Are elements of the Skeptic community expounding dogma rather than skepticism ?

drg85

Student
Joined
Jul 24, 2011
Messages
27
Greetings folks - Apologies for making my first post such a potentially off putting one, I've been a lurker on here sometime and a contributing guest author to the site so I thought I'd get your opinions on this subject.

Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.

goo.gl/raSxB


What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...
 
Last edited:
Greetings folks - Apologies for making my first post such a potentially off putting one, I've been a lurker on here sometime and a contributing guest author to the site so I thought I'd get your opinions on this subject.

Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.

goo.gl/raSxB


What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...

Occasionally people behave like flawed human beings, make mistakes, do not engage in critical thinking 24/7, act dismissive in regards to particularly silly claims. Appalling, ain't it?
 
has Dawkins actually owned up to the Elevatorgate thing then, it was my understanding that the person who made those comments had signed in as Dawkins (the blog requires a comments sign in name but doesn't check identities) but that Dawkins in that case wasn't the real world Dawkins

You have something I didn't hear then, when did Dawkins publically acknowledge that he posted that ?
can you link ?
 
Occasionally people behave like flawed human beings, make mistakes, do not engage in critical thinking 24/7, act dismissive in regards to particularly silly claims. Appalling, ain't it?

Only appalling if they claim to speak for an entire community - comments in private are one thing and we're all guilty of it, but an entirely different ball game if you go blog about it or claim to speak for an entire subset of people. Particularly galling is when skeptics are publicly unskeptical :)
 
Only appalling if they claim to speak for an entire community - comments in private are one thing and we're all guilty of it, but an entirely different ball game if you go blog about it or claim to speak for an entire subset of people. Particularly galling is when skeptics are publicly unskeptical :)

Well, I'm not sure how I or any skeptic can speak for anyone but ourselves. For perspective you might want to give a few examples of what you feel are skeptics behaving unskeptically.
 
Well, I'm not sure how I or any skeptic can speak for anyone but ourselves. For perspective you might want to give a few examples of what you feel are skeptics behaving unskeptically.

Sure thing. I actually outlined it in my blog, but as I'm a new forum user I cannot hyperlink - if you copy and paste below into your browser you'll get it. Sorry for hassle, should have made that clearer.

goo.gl/raSxB
 
link please ?
:D

Just replied to yer PM there! About Dawkins personally acknowledging ? PZ Myers confirmed it was him. In any case, even if it was some awful troll, let's assume Dawkins said it - or people believed he did in any case. The reaction is more what puzzles me from skeptics. Think I outline in blog :)
 
Just replied to yer PM there! About Dawkins personally acknowledging ? PZ Myers confirmed it was him. In any case, even if it was some awful troll, let's assume Dawkins said it - or people believed he did in any case. The reaction is more what puzzles me from skeptics. Think I outline in blog :)

I thought this wasn't as much a sceptic issue as an Atheist one.
;)
 
As I've remarked many times before, to recognise that crystal healing, homeopathy, Uri Geller and such are a load of nonsense does not require any extraordinary intelligence or critical thinking skills. These are very easy problems to solve. Plenty of people still can't solve them, of course, which is why the skeptical movement is valuable, but the bar to get on board the skeptical ride is not set very high.

Thus it should be no surprise that when controversies arise within the skeptical movement that a lot of dumb things get said.

If any proof is required of this claim, take a look at the Social Issue and Current Events forum. ;)
 
Thus it should be no surprise that when controversies arise within the skeptical movement that a lot of dumb things get said.

If any proof is required of this claim, take a look at the Social Issue and Current Events forum. ;)

Oh dear :) Just about to comment on something you wrote there. Watch this space!
 
drg85, I just read your blog and I wholeheartedly agree.

I first heard about this whole flap on the Skeptics Guide to the Universe podcast. They devoted what seemed an inordinate amount of time to it, and the attacks on Dawkins were cringeworthy to the point where I started to feel like I was listening to some tabloid podcast instead of a skeptical one. It really pains me to see such a rift happening in the skeptics community, especially over something so personal and ideologically sloppy.

As you said, it smacks of a "cult of personality" that is unseemly for a community ostensibly dedicated to free thinking and critical analysis.

Rebecca Watson is of course entitled to her own feelings and opinions, and there's nothing wrong with voicing them publicly. So she was made to feel uncomfortable in a situation involving a certain individual of the male sex. What bothers me about it is that she deemed it necessary to make a condescending address to the entire male population, advising them on how to behave. While her feelings are understandable, the attitude she expressed came across as arrogant, condescending, and somewhat hyperbolic.

The worst part is that I almost feel wrong about criticizing her for it, because of course I do believe in respecting the rights and personal space of women, and I don't mean to belittle her feelings and her right to not be harassed.

But hearing the story as she told it, was she really harassed? So a guy in an elevator invited her to his room for "coffee." Hardly a slick, Casanova-style move. Sure, it's even a bit creepy. But you know, so what? She was exiting a bar, and it's not uncommon for people to get propositioned while exiting bars. What kind of people typically exit bars? Drunk people! The guy was likely a little drunk and a little awkward around women, and drunken, awkward people often act out in socially unacceptable ways. As Rebecca originally reported the story, the guy didn't try to touch her in any way, make a pass, or even an indecent proposition. It's the kind of thing most people might feel slightly uncomfortable about in the moment, but then probably just shrug off afterwards. Making such a big dramatic showpiece out of it seems rather histrionic to me.

I also see Richard Dawkins' point of view. Dawkins appears to be looking at the situation from a more generalized view, and trying to reconcile Rebecca's mildly unsettling experience on a global human rights scale. Women's rights are still an issue in the US, and they're under constant threat every day by political factions that would strip away much of the significant progress we've attained over the past 40-odd years. But the situation here is nothing compared to how badly women have it in other parts of the world. Dawkins was merely trying to put the whole thing into perspective.

My point is, if women really value being treated as equals, then it shouldn't be a problem to accept the occasional discomfort that goes along with dealing with men on an equal footing. It looks to me like on one hand, Rebecca wants to be considered equal to men, but on the other hand she expects to reserve the right to act like a princess whenever confronted with an uncomfortable situation around them. This incident wasn't so much an issue of her "human rights" being violated, but Rebecca using a minor incident as an opportunity to kick up a little drama and pitch a controversial lecture at a bunch of guys.

For the record, I like Rebecca. I think she's smart and personable and attractive, and her online/onstage persona is a lot of fun. I generally share her interests, and find myself in agreement with most of her opinions. I like that she's spun this whole thing with a lot of humor and even a few raunchy jabs here and there. That's cool and awesome. But to spearhead a general boycott of Richard Dawkins over this? Kind of arrogant and annoying.

Whatever. My 2¢.
 
Last edited:
As you said, it smacks of a "cult of personality" that is unseemly for a community ostensibly dedicated to free thinking and critical analysis.

Thanks so much for reading John - I even understood that RW had an emotive connection perhaps and so would have excused her finding it difficult to be objective. What worried me was the poor behaviour of numerous skeptics and science writers!
 
Yeah, it's a little troubling.

But on the other hand, are any of us so naive as to think that a skeptical (and/or atheist) viewpoint alone will inure our community against such typically human political and social frictions?
 
Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking.
I realize that it is not central to the issue, but I must respectfully disagree on this point.

The smart-aleck-ry, insults, bickering, and dismissive or downright hostile rude behavior is endemic to this forum. It is a part of the culture here. There are posters that are well mannered and civil, but this rude behavior is everywhere and inescapable.

The worst threads are those that deal with fringe topics and started by or posted in by members that have earned a reputation as not being ernest or being unwilling to adopt the viewpoints of others. Even normally well-behaved members seem to take that as an invitation to throw out civility and to make blatant ad hominums against the people they perceive as being unworthy of a civil discussion.

Regards, Canis
 
Whatever. My 2¢.

And a nice 2c it was.

I think the worst thing for me out of the whole debacle was that it was completely counter-productive. You know, as much as it sucks, the world is still run by fat white men - the *last* thing you want to give the guys holding the keys to the kingdom is an excuse to reject the entire ideology of sex equality because "those chicks are just noisy femos". It takes planning and patience.

This may suck, but lots of things in the world suck.
 
And a nice 2c it was.

I think the worst thing for me out of the whole debacle was that it was completely counter-productive. ....
I found it quite enlightening for identifying people whose lack of skeptical posts and blogs I might have previously had undeserved respect for.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom