Greetings folks - Apologies for making my first post such a potentially off putting one, I've been a lurker on here sometime and a contributing guest author to the site so I thought I'd get your opinions on this subject.
Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.
goo.gl/raSxB
What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...
Reading these forums I see the vast majority of posters are skeptics in the classical sense - without being rude, they will disagree, ask for clarification or evidence and there are little traces of dogmatic thinking. Yet interestingly enough in the wake of the 'elevatorgate' debacle there were many examples of "leading" figures in the skeptic community taking an approach which was the very anti-thesis of skeptical. There were also several examples of logical fallacies, as well as a creeping wave of people trying to marry skepticism to ideology. Evidently this was an emotive issue but it saddened me that a cause I think so worthwhile is at risk of being deemed hypocritical. I've written about it here, I'd be grateful if you'd take a look and share your thoughts.
goo.gl/raSxB
What do others think ? I realise this may be an entrenched issue but it would be very disheartening, as a skeptic community, if we couldn't rationally examine it...
Last edited: