Jew=Israeli=Zionist

Thunder

Banned
Joined
Nov 18, 2006
Messages
34,918
According to some folks in this world, Jew=Israeli.

They use the term Jew and Israeli interchangeably. When speaking of Israelis, they never refer to all Israelis, but just Jewish ones. As if only the Jewish ones are real Israelis.

Whne referring to settlers, they also call them "Jews". Not Israelis...not settlers. Just Jews. Why do they do this?

Even more interesting, is when folks associate Jew with Zionist.

All Zionists are Jews. All Jews are Zionists. Any Jew who is not a Zionist, is a bad Jew.....an apostate....and possibly even better off dead.

But they also get mad when anti-Semites refer to Jews as Zionists, even though they consider a Jewish non-Zionist or anti-Zionist as the scum of the Earth.

why is this?
 
Name those in this forum who think this.

I've seen you mistakenly use the word Jew when you should have used Israeli.
 
Name those in this forum who think this.

I've seen you mistakenly use the word Jew when you should have used Israeli.

i only do that to make a point.

others do it, to be dishonest. or racist.

and I think you are very familiar with the posters at JREF who do this. and maybe even the various right-wing organizations throughout the world.
 
Any Jew who is not a Zionist, is a bad Jew.....an apostate....and possibly even better off dead.

You started off downhill and hit rock-bottom about then.
 
DOC, I think is one offender. Most of those who seem to support Alex Jones on this board have also made this "error," (quoted simply because I'm not sure they're doing it intentionally.)
 
BTW, neat edit to the OP. You originally were taking about people on this forum.

wow, you have been beaten by your own straw-man. create another one, maybe you can get em fight each other. :rolleyes:

and to answer the title, No.
 
Even more interesting, is when folks associate Jew with Zionist.

All Zionists are Jews. All Jews are Zionists. Any Jew who is not a Zionist, is a bad Jew.....an apostate....and possibly even better off dead.

Sorry, but I don't follow. Is this your opinion, or your idea of other peoples' opinion?
 
Sorry, but I don't follow. Is this your opinion, or your idea of other peoples' opinion?

Israeli cannot=Jew.

#1. more than 20% of Israelis are not Jews. so suggesting Israeli=Jew suggests you do not believe non-Jewish Israelis are really Israelis, which is racist.

#2. its disgusting and pathetic to argue that the only good Jew is a Zionist Jew. Many Neo-Nazis and other jerks argue that Jew=Zionists, and right-wing Jews actually vindicate this idea when they demean and insult those Jews who not only are anti-Zionist or non-Zionist, but simply critical of Israeli actions while still recognize and respect Israel's right to exist. These right-wing Jews liken such folks to Judenrat or other Jews who helped the Nazis, which is a horrific and shameful comparison.

#3. A Zionist is someone who accepts the right of Israel to exist as a Jewish nation-state. Many more Zionists throughout the world are actually Christians, not Jews. This is because there are soo many more Christians in this world.

So again, Zionist cannot=Jew.

Islamic extremists associate Jew with Zionist, out of ignorance and bigotry.

Clearly, all those who argue that Jew=Zionist=Israeli do it for bigoted, extremist, and ignorant reasons. And to push a very narrow political agenda.
 
Last edited:
Sorry, but I don't follow. Is this your opinion, or your idea of other peoples' opinion?

Actually, TB, I got it. He's saying that just because someone is one, it doesn't necessarily follow that they're the other. A person might be a Zionist, but they may or may not be a Jew, who may or may not be Israeli.

IIRC, Skeptic is Israeli, and Jewish, but not necessarily a Zionist. Got it?

The problem we're reading here is that some people want to use the terms interchangeably, (such as MaGZ, and a few others), and it just ain't so.
 
Okay, got it, you were representing other peoples' opinions. It wasn't clear from your OP. So who are these people arguing that Israeli = Zionist = Jew?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom