Fair enough, but without a scientific paper providing a theory, and proof their of, or at least some real science and math to back up your claims, the qualifications and education of you or your members is irrelevant.
uh huh....prove it.
Wrong. A flawed, both in terms of the methodology and interpretation of results, study done by a number of scientists showed a number of chips that were somewhat exothermic, but which would require 100's of layers of such to raise steel to a temp where it would lose strength.
The limited results of the paper (A) have not been verified by an independent lab, (B) are in opposition to every other analysis of WTC dust, none of which found thermite in the samples. Many other studies of the WTC dust did find paint as a common constiuent of the dust...not mentioned in the Jones/Harrit Paper.
The one person, a fellow truther named Henry-Couannier, could not find these alleged thermite chips, when he tested/checked a sample of the same dust that Jones tested.
Jones himself, in an email debate with Dr. Frank Greening, Chemist, was forced to admit that in all likelihood the thermite was that weak exothermically, that it must have been used ONLY AS FUSES for more TRADITIONAL EXPLOSIVES in the collapses.
The same paper DID NOT rule out as a possible source of these chips, paint and primer used at the WTC, or any other possible sources for that matter.
flyash, friction, welding, all possible sources. No VERIFIED proof that the iron microspheres found in their samples HAD TO COME from the chips.
WRONG. Provide us with the tesimonies that the number of witnesses mentioned SAW MOLTEN STEEL or IRON. In reality, what it amounts to, are a half-dozen or so people witnessed molten or previously molten METAL. This metal could have been Aluminum (the entire WTC outer facade was covered in aluminum) or other metals.
1. Bentham is a sham journal. It solicits UNQUALIFIED people to be editors and reviewers of articles. It solicits people with NO EXPERIENCE in the given field to do so. It is a "Pay to Publish" journal which will publish ANYTHING as long as you pay the $600 fee.
2. See my above comments for the rest of the gibberish above.
The so called EVIDENCE is from a horrible flawed study, has not been verified or reproduced NOT ONLY by an INDEPENDENT LAB, but NOT EVEN by a FELLOW TRUTHER. All other analysis of dust samples from the collapses DO NOT find thermite, but they DO FIND PAINT.
They did not analyze the collapse beyond initiation for one very simple and practical reason...once the collapse began, there was not halting it, and hence no need to look at everything from initiation onward.
Not true. Gage and his cohorts have provided NO PROOF that (A) the towers fell at free fall. They have carefully now said "near" free fall, which is an unscientific, vague, subjective term, which has no value because it can not be tested. (B) They have provided no proof, no scientific calculations to prove that a collapse at the speed of those of the WTCs could only occur from preplanted predetonated explosives.
He is grouping together the full list of first responders who heard EITHER explosions OR saw flashes. The latter group consists of just a couple of witnesses. 90% or more of the witnesses heard "explosions". We all know many things (aeresol Cans, Oxygen tanks, electrical transformers, cars) can all cause explosion like noises when they are exposed to heat or trauma. Most of the testimony refers to the things that sounded LIKE explosions, which of course is the use of SIMILE to describe the character of the sound, not the source.
Wrong. Yes there was ejection of steel from the buildings. The forces acting both downward, and upward, would have forced large sections of the tower out laterally, the path of least resistance in those cases.
Where did that number come from? A good portion of the concrete was pulverized, but no where close to most or all of it. There is plenty of photo evidence of large chunks of concrete, as well as loads of Macrosized concrete. I have seen NO EVIDENCE OF PULVERIZED METAL DECKING. Most of the cloud of dust was GYPSUM WALLBOARD.
1. Misleading. What has been shown, and explained by NIST (generously explained after requests from Gage et al, not forced to admit or any similar suggestion), is that part of the building, part of the NORTH FACE of the building, during the entire building collapse, had a 2.25 second interval that was timed at that of Free fall.
2. No proof has been provided, no calculations or otherwise, to prove that this 2.25 seconds of North Face Free fall, at the time it occurred, REQUIRED the use of explosives to occur.
1. It was not the path of most resistance. No proof that it was has been given by Gage et al.
2. Once again, their use of the nonscientific, vague, general term "near freefall" makes all discussion of it irrelevant, as it cannot be contested scientifically.
(A) Gage has provided NO PROOF that NIST OVERSTATED the duration or severity of the fires.
(B) the rest of his comment is subjective and unfounded OPINION.
(C) Once again, no evidence of molten STEEL or IRON.
I am not sure as to the validity of this claim. I have not read any direct words from NIST stating that the FBI (The forensic investigators) or FEMA or NIST did not test for explosive residue. It is possible.
What???? What??? "Explosive Demolition was the most likely hypothesis"? Saying it does not make it so Mr. Gage. WRONG!!!!!!
The publicly available videos (all Gage has to work with) allow limited viewing of the collapse because, (A) almost all of them show the collapse only from one side, (B) are obstructed by smoke after a second or two into the main collapse. I will plead ignorance on this particular point beyond this.
popicock! (A) The entire section is not seen to disintigrate. It is obstructed from view when much of it is still intact. (B) the crushing of it, does not reduce its mass, and hence its momentum, which is the overwhelming factor that caused the collapse to progress unstoppably.
they were unable to provide an explanation, because unlike truthers, they do not want to make wild speculations without proper analysis, which they already admitted they did not do, as there was no need (see above).
Blah blah blah!!!
TAM