Treadmill physics

Almo

Masterblazer
Joined
Aug 30, 2005
Messages
6,846
Location
Montreal, Quebec
Hi!

I was on a treadmill the other day, walking at a brisk pace. I cranked the incline to 10 or 15%. I didn't feel much of a difference,though there was some. But I was walking efficiently, keeping my center of mass as motionless as I could. This got me to thinking about the physics.

If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not increasing my potential energy. All I'm doing is spending energy to keep my legs moving with the belt. My thought is that the extra effort is just for lifting my feet from closer to the floor to further from the floor because of the incline.

But I'm not the only one to wonder this. I've seen huge arguments where people say "But the forces are exactly the same on the treadmill or on the ground, so there's no difference."

My approach to complex physics problems is always to consider energy, since working from forces is hard. There's a reason we invented Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The problems you can solve with those (like a sphere rolling without slipping down a cylindrical tube with larger radius than the ball) can be an absolute nightmare working from the forces.

I imagine people who really feel the difference with the incline on with the treadmill are letting their center of mass move a bit forward and backward relative to the front of the machine, and that means each step has to add potential energy when going back up the incline.

I'm wondering if some of the many really smart physics people hanging around here could shed some light on this, and tell me if I'm missing something.
 
You are doing work above and beyond the weight of your foot. When you plant your foot on the front of the (tilted) treadmill, you need to press down on that foot with your-weight's worth of force in order to hold your body up. Your foot then travels downwards, exerting force all the way. That's mechanical work (force times displacement). If the treadmill didn't have any resistance or speed control, it'd accelerate under the force of your foot, and this work would increase the belt's kinetic energy. Since the belt has internal friction/brakes, this work goes into heating up the brakes.

Contrast that with the flat treadmill. You're pushing straight down with your foot. When your foot gets displaced it goes straight backwards, in a direction perpendicular to the force, so the force does no work.
 
If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not increasing my potential energy.

You're right. But think of the treadmill as a device that is extracting energy from you. If you stood still, it could gather energy by lowering your mass. So you have to put that much energy back just to remain in one place.


All I'm doing is spending energy to keep my legs moving with the belt. My thought is that the extra effort is just for lifting my feet from closer to the floor to further from the floor because of the incline.

No, it's also to heat up components within the treadmill.
 
If the treadmill didn't have any resistance or speed control, it'd accelerate under the force of your foot, and this work would increase the belt's kinetic energy. Since the belt has internal friction/brakes, this work goes into heating up the brakes.

It's a powered treadmill. You tell it how fast you want to go, and you just keep up with it.

You're right. But think of the treadmill as a device that is extracting energy from you. If you stood still, it could gather energy by lowering your mass. So you have to put that much energy back just to remain in one place.

I don't quite agree here. If you're not actually moving backward, you're not gaining any net kinetic energy.
 
Last edited:
It's a powered treadmill. You tell it how fast you want to go, and you just keep up with it.

That doesn't mean that energy doesn't flow into it from the belt.

I don't quite agree here. If you're not actually moving backward, you're not gaining any net kinetic energy.

I didn't say that the runner gained or lost kinetic energy.

I said that if you stood still, you would lose GPE because you'd be getting closer to the ground. So you have to put in energy to maintain your position and your GPE. Because of the treadmill, instead of this energy going to increasing your kinetic energy (as would happen on a flat surface), the energy is going into the treadmill.

If it's a very efficient treadmill, that energy is going into heating up the brakes.

If it's inefficient, it's going into reducing the power that the motor needs to provide to overcome friction.
 
I like to at least start with the simple approach.

Most of the work of real-world walking involves swinging one leg out in front while pushing backwards against the ground with the other. On the treadmill, you still have to swing the one leg forward, but the other leg gets a free ride. Somewhat less when set on incline, but still.

On a motorized treadmill, the forces are not the same. The treadmill is doing a lot of the work.
 
It's a powered treadmill. You tell it how fast you want to go, and you just keep up with it.

When you're going uphill, that means that you are powering it. Your feet are applying a force that tries to speed up the belt, and the computer notices this and does something (Applies brakes? Loads the motor so it acts as a generator?) that prevents it from accelerating.

Think through the forces and imagine what would happen if the belt were frictionless and the controller disconnected. Can you see that each "uphill" stride will make the belt accelerate?
 
I said that if you stood still, you would lose GPE because you'd be getting closer to the ground. So you have to put in energy to maintain your position and your GPE.

This isn't a rigorous use of the word energy. If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not putting energy in. I am doing something that keeps the energy the same. That's not the same as putting energy in.

The example is a box sitting on a table. If the table didn't stop the box from falling, it would lose potential energy and (temporarily) gain kinetic energy. The table doesn't put energy into the box to keep it stationary. It exerts a force opposite the force of gravity which keeps the potential energy the same and the kinetic energy zero.

Neither the table nor the box does any work.

Where I lose energy on the treadmill is from moving my legs to remain stationary. This gives my legs kinetic energy, and expends chemical energy. But it puts no net kinetic or potential energy into me as a whole, since my velocity and height remain the same.

So my argument is that yes, I lose energy on the treadmill. Yes, that is due to exerting forces on the belt. But when I increase the incline, it only makes it a little harder to lift my legs, but I don't have to do all the extra work to increase my potential energy like I would on a real slope.

Try running up the down escalator some time.

I am going to, but I will not try to move. I will try to remain stationary. If that's less work than climbing stairs, then I'm right about the potential energy thing.
 
Last edited:
I like to at least start with the simple approach.

Most of the work of real-world walking involves swinging one leg out in front while pushing backwards against the ground with the other. On the treadmill, you still have to swing the one leg forward, but the other leg gets a free ride. Somewhat less when set on incline, but still.

On a motorized treadmill, the forces are not the same. The treadmill is doing a lot of the work.

Could you elaborate on the highlighted please? The last thread I read which had a lot of stuff about treadmills, the (in)famous faster than downwind cart thread, led me to believe that moving on a (moving) treadmill was the same as moving on a stationary road. I'm probably misunderstanding something, but as someone who runs on both a treadmill and a road, I don't notice any free ride at all.
 
Where I lose energy on the treadmill is from moving my legs to remain stationary. This gives my legs kinetic energy, and expends chemical energy. But it puts no net kinetic or potential energy into me as a whole, since my velocity and height remain the same.

So my argument is that yes, I lose energy on the treadmill. Yes, that is due to exerting forces on the belt. But when I increase the incline, it only makes it a little harder to lift my legs, but I don't have to do all the extra work to increase my potential energy like I would on a real slope.
you expending enough energy to stop you dropping in height (which you would do if you stopped) that same amount of energy would be enough for you to rise up the same amount of height on a stationary incline
 
you expending enough energy to stop you dropping in height (which you would do if you stopped) that same amount of energy would be enough for you to rise up the same amount of height on a stationary incline

I don't agree. Remember my box example. If the center of mass is not moving, then you're not putting energy in. You are doing something to keep the energy the same. I expend energy to move my legs, not raise my center of mass.
 
Hi!

I was on a treadmill the other day, walking at a brisk pace. I cranked the incline to 10 or 15%. I didn't feel much of a difference,though there was some. But I was walking efficiently, keeping my center of mass as motionless as I could. This got me to thinking about the physics.

If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not increasing my potential energy. All I'm doing is spending energy to keep my legs moving with the belt. My thought is that the extra effort is just for lifting my feet from closer to the floor to further from the floor because of the incline.

But I'm not the only one to wonder this. I've seen huge arguments where people say "But the forces are exactly the same on the treadmill or on the ground, so there's no difference."

My approach to complex physics problems is always to consider energy, since working from forces is hard. There's a reason we invented Lagrangian and Hamiltonian mechanics. The problems you can solve with those (like a sphere rolling without slipping down a cylindrical tube with larger radius than the ball) can be an absolute nightmare working from the forces.

I imagine people who really feel the difference with the incline on with the treadmill are letting their center of mass move a bit forward and backward relative to the front of the machine, and that means each step has to add potential energy when going back up the incline.

I'm wondering if some of the many really smart physics people hanging around here could shed some light on this, and tell me if I'm missing something.

You can consider it from a force point of view, or from an energy point of view. Both analyses will show that walking at speed x on a powerful treadmill that keeps a constant speed is equivalent to walking at the same speed on solid ground with the same inclination as the treadmill.

If you look at it from an energy point of view, it's essential to remember that energy calculations will differ in different frames of reference. If you're walking on an inclined treadmill in a room, it seems reasonable to look at the situation from the inertial frame of reference in which the room is at rest. In this frame of reference, if you keep walking at the speed of the treadmill, you are effectively at rest. Your legs are doing work against the treadmill to hold you in place: if you stopped walking, the treadmill would carry you backwards and downwards.

Now imagine you are walking at the same speed up a road that has the same inclination as the treadmill. In order to easily compare the two situations, we choose an equivalent frame of reference. We look at an inertial frame of reference that is moving steadily at the same speed as you are. Viewed in this frame of reference, we can see that this situation is identical with the previous one: you are effectively at rest in the frame of reference, and your legs are once more doing work to keep you in this position.

In both cases, in the chosen frame of reference, you have no net kinetic energy and your potential energy is also constant. In both cases, the surface that you are walking on does have kinetic energy.
 
This isn't a rigorous use of the word energy. If my center of mass is stationary, I'm not putting energy in. I am doing something that keeps the energy the same. That's not the same as putting energy in.

I have a mortgage that takes money out of my bank every month. I have to put money in my bank account every month to keep my balance the same. Care to tell me I'm not putting money in?

You are adding energy to you, the belt is removing energy at the same rate. You remain motionless but the treadmill heats up.
 
I don't agree. Remember my box example. If the center of mass is not moving, then you're not putting energy in. You are doing something to keep the energy the same. I expend energy to move my legs, not raise my center of mass.

You're still not seeing it. Draw a mark anywhere on the treadmill surface and watch what happens to its elevation (ignore it's horizontal component). It sinks. Since your body's elevation isn't changing, you must be rising relative to the surface of the treadmill. That's what counts as far as the energy expended by your legs, since that's what they're in contact with.

I think it's easier to see this if you picture yourself riding a bike on the treadmill. Lift your feet off the pedals and it would roll "downhill" off the treadmill, independent of the speed setting. It takes your pedaling energy to keep it from doing that.
 
I have a mortgage that takes money out of my bank every month. I have to put money in my bank account every month to keep my balance the same. Care to tell me I'm not putting money in?

Using non-applicable analogies doesn't help, I'm afraid. I have a master's in physics, and I'm looking for a rigorous answer to this. The reference-frame answer just above seems correct to me, and I'm digesting it before commenting on it.
 
I don't quite agree here. If you're not actually moving backward, you're not gaining any net kinetic energy.

As others have pointed out, you are gaining kinetic energy with respect to the frame of reference of the top surface of the belt, which is what matters because that is the surface you are interacting with. Consider an elevator moving down at a constant speed. Is it easier to climb a ladder in that elevator than it is for an elevator that is not moving? Since you're interacting with the elevator, the frame of reference for any energy calculations should be the one in which the elevator is not moving. Consider the earth, which at the equator is moving beneath your feet at about 1000 mph. Is it easier to walk east than west?

Of course on the treadmill the wind is always moving at the same speed you are wrt the top surface on the belt, while out in the world the wind could be aiding or opposing you.
 
Using non-applicable analogies doesn't help, I'm afraid.

I did not intend to provide a non-applicable analogy. Could you tell me in what way it isn't useful here?

I have a master's in physics, and I'm looking for a rigorous answer to this. The reference-frame answer just above seems correct to me, and I'm digesting it before commenting on it.

I gave that response because your OP suggested that you were most interested in an explanation based on the energy flow.
 
Most of the work of real-world walking involves swinging one leg out in front while pushing backwards against the ground with the other. On the treadmill, you still have to swing the one leg forward, but the other leg gets a free ride. Somewhat less when set on incline, but still.

There's no free ride. You still have to push back against the belt in order to maintain your position. Otherwise you would go off the back of the treadmill.

Steve S
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom