California governor signs bill requiring schools to teach gay history

Grizzly Adams

Graduate Poster
Joined
May 16, 2010
Messages
1,226
California governor signs bill requiring schools to teach gay history

Los Angeles (CNN) -- Democratic California Gov. Jerry Brown said Thursday he had signed a bill that will require public schools in the state to teach students about the contributions of lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender Americans.
...
"History should be honest," Brown said in a statement.
...
"Today we are making history in California by ensuring that our textbooks and instructional materials no longer exclude the contributions of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) Americans," Sen. Leno [the bill's author] said in a statement.
Okay, first I want to state that I'm not one of the loons described later in the article who think this is opening the doors to infect California students with the gay. I have no problem whatsoever with teaching kids about stuff that was done by gay people.

But why is it that there needs to be attention drawn to the fact that they were gay? Who cares? I have a sneaking suspicion that societal contributions by gays that are important enough to warrant limited classroom time are already included in the cirriculum. And contributions that are excluded aren't excluded because the contributor was gay. Does a student really need a module on assless chaps simply because their inventor was (I can only assume) gay?

Does Oscar Wilde deserve to be pigeonholed in the <SNIP> module in literature class instead of the late 19th-century module alongside Dickens? Or is it going to be "class, we'll spend this week on Oscar Wilde - we're going to read The Importance of Being Earnest and The Picture of Dorian Gray; and by the way, Mr. Wilde had a penchant for buggery."?

It seems rather silly to me to put so much emphasis on how someone liked their coitus.

Edited by Locknar: 
Edited, breach of rule 9.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
California governor signs bill requiring schools to teach gay history


Okay, first I want to state that I'm not one of the loons described later in the article who think this is opening the doors to infect California students with the gay. I have no problem whatsoever with teaching kids about stuff that was done by gay people.

But why is it that there needs to be attention drawn to the fact that they were gay? Who cares? I have a sneaking suspicion that societal contributions by gays that are important enough to warrant limited classroom time are already included in the cirriculum. And contributions that are excluded aren't excluded because the contributor was gay. Does a student really need a module on assless chaps simply because their inventor was (I can only assume) gay?

Does Oscar Wilde deserve to be pigeonholed in the <SNIP> module in literature class instead of the late 19th-century module alongside Dickens? Or is it going to be "class, we'll spend this week on Oscar Wilde - we're going to read The Importance of Being Earnest and The Picture of Dorian Gray; and by the way, Mr. Wilde had a penchant for buggery."?

It seems rather silly to me to put so much emphasis on how someone liked their coitus.
Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content edited.

Because what was done to them was done to them because they were gay obviously. That would be like teaching about slavery in the US without pointing out that they were slaves because it was considered alright to make black people slaves.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Do you think that it is unimportant to know how a state/country treated their minorities? Should we not teach "black history"? Or teach about suffragettes?

Do you think the struggles with social acceptance of gay people is irrelevant, and doesn't deserve any attention, even in a sociological or anthropological vein? How about black people? Women? Native Americans?

Why do you assume that "teaching gay history" means having "a module on assless chaps"?

Because your post seems to imply that "teaching gay history" means teaching nothing but Village People lyrics and fashion. Which, by the way, is pretty insulting. You're ignoring that "gay history" encompasses more than just stereotypical (and a false stereotype at that) "gay culture". It also happens to involve the actions of people who are not gay, how gay people were treated by the sexual preference majority, what sorts of battles gay persons had to fight (and win) to be accepted into modern society, and what that meant for the rest of modern society.

That you are overlooking that, and focusing on "assless chaps" is a demonstration of exactly why "gay history" needs to be taught openly, and to everyone.
 
Because what was done to them was done to them because they were gay obviously.
I know Oscar Wilde was imprisoned in France for his <snip>, and I'm not against his gaiety being discussed in that context because that was a major event in his life. But beyond that sort of thing, I don't see what all the fuss is about. So Person X was an important figure in history. Person X did A, B, and C. Unless the gayness was integral to the story of Person X, why bother to mention it?

Edited by kmortis: 
Removed indecent language
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I know Oscar Wilde was imprisoned in France for his <SNIP>, and I'm not against his gaiety being discussed in that context because that was a major event in his life. But beyond that sort of thing, I don't see what all the fuss is about. So Person X was an important figure in history. Person X did A, B, and C. Unless the gayness was integral to the story of Person X, why bother to mention it?
Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content edited.

For the same reason they used to still point out that Martin Luther King Jr. was black? Come to think of it, every time I tip a waitress I am reminded that George Washington was a white dude.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
"Assless chaps" is a tautology. If they had an ass, they wouldn't be chaps. If students spent less time being gay and more time learning vocabulary, this wouldn't be a problem. I can guarantee that the SAT is more concerned with vocabulary than hot throbbing boy-boy or girl-girl sex, which is yet another reason why standardized testing is ruining education. In conclusion, Libya is truly a land of contrasts.
 
If the law were implemented by evangelical bigots, it might indeed turn out the way you describe. In fact what you say about Oscar Wilde is very similar to how he's discussed in one of the "Politically Incorrect Guide" books.

But it's not going to be implemented by evangelical bigots. They hate this law, and that they can't use it to push their agenda of denouncing the filthy sodomites.
 
Last edited:
"Today we are making history in California by ensuring that our textbooks and instructional materials no longer exclude the contributions of LGBT (lesbian, gay, bisexual and transgender) Americans,"
Is this really an issue, or is it a soloution in search of a problem? What historical figures are/were being excluded because of what they liked to do with their set of genitals?
 
I know Oscar Wilde was imprisoned in France for his <SNIP> , and I'm not against his gaiety being discussed in that context because that was a major event in his life. But beyond that sort of thing, I don't see what all the fuss is about. So Person X was an important figure in history. Person X did A, B, and C. Unless the gayness was integral to the story of Person X, why bother to mention it?
Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content removed.


Out of curiosity, do you know what Oscar Wilde's sexual preferences were, in detail? I don't. He may have been charged with violation of some form of 'sodomy' law, but those laws also often included any sexual behavior other than intercourse in the missionary position.

Unless you know that Oscar Wilde engaged in anal intercourse in the event that led to his arrest, perhaps the term <SNIP> should be replaced by something else (e.g. homosexual behavior).

Edited by Locknar: 
Edited, breach of rule 9.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Is this really an issue, or is it a soloution in search of a problem? What historical figures are/were being excluded because of what they liked to do with their set of genitals?
It's not so much a question of inclusion, but that history has been presented in a way that encourages the belief that homosexuals contribute nothing to the country, and that nothing is lost by ostracizing them.

For example, I learned about Aaron Copland in high school band class, but I didn't know until this moment that he was gay. I admit it would have been awkward to learn that specifically in the band class, but knowing it might have prevented me from going around for years thinking of homosexuals as "degenerates" and "defectives."
 
To illustrate the above point, I'll relate something that happened earlier today while I was at the bookstore (and after I wrote the preceding post). I spent most of the time in the philosophy and sociology section. Looking over one of the shelves, I saw a book turned around with the title against the wall. Well, how can I resist that?

I pulled the book out and took a look at it. The title was Queers In History. Inside was an encyclopedic listing of people whose sex lives or love lives went outside the prescribed conservative Christian norms, with the evidence for each. Pim Fortuyn. Napoleon Bonaparte. Ernst Rohm. Marlon Brando. Billie Holiday. James Buchanan. Andy Warhol.

Now, did that book turn itself around? Was it the "natural state" of that book, unlike every other book on the shelf, to have its title hidden? No, someone did that before I came along. I don't know why, but I can guess and so can you.

That's what this law is about. There's a campaign of denial that was going on long before the law was passed. "Who cares?" The deniers care very much. Apparently enough to do petty, futile things like hiding books in a bookstore.

(More about the problems that particular book has faced here)
 
Last edited:
California governor signs bill requiring schools to teach gay history


Okay, first I want to state that I'm not one of the loons described later in the article who think this is opening the doors to infect California students with the gay. I have no problem whatsoever with teaching kids about stuff that was done by gay people.

But why is it that there needs to be attention drawn to the fact that they were gay? Who cares? I have a sneaking suspicion that societal contributions by gays that are important enough to warrant limited classroom time are already included in the cirriculum. And contributions that are excluded aren't excluded because the contributor was gay. Does a student really need a module on assless chaps simply because their inventor was (I can only assume) gay?

Does Oscar Wilde deserve to be pigeonholed in the <SNIP> module in literature class instead of the late 19th-century module alongside Dickens? Or is it going to be "class, we'll spend this week on Oscar Wilde - we're going to read The Importance of Being Earnest and The Picture of Dorian Gray; and by the way, Mr. Wilde had a penchant for buggery."?

It seems rather silly to me to put so much emphasis on how someone liked their coitus.
Edited by Locknar: 
Moderated content removed.


Duh! Gay community is just attention whores. Ever heard the word "flamer" before? DO catch up.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
For the same reason they used to still point out that Martin Luther King Jr. was black? Come to think of it, every time I tip a waitress I am reminded that George Washington was a white dude.

Nope. He was GREEN. Get it right.
 
If there's nothing wrong with being gay, then this shouldn't be a problem.

Is there something wrong with being gay?
 
I suppose the more we load the standard public school curriculum up with worthless politically-correct crap, the less the education officials will fear that they will risk being held accountable for the utter failure of the schools to adequately teach basic vital skills such as mathematics and literacy.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom