The US was NOT strongly isolationist before Pearl Harbor.

Gawdzilla Sama

TImeToSweepTheLeg
Joined
Nov 25, 2009
Messages
45,052
Location
Northern St. Louis County, Missouri.
Discussion "elsewhere" has made me aware that the idea that the US was strongly isolationist before Dec. 7th, 1941 still holds for some people. I'd like to take this opportunity to point out the results of polls taken by the Gallup organization and the Public Opinion Quarterly during 1939-1941 show that the US was NOT primarily isolationist.

The fact of the matter is that many people were aware that we had to face up to the fact that we would drawn into the war, and, albeit it reluctant to face the maelstrom yet again, knew that we would have to fight the Axis.
 
The fact of the matter is that many people were aware that we had to face up to the fact that we would drawn into the war, and, albeit it reluctant to face the maelstrom yet again, knew that we would have to fight the Axis.

Is that the 1939-45 War or the 1941-45 War
:D
I have heard the isolationist claim before, but its always been said in regard to political policy, so thats not something a gallup poll will help with
This wiki page lays it all out nicely
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_Acts_of_1930s
The Neutrality Acts were laws that were passed by the United States Congress in the 1930s, in response to the growing turmoil in Europe and Asia that eventually led to World War II. They were spurred by the growth in isolationism and non-interventionism in the US following its costly involvement in World War I, and sought to ensure that the US would not become entangled again in foreign conflicts.
;)
Note, I have no position on this myself, but I'm interested in hearing other viewpoints
thanks
 
Last edited:
Gawdzilla would you happen to have any sort of online source to those polls? And the isolationist element of your comment - I wonder if there is a distinction between political isolation and emotional.

Given the huge immigration rates of the previous 50 years or so - there would be a huge number of people who had relatives living in some of the countries threatened
 
Discussion "elsewhere" has made me aware that the idea that the US was strongly isolationist before Dec. 7th, 1941 still holds for some people. I'd like to take this opportunity to point out the results of polls taken by the Gallup organization and the Public Opinion Quarterly during 1939-1941 show that the US was NOT primarily isolationist.

The fact of the matter is that many people were aware that we had to face up to the fact that we would drawn into the war, and, albeit it reluctant to face the maelstrom yet again, knew that we would have to fight the Axis.

Thanks mate. I understand what you are saying. I will take it on board for future conversations. .
 
We know that the US government was involved in foreign affairs, and even military action, in the years leading us to WWII. I suspect that the will of the general populace was to be more isolationist than the government. However, I suspect that the well-informed public doubted that it was possible.

I'm not sure that the concept of "America" has been well defined when you speak of "America" not being strongly isolationist. Should we refer to the government, the masses, the likely voters, or what?
 
Gawdzilla would you happen to have any sort of online source to those polls? And the isolationist element of your comment - I wonder if there is a distinction between political isolation and emotional.

Given the huge immigration rates of the previous 50 years or so - there would be a huge number of people who had relatives living in some of the countries threatened

I have the Gallup polls for 1939-1941 here, but the Gallup site also has information on this. As I've decided to go into this to some depth I will be going to Mizzou for the Public Opinion items. They're on microfiche so I can get digital copies easily.

Anybody who wants to see the Gallup material should send me a PM.

One think I'll say up front, I started looking at this in the 1990s while I was at Purdue. I've read section one of EVERY New York Times for 1939-1941, as well as dozens of books, papers and other items on this. My OP is based on that cumulative study.

There are two schools who support the "America was isolationist" meme more than any others. One is the "just let it happen" CTers. They need to have an America that would have to be tricked into war.

The other school is the "all war is bad" school. They simply don't want to hear that America would have gone to war in 1941 or 1942 without an attack. For those folks, the Congressional Record is a good starting point.

The above does not include the people who just never questioned the idea, of course. It has had much support, especially from lazy historians who don't check the secondary sources they're repeating.
 
Is that the 1939-45 War or the 1941-45 War
:D
I have heard the isolationist claim before, but its always been said in regard to political policy, so thats not something a gallup poll will help with
This wiki page lays it all out nicely
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neutrality_Acts_of_1930s

;)
Note, I have no position on this myself, but I'm interested in hearing other viewpoints
thanks
Some of the "real-time" debate can be found here.
 
We know that the US government was involved in foreign affairs, and even military action, in the years leading us to WWII. I suspect that the will of the general populace was to be more isolationist than the government. However, I suspect that the well-informed public doubted that it was possible.

I'm not sure that the concept of "America" has been well defined when you speak of "America" not being strongly isolationist. Should we refer to the government, the masses, the likely voters, or what?

I'm primarily speaking of public opinion, and the impact that had on the chances that FDR could have gotten a declaration of war against the Axis by, approximately, mid-1942.
 
Japan didn't attack Pearl Harbor because they thought it would be a swell idea to draw the US into the war. They did it because the US had long been making signs of actively interfering with their expansion plans for southeast Asia and the Pacific, including a military build up in the Philipines.
 
Discussion "elsewhere" has made me aware that the idea that the US was strongly isolationist before Dec. 7th, 1941 still holds for some people. I'd like to take this opportunity to point out the results of polls taken by the Gallup organization and the Public Opinion Quarterly during 1939-1941 show that the US was NOT primarily isolationist.

The fact of the matter is that many people were aware that we had to face up to the fact that we would drawn into the war, and, albeit it reluctant to face the maelstrom yet again, knew that we would have to fight the Axis.

Huh, so what did they say was the reason for us not interfering when Poland and France were overun?

I wonder. Letters to the editor?
 
I'm primarily speaking of public opinion, and the impact that had on the chances that FDR could have gotten a declaration of war against the Axis by, approximately, mid-1942.

I'm talking about 1940 and 1941, why was the will of Congress reluctant until Pearl Harbor? Hmmm, freedom fries?

You do know what happened in 1940 right?

May 9, 1940 Luxembourg. Set up and step off May 10,
Netherlands
Belgium
France
June 5, 1940 final push on Paris, starting on the Somme
June 22, 1940 armistice Germany and occupied France.

How many days between June 22 1940 and Dec. 7 1941?
 
For starters.

FEBRUARY 22 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #3a
If Germany and Italy go to war against England and France, do you think we should do everything possible to help England and France win, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 69%
No................................31
Six per cent expressed no opinion.
By Political Affiliation
Yes No
Democrats.................... 71% 29%
Republicans................... 69 31
Third party supporters......... 65 35
By Income
Upper........................73% 27%
Middle....................... 70 30
Lower........................ 66 34
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #4a
If Germany and Italy defeated England and France in a war, do you think Germany and Italy would then start a war against the United States?
Yes................................62%
No................................ 38
Sixteen per cent expressed no opinion.
 
For starters.

FEBRUARY 22 EUROPEAN WAR
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #3a
If Germany and Italy go to war against England and France, do you think we should do everything possible to help England and France win, except go to war ourselves?
Yes................................ 69%
No................................31
Six per cent expressed no opinion.
By Political Affiliation
Yes No
Democrats.................... 71% 29%
Republicans................... 69 31
Third party supporters......... 65 35
By Income
Upper........................73% 27%
Middle....................... 70 30
Lower........................ 66 34
Interviewing Date 2/4-9/39
Survey #147-A Question #4a
If Germany and Italy defeated England and France in a war, do you think Germany and Italy would then start a war against the United States?
Yes................................62%
No................................ 38
Sixteen per cent expressed no opinion.

And who conducted the survey, how was the sample obtained and where, what was the margin of error?
 
One think I'll say up front, I started looking at this in the 1990s while I was at Purdue. I've read section one of EVERY New York Times for 1939-1941, as well as dozens of books, papers and other items on this. My OP is based on that cumulative study.

Well the New York Times may not be a great sample either, sorry. That is the Big Apple after all not a small potato.
 
A few interesting poll results as I come across them:

Interviewing Date 5/20-25/39
Survey #158-A Question #4
In the present fight between Japan and China, with which side do you sympathize?
Japan.............................. 2%
China..............................74
Neither.............................24

Interviewing Date 5/20-25/39
Survey #158-B Question §2
Would you join a movement in this country to stop buying goods made in Japan?
Yes................................ 66%
No................................ 34
Interviewing Date 5/20-25/39
Survey #158-A Question #5
Do you think the United States should forbid shipment of arms or ammunition from this country to Japan?
Yes................................ 72%
No................................ 28
Interviewing Date 5/20-25/39
Survey #158-B Question #5
Do you think the United States should forbid shipment of arms or ammunition from this country to China?
Yes................................40%
No................................ 60
 
Last edited:
I'm primarily speaking of public opinion, and the impact that had on the chances that FDR could have gotten a declaration of war against the Axis by, approximately, mid-1942.


I think that if Germany hadn't shifted its focus to London, and continued to bombard the airbases as successfully as they did during the first half of the Battle of Brittain, we would have gone to war to protect England from invasion. It's a complete guess, but I think public opinion wouldn't have stood for the invasion of an english-speaking country.


ETA: I realize how remarkably racist that is. But what can you do? People in the 1940s were pretty racist.

ETA: Except my grandpa.
 
Last edited:
I think that if Germany hadn't shifted its focus to London, and continued to bombard the airbases as successfully as they did during the first half of the Battle of Brittain, we would have gone to war to protect England from invasion. It's a complete guess, but I think public opinion wouldn't have stood for the invasion of an english-speaking country.


ETA: I realize how remarkably racist that is. But what can you do? People in the 1940s were pretty racist.

ETA: Except my grandpa.

I don't think race had much to do with it. Our ties to England had more impact.
Edward R. Murrow "set fire to London in our living rooms."

Special Survey
Interviewing Date 7/1-6/39 (U.S. only)
Survey #162 Question #1
What country do you like best?
England............................ 43%
France............................. 11
Finland............................ 4
Switzerland......................... 4
Sweden............................. 4
Ireland............................. 3
Germany........................... 3
Italy............................... 2
Norway............................ 2
Russia............................. 1
Others............................. 7
No opinion......................... 16
Great Britain Only
United States....................... 33%
France............................. 22
Russia............................. 12
Scandinavia......................... 3
Germany........................... 3
Switzerland......................... 2
Holland............................ 1
Belgium............................. 1
Others............................. 4
No opinion......................... 19
France Only
United States.......................26%
England............................23
Switzerland......................... 15
Belgium............................. 9
Russia............................. 7
Italy...............................4.5
Sweden............................25
Spain..............................1.5
Others............................. 7
No opinion.........................5.5
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom