Merged Sarah Palin: "I am the victim of a blood-libel" / Liberals use the term too

You just knew it was going to go this way. Palin is always the victim. It's her defining characteristic. It's her raison d'etre. It's her energy source. It's her drug of choice.
 
Gifford said this, of Sarah Palin's map of the USA with gun-sights naming those politicians she does not like:

"The way she has it depicted has the cross hairs of a gun sight over our district," Giffords told MSNBC television last year. "When people do that, they've got to realize there's consequences to that action."


Gifford just happened to have one of these cross-hairs with her name on it.

Now, is this map or Palin's rhetoric even partially to blaim for this attempted assassination?

The evidence so far seems to suggest no. But that does NOT mean that we cannot criticise and condemn violent rhetoric.


..I would be on Sarah's side of this issue, if after taking down the map, she had apologized for the gun-sights, saying in retrospect she now sees that it perhaps was inappropriate. But no, she lies and claimed that they were actually "surveyor's markers", even though months ago she said there indeed bull'seyes.

Here’s the problem, as Weigel and others have ably pointed out: Palin herself has played up the notion that the map was populated with bullseyes. Politico’s Jonathan Martin points out that after the election she tweeted about the “‘bullseye’ icon used 2 target the 20 important Obamacare-lovin’ incumbent seats?”

http://www.usnews.com/opinion/blogs...9/palin-aides-inane-bullseye-map-defense.html


So Sarah, you reap what you sow.


....and here's her Tweet!!!

http://twitter.com/SarahPalinUSA/status/29677744457

Remember months ago "bullseye" icon used 2 target the 20 Obamacare-lovin' incumbent seats? We won 18 out of 20 (90% success rate;T'aint bad)

7:43 AM Nov 4th, 2010 via Twitter for BlackBerry®
Retweeted by 100+ people
 
Last edited:
I'm impressed. She not only avoids giving any indication she has second thoughts about inflammatory rhetoric, but she managed to do so using terminology that is itself inflammatory! Not just a martyr, but a petulant one! I look forward to seeing if she can whine her way to another Republican nomination.
 
And she is a liar. She claims the bulls-eyes were not bulls-eyes, yet she HERSELF said they were bulls-eyes.

I think if she wants to ever be taken seriously, she needs to learn to be honest with the American people.


..and yes, I expert her to say sometime in the next few days, that she along with the murdered people and the severely wounded Gifford, are the victims of this horrible tragedy.


and being that Gabbie Gifford is Jewish and Gabe Zimmerman was Jewish (he's now dead), I find it highly insensitive and just a bit offensive for Palin to use the term "blood-libel". :mad:

If anything, THEY were the victims of a blood-libel, while Palin is simply a victim of her own recklessness, stupidity, and arrogance.


ADL.....let her have it!!!
 
Last edited:
They were targeting certain seats in the election... so they put target sights on them. No remotely rational person would see that as "go and shoot that person".

There is inflammatory rhetoric out there, but this isn't it.
 
They were targeting certain seats in the election... so they put target sights on them. No remotely rational person would see that as "go and shoot that person".

no, the crosshairs actually targeted people..not seats.

before the map was taken down by Mrs. Liar, I went to the site and moved my mouse to each crosshair. Each cross hair brought up a name, not a Congressional district number.

Now, were the crosshairs targeting Congressmen for assassination? I doubt it.

But the imagery and the analogy was clear. And a crazy lunatic might actually take the crosshairs VERY, VERY literally.
 
Last edited:
picture.php



..disgusting.
 
But the imagery and the analogy was clear. And a crazy lunatic might actually take the crosshairs VERY, VERY literally.

We cannot anticipate the actions of crazy lunatics because, by virtue of being crazy lunatics, their actions are unpredictable.

The key is that rational people wouldn't interpret Palin's map as suggesting assassination. We can't function as a society if we try to guess what irrational people might be interpreting.

That said, the violence imagery and rhetoric in politics (on all sides) should be toned down, as a matter of good taste, not for fear of crazy people taking things too literally.
 
[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=492&pictureid=4200[/qimg]


..disgusting.

The spelling is atrocious. And I wonder what the author imagines a "Lesbian Luncheon" might be? It sounds rather formal.
 
That said, the violence imagery and rhetoric in politics (on all sides) should be toned down, as a matter of good taste, not for fear of crazy people taking things too literally.

I somewhat agree, but I do still think that angry, paranoid people can indeed be influenced by violent political imagery.

Itzhak Rabin was assassinated at a time when pictures of him as a Nazi SS Officer were at an all-time high.

If you repeat again, and again, and again, that someone is a tryant who is taking away your freedoms and rights, eventually someone is gonna believe it and take it to the next step.
 
Last edited:
We cannot anticipate the actions of crazy lunatics because, by virtue of being crazy lunatics, their actions are unpredictable.

The key is that rational people wouldn't interpret Palin's map as suggesting assassination. We can't function as a society if we try to guess what irrational people might be interpreting.

That said, the violence imagery and rhetoric in politics (on all sides) should be toned down, as a matter of good taste, not for fear of crazy people taking things too literally.

Exactly.


Personally, I think that people are getting carried away with this because it hits all their buttons - Palin, gun control, populist demagogery.
 
They were targeting certain seats in the election... so they put target sights on them. No remotely rational person would see that as "go and shoot that person".
The typical argument seems to be that there are plenty of not remotely rational people out there. Which is fairly weak argument, but certainly understandable in light of current circumstances.

There is inflammatory rhetoric out there, but this isn't it.
Her rather consistent use of gun terminology ("Don't retreat, reload." etc.) is in general rather inflammatory. I wouldn't have a particular issue with it if every once in a while she'd mention that it is rhetoric and metaphor and not a literal call to shoot political opponents. This is one of those situations where the right move for her is obvious and yet she seems utterly incapable of making it. Just come out and say "we regret what happened and it is not something I support." You don't have to admit anything except that you don't endorse innocent people being shot, which is something that anyone with basic humanity should be capable of.

It won't bother her supporters, and it won't silence her detractors, but to the vast numbers of people who don't much care about her in the first place it's the soundbite that lets them say "yeah, obviously she didn't intend for this woman to get shot." As it is she just looks like she's covering her ass.
 
I somewhat agree, but I do still think that angry, paranoid people can indeed by influenced by violent political imagery.

Itzhak Rabin was assassinated at a time when pictures of him as a Nazi SS Officer were at an all-time high.

If you repeat again, and again, and again, that someone is a tryant who is taking away your freedoms and rights, eventually someone is gonna believe it and take it to the next step.

And yet we see just as many cases of assassination and attempted assassination of political figures by crazy people for crazy, nonpolitical reasons that have nothing to do with the language used by the victim's political opponents. Even William Pitt's worst political enemies never accused him of controlling people's thoughts by magnetic fluids in the air. Reagan wasn't shot because of any Democratic slanders, he was shot because some crazy person was in love with Jodie Foster. Crazy people are crazy; it doesn't matter what you say because they're going to interpret it their own way. You can tell them "the president is Satan incarnate!" or tell them "Cake is made from angel farts!" and get the same result, which is usually they decide to masturbate in public. Mental illness shouldn't be politicized any more than politics should be mentally illed.
 
We cannot anticipate the actions of crazy lunatics because, by virtue of being crazy lunatics, their actions are unpredictable.
I think the brush used here is much to broad. Brain function is not binary, i.e. normal or crazy lunatic. We're being led to believe the killer is lucid enough to plead the fifth, attend college, get jobs, each of which requires brain function which produce predictable (read producing normal feedback acceptable to teachers, peers, managers, etc.) results. Of course he also had "crazy" brain functions. The fact is he was/is quite able to respond, on occasion, to external stimulus in predictable ways.

But he's so crazy that he couldn't possibly respond to political rhetoric. In fact we're so damn certain, we must all just accept it.

Let's just say I'm skeptical ;)
 
I don't hold Palin personally responsible for the actions of what was clearly a troubled young man. True the general tenor of the campaign was disturbingly "2nd Amendment" but lots of people (on both sides) were using that inappropriate imagery.

Of course she's going to walk back her rhetoric now, it looks extremely bad in retrospect when apparently none of her people could see that at the time. But "reap what you sow"? Nope, not her fault. Not entirely.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom