Everything is conjecture

Larechar

Thinker
Joined
Nov 4, 2010
Messages
171
[every statement, anyhow.]

and the title of this thread is a Paradox :)

[eta]Everything you know is based on Faith; and that is also a Paradox ;)[/eta]

Any conjecture?
 
Last edited:
[every statement, anyhow.]

and the title of this thread is a Paradox :)

Any conjecture?

Yes, everything in the human mind is conjecture, or abstraction and abstraction might contain inventions, inventive conjecture.
 
Yes, everything in the human mind is conjecture, or abstraction and abstraction might contain inventions, inventive conjecture.

I call conjecture on that statement. Everything that's definable is conjecture! Depending on how you meant it, yes, the human mind defines while the Universe just is, but that's also conjecture.

You're run-on was lost on me.
 
I call conjecture on that statement. Everything that's definable is conjecture! Depending on how you meant it, yes, the human mind defines while the Universe just is, but that's also conjecture.

You're run-on was lost on me.

By inventive conjecture I mean something like mathematics.
Mathematics is a kind of abstraction of things discovered through experience.
Also mathematics is a usefull tool, an aid to conjecture.
It includes the invention of logic, which can be used to examine conjecture.
 
Unfortunately, "everything is conjecture" is followed too often by, "so therefore you can't prove my pet theory wrong."
 
Unfortunately, "everything is conjecture" is followed too often by, "so therefore you can't prove my pet theory wrong."

All 'proof' is probabilistic. Anyone who will not accept a sufficiently high probability that his pet theory is wrong, is ill adapted to life in these cosmos.
 
e=mc2 is not conjecture,not unless we have conjectural atomic bombs and nuclear reactors.
 
e=mc2 is not conjecture,not unless we have conjectural atomic bombs and nuclear reactors.

Sure it is, if you're a brain in a vat hooked up to experience a virtual world where e=mc2 works. Prove I'm wrong. :)
 
Conjecture definition
1. Inference or judgment based on inconclusive or incomplete evidence; guesswork.
2. A statement, opinion, or conclusion based on guesswork
Given that definition, I call baloney on the thread title. Unless you believe the Universe doesn't exist, then evidence of/from the Universe exists. If you are basing a conclusion on evidence, you are not guessing. Yes, conclusions are based on incomplete evidence, but that is not the equivalent of inadequate evidence.
 
I can't stand solipsism. I can stand it even less when its been used as a passive aggressive backhanded excuse for irrational nonsense.

There's a difference between "I think therefore I am" and "I think therefore there's a giant invisible bearded guy wizard father figure in the sky that is vitally concerned with what I do in my bedroom."

ETA: And yet another prime example of "Obi-Wan Kenobi Speak"
 
Last edited:
Sure it is, if you're a brain in a vat hooked up to experience a virtual world where e=mc2 works. Prove I'm wrong. :)

The virtual world would be based on the real world. You could have e=mc3 in your virtual world.
 
The virtual world would be based on the real world.

Not necessarily. I'm not talking about a virtual world created in this world. I'm talking about a virtual world in which you're the only person (entity?) experiencing it. I'm made up, the idea that you ever were a human being is made up. Gravity, energy, atoms, etc.: all made up. So e=mc2 doesn't apply there, since there's not even any e or m or light to produce a c.

Yes, that's how silly it gets, when one searches for ways to show that everything is conjecture. It's possible, but it's pointless, because then absolutely nothing can be learned, because no answer is more right than any other.

My reaction is always: yes, everything is conjecture. So what? What are you going to do now?

Despite claiming everything is conjecture, people still generally seem to act as if it's not, because they still believe in basic cause and effect, like not stepping off of high buildings if they don't want to fall.
 
My reaction is always: yes, everything is conjecture. So what? What are you going to do now?

Despite claiming everything is conjecture, people still generally seem to act as if it's not, because they still believe in basic cause and effect, like not stepping off of high buildings if they don't want to fall.


QFT.
 
e=mc2 is not conjecture,not unless we have conjectural atomic bombs and nuclear reactors.

e=mc2 is an abstraction derived from experience. A mathematical tool which can be applied in the known universe.

Even though we don't know anything for certain, or the basis for anything, we can derive abstract models and apply them to existence as we know it.
 
I can't stand solipsism. I can't stand it even less when its been used as a passive aggressive backhanded excuse for irrational nonsense.

There's a difference between "I think therefore I am" and "I think therefore there's a giant invisible bearded guy wizard father figure in the sky that is vitally concerned with what I do in my bedroom."

ETA: And yet another prime example of "Obi-Wan Kenobi Speak"

You and I are sitting on the same bench, then. I can't stand it, either.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom