You might be a FUNDY ATHEIST

  • Thread starter Thread starter Guest
  • Start date Start date
It's an entire web page full of ad hominem attacks, straw men, and other elementary logical fallacies.

One wonders what makes it worthy of Whodini's attention...
 
Thanks, Whodini.

Question: Did Anus bring something to the discussion, or complain about something?
 
Hey brainwashed Unas, you forgot to say "They are trolls".. LOL :)
 
hammegk said:
Thanks, Whodini.

Question: Did Anus bring something to the discussion, or complain about something?


WHO?

I didn't see anybody.

;)

Yeah, looking at you-know-who's post counts and who he's posted to, and the content of his posts makes his motives pretty transparent. But no, he's not a troll, no sirreeee, because he's Mr. Policeman!

:D
 
From Whodini's link:
----
You spend hours arguing that a-theism actually means "without a belief in God " and not just " belief that there is no god" as if this is a meaningful distinction in real life.
----

I am really surprised about this. Everybody I know feels the distinction is important; especially christians.
Most christians can deal with indifference about god, but get really hurt or molested by negation of god.
This list seems made by christian fundamentalist...Certainly those arguments are too radical for the average catholic.
 
Peskanov said:
From Whodini's link:
----
You spend hours arguing that a-theism actually means "without a belief in God " and not just " belief that there is no god" as if this is a meaningful distinction in real life.
----

I am really surprised about this. Everybody I know feels the distinction is important; especially christians.
Most christians can deal with indifference about god, but get really hurt or molested by negation of god.
This list seems made by christian fundamentalist...Certainly those arguments are too radical for the average catholic.

Since you are aware that your cult is about to perish, YOU CERTAINLY ATTEMPT TO TURN US AGAINST EACH OTHER, LIKE THE ATHEISTS THAT YOU ARE, THEN CLAIM TO BE "MORALLY GOOD"...:) But that wont work this time, especially dealing with the educated...

Christians means disciples of Christ, and we are all called to love one another regardless of belief, race, cultures, even enemies.

the body is the temple of God, each individual is their own church, their own religion. Who have their "own" philosophies and beliefs, and may not share that with the rest of the members of the same "Organized religion""..

Even if we share different beliefs (I prefer blue, while you prefer red. Jesus was 33 yrs old, Jesus was 32 yrs old..etc.) Regardless of our misconceptions, the fact is, whats important is our virtues.... Kapeesh.......
 
muscleman said:
Since you are aware that your cult is about to perish, YOU CERTAINLY ATTEMPT TO TURN US AGAINST EACH OTHER, LIKE THE ATHEISTS THAT YOU ARE, THEN CLAIM TO BE "MORALLY GOOD"...
Muscleman is employing the straw man fallacy, by attacking an argument that Peskanov did not make.
 
Unas is appealing to authority by constantly referring to that webpage like it proves her points or something.

Unas committed the fallacy of changing the subject by completely diverting the topic of the original post in this thread.

Unas committed a semi-ad hom , by stating: "One wonders what makes it worthy of Whodini's attention..."

Unas is committing the fallacy of style over substance by arguing that the presentation of the 'You Might be a Fundy Atheist' page somehow affect its contents.


Hey, this is fun Unas. I can keep this up too. Glad I took you off ignore temporarily.

Thanks for the site!

:D
 
hahahahahaha, thanks for the site too brainwashed cult Una! Ill use that for sometime later..
 
Whodini said:
This deserves a post every once in a while. Some of them really hit home (some do not though):


http://www.tektonics.org/fundyath.html
It contained some funny bits, though a bit mean-spirited. it was unlike the Jeff Foxorthy "You might be a redneck..." routines that is modelled after in that it is obvious to all that Foxworth really likes rednecks. I did not get the impression that the author(s) of this list thought that atheists are basically good people with some funny quirks.

But even so, it is always good to be able to laugh at yourself.
 
Whodini said:
Unas is appealing to authority by constantly referring to that webpage like it proves her points or something.
False. I merely provide a handy reference to the definitions of the fallacies I refer to.
Whodini said:
Unas committed the fallacy of changing the subject by completely diverting the original post in this thread.
The "original post in this thread" is exactly as Whodini posted it, and has not been changed or "diverted" in any way. If Whodini does not wish his posts to be commented upon, he can simply cease posting.
Whodini said:
Unas committed a semi-ad hom , by stating: "One wonders what makes it worthy of Whodini's attention..."
Possibly. I shall be more careful in the future.
Whodini said:
Unas is committing the fallacy of style over substance by arguing that the presentation of the 'You Might be a Fundy Atheist' page somehow affect its contents.
False. I made no comment whatsoever upon the presentation of the page in question.
 
ILL IMPERSONATE TO BE AN ATHEIST JUST FOR THIS POST 2 SHOW HOW THEY RESPOND

Unas said:
False. I merely provide a handy reference to the definitions of the fallacies I refer to.

Giving reference to a website doesnt necessarily mean the website is a dogma and something we can lay all our trust to..

Unas said:

The "original post in this thread" is exactly as Whodini posted it, and has not been changed or "diverted" in any way.

Of course you tried to changed it, you started talking about "Ad hominem" instead of showing the fallacy of the topic...

Unas said:

If Whodini does not wish his posts to be commented upon, he can simply cease posting.
Possibly. I shall be more careful in the future.
False. I made no comment whatsoever upon the presentation of the page in question.

You made no comment on the question? Are you on crack? See above, you typed it yourself...

THATS HOW THE ATHEISTS RESPONDS, LIKE A MORON, THEN ACCUSES US OF BEING A MORON....... POINTLESS COMMENTS...
 
Unas committed the fallacy of appealing to popularity yet again by referencing his "handy reference" page for the nth time.

Unas also is knowingly and consciously arguing based on falsehoods, by stating

"The "original post in this thread" is exactly as Whodini posted it, and has not been changed or "diverted" in any way."
03-10-2003 12:30 AM

when I in fact said:
(emphasis mine)

"Unas committed the fallacy of changing the subject by completely diverting the topic of the original post in this thread."
03-10-2003 12:24 AM

I await further use of that handy reference page.
 
Re: ILL IMPERSONATE TO BE AN ATHEIST JUST FOR THIS POST 2 SHOW HOW THEY RESPOND

muscleman said:
Giving reference to a website doesnt necessarily mean the website is a dogma and something we can lay all our trust to.
I have not claimed that the Logical Fallacies website is 'dogma'. Muscleman again employs a straw man, by attacking an argument that I did not make.
muscleman said:
Of course you tried to changed it, you started talking about "Ad hominem" instead of showing the fallacy of the topic.
Incorrect. I pointed out that the page in question was, in fact, full of fallacies -- including several hominems.
muscleman said:
You made no comment on the question?
As I stated, I made no comment on the presentation of the website that Whodini referred to. Muscleman dishonestly twists this to another meaning -- a classic straw man fallacy.
muscleman said:
Are you on crack?
Ad hominem. Dismissed for lack of content.
muscleman said:
See above, you typed it yourself...
The statement "If Whodini does not wish his posts to be commented upon, he can simply cease posting" clearly refers to Whodini's own posts, not the website Whodini referred to. Muscelman's dishonest practice of ignoring the context of the posts he answers is noted.
muscleman said:
THATS HOW THE ATHEISTS RESPONDS, LIKE A MORON, THEN ACCUSES US OF BEING A MORON.
I have not referred to Muscelman as a "moron". He again employs the straw man fallacy.
 
Whodini said:
Unas committed the fallacy of appealing to popularity yet again by referencing his "handy reference" page for the nth time.
False. I have made no reference to the popularity of the page.

Whodini should simply stop lying about what others have said and done.
 
Re: Re: ILL IMPERSONATE TO BE AN ATHEIST JUST FOR THIS POST 2 SHOW HOW THEY RESPOND

Unas's dishonesty, as discussed above, is noted.
 
Whodini said:
Unas also is knowingly and consciously arguing based on falsehoods, by stating

"The "original post in this thread" is exactly as Whodini posted it, and has not been changed or "diverted" in any way."
03-10-2003 12:30 AM
Where is the falsehood in that statement? Whodini has yet to point it out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom