Invited on another Psychic's Show

RSLancastr

www.StopSylvia.com
Joined
Sep 7, 2001
Messages
17,135
Location
Salem, Oregon
Well, not me specifically.

I am on a mailing list of all of the para-x show hosts, and one of the hosts sent out an email to all of the rest of us offering to have us on her show as guests. It's an invitation I may be making myself some time soon.

Rather than just accept the invitation, I replied with this:

[Name]:



Thanks for the invitation!



I see from your Show Page that you are a Psychic Medium, So, before you decide whether or not you would like to have me on your show, let me make sure you understand my thoughts regarding psychics. I have seen nothing which would lead me to think that there is such a thing as actual psychic powers. I am a skeptic, and I invite you to read my show page at www.para-x.com/residentskeptic.html to read a bit about me and my "philosophy" when it comes to interacting with believers in the paranormal. The past two episodes of my para-x show "Resident Skeptic" can be heard or downloaded from the OnDemand page. In them, I talk about "How Psychics Do What They Do -or- How People Who Claim To Be Psychic Fool Many People Into Believing Them."

[Name], I am saying all of this to you NOT to be "in your face" with my skepticism, nor as some sort of a dare to you to "prove" yourself to me. And if you have me on your show, I do not intend to try to turn it into a "showdown" between us. I was a guest on MamaLisa's show in January, and, while making it clear I was a skeptic, Lisa and I had a good time with it. And she and I had a phone call before I accepted HER invitation to be on HER show, in which I made all of these things clear to her as well. That phone call ended up lasting more than three hours, and by the end of it we had become dear friends. So, to spell it out, I believe that all people who say that they are psychic fall into one of two categories:


1) Not psychic but Self-Deluded, or
2) not psychic and Knowingly Fraudulent.

If you'd still care to have me on your show, I would be more than happy to do so. I would prefer

live to Prerecorded, but whichever is best for you is fine by me. I live in Oregon (Pacific Standard Time), so the 9pm EST show time is not a problem fo me.

Best regards,

Robert S. Lancaster

Yet ANOTHER psychic asked me last week to be on HIS show on April 22! He and I had an hour-long Skype conversation about all of this before I accepted the invitation and, while we did not become "dear friends", at least he will not feel blindsided by my skepticism when I'm on his show.
 
As long as you have his respect, dear-friends isn't necessary!

Congratulations!
 
Still, Rob, just for the yucks, you should accept at least one invitation and DON'T warn them you are a skeptic.
 
Yet ANOTHER psychic asked me last week to be on HIS show on April 22! He and I had an hour-long Skype conversation about all of this before I accepted the invitation and, while we did not become "dear friends", at least he will not feel blindsided by my skepticism when I'm on his show.

But, why not blindside them?
If they truly are what they claim then what difference should it make what you are or are not?

Not to mention the simple fact that blindsiding a psychic should be impossible to begin with. If they make the claim of being such then they are asking for it.

There is such a thing as being too nice you know Robert.

What is the point of being the resident skeptic of that paraplace if you can't have a little fun with it sometimes?
 
Rob, I'm going to be cynical here. They are getting you on only for their ratings. Their audiences dwindle, so they look for the Jerry Springer option - face-slapping potential, good versus evil, etc. Butter up the guest, promise sweetness and cookies, try to start a controversy. Doesn't matter who wins, it's the fight that sells tickets.

So I would suggest keeping a VERY wary eye open for the hidden agendas.
 
But, why not blindside them?
If they truly are what they claim then what difference should it make what you are or are not?

Not to mention the simple fact that blindsiding a psychic should be impossible to begin with. If they make the claim of being such then they are asking for it.

You seem to think that they are claiming to know everything, but they don't.

There is such a thing as being too nice you know Robert.

Perhaps. but I don't think I'm there yet.

What is the point of being the resident skeptic of that paraplace if you can't have a little fun with it sometimes?

The point (And the fun, for me), is in reaching a different audience and, I hope, getting them to consider a point of view that they mught not otherwise have considered. The fun is in building that bridge.

And blindsiding hosts there is not only rude, and not my style, but it would be an ungrateful way for me to repay the kindness that the owner of the station and the rest of that community has shown me. And the people I am hoping to reach are NOT going to think well of skepticism if they see me as someone who just takes cheap shots at hosts who have invited me on their show.
 
Rob, I'm going to be cynical here. They are getting you on only for their ratings. Their audiences dwindle, so they look for the Jerry Springer option - face-slapping potential, good versus evil, etc. Butter up the guest, promise sweetness and cookies, try to start a controversy. Doesn't matter who wins, it's the fight that sells tickets.

So I would suggest keeping a VERY wary eye open for the hidden agendas.

Thanks for that, Zep. Every time I appear on a show - particularly a paranormal-themed one, there are some here who warn me of all manner of evil motivations on the part of the show's host. Hell, when it was announced that I was to be on Anderson Cooper 360 back in 2007, loads of people at TAM5 warned me that I was being set up, and that the show would be a love letter to Sylvia, with the skeptical point of view marginalized at best. And it turned out quite the opposite!

The odds are I will eventually get screwed over on a show. I know that, and keep an eye out for any signs of it. But - for whatever reason - so far I have met with nothing but respect and kindness in every show where I've appeared.

Will my luck run out on one of the para-x shows? I don't think so, but time will tell. Meantime, I will assume good intentions on these hosts' part, but will, I hope, be able to handle it if bad intentions reveal themselves.

-RSL
 
You seem to think that they are claiming to know everything, but they don't.

They are claiming to know things that so called normal people would have no way of knowing unless they possessed the same psychic powers that they have.
Is that not true?

If that is not true then what would be the point in being psychic at all?

They claim to know, see and understand things that mere normal human beings can not.
I heard of this site called StopSlyvia.com you should check it out sometime.
It's all about how much harm is spread through the world by a psychics lies and self delusion.

I know you have made "Dear Friends" and that sure is special and all but don't ever forget who you are dealing with.

Since you are now making excuses for their lies sounds to me like the title "Resident Skeptic" is going to mean the same there as it does every other pro psychic site.

Hey Robert, did it hurt when you sold out or did you even notice?
 
And blindsiding hosts there is not only rude, and not my style, but it would be an ungrateful way for me to repay the kindness that the owner of the station and the rest of that community has shown me. And the people I am hoping to reach are NOT going to think well of skepticism if they see me as someone who just takes cheap shots at hosts who have invited me on their show.

Ladies and gentlemen, the most noble, immeasurably honorable, incredibly gracious Robert S. Lancaster. Give him a hand!!!!!
 
Last edited:
They are claiming to know things that so called normal people would have no way of knowing unless they possessed the same psychic powers that they have.
Is that not true?

If that is not true then what would be the point in being psychic at all?

iT IS TRUE THAT PSYCHICS CLAIM TO KNOW THINGS WHICH THE REST of us don't, but I don't know of any psychic who claims to know everything, which was my point. To gritigize one for not being able to do something they never claimed they could do is pointless, and does skepticism no good.

Randi has often stressed this when discussing investigatimg claims of the paranormal. He says something like "when someone claims to be able to play the piano, you can't hand them a violin and demand they prove it."

If I witheld the fact that I am a skeptic from a psychic hosting a show where I was a guest, and then blidsided them with it and they expressed surprise, what wouldthat prove, unless they had previously specifically claimed the ability to know whether or not a person was a skeptic. part of the power of stopsylvia comes from my criticizing Browne for not doing the things she stated she could do, not for her failing to do things she never claimed she could do.

They claim to know, see and understand things that mere normal human beings can not.

See above.

I heard of this site called StopSlyvia.com you should check it out sometime.
It's all about how much harm is spread through the world by a psychics lies and self delusion.

Yes. Your point?

I know you have made "Dear Friends" and that sure is special and all but don't ever forget who you are dealing with.

Yes, but while I don't for a moment approve of what they do, I also do not put them all on pae with Sylvia in terms of the scale of harm they do.

Since you are now making excuses for their lies

Please show me where I did this, as I am unaware of having done so. Otherwise, take your strawman slsewhere.

sounds to me like the title "Resident Skeptic" is going to mean the same there as it does every other pro psychic site.

that being what, in your opinion?

Hey Robert, did it hurt when you sold out or did you even notice?

Brattus, you've been accusing me of one thing after another almost from your first post here. saying that SSB will never make a bit of difference. That it would never change anyone's mind about her. Or, if it did, they would just latch on to the next psychic they saw. And on and on. So for you to now tell me that I have "sold out" (while providing no evidence of it) does not hurt me, nor shame me, nor even sadden me much.

I knew full well that when I mentioned here a few weeks ago that I consider MamaLisa a "dear friend" that it would raise some eyebrows, and disappoint some. But I have shared every step of this strange journey with the members of this forum, and I thought it would be dishonest to not acknowledge here that I had, totally unexpectedly, developed a feiendship with someone who claims to have psychic abilities. If that takes me down a peg or three in the eyes of some here, that's a price
i'm willing to pay.

And Brattus, thanks for speaking your mind about this. I imagine you are by no means alone in it.
 
I watch members on this forum gripe, moan and complain about psychics . . . and other forms of "woo." I have heard that some like to troll on paranormal sites just to get the chance to call people stupid . . . or worse. Here, you are "preaching to the choir" and there you're not making any kind of difference, except perhaps proving their opinion of skeptics. On this paranormal radio station Robert has an opportunity to change minds. Because the word "skeptic" is in the title of his show, there are some believers who won't listen - thanks to the trolls who call themselves skeptics. By being a guest on a psychic's show he can spread his message and, at the very least, bridge a social gap. I think the more shows he can get on, the better.

As for his style of communicating with kindness, I ask you: If someone invited you into their home, would you go hoping to start a fight? My momma taught me better, and I'll wager yours did, too. This station is their home. Robert is the intelligent, respectful guest at the party who has a differing point of view that may be interesting.
 
Is a 'friend' different to a 'dear friend'? What makes someone a 'dear friend' as oppossed to just a 'friend'?

Just curious how this deluded person or fraud became a 'dear friend' after a 3 hour phone conversation.
 
I watch members on this forum gripe, moan and complain about psychics . . . and other forms of "woo." I have heard that some like to troll on paranormal sites just to get the chance to call people stupid . . . or worse. Here, you are "preaching to the choir" and there you're not making any kind of difference, except perhaps proving their opinion of skeptics. On this paranormal radio station Robert has an opportunity to change minds. Because the word "skeptic" is in the title of his show, there are some believers who won't listen - thanks to the trolls who call themselves skeptics. By being a guest on a psychic's show he can spread his message and, at the very least, bridge a social gap. I think the more shows he can get on, the better.

As for his style of communicating with kindness, I ask you: If someone invited you into their home, would you go hoping to start a fight? My momma taught me better, and I'll wager yours did, too. This station is their home. Robert is the intelligent, respectful guest at the party who has a differing point of view that may be interesting.
I agree with all that - I know Robert has the best interests at heart and I do hope he makes some positive impact.

But what I genuinely hope does not happen is that Robert's kindness is abused by con-artists. Remember: Most psychics' incomes depend on their ability to scam as many people as possible. So if Robert goes onto their prime "patch" and through his actions diminishes their income stream, that would seem to be a rather poor business model for scammers to allow...and they won't, I think we can depend on it. It would make more sense they actually used Robert as some sort of fall-guy "skeptic", with the setup now and the sting to follow.

Diplomacy: The art of saying "Nice doggie" until you find a big rock.
 
Is a 'friend' different to a 'dear friend'? What makes someone a 'dear friend' as oppossed to just a 'friend'?

Don't you have some friends who you feel more of a connection to than others? I do.

Just curious how this deluded person or fraud became a 'dear friend' after a 3 hour phone conversation.

Fair enough. During the course of that call, we spoke of many things, not just the skeptic/believer dynamic. And perhaps I was being played by a master manipulator, though I don't think so. And maybe my isolated situation now, cut off in many ways from most of my old friends, has made me more anxious to make new friends than is healthy, I considered these things after that conversation. But she and I have had more phone and online conversations since, and I continue to feel close to her.
 
Brattus, you've been accusing me of one thing after another almost from your first post here. saying that SSB will never make a bit of difference. That it would never change anyone's mind about her. Or, if it did, they would just latch on to the next psychic they saw. And on and on. So for you to now tell me that I have "sold out" (while providing no evidence of it) does not hurt me, nor shame me, nor even sadden me much.

I knew full well that when I mentioned here a few weeks ago that I consider MamaLisa a "dear friend" that it would raise some eyebrows, and disappoint some. But I have shared every step of this strange journey with the members of this forum, and I thought it would be dishonest to not acknowledge here that I had, totally unexpectedly, developed a feiendship with someone who claims to have psychic abilities. If that takes me down a peg or three in the eyes of some here, that's a price
i'm willing to pay.

And Brattus, thanks for speaking your mind about this. I imagine you are by no means alone in it.

Well first off when I first started posting on here I was an awestruck fan.
Your Kaz site really impressed me and still does.

But after about 6 months of posting on here I started to notice that no one on here ever disagreed with you regarding anything.
You started articles about SB smoking cigarettes or not and putting up photos of her desk with an ashtray on it as proof.
No one ever questioned that or anything else you started threads about or posted about.

No one can be right about everything all the time.

When I first decided to share my opinion I was attacked by your groupies as if I were torturing puppies on live TV.
You would think I was crucifying their Christ the way they carried on.
Something about that just isn't right at all.

Perhaps "sold out" isn't the right term to use. Maybe coming to a cross road is the correct phrase.
Have you asked yourself recently how much value do I really place on my skepticism?

When you have a one sided conversation going like a web site where no one talks back then you can be as nice and reasoned as you like.
Once you bring the same subject into an open conversation whether it is on a forum like this or a internet radio show that takes calls you can't be nice and ask the questions that need to be asked in order to progress that conversation.

You have gone from spending a unimaginable amount of time creating and maintaining a web site dedicated to bringing down a big time TV psychic to making excuses for their lies and self delusions because they are nice to talk to on the phone.

Gimme a break!

You of all people should know that the gift of gab and charisma are standard tools of the trade for those liars, crooks and cons.

I will use my own pretend psychic powers and predict that in another 6 months you'll be on here actively promoting a psychic or two stating that SB was fake but your new "dear friends" are the real deal.

Hurt, shame and saddened? No way! That has never been my intention. But, I would like you to wake the hell up!

Thanks for your thanks but I doubt it's sincerity.
 
I watch members on this forum gripe, moan and complain about psychics . . . and other forms of "woo." I have heard that some like to troll on paranormal sites just to get the chance to call people stupid . . . or worse. Here, you are "preaching to the choir" and there you're not making any kind of difference, except perhaps proving their opinion of skeptics. On this paranormal radio station Robert has an opportunity to change minds. Because the word "skeptic" is in the title of his show, there are some believers who won't listen - thanks to the trolls who call themselves skeptics. By being a guest on a psychic's show he can spread his message and, at the very least, bridge a social gap. I think the more shows he can get on, the better.

As for his style of communicating with kindness, I ask you: If someone invited you into their home, would you go hoping to start a fight? My momma taught me better, and I'll wager yours did, too. This station is their home. Robert is the intelligent, respectful guest at the party who has a differing point of view that may be interesting.

When you have a one sided conversation going like a web site where no one talks back then you can be as nice and reasoned as you like.
Once you bring the same subject into an open conversation whether it is on a forum like this or a internet radio show that takes calls you can't be nice and ask the questions that need to be asked in order to progress that conversation.

But responding to post like this is a complete waste of time anyway because it is either RSL way or troll. No grey areas at all.
 
I agree with all that - I know Robert has the best interests at heart and I do hope he makes some positive impact.

But what I genuinely hope does not happen is that Robert's kindness is abused by con-artists. Remember: Most psychics' incomes depend on their ability to scam as many people as possible. So if Robert goes onto their prime "patch" and through his actions diminishes their income stream, that would seem to be a rather poor business model for scammers to allow...and they won't, I think we can depend on it. It would make more sense they actually used Robert as some sort of fall-guy "skeptic", with the setup now and the sting to follow.

Diplomacy: The art of saying "Nice doggie" until you find a big rock.

While I appreciate the concern Zep, I do wish that you would give me some credit for not being some totally naive shmuck. I'm no James Randi, but this isn't my first dance either. I've been working both sides of this bridge I'm trying to build since 2001. I've had people saying "nice doggie" to me, and people swinging rocks at me, from BOTH sides, so I am not unaware of the possibilities you mention.

That is, of course, no guarantee that I will be ready for the next rock when it comes (and it WILL come, eventually), but, again, sometimes I wish the predictors of gloom and doom in this regard would stop and consider my track record. It hasn't been spotless, by any stretch of the imagination, but I haven't done badly either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom