Yahoo Answers: How some astrohysicists fool people with illogic.

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
I put this question yesterday in Yahoo Answers:

http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20111107153236AA5HwexYour Open Question


What is the equation in math notation by which the universe came forth from nothing and no creator either?

Atheist astrophysicists like Hawking, Stenger, Krauss (not many, perhaps only as can be counted with the fingers of one hand) tell us in effect that the fact of the existence of the universe where we live in and are part and parcel of came forth from nothing, i.e. from no antecedent material for its composition and no creator whatsoever who is self-existing.

They work with mathematics to come to this conclusion.

Now, is there anywhere in the internet their equations in math notation by which on the left side before the = sign there is the notation of un or whatever for universe, and on the right side after the = sign there are all kinds of symbols and digits and letters and signs whatever showing that with that equation: there is the mathematical demonstration with mathematical certainty that the universe where we live in and are part and parcel of came forth from nothing, i.e. no antecedent material of composition and no creator whatsoever who is self-existing.


http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20111107153236AA5Hwex

--------------------

[ You might not find any trace of this question because it will be deleted eventually. ]


What I got from people who love to answer questions are mockery, parody, and evasions.


Then this morning earlier I introduced this question:

Preview Your Question


Your Question

How do astrophysicists like Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss prove that the universe came forth from nothing?

There are astrophysicists like Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss (not more than the fingers in one hand though) state that the universe came forth from nothing, not from any pre-existing material of composition and not from any creator who is self-existing.

I asked people in Yahoo Answers whether there is any publicly accessible equation made available by such astrophysicists whereby on the left side of the = sign there is the 'un' representing the universe and on the right side of the = sign there are all kinds of symbols, letters, digits, signs, whatever representing their mathematical demonstration that the universe came forth from nothing, nothing of any pre-existing material and nothing of any creator who is self-existing.

No one came up with any such equation in the internet, and I believe neither in any publications outside the internet will anyone find such an equation because people like Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss cannot produce such an equation.

What they do is use words and concepts instead to show how their manipulation of words and concepts prove that the universe came forth from nothing, from no pre-existing material and from no creator who is self-existing.

Now, I am asking the people who understand the words and concepts of Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss and their kind of something from absolute nothing school of cosmology astrophysicists, to present how they use words and concepts to demonstrate that the universe came forth from nothing, from absolute nothing, not from any pre-existing material and not from any creator who is self-existing.

Please present your understanding of these astrophysicists with successive statements so that the second follow from the first, and the third follow from the second, and so forth until the last statement tells readers that wherefore the universe came forth from nothing, nothing of any pre-existing material and nothing from a creator who is self-existing.

Like for example you are teaching cooking, specifically how to prepare beef stew:

1. Obtain the following ingredients:

---- 3 lbs boneless chuck roast, cut into 2-inch pieces
---- 3 tbsp vegetable oil
---- 2 tsp salt
---- 1 tbsp freshly ground pepper
---- 2 yellow onions, cut into 1-inch chunks
---- 1/4 cup flour
---- 3 cloves garlic, minced
---- 1 cup red wine
---- 3 cups beef broth
---- 1/2 tsp dried rosemary
---- 1 bay leaf
---- 1/2 tsp dried thyme
---- 4 carrots, peeled, cut into 1-inch slices
---- 2 stalks celery, cut into 1-inch slices
---- 3 large russet potatoes, peeled and cut in eighths
---- fresh parsley to garnish (optional)

2. On medium-high heat, add the vegetable oil to a large heavy pot (one that has a tight fitting lid).

3. When it begins to smoke slightly, add the beef and brown very well. Do in batches if necessary. Add the salt and pepper as the beef browns.

4. Once browned, remove the beef with a slotted spoon set aside.

5. Add the onions and sauté for about 5 minutes, until softened.

6. Reduce heat to medium-low, and add the flour and cook for 2 minutes stirring often.

7. Add the garlic and cook for 1 minute.

8. Add wine and deglaze the pan, scraping any brown bits stuck to the bottom of the pan. The flour will start to thicken the wine as it comes to a simmer.

9. Simmer wine for 5 minutes, and then add the broth, bay leaves, thyme, rosemary, and the beef.

10. Bring back to a gentle simmer, cover and cook on very low for about 1 hour.

11. Add potatoes, carrots, and celery, and simmer covered for another 30 minutes or until the meat and vegetables are tender. Taste and adjust seasoning.

12. Turn off heat and let sit for 15 minutes before serving. Garnish with the fresh parsley if desired.

13. Voila, here is your beef stew ready for the dining table.


[ Cf. http://americanfood.about.com/od/classicchowdersandstews/r/beefstew.htm ]

So, I am addressing my question to Hawking, Stenger, and Krauss and people who understand them and accept their idea that the universe came forth from nothing, from no pre-existing material and from no creator who is self-existing, please present a succession of statements showing how your words and concepts at the last statement convey necessarily the idea that the universe came forth from nothing, from no pre-existing material and no creator who is self-existing.

I am sure that what you will be doing is ‘magical’ manipulation of words and concepts.

In other words, anyone who claim to be able and to have shown that the universe came forth from nothing, no pre-existing material and no creator who is self-existing, is either ignorant of logic or deceitfully into fooling people with illogic by way of fraudulent sleight of hand magic with words and concepts.

​



What happened when I submitted the question?

Here:

Yahoo Answers said:
Yahoo Answers is not available at present.


Well, that is nothing new with Yahoo Answers, they even deleted my questions already out in the web and for some days open to everyone in the web; on other occasions they deleted my questions right away and when I demanded why they in effect beat about the bush.


The earlier question on equation of universe from nothing, it iwll be deleted from Yahoo Answers eventually.




Yrreg​
 
The universe is like this: 12 + 16 + 18 - 14 - 9 - 3 - 9 - 11

It all adds up to nothing, but it doesn't look that way from someone who's actually inside the equation.
 
Can anyone translate?

Lately I've been trolling the internets.

And it's been working really well.

But recently the internets have been deleting my trolls.

What gives you guys?
 
I put this question yesterday in Yahoo Answers:




What I got from people who love to answer questions are mockery, parody, and evasions.


Then this morning earlier I introduced this question:




What happened when I submitted the question?

Here:




Well, that is nothing new with Yahoo Answers, they even deleted my questions already out in the web and for some days open to everyone in the web; on other occasions they deleted my questions right away and when I demanded why they in effect beat about the bush.


The earlier question on equation of universe from nothing, it iwll be deleted from Yahoo Answers eventually.




Yrreg



:dl:
 
Read post #1 thoughtfully with full intelligence alert, then consult me for any...

I'm lost with this thread.

Can anyone help me out?


Read post #1 thoughtfully with full intelligence alert, then consult me for any word you don't know, or anything else at all you cannot comprehend.


I am going to take a nap now and hope later some people with good comprehension and relevant ideas in their mind coupled with pure sincerity to know the facts will be present in this thread.



Yrreg
 
You ask a question which contains misconceptions from the start, you use unecessarilly convoluted language, you misuse idiomatic English, your post contains several redundancies which detract from the sense, and you veer into derails about recipes - and for some reason you are surprised that people just raise their eyebrows and go back to playing solitaire?

If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions.

Your very first sentence, proposing that the universe came from nothing, contains an incorrect premise so your question as posed cannot be answered.

Perhaps you should rephrase your question removing all assumptions, redundancies, idiom and recipes.
 
Read post #1 thoughtfully with full intelligence alert, then consult me for any word you don't know, or anything else at all you cannot comprehend.
Thanks. The only thing I don't understand about your post is every friggin' word of it.

I am going to take a nap now and hope later some people with good comprehension and relevant ideas in their mind coupled with pure sincerity to know the facts will be present in this thread.
You're not even asleep yet, and visions of sugar plums dance in your head. Good trick.
 
Read post #1 thoughtfully with full intelligence alert, then consult me for any word you don't know, or anything else at all you cannot comprehend.


I am going to take a nap now and hope later some people with good comprehension and relevant ideas in their mind coupled with pure sincerity to know the facts will be present in this thread.



Yrreg

My hovercraft is full of eels.
 
I'm lost with this thread.

Can anyone help me out?


He's trying to avoid answering the rebuttals to his argument in this thread.

As for what he's asking, I don't know how accurately I'm parsing it. It looks as though he's asking for the math equation describing the formation of the universe (in typical creationist fashion, the idea of saying "I don't know" is anathema to him). From the looks of things (since he was answered with "mockery, parody, and evasions"), he didn't like the answers he recieved. But that's the question he asked on Yahoo. I think what he's asking here is why his follow-up question appears to have vanished.

And there's a recipe for beef stew in the mix.

All-in-all, I'm not sure what yrreg wants in this thread.



Edit: Also this. Very much this.
You ask a question which contains misconceptions from the start, you use unecessarilly convoluted language, you misuse idiomatic English, your post contains several redundancies which detract from the sense, and you veer into derails about recipes - and for some reason you are surprised that people just raise their eyebrows and go back to playing solitaire?

If you want an answer, the first thing you need to do is to ask a question in a simple, clear way, without assumptions.

Your very first sentence, proposing that the universe came from nothing, contains an incorrect premise so your question as posed cannot be answered.

Perhaps you should rephrase your question removing all assumptions, redundancies, idiom and recipes.
Well said, Agatha! :clap:
 
Last edited:
I'm lost with this thread.

Can anyone help me out?


Gerry believes that every single thing that happens in the universe is personally directed to him. So, when Yahoo glitched for a moment, he thought it was a direct rebuff of him and his beliefs. This is so even though Yahoo Answers is a computer program.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom