Ear Candle Worked?

auntysocial

New Blood
Joined
Aug 17, 2010
Messages
17
First off, I'd like to say I'm thoroughly a skeptic when it comes to those products that claim to remove "toxins" or pretend to cure all. That being said, I had a clogged ear to the point where I could barely hear from it. I did not want to go through my sister's very unpleasant and painful experience of having her ear cleaned by her GP that caused several days of soreness. So, I reluctantly tried an ear candle, which was recommended to me by family members that tried them, and after using 2 or 3 it actually did clear the blockage in my ear.

Now, I'm not saying for a second that it created a vacuum and sucked out the wax, or that it did anything remotely resembling removing toxins, curing tinnitus, or any of the junk they claim ear candles do, other than a definite reduction in the blockage of my ear.

Any thoughts on what might have happened? I'm thinking that it could have something to with the smoke and heat drying out the wax enough to break it up a little. Is that possible?

ETA: It was also not the simple act of sticking the candle in my ear that removed the blockage. For one, the candle barely goes inside your ear, and I had tried Q-tips before using the ear candle.
 
Last edited:
First off, I'd like to say I'm thoroughly a skeptic when it comes to those products that claim to remove "toxins" or pretend to cure all. That being said, I had a clogged ear to the point where I could barely hear from it. I did not want to go through my sister's very unpleasant and painful experience of having her ear cleaned by her GP that caused several days of soreness. So, I reluctantly tried an ear candle, which was recommended to me by family members that tried them, and after using 2 or 3 it actually did clear the blockage in my ear.


Post hoc ergo propter hoc?
 
To the OP: You could have stuck ANYTHING in your ear and it would clear the blockage a bit. Although a lighted bit of beeswax would not be my first choice...:eye-poppi
 
First post promoting some woo? Check.
Claiming to be a skeptic? Check.
Now what conclusion do we normally draw from this...?
 
We already have Q Tips that clean our ears. Maybe that's just not good enough for some people, but really, what's with having the urge to try some goofy wax candle burning thing to clean them out? Does holding a controlled fire up to your ears really seem like a great idea? Is that a risk anyone should even think about taking, especially given the fact that you can buy a million Q tips for like 5 bucks at any store?

Let's go to Silly Land for a second and pretend that it could actually work. Why the hell would I even consider such a silly thing when I could just use a damn Q Tip? I can't think of too many things that are more pointless and unneeded than an ear candle. What dumb ass even thought this up anyway? What could he have been doing that somehow caused him to think a candle should go up to his ears? Jesus, that is ****** retarded.
 
Last edited:
I can reply with an anecdote of my own. I have been experiencing some strong pains in my left foot recently, a combination of mild arthritis and old toe injury. The foot specialist recommended a cortisol injection, and made an appointment for me for the following week for me to see a different doctor who would apply the injection. I went to my appointment, and this doctor said that he did not want to apply the injection, because the pain I was experiencing is occasional rather than constant, and he preferred I made some other check ups first.

The funny thing is, since that second appointment, the pain has practically stopped. If I had the cortisol injection that day, I would have thought it really worked, as the pain has gone. But, I didn't have any treatment! So, shall I recommend to other foot pain sufferers to go to a doctors office, have a five minute chat with the doctor, and then go home without any treatment or medication, as it clearly worked for me?

Obviously not. But, when you go by you own experience, you just don't have enough information to decide whether a change in your condition was due to treatment, spontaneous remission, or something else entirely.
 
Obviously not. But, when you go by you own experience, you just don't have enough information to decide whether a change in your condition was due to treatment, spontaneous remission, or something else entirely.

Good points. And your anecdote is far less retarded than wanting to light a candle in your ear or whatever. That's just stupid. ;)
 
Seems like a bad idea.
I never said it wasn't. I know the substance inside was not ear wax, that is why I said I know it didn't create a vacuum.

To the OP: You could have stuck ANYTHING in your ear and it would clear the blockage a bit. Although a lighted bit of beeswax would not be my first choice...:eye-poppi

I'm sure you didn't see this, but I did edit my post to add I tried Q-tips first and the candle barely goes further inside your ear than your finger.

I'm honestly really sad by all of your responses. No one even commented on the actual question I asked and seemed to ignore everything I said. Instead you just accuse me of lying, which I'm not. I DON'T believe the claims the ear candle people make, which I very clearly stated, and yet it worked. I'll also add, I was unaware of the dangers when I did try it since, as I said, I knew people who had used them without issue. I was truely interested to know if anyone had any idea why it did work from a purely non-woo scientific standpoint, but it looks like all you folks are interested in is ridicule.
 
I never said it wasn't. I know the substance inside was not ear wax, that is why I said I know it didn't create a vacuum.



I'm sure you didn't see this, but I did edit my post to add I tried Q-tips first and the candle barely goes further inside your ear than your finger.

I'm honestly really sad by all of your responses. No one even commented on the actual question I asked and seemed to ignore everything I said. Instead you just accuse me of lying, which I'm not. I DON'T believe the claims the ear candle people make, which I very clearly stated, and yet it worked. I'll also add, I was unaware of the dangers when I did try it since, as I said, I knew people who had used them without issue. I was truely interested to know if anyone had any idea why it did work from a purely non-woo scientific standpoint, but it looks like all you folks are interested in is ridicule.


Well, if you'll back off of your insistence that it really did work why won't anyone believe me and listen to the responses, I'm guessing you can expect less ridicule in the future.
 
Since you obviously didn't read the link, I'll post the relevant text here.

Why Candling Can't Work

Since wax is sticky, the negative pressure needed to pull wax from the canal would have to be so powerful that it would rupture the eardrum in the process. However, candling produces no vacuum. Researchers who measured the pressure during candling of ear models found that no negative pressure was created. The same investigators candled eight ears and found that no ear wax was removed and candle wax was actually deposited in some of them!

The notion that the ear canal is connected to structures beyond the eardrum is false. A review of a good anatomy book should dispel this notion. The external ear canal, with an intact eardrum, is not connected to the brain, the sinuses targeted by the procedure (those above your eyes), or the Eustachian tubes (the passageways between the internal ear and the back of the throat). While some claim that the eardrum is porous and quickly allows impurities to pass through, this is untrue. The "impurities" that appear in the collected wax (usually on a paper plate or other collecting device) are nothing more than the ashes from the burnt wick and wax of the cone itself.

In other words, all of it is based off of an impossible premise. Instead of being sad, how about catching a clue? Ear candling is total BS. You're either too dull to realize that or you live in Fantasy Land.
 
Last edited:
The funny thing is, since that second appointment, the pain has practically stopped. If I had the cortisol injection that day, I would have thought it really worked, as the pain has gone. But, I didn't have any treatment! So, shall I recommend to other foot pain sufferers to go to a doctors office, have a five minute chat with the doctor, and then go home without any treatment or medication, as it clearly worked for me?

Of course not, but the difference with my situation is that with each candle the blockage diminished, until it was completely gone immediately after using the candle. Plus, I'm not recommending them to anyone.
 
Of course not, but the difference with my situation is that with each candle the blockage diminished, until it was completely gone immediately after using the candle. Plus, I'm not recommending them to anyone.

What I would like to know is what made you decide that a controlled fire on the end of a waxy stick somehow amounts to a better idea than just using a Q Tip? Even if the Q Tip didn't work, isn't putting a controlled candle fire up next to your head kind of drastic?
 
Last edited:
http://www.straightdope.com/columns/read/1103/how-do-ear-candles-work

That site also provides a detailed explanation on how ear candles really work.

Upon slicing open the candle stub, however, we found a considerable quantity of brown wax and whitish powder. The manual had the audacity to intimate that the powder was candida yeast extracted from the ear, conceding that possibly "1% to 10%" was from the used candle. The disappointed MDs were more inclined to say it was 100 percent, but just to be sure we burned another candle in the open air. When we sliced it open we found wax and powder identical to that in the first. Conclusion: it's a hoax
 
I read the link Bozman (actually yesterday when I was researching ear candles) and if you bothered to read anything I wrote, you'd see I never claimed it sucked the ear wax out! Nor did I say it had any effect on anything other than the ear wax clogging my ear. I did propose that heat and smoke could dry ear wax out having an effect on the blockage. I'm curious to know if that is at all possible. I don't need you to quote me a bunch of other stuff that I've repeatedly said I'm not contesting.
 
What I would like to know is what made you decide that a controlled fire on the end of a waxy stick somehow amounts to a better idea than just using a Q Tip? Even if the Q Tip didn't work, isn't putting a controlled candle fire up next to your head kind of drastic?
As I said earlier I did try a Q tip, several in fact, over several days.
 
You know the funny thing ? On regular basis people come to speak about ear candling and how it worked for them one way or another.

1) date of the straight dope article : March 10, 1995 I will let that sink in

2) aunty, how do you know it REALLY worked ? I have on regular basis wax obstruction , well guess what, sometimes those have a temporary remission on their own for a few hours, and then gradually close again. Sometimes it is enough for me to lay on the side of the head to get an effect (as opposed to stay standing).

case in point, without somebody looking inside your ear , you have no way to know why and how you come to hear better, and you cannot even know if it is really a quantitative effect, or just delusion, without a proper aural examination.

ETA:

Interresting quote maybe explaining change of aural peceptitivity after an ear candling :
When the candle had burned down to two inches we snuffed it and examined the treated ear with the otoscope. No change, except that possibly the wax was dented where the candle had been stuck in.
 
Last edited:
In my post I said that you could have stuck anything in your ear and it would have worked. That was not facetious - it is quite true.

Sticking something in your ear widens the canal and tends to unblock it as a result. Further, your ears naturally exude the wax to the outside anyway (blockage would cause hearing loss and infections). So partially unblocking them helps this process. Something slightly sticky like beeswax would also make excess earwax stick to it. Repeat the process a few times and the result will be as you describe.

You could have used a stick, a rolled handkerchief, a pencil or pen, or your little finger to just the same effect. However anything that can reach the eardrum is highly NOT recommended.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom