Left-Right politics as a predictor of AGW stance

Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
19,046
Location
London EC1
Why is there such polarisation / correlation between political leaning and opinion on climate change? To the extent that knowing somebody's political stance is a remarkably good predictor of their stance on global warming? The only half-decent explanation I have seen is the affect heuristic (people believe what suits them).

Any other reasons?

(My suggestion is that this thread should not be about science)
 
i don't think its really about Right vs. Left.

its more about folks who have a deep understanding and respect for science, and those who don't.
 
So the correlation is a fluke? Or (left/right)* leaning people have (good knowledge/bad knowledge)* of science?

*Which way round?
 
I think there is a definite correlation. And it isn't just AGW. You see in other sciences too, such as evolution. On these matters it has been the conservative establishment that for some reason has made it a plank position, regardless of what the scientific institutions are saying. This is not to say all conservatives are anti-science, just that in the vast pool of uneducated unscientific Americans, a political faction such as the conservative movement, has taken a particular policy position on these matters of science. There are always outliers in individuals, but the official institutional line is clear.
 
Francesca, is this based on your own observations or is there a study you're referring to? I'd be interested to see one.

As for why it might be, I think it's pretty simple: regulation, preservation of the status quo, and culture.

Radicals and liberals are in favor of regulating commercial activity when it has negative effects on the general public. Conservatives and reactionaries either oppose this idea in principle or think that changes should be voluntary, and if the latter they know that this makes it easier to not do anything to change their business practices. They don't want to be told what to do, even if the new rules are best for everyone including themselves. What they have now is working for them (for now).

More specifically, a lot of the sources for FUD about climate destabilization are petroleum companies who have a thing that has worked well for them and don't want to give it up. This is an attempt to keep their customers chained to them as long as possible, since they know that everyone will move on to the other companies that are already developing renewable energy. In fact, people already are moving on, and the Europeans and Chinese are already taking market share, so the "supply-chained customer" model isn't going to work much longer. But if conservatism is about conserving current social arrangements, these companies' positions are not surprising.

Insurance companies are a notable exception with regard to climate destabilization, since they know that they will have to pay more as this century wears on. I doubt you'll find more liberals there than in oil and car companies, but I could be wrong.

I also think that there is a conjunction of this kind of political and economic power with power as energy and the way people personally identify with their instruments. Some climate change deniers appear to be "Prometheans", those who seem to have a cultural belief that power as energy comes from burning things. Generating electricity via non-burning resources just doesn't appeal to their tastes and cultural affinities, never mind that it already gets the job done and will do even better as investment and development proceed.

Also consider where the oil industry in the United States (at least) has a large presence. It now tends to be in areas where the prevailing cultural myth is one of the fiercely independent pioneer, who extracts a living from the soil with his bare hands, and who knows more "real" things than the deluded eggheads from the cities back East.

I also suspect that some also want the personal power of loud high-horsepower machines to intimidate the other primates, but that's just my own notion. This may be part of the reason the deniers include working-class keyboard minions who volunteer to follow the party line fed to them by denier PR operations, even though they don't materially benefit. It might also mean that they don't want a quieter world where the intellectuals can get more reading done. ;)
 
Last edited:
Well, I don't think many people have seriously considered this issue on either side of the political spectrum. People simply accept the position of "opinion leaders" within each party. Few people I've met actually understand the science beyond newspaper headlines or talking points.

Also, although the science is pretty solid on AGW (certainly the dangers of releasing immense quantities of previously sequestered Co2 is understood)-- there is also a political agenda behind AGW. For example, errors in the IPCC report, such as Himalayan glaciers disappearing by 2035, et al., ALWAYS error on the side of global catastrophism. The reason given by the IPCC is perhaps understandable--they say they wanted to affect political change ... they wanted to force politicians to act before it's too late.

Perhaps the scientists should let the science speak for itself. It seems to me scientists hurt their cause whenever they try to mix politics with science: It gives the anti-science crowd fodder to make hay with.
 
Last edited:
Perhaps the scientists should let the science speak for itself. It seems to me scientists hurt their cause whenever they try to mix politics with science: It gives the anti-science crowd fodder to make hay with.

Scientists generally try and let the science speak for itself. Science is the means, not the end. Unfortunately, the people who pay the scientist's bills and the politicians they lobby, take the science and either cherry-pick convenient data or twist it to where it barely resembles what the real results are.

Michael
 
Francesca, is this based on your own observations or is there a study you're referring to? I'd be interested to see one.
No, and I would be interested to see one too, but it's just my own observation (that I would expect some broad agreement with).
 
IMO the most vocal climate deniers tend to be Libertarians who tend to drag the other conservatives along as they frequently get their information from the same places.

I think this is because global warming represents a problem that needs government action to solve and is caused by failure to regulate. This challenges the fundamental Libertarian world view and as a consequence they need to either change their core beliefs or deny there is a problem.

You don’t see many of these people in the US mostly because there is no such thing as a far or even much of a moderate left anymore but you can find similar things on the far left in Europe where global warming makes their ideas on world social and economic development impractical. Like the libertarians, when faced with something that challenges their view of how the world should be they chose to deny the facts.
 
I think there is a definite correlation. And it isn't just AGW. You see in other sciences too, such as evolution. On these matters it has been the conservative establishment that for some reason has made it a plank position, regardless of what the scientific institutions are saying. This is not to say all conservatives are anti-science, just that in the vast pool of uneducated unscientific Americans, a political faction such as the conservative movement, has taken a particular policy position on these matters of science. There are always outliers in individuals, but the official institutional line is clear.

The Lee Atwater effect is spreading. (cough Newscorp couch) In the late 80’s US Republicans really bough into the political ideas of Lee Atwater, one of these being that facts don’t matter. You make something “fact” through repetition form seemingly different sources. It’s made for good politics, but is essentially crippling the right as far as good policy and decision making goes.
 
Scientists generally try and let the science speak for itself. Science is the means, not the end. Unfortunately, the people who pay the scientist's bills and the politicians they lobby, take the science and either cherry-pick convenient data or twist it to where it barely resembles what the real results are.

Michael

I agree. Politicians and reporters are not known for their scientific backgrounds. I suspect many posters here have shared the experience wherein a reporter "makes news" out of our work, if not completely misrepresenting it. And I'm not sure if politics can ever be completely eliminated from science, as anyone who has sought a grant can attest to. My only thought, is that politics should be removed from science wherever possible. That way, the debate stays on the high ground--where scientists can do nothing but score points and take scalps.
 
ALWAYS error on the side of global catastrophism. The reason given by the IPCC is perhaps understandable--they say they wanted to affect political change ... they wanted to force politicians to act before it's too late.

Perhaps the scientists should let the science speak for itself. It seems to me scientists hurt their cause whenever they try to mix politics with science: It gives the anti-science crowd fodder to make hay with.


It seems to me that when “scientists” mix politics into their “science” the way the Chicken Littles have been doing, in order to deceive the general into believing that there is some terrible cataclysm forthcoming, and to promote a radical, destructive political agenda ostensibly aimed at preventing this ersatz cataclysm; then it is they who become the “anti-science crowd”.

“Science” corrupted in such a manner into an extremist political tool is no longer science at all, but a vulgar mockery thereof.
 
Last edited:
It seems to me that when “scientists” mix politics into their “science” the way the Chicken Littles have been doing, in order to deceive the general into believing that there is some terrible cataclysm forthcoming, and to promote a radical, destructive political agenda ostensibly aimed at preventing this ersatz cataclysm; then it is they who become the “anti-science crowd”.

“Science” corrupted in such a manner into an extremist political tool is no longer science at all, but a vulgar mockery thereof.

Such as when libertarians, paultards and similar cranks predict the collapse of everything under the sun if government is not immediately abolished?

Such as when militant anti-environmentalists predict total ruin, should even the least bit of environmental protection legislation be enacted?

Such as when Republicans predict "mushroom clouds of American cities", should they not be allowed to use the constitution and the bill of rights for toilet paper?
 
I think each side tends to support or denigrate AGW because it suits their worldview. Certainly on the Left there is a great deal of support for the notion that we are ruining the planet based on the latest bugaboo: aerosols, nuclear power, carbon dioxide, etc. On the right there is much more support for business and industry, and less for environmentalism. Plus there is a lot of suspicion that those pushing AGW certainly do not appear to be walking the walk. See Al Gore's utility bills, Laurie David's use of private jets, or the Kennedy opposition to the Cape Wind project. Or the notion of people jetting around the globe to hold these conferences; surely if they were serious they'd hold netmeetings instead?

And I say this as a conservative who's come around to the idea of AGW as reasonably true (if often overhyped).
 
Why is there such polarisation / correlation between political leaning and opinion on climate change? To the extent that knowing somebody's political stance is a remarkably good predictor of their stance on global warming? The only half-decent explanation I have seen is the affect heuristic (people believe what suits them).

Any other reasons?

(My suggestion is that this thread should not be about science)

In the late 1960s and early 1970s, the newborn ecology movement was being adopted by the left. It was theorized at the time that class warfare, no longer working as a rationale to control business, was being abandoned in favor of ecological reasoning as a method to control it.

Big business is a vile, hated thing in their minds, and when a new raison d'etre for controlling it waddled along, it was latched onto and gripped like a kid squeezing a hamster.

In both cases, class warfare and ecology, now called environmentalism, the right is just reacting and saying, "Nope, sorry! Not good enough reasons!"


You will also note that there is much hyperbole about how horrible global warming is, yet the actual dangers don't seem to justify much of anything. So there is a big disconnect there, too. Some suggest, with good reason, that this may be a boon to humanity, increasing the amounts of farmland and the rate at which plants grow thanks to increased CO2. And now, a theory: Said benefits must be denied because that interferes with the use of environmentalism as memetic argument to control big business. That's a theory right there. Pay attention to observations to see if it plays out, or has been for years.
 
Last edited:
Leftists tend to think of society first.
Righties tend to think of their own well being and their family's well being first.

(this is using the most recent study on the topic)

So I think left leaning people would lean towards action on AGW and right leaning people would oppose action if it is seen as imposing cost on themselves or their families.

A Friedman libertarian thinks of society as a whole but in a utilitarian view. They look at AGW as a risk v. reward scenario.

Anarcho-Capitalists say screw society and think they can transplant all the talented people to the moon and live there.
 
Leftists tend to think of society first.
Righties tend to think of their own well being and their family's well being first.

(this is using the most recent study on the topic)

So I think left leaning people would lean towards action on AGW and right leaning people would oppose action if it is seen as imposing cost on themselves or their families.

A Friedman libertarian thinks of society as a whole but in a utilitarian view. They look at AGW as a risk v. reward scenario.

Anarcho-Capitalists say screw society and think they can transplant all the talented people to the moon and live there.

And how do you call the right-wing people and libertarians who think they can make AGW go away by denying it?
 
In the late 1960s and early 1970s, the newborn ecology movement was being adopted by the left. It was theorized at the time that class warfare, no longer working as a rationale to control business, was being abandoned in favor of ecological reasoning as a method to control it.

Big business is a vile, hated thing in their minds, and when a new raison d'etre for controlling it waddled along, it was latched onto and gripped like a kid squeezing a hamster.

In both cases, class warfare and ecology, now called environmentalism, the right is just reacting and saying, "Nope, sorry! Not good enough reasons!"
Someone's been reading a little too much Ayn Rand. If you could just drag this straw-man out 1253 more pages you might just have a best seller/ cult classic on your hands!

Daredelvis
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom