The world according to Samuel Huntington

Joined
Nov 9, 2008
Messages
4,032
In the light of current developments in Arabia it will be interesting to reflect on the future global geostrategic landscape. Who is hot and who is not. Who likes who. Who will be the main players. Which alliances are we going to see.

In my view Samuel Huntington's Clash of Civilizations will be closest in accurately describing in what is going to happen and in fact happens today. This map summarizes Huntington's predictions. He predicts the emerging of 8 civilizational blocks succeeding that bipolar SU/US world order, resulting in a identitarian multipolar world order.

Timeline:

The theory was originally formulated in a 1992 lecture[1] at the American Enterprise Institute, which was then developed in a 1993 Foreign Affairs article titled "The Clash of Civilizations?",[2] in response to Francis Fukuyama's 1992 book, The End of History and the Last Man. Huntington later expanded his thesis in a 1996 book The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order.


He developed his theory in 1992, shortly after the demise of the Soviet-block. I read the book in 2000 and made a huge impact on me. The attacks of 9/11 were a great confirmation of this theory (I was fooled as well then by the US-gov).

This is a very interesting graph picturing the relations between these 8 civilizational blocks. Thicker lines mean relatively more tensions/conflict potential.
 
Last edited:
http://www.wnd.com/index.php?pageId=252377

One of the very few sane voices left in America: Patrick Buchanan. Comments after Tunisia but before Egypt.

America had no role in this uprising, and our diplomats had been appalled at the corruption. Yet Ben Ali was an ally in the war on terror, and what happened in Tunisia could trigger a series of devastating blows to the U.S. position in the Middle East.

We all remember that GW Bush insisted on making the world safe for democracy. He might come to regret what he wished for.

And should a new wave of revolts sweep the region, we might see the final collapse of the neoconservative foreign policy of George W. Bush.

And that is what is happening now. 'Clean Break' turned into 'Dirty Broken Beyond Repair'. Proof:

http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742558,00.html
Israel is urging western leaders to back Mubarak. "Better the devil you know...". Back to uncle Pat:

And when Bush, having declared at his 2005 inaugural that his goal was now to "end tyranny in our world," called for elections in the Middle East, he got the results his policies had produced. In Palestine, Hamas swept to power. In Lebanon, Hezbollah made such gains it was brought into the Lebanese government it has just brought down. When Egypt's Hosni Mubarak allowed some electoral districts to be contested, the Muslim Brotherhood won most of them. In Iran in 2005, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad was elected and became an instant favorite of the Arab masses because of his hostility toward Israel.

Egypt has no oil so it has nothing to expect from the West except a louse billion or so to keep the local satrap in power on the promis to be nice towards Israel. China has much more dollars to offer and is likely waiting in the wings to take over America's role in the Maghreb. Let's look again to what good ol' Sam Huntington had to say about who love's who on the planetary monkey rock:

http://image.absoluteastronomy.com/...u/huntington_clash_of_civilizations_chart.gif

Islam has only enemies... except for China. Although the post-NWO future will be multi-polar, it is likely that China will ally itself with Islam, against the Christendom of the North (Paris-Berlin-Moscow), possible enhanced with rump America, after the dollar and 9/11 and neocon policy meltdown.
 
'The Egyptian revolution threatens an American-imposed order of Arabophobia and false choices':

"I'm thrilled by what I see in the Cairo streets, but when I turn on American television I see only grim faces.
...

So racism against Arabs is shutting down the American mind once again.
...

Why is America so afraid?
"

America is afraid for the very same reason why George Soros is not parading in Cairo, promoting another 'color coded democratic revolution': this means The End of the American Era in 2012 max.. Not even I am pleased because these developments come way too early for my Euro-centrist racialist agenda.
 
Last edited:
http://www.wnd.com/index.php?pageId=252377

One of the very few sane voices left in America: Patrick Buchanan. Comments after Tunisia but before Egypt.



We all remember that GW Bush insisted on making the world safe for democracy. He might come to regret what he wished for.



And that is what is happening now. 'Clean Break' turned into 'Dirty Broken Beyond Repair'. Proof:

http://www.spiegel.de/politik/ausland/0,1518,742558,00.html
Israel is urging western leaders to back Mubarak. "Better the devil you know...". Back to uncle Pat:



Egypt has no oil so it has nothing to expect from the West except a louse billion or so to keep the local satrap in power on the promis to be nice towards Israel. China has much more dollars to offer and is likely waiting in the wings to take over America's role in the Maghreb. Let's look again to what good ol' Sam Huntington had to say about who love's who on the planetary monkey rock:

http://image.absoluteastronomy.com/...u/huntington_clash_of_civilizations_chart.gif

Islam has only enemies... except for China. Although the post-NWO future will be multi-polar, it is likely that China will ally itself with Islam, against the Christendom of the North (Paris-Berlin-Moscow), possible enhanced with rump America, after the dollar and 9/11 and neocon policy meltdown.

Pat Buchanan thinks Persians are Arabs?
 
The very pro-American Der Spiegel comes today with a very alarming article about the state of American finances...

http://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/soziales/0,1518,742473,00.html

... and lists a number of US states that are facing immediate bankruptcy.

These developments will be studied with great interest in Beijing, who no doubt will be contemplating to go after Taiwan at the first opportunity. That moment could come quickly and will be accompanied by massive dumping of these 3 trillion dollars that China holds and in it's wake a few trillion Japanese dollars as well. At that moment the dollar will crash and the US will be unable to pay for any import whatsoever. At that moment Europe and Russia should intervene and come to aid with food and energy (with a few strings attached).
 
Last edited:
<geez sam huntington - thought I'd heard enough from him in undergraduate years>

Anyway, I never really bought into his thesis but he was definitely required reading in school years. Suffice to say that there's plenty of criticism of his concepts in that essay and I think if we're going to start predicting the future, its a fairly safe bet that Sam Huntington won't be celebrated by future IR policy wonks as having had some amazing predictive power, but rather as more of a cultural artifact of his time.

Though I will say this: Fukayama will be more the laughing stock (already is kinda).
 
Last edited:
You expect logic from a Neo Nazi?

What did I do that I had to wait until post #8 to encounter the usual level of lucidity? Could it be that doubt is setting in for our brave NWO warriers regarding the feasibility of their little pet project?
 
<geez sam huntington - thought I'd heard enough from him in undergraduate years>

Anyway, I never really bought into his thesis but he was definitely required reading in school years. Suffice to say that there's plenty of criticism of his concepts in that essay and I think if we're going to start predicting the future, its a fairly safe bet that Sam Huntington won't be celebrated by future IR policy wonks as having had some amazing predictive power, but rather as more of a cultural artifact of his time.

Though I will say this: Fukayama will be more the laughing stock (already is kinda).

So who is your current geopolitics hero, if I may ask? Or better, your take on the subject of this thread? I mean, I hope I can expect at least some representative of our esteemed global hegemon to have an idea, any idea, about the future?
 
Last edited:
From wiki: Huntington believed that while the age of ideology had ended, the world had only reverted to a normal state of affairs characterized by cultural conflict. In his thesis, he argued that the primary axis of conflict in the future will be along cultural and religious lines.
Bolding mine.

Looking at the past 2000 years, the normal state of affairs consists of massive infighting between different nations within the same "cultural block" as defined by Huntington.
 
What did I do that I had to wait until post #8 to encounter the usual level of lucidity?

Follow up your own post five times before anyone could be bothered to read your trash.

If you post fast enough, you could get it down to post #100 before anyone points out that your sources tend to be neo-Nazi apologists.
 
From wiki: Huntington believed that while the age of ideology had ended, the world had only reverted to a normal state of affairs characterized by cultural conflict. In his thesis, he argued that the primary axis of conflict in the future will be along cultural and religious lines.
Bolding mine.

Looking at the past 2000 years, the normal state of affairs consists of massive infighting between different nations within the same "cultural block" as defined by Huntington.

Small objection. Before Napoleon there was no such thing as a 'nation'. Oh, and Huntington does predictions about the future and does not explain the past. Wars between France and Germany, or Lybia and Egypt will be unlikely in the future, instead we will see conflict between 'culture circles'. The Dutch for instance are not afraid of Germany or Britain, but very uneasy about the growing influence of Islam in Holland. That is what Huntington is talking about. Gerald Celente even predicts that the Europeans will throw out the Muslims between 2012-2016. Until 1 week ago I thought that time frame would be premature.

http://www.depers.nl/buitenland/510512/Islamhaat-niet-meer-te-stuiten.html
Trendprofeet Gerald Celente maakt voor De Pers een tijdreis naar 2012, het jaar waarin de haat tegen moslims in Europa culmineert in grootschalige etnische zuiveringen.

‘Moslims in Europa, pak je koffers en vlucht. Je bent niet veilig meer! De etnische zuiveringen gaan beginnen, de enkele jaren geleden nog onvoorstelbare verdrijving van miljoenen mensen. Ik zei het twintig jaar geleden al: de historie van Europa is onze nabije toekomst en dit keer zal volgens het volk de moslim de oorzaak van álle problemen zijn.

Celente predicts large scale ethnic cleansing of millions of muslims from Europe. This conflict will start at the level of the population, not of the establishment.

All in the spirit of Huntington.
 
Last edited:
What did I do that I had to wait until post #8 to encounter the usual level of lucidity? Could it be that doubt is setting in for our brave NWO warriers regarding the feasibility of their little pet project?

"They are not replying to me. Oh how absolutely terrified they are of me!! Victory is just a couple of Sieg Heils away!"
 
Oh, and Huntington does predictions about the future and does not explain the past.

Oh well that's a point in his favour then! I want all my future-predictors to make no effort at explaining the past, because there is no need for any complex understanding of the past if we are predicting the future: all we need is a dartboard with different outcomes and some darts!

You're not doing yourself any favours here my friend...:) So while my instinct is to run away from this discussion given the calibre of your thinking revealed by posts like this I will have to say: I have no one hero of IR theory. Most everyone has weaknesses somewhere. If I were to pick a spot on the IR political spectrum I'd call myself something of a left-leaning realist.

I cast a wide net and agree when I agree and don't when I don't..;)

PS: anyone catch the skeptic's guide recently on "predictions"? Really great interview, check it here.

PPS: And before you pigeonhole me 9/11 Investigator - you might be surprised to know that alongside authors like Fisk, Said and more mainstream people, various quarterlies and broadsheets, lie a few years of American Conservative subscriptions and about 3 books by Pat Buchanan. I wrote a paper on him for school: "The Foreign Policy of Pat Buchanan" if you're interested PM me with an email address...
 
Last edited:
Small objection. Before Napoleon there was no such thing as a 'nation'.
Nations, kingdoms, tribes - point is, people always fought neighbours in the same culture block over local issues.

Oh, and Huntington does predictions about the future and does not explain the past.
If Huntington says the world will revert to a normal state of affairs characterized by cultural conflict, then clearly he doesn't understand what the normal state of affairs is.

Wars between France and Germany, or Lybia and Egypt will be unlikely in the future
According to his map Iran and the other Gulf states will be part of the same block, yet wikileaks tells us those Guld states attempt to incite the US to attack Iran. Nothing new to see here, just a classic local conflict where one side attempts to gain an outside ally.

Gerald Celente even predicts that the Europeans will throw out the Muslims between 2012-2016. Until 1 week ago I thought that time frame would be premature.
And you believe him? Last year he predicted the collapse of the world's economic system, before the end of the year.

Unless I missed it, that didn't happen. Sounds to me the guy is a professional doomsday-prophet. Not credible at all.

Celente predicts large scale ethnic cleansing of millions of muslims from Europe. This conflict will start at the level of the population, not of the establishment.
And I predict the pendulum is just swinging back and forth. For years we were too accommodating to immigrants, now we swing the other way.
 
According to his map Iran and the other Gulf states will be part of the same block, yet wikileaks tells us those Guld states attempt to incite the US to attack Iran. Nothing new to see here, just a classic local conflict where one side attempts to gain an outside ally.

You confuse that motivations of the Arab rulers (American satraps) with the motivations of the populations. In 1989 Eastern European nations managed to free themselves from their Soviet colonizer and their satraps (Honecker, Ceaucescu, etc.). These nations abandoned marxist ideology and returned to European tradition: Christian normality (well sort of). In Arabia we witness a similar process, namely Arabian nations getting rid of the American imperialist. And like Honecker and con sorte, the satraps will have to flee.
 
You confuse that motivations of the Arab rulers (American satraps) with the motivations of the populations. In 1989 Eastern European nations managed to free themselves from their Soviet colonizer and their satraps (Honecker, Ceaucescu, etc.). These nations abandoned marxist ideology and returned to European tradition: Christian normality (well sort of). In Arabia we witness a similar process, namely Arabian nations getting rid of the American imperialist. And like Honecker and con sorte, the satraps will have to flee.
Ever hear of Sunni vs Shiite? You will find Sunni Arabs in the Gulf are far more concerned with Shiite Iran than with India, China or Japan - even though Iran is culturally and religiously much closer to them.
But differences are always amplified over short distances. Huntington ignores that, which is why he's wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom