Terra revolving round Sol question

CplFerro

Graduate Poster
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
1,962
Dear All,

My question is an hypothetical: if Terra and Sol were the only bodies in the cosmos, would there be any way to tell that Terra was revolving around Sol? Couldn't, in such a situation, it be interpreted equally plausibly that Sol was rotating in such a way as to make it appear Terra was revolving round it?

Cpl Ferro
 
It's that way now. We can construct a cosmology such that the Earth is the unmoving center of the universe, and the rest of the cosmos spin around it. However, such a model requires so many novel forces and assumptions that it rapidly becomes simply absurd.

So yes, we could create a model by which the Sun revolved around the Earth if those were the only two bodies in existence.

We'd probably be able to tell what was revolving around what once we discovered the concept of gravity, however. Technically speaking the Sun DOES revolve around the Earth--or rather, both revolve around the center of mass. The issue is that in the Earth/Sun system the center of mass is so close to the Sun's center of mass that, given the other effects in the solar system, they're indistinguishable over time (ie, the Sun's center of mass wiggles a lot more than would be the case if it was just the Earth and the Sun). We knew that a long time ago, before we observed it--it's a consequence of the way gravity works. Otherwise we'd have to explain why all objects are attracted to Earth, rather than all objects being attracted to heavy objects or light objects (if we drop two balls of the same mass at the same time on opposite sides of the world they both fall down--which would be impossible if gravity was inversely proportional to mass, which is one way to construct a system where the Sun revolves around the Earth).
 
It's that way now. We can construct a cosmology such that the Earth is the unmoving center of the universe, and the rest of the cosmos spin around it. However, such a model requires so many novel forces and assumptions that it rapidly becomes simply absurd.

Are there physicists who concentrate on modeling the universe in this way? It seems like it could lead to some breakthrough trying to look at the universe from this frame. Or maybe not.
 
Technically speaking the Sun DOES revolve around the Earth--or rather, both revolve around the center of mass.

This is the answer. If the Sun and the Earth were the only bodies in the cosmos, they would in fact be revolving around each other.
 
No one I know of is working on modeling the universe sa revolving around the Earth. It'd be silly to try--once you get to the edge of the solar system things are moving faster than light, as I recall. And the whole orbits within orbits within orbits within orbits thing.
 
Dear All,

My question is an hypothetical: if Terra and Sol were the only bodies in the cosmos, would there be any way to tell that Terra was revolving around Sol? Couldn't, in such a situation, it be interpreted equally plausibly that Sol was rotating in such a way as to make it appear Terra was revolving round it?

Cpl Ferro

No once you invent gravity the answer becomes obvious no matter your perspective
 
Dear All,

My question is an hypothetical: if Terra and Sol were the only bodies in the cosmos, would there be any way to tell that Terra was revolving around Sol? Couldn't, in such a situation, it be interpreted equally plausibly that Sol was rotating in such a way as to make it appear Terra was revolving round it?

Cpl Ferro

I thought that they are both revolving around the centre of mass. It's just that Sol is so massive that the centre of mass lies with in Sol
 
if Terra and Sol were the only bodies in the cosmos, would there be any way to tell that Terra was revolving around Sol? Couldn't, in such a situation, it be interpreted equally plausibly that Sol was rotating in such a way as to make it appear Terra was revolving round it?
People would start off thinking that, just as they did before the "Copernican revolution", which took a hundred years to happen. With no other astronomical bodies it would take longer, but eventually some Newton would come along, and/or somebody would send up rockets which take the place of astronomical bodies, and people would work out what's cooking with orbits and gravity. They'd work out that the smaller body was orbiting the bigger body.
 
General relativity, our current best theory of gravity and a massive conceptual advance (one that has still not been fully appreciated by most people) allows us to choose any coordinate system we like. Its predictions for all physical experiments are independent of coordinate choice, and - unlike in Newtonian theories - there is nothing that prefers one coordinate system over another apart from convenience. There are no inertial frames, and all gravitational "forces" are "fictitious" in the sense of Newton.

As a result, you're perfectly free to choose coordinates in which the sun goes around the earth, or in which the earth isn't rotating and all the stars go around it once/24 hours. Do those coordinates "require many novel forces and assumptions"? Nope, not in the slightest - no assumptions are necessary, nor are there any new forces. Are they more complex? Not really - calculations can be done in whatever coordinates are the most convenient, and the results transformed to any other, so on that basis it's very hard to argue that one set of coordinates are more complex than another.

But come on - doesn't the earth really go around the sun? Well, people used to think that there was an absolute rest frame, and really things at rest with respect to the earth and air where at rest. Galileo and Newton overturned that notion by making it clear that "at rest" is a meaningless statement, one that only has relative meaning. General relativity to a large degree overturned even the notion that acceleration or rotation is absolute, because it allows one to use any coordinates whatsoever, and proves that all physical predictions are unchanged.
 
Last edited:
Sol does not believe that Terra revolving around Sol is an objective statement.
Is Terra available for comment?

No one I know of is working on modeling the universe sa revolving around the Earth. It'd be silly to try--once you get to the edge of the solar system things are moving faster than light, as I recall.
Why do you think this? If I want to know where to point a telescope, I'd probably use the usual equatorial coordinate system of declination and right ascension with sidereal time adjustment (ok, another radial would need to go somewhere, e.g., distance). The universe doesn't break in those coordinates. To check the predictions of any gravitational model, as a practical matter one would likely transform to those coordinates anyway, or something like them.
 
Stick to your guns Dinwar. You're free to use any coordinate system you like, just as you're free to use any map you like, but that doesn't mean the sun goes round the earth just as it doesn't mean the earth is flat and rectangular.

This came up on another thread recently, wherein Einstein's Relativity: The Special and General Theory was mentioned. There's an important bit that says this:

"Now we might easily suppose that the existence of a gravitational field is always only an apparent one. We might also think that, regardless of the kind of gravitational field which may be present, we could always choose another reference-body such that no gravitational field exists with reference to it. This is by no means true for all gravitational fields, but only for those of quite special form. It is, for instance, impossible to choose a body of reference such that, as judged from it, the gravitational field of the earth (in its entirety) vanishes".

In similar vein you can't pick a coordinate system that makes the Sun's gravitational field vanish. The Earth is "falling" around the sun so we don't feel the Sun pulling us up into the sky. But we do notice tides, which would be about half as big without any moon. Doubtless somebody will say Ah, but what if the Earth wasn't rotating? but it all starts getting a bit specious and silly. And besides, we have the CMBR which allows us to gauge our motion through the universe. This doesn't provide an "absolute reference frame" in that inside a black box you still can't tell whether you're moving. But all you have to do is look out the window and then you can. The universe is as absolute as it gets, as it were. Motion is still relative, but when it's relative to the universe, that's the end of the line.
 
As happens quite often, Farsight's talking about things completely irrelevant to the issue at hand. Absolutely no one here even obliquely implied that the Sun's gravitational field goes vanishes completely in any system of coordinates.

Actually, the relevant claim is that gravitational field makes sense in whatever coordinate system you choose, not that it vanishes, and that all coordinate choices produce no measurable differences whatsoever. And that is exactly what Einstein said.
 
How fast? I really wanna know! :)

In those coordinates, fast. Very fast, if they're distant stars.

But as Vorpal points out, this doesn't pose a problem (any more than Hubble expansion does). The naive speed of light is a limit only in inertial frames. But there aren't any inertial frames globally, and a frame in which the earth doesn't rotate is certainly not inertial.
 
Last edited:
sol invictus said:
Do those coordinates "require many novel forces and assumptions"? Nope, not in the slightest - no assumptions are necessary, nor are there any new forces.
This doesn't make any sense to me. I mean, if you assume that the Earth is stationary and everything is rotating around it the further away stuff is the faster it has to move--eventually exceeding the speed of light multiple times over. No force we know of can do that. Worse, the stuff around us has orbits so squirrel they make the paths Billy takes in Family Circus look downright straightforward. This requires either a serious revision to our understanding of inertia, or some extremely weird gravity that's not caused by any detectable bodies.

Are they more complex? Not really - calculations can be done in whatever coordinates are the most convenient, and the results transformed to any other, so on that basis it's very hard to argue that one set of coordinates are more complex than another.
Perhaps you and I are talking about different things. I'm not talking about putting the origin of a coordinate system on Earth's center of mass--I'm talking about assuming, as the Greeks and Medieval Europeans did (and everyone else--but those guys worked out the details), that the Earth was stationary and everything revolved around it. That IS more complex than our current understanding of the solar system at least (can't compare it to our total cosmology, because they didn't have anything comperable), because it required orbits within orbits within orbits in order to account for the observed planetary motion (I forget what it's called off-hand, but it's when the planets appear to be moving backwards in the sky).

Please understand, I'm not saying you're wrong--this is your area of expertise, after all. I'm merely showing how I'm thinking, and why what you're saying doesn't make any sense to me. I think you and I are talking about fundamentally different and incomperable things.

Vorpal said:
Why do you think this?
There's a difference between mapping and modeling. No one is modeling a geocentric universe, because the idea is stupid--we're demonstrably not the center of our own solar system, let alone galaxy, let alone the universe. They MAP the universe based on Earth at the center, sure; but again, mapping isn't modeling.
 
This doesn't make any sense to me. I mean, if you assume that the Earth is stationary and everything is rotating around it the further away stuff is the faster it has to move--eventually exceeding the speed of light multiple times over. No force we know of can do that.

That's not the case.

Choosing coordinates in which the earth isn't rotating is simply, well, a choice of coordinates. It's a convention for a set of labels. So long as your labels uniquely identify points in spacetime, you can use those labels with no problems. If you know how to correctly write the laws of physics in the new coordinates, they are the same laws, and therefore they make exactly the same predictions the laws written in the old coordinate did.

That was Einstein's great insight. It was so powerful that it allowed more than just a convenient, coordinate-independent packaging of the known laws of physics - it allowed him to write down the correct generalization of Newton's law of gravity.

Perhaps you and I are talking about different things.

No, I don't think we are.

I'm not talking about putting the origin of a coordinate system on Earth's center of mass--I'm talking about assuming, as the Greeks and Medieval Europeans did (and everyone else--but those guys worked out the details), that the Earth was stationary and everything revolved around it. That IS more complex than our current understanding of the solar system at least (can't compare it to our total cosmology, because they didn't have anything comperable), because it required orbits within orbits within orbits in order to account for the observed planetary motion (I forget what it's called off-hand, but it's when the planets appear to be moving backwards in the sky).

They were called "epicycles". They were more complex in the sense that they had to keep adding more and more of them, with more and more new parameters. But GR gives us a unified framework in which to construct the unique set of "epicycles" appropriate to whatever coordinates we choose to use. It doesn't require any new parameters, or any additional experimental data - it's a prediction, if you want, although not one with any additional physical content.

Please understand, I'm not saying you're wrong--this is your area of expertise, after all. I'm merely showing how I'm thinking, and why what you're saying doesn't make any sense to me. I think you and I are talking about fundamentally different and incomperable things.

General relativity (or general covariance) is not an easy thing to understand. But it's worth trying, because it's really quite profound.
 
Choosing coordinates in which the earth isn't rotating is simply, well, a choice of coordinates. It's a convention for a set of labels.
Okay, we're talking about different things. As I said before, mapping isn't modeling. To put it in terms I'm familiar with, you can pick any point on Earth's surface as your stable point in order to draw a map of Earth's tectonic plates and it works fine. If you try to model the Earth using any given point as perfectly stable you run into all sorts of problems. And I'd say exceeding the speed of light multiple times over is a bit of a problem.
 
Okay, we're talking about different things. As I said before, mapping isn't modeling. To put it in terms I'm familiar with, you can pick any point on Earth's surface as your stable point in order to draw a map of Earth's tectonic plates and it works fine. If you try to model the Earth using any given point as perfectly stable you run into all sorts of problems. And I'd say exceeding the speed of light multiple times over is a bit of a problem.

You're not exceeding the speed of light as such. No overtaking of light rays happens, so it's all quite consistent.

In just the same way you could do what sol says and work out the motion of the distant stars you can work out the motion of the light from those distant stars, and see that nothing can go faster than it.

The physical speed limit is still in place - the numbers you use to describe it just happen to be different.
 
Okay, we're talking about different things.

Perhaps so, but it certainly doesn't sound like that from your comments.

As I said before, mapping isn't modeling. To put it in terms I'm familiar with, you can pick any point on Earth's surface as your stable point in order to draw a map of Earth's tectonic plates and it works fine. If you try to model the Earth using any given point as perfectly stable you run into all sorts of problems. And I'd say exceeding the speed of light multiple times over is a bit of a problem.

I'm saying you can map and model the entire universe using any coordinate system you wish (within reason - some coordinates don't cover the whole spacetime, or cover it more than once, or have other annoyances), and there is never a problem.

There's no problem with coordinate velocities exceeding c in non-inertial frames. If there as, cosmology would be nonsense, because distant parts of the universe are expanding away from us at arbitrarily large speeds (think about Hubble's law).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom