with Christmas cards.

Mrs. Horton doesn't know the exact model number the piece she found referred to. She only knows it said "Toshiba". (God, the things were everywhere at that time! "Hey, Tosh, got a Toshiba?" was one of the most irritating adverts of all time.) And it sounds as if "Toshiba" was about all that was left legible by the time of the trial.

Suppose you have a bit of a random Toshiba manual that came down in Northumberland with the Christmas cards. And you want a particular Toshiba model, that was only supplied to Libya, to be implicated in this bombing. Maybe you do get a manual for the model in question and substitute a page of that for Mrs. Horton's page. Then you damage it a bit, partly to make it more plausible it was close to the explosion, and partly to obscure anything else she might have remembered about it that might lead to a suspicion it wasn't the same bit of paper.

It's at least as plausible a story as the idea that the same manual simultaneously had a few small scraps blasted hard into some of the clothes that were around the bomb, and yet at the same time one page survived "almost intact" to be blown over 60 miles in a 90mph gale, and come down just "a bit tatty round the edges".

Never mind how the fibreglass timer fragment couldn't have survived the explosion, how did a sheet of paper pull off that trick?

Rolfe.

Well, quite. According the recent tests carried out by Wyatt, not only was the survival of the fragment "unbelievable", but all trace of the timer and circuit board was "obliterated", and yet we have the Crown themselves supporting the Hayes/Feraday theory that the page found by the Horton's was part of the very same Toshiba manual contained around the bomb.

I agree with your suggestion about the manual, and it's plausible given the other anomalies surrounding the identification of the fragment and indeed the operation and housing of the bomb.

However, as you rightly point out, Toshiba radio cassettes were widely used during the 80's. So the page found by the Horton's could quite easily have been an innocent radio which had been carried by one of the passengers or crew. Surely, even the bungling Hayes/Feraday combo wouldn't have us believe that it came from the original device, when found 'almost intact' by the Horton's, together with the hope they wouldn't have remembered some of the other details noted aside from the make Toshiba?

If however, it was part of the housing of the actual bomb, and as impalusible as it seems, did somehow become blown out with the resulting explosion, and landed in the Horton's garden with the other debris they recovered. However, to the horror of the FBI, MI6 AND BKA, it showed a particular model (ie. Bombeat 453, as found by the BKA in Neuss) which they definitely did not want associated with the bombing, then that would also be good reason to have it damaged beyond recognition, and used as evidence that this was part of the bomb and was assigned to the Toshiba models apperently specifically ordered by Libya.

Both are possible I suppose, and I am thinking aloud here, but your scenario is certainly more plausible.

As it is, here is the photo (often wrongly referred to as the fragment of timer) of the initial chip, given reference AG145 -

chiplarge002.jpg
 
Last edited:
If however, it was part of the housing of the actual bomb, and as impalusible as it seems, did somehow become blown out with the resulting explosion, and landed in the Horton's garden with the other debris they recovered. However, to the horror of the FBI, MI6 AND BKA, it showed a particular model (ie. Bombeat 453, as found by the BKA in Neuss) which they definitely did not want associated with the bombing, then that would also be good reason to have it damaged beyond recognition, and used as evidence that this was part of the bomb and was assigned to the Toshiba models apperently specifically ordered by Libya.


I just can't swallow it. I'm prepared to consider that the timer fragment might have survived, despite Wyatt's tests, and even that the few, small scraps of manual might also have survived, blasted into pieces of cloth. I don't know enough about explosives to declare these to be impossible.

However, the idea that a complete page of the manual could survive, pretty much intact, and blowing free on the wind? Pull the other one! This becomes even more incredible when you consider these scraps that were blasted into the cloth. How did one page survive intact while other pages were mutilated to that extent? It's ridiculous.

I'm also very dubious that the exact model of radio could be deduced solely from the scraps recovered from the cloth, even if they were entirely genuine finds. Altogether, I find identification evidence which relies on the manual to be highly suspect.

Rolfe.
 
I just can't swallow it. I'm prepared to consider that the timer fragment might have survived, despite Wyatt's tests, and even that the few, small scraps of manual might also have survived, blasted into pieces of cloth. I don't know enough about explosives to declare these to be impossible.

However, the idea that a complete page of the manual could survive, pretty much intact, and blowing free on the wind? Pull the other one! This becomes even more incredible when you consider these scraps that were blasted into the cloth. How did one page survive intact while other pages were mutilated to that extent? It's ridiculous.

I'm also very dubious that the exact model of radio could be deduced solely from the scraps recovered from the cloth, even if they were entirely genuine finds. Altogether, I find identification evidence which relies on the manual to be highly suspect.

Rolfe.

I agree, the discovery by the Horton's quite simply could not possibly have been a page from the same manual we're led to believe concealed the bomb. It's simply inconceivable.

This an aspect that I'm astounded was not made more of by Megrahi's defense during the trial. Even accepting that it was from the page found by the Horton's, (as the court seemingly did!) why would such evidence be subjected to such 'tests' resulting in it being so dramatically changed from it's original state and then presented to a witness for them to confirm that this was their discovery?

I can understand and appreciate some tests and an evaluation of particular items of evidence found, but to the extent that the evidence then becomes altered beyond recognition? The page, and the claims made about it becoming altered due to the scientific and/or explosive testing, parallels the claims made by Bollier re:the fragment.
 
Last edited:
Altered by testing or not, I simply can't see how an item of that description could have survived.

I note the actual judgement only mentions the scraps found in the cloth, not the Horton page. I don't know if anything can be deduced from that. I do know Megrahi's defence missed quite a few tricks though, by accident or design.

Rolfe.
 
Great discussion! Sorry I haven't been involved more, but I like where you guys are taking it. If you have the transcripts handy, Feraday is quizzed about the Horton page. If I read it right, he says that page was received at RARDE May 11 1989. Isn't that the day before those other bits of manual were found inside PI/995?

Sorry, that's Day 18. Do a word search for "HIBA" with quotes.
 
Some interesting stuff put together here
http://lockerbiedivide.blogspot.com/2010/01/primary-evidence-toshiba-owners-manual.html
What's up with the winning streak from mid-May to June 1? It starts with PT/2, found in clothes perchance the day after they ingested (at request I'd guess) the previously known manual fragment PK/689
689.jpg

3hundred whatever grams of semtex, dude.

May 16, I guess that's the exam of that one. In the meantime tho, on May 12, Hayes find PT/2 inside clothing, perfectly matching their control manual PT/1. Another found on May 18, 22, and June 1, each time in blast-damaged clothing later traced to Malta. The latter two were from the curiously symbolic blue babygro. There's probably others, but that's a partial list.
 
Okay, I've managed to track down the exact details of the fragments of the Toshiba Manual presented at Zeist. The portion(s) extracted by Hayes embedded in the Slalom shirt collar (PP 8932/PI 995) and that of Mrs Horton, found in her garden on 22 December.

According to the court judgement, the bits of radio manual used to make the identification were small scraps recovered from four different items of cloth found on the ground. The paper seemed to have been blasted into the fabric by the explosion. This is just about credible, assuming the scraps were propelled into the cloth by something hard, which also shielded them as they moved at great speed away from the centre of the explosion. What is less credible is that enough remained to determine exactly which model of radio the manual referred to, given the amount of standard, repeated text on most of these things.

So far I've only managed to find 3 references to the Manual. The two productions Hayes and Mrs Horton's discoveries, and another extracted by Hayes from the Blue Babygrow determined to be in the primary suitcase.

Rolfe said:
However, Mrs. Horton's find is different. She said she handed in a fairly substantial piece of paper to the police, either the intact manual or an intact page (possibly the cover?). She found this in her garden, the day after the crash. Her gripe was that at the time of the trial she was asked to confirm the identity of that exhibit, and she believed it had been tampered with - she said it was damaged and burned, which it hadn't been when she picked it up. The police line was that it had been damaged during forensic testing.

This is weird. First, while it's just conceivable that small scraps might have survived embedded in the cloth, as described, the chances of the intact manual or even an intact page surviving that explosion are lower than the proverbial snowball in hell. Second, if there were four separate punched-out scraps recovered, how exactly could the manual or even a page of it be recovered virtually intact?

Caustic Logic made an interesting suggestion. Suppose Mrs. Horton picked up some random piece of litter from her garden 60 or 70 miles away. Maybe it was a manual for a radio or something like that, they're not exactly uncommon. Maybe it was something that came down from PA103, or maybe not. But it can't have been something that was inches from that explosion! She didn't photocopy it, did she even take a note of what was written on it? She just handed it in.

Mrs Horton's full testimony at Zeist:

Zeist Transcripts said:
(Day 06, pp962)

23 Q Mrs. Horton, what is your full name?

24 A Gwendoline.

25 Q And what's your address?

963

1 A xxxxxxxxx xxxx, xxxxxxxxxx, xxxxxx,

2 Northumberland.

3 Q And do you live there with your husband,

4 Robert?

5 A Robert Geoffrey, yes.

6 Q Do you remember coming to learn that

7 there had been a crash of an aeroplane in the Lockerbie

8 area on the 21st of December 1988?

9 A Yes.

10 Q When did you first learn of that?

11 A I think, if I remember rightly, we heard

12 it on the news that night. And then the following

13 morning a neighbour confirmed that this had happened.

14 Q On that following day, did you notice

15 something around the area where you lived?

16 A We did.

17 Q What did you notice?

18 A Just what we thought was just debris,

19 possibly from a passing car or something.

20 Q Yes.

21 A Until we were aware that there was also

22 a lot of debris in the fields surrounding our house.

23 Yes.

24 Q And was there a suggestion made to you

25 as to where that debris might have come from?


964

1 A Yes. Our neighbour, who had come up for

2 a coffee, said it was -- she understood it was from the

3 plane that had crashed, and that all the local farmers

4 were collecting it in the fields.

5 Q So having learned that, what did you

6 yourself and your husband do?

7 A We went out with the specific idea of

8 collecting this stuff, because this neighbour had said

9 to hand it in to the police. So we went out to collect

10 what we could.

11 Q And did you hand material in to the

12 police on that day?

13 A I can't remember if it was that day or

14 the following day.

15 Q How many times did you hand material in

16 to the police?

17 A Twice.

18 Q And how did you carry this stuff once

19 you'd gathered it?

20 A Just in a carrier bag, I think, at the

21 time.

22 Q I would like to ask you about one item

23 in particular. Do you remember coming upon a document

24 of some sort that made reference to a radio cassette

25 player?

965

1 A Yes, I do.

2 Q Can you describe what that item was

3 like?

4 A Well, from what I remember, it was

5 possibly about -- I know I'm supposed to say it. About

6 that kind of size, you know, about possibly eight by

7 eight, or something like that, inches.

8 Q Could you see writing on it?

9 A I could see writing, because I remarked

10 to my husband, "This appears to be from a cassette

11 player," or something like that. I do remember it was

12 something electrical.

13 Q And did you hand that item in to the

14 police?

15 A Yes, that went into the bag as well.

16 Q Right. I wonder if you would look,

17 please, at Label 24. You'll see there is a bag which

18 contains items there. Do you recognise anything?

19 A Well, not in its present state. I'm

20 sure when I handed it in, it was in one piece.

21 Q Yes.

22 A Yes.

23 Q Perhaps -- I wonder if it could be put

24 on the document imager, to see if we can see it. You

25 can see within the police plastic bag, I think as


966

1 you've described, more than one piece of a document.

2 And you can at least see writing on it?

3 A Yes.

4 Q Do I understand you to say that when you

5 handed it in, it was in one piece?

6 A It was in one piece, sir. I am

7 practically sure of that, yes.

8 Q But apart from that, you recognise the

9 item?

10 A Yes. Uh-huh.

11 Q Whereabouts did you find that item?

12 A In the fields -- we are a private house

13 on the roadside. In the field opposite, they are known

14 as the glebe fields, and it was in the bottom glebe

15 field, down beside the burn, down in the bottom. In

16 the dean.

17 Q Thank you very much.

18 LORD SUTHERLAND: Mr. Taylor.

19 MR. TAYLOR: If Your Lordship could give me

20 one moment, please.

21 My Lord, I have no questions for the witness.

22 Thank you.

23 LORD SUTHERLAND: Mr. Macleod.

24 MR. MACLEOD: I have no questions, My Lord.

25 LORD SUTHERLAND: Thank you, Mrs. Horton. You


967

1 are free to go. Thank you for coming.

2 THE WITNESS: Thank you.


So, Mrs Horton finally concedes, under some protest and clearly perplexed, that she does "recognise the Item? yes, uh-huh."


Is it possible that during the investigation a page of the manual the authorities wanted it to be was substituted for whatever she handed in? And singed a bit to make it look as if it had indeed been near the explosion?

Well, that does seem plausible, although why not just find it in another area where Hayes is investigating? Why take your plot outwith the confines of those intimately involved in the examining pieces? Do we require a corroborating source, and one outwith the primary investigators, or indeed better still, a member of the public who found something very similar many years ago could provide this corroboration?

I'd have thought that would have been shot down in court - that it would be obvious such a large piece couldn't survive. And indeed the court doesn't seem to have relied on it for identification. But then we have the Crown Office even NOW declaring that Mrs. Horton's page was indeed the same manual.

I'm also intrigued by the comment that the compacted fragments found in the shirt (five leaves compacted together) came from the same page. How could that happen? I'd have assumed these leaves would have been consecutive pages. Did the hard object flying off the explosion fold and corrugate one page then?

It's all very peculiar.

Rolfe.

Some further details of how the Zeist court (and more recently the Crown Office) viewed the connection between Hayes extraction from the short collar and Mrs Horton's discovery in Nrthumberland.

Zeist Transcripts. Day 78 pp9385 said:
16 A day or so after the destruction of the

17 aircraft, near her house in Longhorsley, Morpeth, in

18 Northumberland, Mrs. Gwendolyn Horton found Label 24, a

19 fragment of the owner's manual for a Toshiba RT-SF16

20 radio/cassette player. Day 6, page 966.

21 On 13 January 1989, in the course of a search

22 in Sector I, Mr. Gilchrist recovered Label 168, which

23 was known as PI 995, a fragment of grey Slalom shirt.

24 In the course of his examination of that,

25 Dr. Hayes extracted Label 26, which included another



9386

1 fragment from the owner's manual.

2 Label Number 24 -- that's the fragment found

3 by Mrs. Horton -- and Label Number 26 were found to

4 match the control sample owner's manual. And although

5 they do not fit precisely together, they come from the

6 same page and are close together.

7 Another fragment which most probably emanated

8 from the owner's manual was Label 374, which was

9 extracted from a piece of blue Babygro, Label 190.

10 Page 2518 and 3110.

So, astoundingly, the Judges fully accept that Mrs Horton's find of an almost intact and recognisable page found about 60 miles east from Lockerbie, forms part of the same page of the manual that was extracted from a badly burned and damaged shirt collar found and logged by Gilchrist and McColm. Although, I'need to double-check the labels assigned to different photo's and evidence, I think the details and photo of the page of manual are on Caustic's post above and on the Lockerbie Divide site this morning.
 
Last edited:
So, astoundingly, the Judges fully accept that Mrs Horton's find of an almost intact and recognisable page found about 60 miles east from Lockerbie, forms part of the same page of the manual that was extracted from a badly burned and damaged shirt collar found and logged by Gilchrist and McColm. Although, I'need to double-check the labels assigned to different photo's and evidence, I think the details and photo of the page of manual are on Caustic's post above and on the Lockerbie Divide site this morning.


Thanks for all that, Buncrana.

That is Completely. Bloody. Insane.

I've been prepared to believe it possible that a small piece of timer circuit board could have survived the "brisant explosion" by being blasted into fabric and blown rapidly away from the explosion. I've even been prepared to believe that a fragment or two of the paper manual might have been preserved in the same way, if a hard object had shielded them from the main blast.

I call total argument from incredulity on the concept that a free sheet of paper could have survived that lot, to show up on the ground 60+ miles away. And double incredulity that the five-fold fragment in the collar came from the same sheet of paper as the free section.

It's BARKING.

Either this is a complete incompetent muddle, with items not in the bomb bag being erroneously identified as being in the bag - and frankly once you get into that where does it stop, is the whole thing a complete mistake and the bomb never was in the Samsonite suitcase at all, was Gauci's mystery shopper just an innocent Lockerbie victim and so on - or somebody has been manipulating the findings.

Rolfe.
 
And talking of the blue babygro, remember the mountain rescue squad swore they'd found it intact....

Rolfe.
 
I do think the statement about the two find being from the same page is some kind of confusion. The details of each don't support that. One is most of a page, the other small bits of several pages.

Rolfe said:
I'd have thought that would have been shot down in court - that it would be obvious such a large piece couldn't survive. And indeed the court doesn't seem to have relied on it for identification. But then we have the Crown Office even NOW declaring that Mrs. Horton's page was indeed the same manual.

Au contraire. It was the radio itself that yilded no specific clues. AG/145 was not a fragment but a lump of 10 diff materias including that famous CB photo (the largest piece). And this itself just narrowed the models down to 7 possibilities, IIRC. Opinion of the Court, para 9
All the other fragments thought to have originated from the radio containing the explosive were consistent with having come from an RT-SF 16.
[...]
Having regard to the presence of fragments of an RT-SF 16 owner’s manual, we also accept that it was that model of Toshiba radio that was involved.

And then of course this "clearly implicates Libya."

If it made more sense, then they'd have to dismiss it as not clear enough to become cartoonishly obvious clue against Libya #473. In retrospect they should have left the exact model uncertain. Dumbasses.

Sorry, I just can't help it sometimes.
 
I do think the statement about the two find being from the same page is some kind of confusion. The details of each don't support that. One is most of a page, the other small bits of several pages.


Yes, that's what I thought. But then we have several statements that the five small pieces were all from a single page. Except that seems close to impossible to me.

Can you locate the actual quotes? I'm going to bed. I have a tennis match to watch at 8 o'clock in the morning!

Au contraire. It was the radio itself that yilded no specific clues. AG/145 was not a fragment but a lump of 10 diff materias including that famous CB photo (the largest piece). And this itself just narrowed the models down to 7 possibilities, IIRC. Opinion of the Court, para 9


Indeedy. But the opinion of the court only lists four fragments found embedded in clothes as regards the manual fragments, not the Horton piece. So I wonder whether the story is that the manual could be identified from the small fragments teased out of the cloth, or if the Horton page was pivotal to the identification?

Then again, was it white or was it black?

If the entire tale that the radio was of a model which was (almost?) exclusively sold to Libya is based on the Horton fragment, then sorry, I call BS. I cannot possibly wrap my brain round the idea that that page survived a bang made by 450g Semtex only inches away. This is far more pivotal than questioning the plausibilily that the timer fragment might have survived.

Either some other passenger on that plane was coincidentally carrying a manual for one of the Libyan batch of radios, or that bloody thing is a plant. A much more obvious plant than the timer fragment.

Let's examine where that page might have come from if the whole story is legit - because it sure as hell didn't come from the bomb suitcase.

Maybe someone in Northumberland had one of the Libyan batch of radios, and threw away the manual, and a page just happened to get mixed in wth the Lockerbie debris. Yeah, right.

Maybe another passenger on the plane was carrying a manual for one of the Libyan batch of radios, and it fell free during the crash and a page came down in Northumberland with the Christmas cards. Yes, maybe. But if so, WHERE WAS THE RADIO? It's unlikely a manual on its own would be in someone's luggage, it would have been carried with the radio itself, probably wrapped as a gift. If something like that came apart to the point where the manual was blowing free, the radio would be in bits on the ground. Is it possible that might have been unremarked by the investigators?

I'm seriously calling plant on this, unless someone can come up with a more plausible explanation. I think the Hortons picked up a page of a Toshiba manual all right, either from the crashed plane or just local litter, but it was nothing to do with Libya. Or the IED. Later, this was substituted with a page of a manual relating to the Libya-only model, and beat up a bit so that Mrs. Horton wouldn't be able to be certain it wasn't the same thing.

Sure, there could have been other ways of getting that evidence in. But if you're a bent scientist combing the evidence, and you're aware of the page picked up in Northunberland, what better way to get your evidence in but to tie it to a real find by a real person who is perfectly on the level?

It's Hayes again, of course. I'm beginning to realise the suspect PI995 isn't the only bit of shenenigans he might be associated with. What else came up (apparently) in that fortninght in May when he was finding these great clues?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
Indeedy. But the opinion of the court only lists four fragments found embedded in clothes as regards the manual fragments, not the Horton piece. So I wonder whether the story is that the manual could be identified from the small fragments teased out of the cloth, or if the Horton page was pivotal to the identification?

True - somehow that picture (btw sorry it was so big) just sticks as "the manual" and I'm seeing them nodding their wigs on seeing it. THAT they can grasp... But as they say:
Subsequently, when the blast damaged clothing was examined in detail there were found embedded in two different Slalom brand shirts, a Babygro, and a pair of tartan checked trousers, fragments of paper which on examination proved to be from an owner’s manual for a Toshiba RT-SF 16 BomBeat radio cassette player.
Specifically not mentioning the most clear fragment among them? A farking page with a few tears in it? And it's the page that says the model number and all, plain as day? Hmmm... apparently it didn't prove a strong contra-indication of the model, but somehow... (by being fake as all get out?) it's not AS convincing as the less telling parts that were lightly burnt and wadded up in the Maltese clothes.

So I still think the whole manual thing was faked and hard to believe. This page is just the icing on the cake of stupid. The long middle of your post is too good to add much to. My thoughts but better. This thing screams plant. The actual radio bits seem borderline plausible, but the paper manual, would you believe it? No, sir. No I wouldn't.

From what Buncrana shared, regarding debris across all the area, I'm presuming a manual page came from the plane. It was a PAGE, which means, not primary suitcase. Probably NOT RT-SF16, not neccessarily even a radio. Mrs. Horton remembered Toshiba. She was on record. They love the vox populi touch for public cases - real people who recall OOPS not quite the same thing, but...

This seems a compromise between "intact page found" and "damaged by farking bomb" - problem is, explicitly, the claim is "intact page damaged by bomb, subsequently damaged in forensics, examined as if all damage was from the bomb." It really does look like no damage was added, a bomb's worth of tearing, or even a bit less.

Sure, there could have been other ways of getting that evidence in. But if you're a bent scientist combing the evidence, and you're aware of the page picked up in Northunberland, what better way to get your evidence in but to tie it to a real find by a real person who is perfectly on the level?

It's Hayes again, of course. I'm beginning to realise the suspect PI995 isn't the only bit of shenenigans he might be associated with. What else came up (apparently) in that fortninght in May when he was finding these great clues?

Well, that's a good question. But it was a fruitful time there. This page we're on about was taken in at RARDE May 11, sent for "non-destructive" finger print testing, recieved back and examed by Dr. Hayes in the state we see May 16. How is "non-destructive" fp test different from a normal one, does anyone know? Is it an Orwellian difference?

I'm seriously calling plant on this, unless someone can come up with a more plausible explanation.

Uh,

uh...

This issue was already decided unanimously by three judges yadda yadda?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom