Is Mainstream Skepticism turning into Fanaticism?

wheunis

Thinker
Joined
Apr 24, 2012
Messages
157
Having been a lurking reader for some relatively medium amount of time, I have seen some quite horrible reponses from so-called skeptics on this Forum.

So I decided against debating this further within those threads, but instead (as appropriate), separate that discussion into it's own thread.

First and foremost, some definitions, as to make my intent and point come across as clear as possible.
I do however encourage any discussion of these definitions as well!

Skeptic:
A person that challenges knowledge, until nothing but truth remains.
Skeptics will normally accept no information as-is, but rather disseminate the given information for fallacies, misinformation, falsehoods, and other inconsistencies - until nothing remains but that which is reliable, provable, and quantifiable as true.
These same values (SHOULD) hold true in challenging the information generally thought to be previously true.

Fanatic:
A person that blindly accepts and/or believes information presented to him.
Fanatics will normally accept any reasonable sounding information, without investigating claims made therein.
Moreover, they will often refuse to see the errors within such information, even when such errors are presented in clear form.
The values of fanatics within previously proven information can vary from situation to situation, as it suits their beliefs.


Which of these are YOU?
If I were a betting man, 90%+ of forum-goers here would loudly proclaim themselves as skeptics. Those same people would take a great offense to what I am about to say.

You're not a skeptic. You're a fanatic.
A rather vast majority of people who call themselves skeptics, would actually not be as skeptic as they claim themselves to be.
Behaviorally, on these forums, I have noticed a rather disturbing trend.

The trend of "No, not now, not ever, impossible".

It's quite easy to spot he divide where skeptics fanatics end, and skeptics start.

A little short story, let's rewind and imagine we are there, at that time.

The Kuiper Belt was "discovered" in the late 1980's. (1987 I think - damn you I'm lazy right now!)
The hypothesis of it's existence has long since been discussed, however.

(The following is an imagine scenario, mixed with factual information)
From that point on, many scientists have been investigating this belt.
At some point, I was one of them.
The following exchange took place between me and you:

Me: Hey, Don't you think there could be REALLY big things in there?
You: Obviously some bigger than others, how big did you have in mind?
Me: Oh, I figure there might be stuff in there as large as Pluto, maybe bigger.
You: Wait, PLANETS inside the belt?!
Me: Yeah. I think it's possible.
You: I don't.
Me: Well, I'm gonna go peek at it some more, see if I can fund some scope for it.
You: Don't waste your time. It's impossible.
Me: What is impossible? Getting funding?
You: No. It is impossible for anything THAT large to be in there.


Turns out, you would have been dead wrong. Even more than just finding what you said was impossible, MULTIPLE such objects were found. One of them even turned out to have become one of Neptune's moons looooooooong ago.

So. The hypothetical You in that conversation...
Do you think he acted skeptically, or fanatically?

I tell you right now, THAT exchange was NOT between 2 scientists of skeptic nature. THAT conversation has 1 fanatic in it...


Is it really ethical for us, here in this forum, to behave that way?
Are we just committing the same crimes as the woo-salesmen by preying on people's weaknesses?
Did you discredit a source of possible information to a fanatic because he was a Journalist; Fully knowing that the fanatic might discard that source because he is distrustful of Journalists?

Even knowing that the Journalist's information is a lie, by proven tests etc - Should we allow ourselves such lowblows and cheapshots just to swing the argument our way?
Shouldn't we, the skeptics, take the high road and maintain to disprove the fallacies by scientific method, instead of just leaning on "because I already know"?

Just because you already know, does not mean that everyone should know.
Dismissing questions about it, theories around it, or discussions into it is NOT how I think we should conduct ourselves.

Anyway, just my take on how we, here in this forum, are fast behaving more and more like the enemies we have sworn to conquer.
 
(Continued and quoted from another thread)

Nope, in my morale structure if you're telling the truth, then thats whats important
I'm not beyond a little psychological manipulation, I'm human

what are you saying wheunis, you don't regard journos as unethical yourself ?
didn't you say earlier ?

just for the record, I'm not an atheist.
:p

See, I'm just not a "means justify the ends" kinda guy.
I always consider the validity of my process as much as the results thereof.

Sure, accidents in processes have led to some fraggin great stuff in the past; But nothing good has ever come from BAD processes...
 
(Continued and quoted from another thread)



See, I'm just not a "means justify the ends" kinda guy.
I always consider the validity of my process as much as the results thereof.

Sure, accidents in processes have led to some fraggin great stuff in the past; But nothing good has ever come from BAD processes...

I don't regard myself as a sceptic either, I'm more of a critical analyst, several times my friends have given me their new hypothesis to see how I tear it apart, its a great learning experience, as I was saying earlier, when you take the conspiracy out of ETH woo, all your left with is the reliability of the source, I see nothing wrong in pointing out to people that often their source is from a profession where making interesting things up to make money is part of the process
I'm not making that up, check out the statistics
http://www.pcc.org.uk/statistics/index.html
:D

you can try it the other way if you like, by going over every single piece of evidence and explaining how its wrong, I tried that, over a 5 year period it bought no joy at all and of course, if at any part of that process they suspect your a disinformationist, then you've wasted your time. So imo its best not to bring your personality or that of the wooster into it, but the character of the source

You say thats unethical in your opinion, but thats like saying you'd take advice on nutrition from a poisoner, theres a saying thats thrown around a lot in history circles, "Always consider the source" its rule number one when examining new information. Getting a woo to consider his sources isnt bad processing, its sound advice, then when they are in a receptive state of mind you can show them the truth, from reputable trusted sources
;)
the way you're saying it, you're making it sound like I just hurl insults til they start crying.
 
Last edited:
...
The Kuiper Belt was "discovered" in the late 1980's. (1987 I think - damn you I'm lazy right now!)
The hypothesis of it's existence has long since been discussed, however.

(The following is an imagine scenario, mixed with factual information)
From that point on, many scientists have been investigating this belt.
At some point, I was one of them.
The following exchange took place between me and you:

Me: Hey, Don't you think there could be REALLY big things in there?
You: Obviously some bigger than others, how big did you have in mind?
Me: Oh, I figure there might be stuff in there as large as Pluto, maybe bigger.
You: Wait, PLANETS inside the belt?!
Me: Yeah. I think it's possible.
You: I don't.
Me: Well, I'm gonna go peek at it some more, see if I can fund some scope for it.
You: Don't waste your time. It's impossible.
Me: What is impossible? Getting funding?
You: No. It is impossible for anything THAT large to be in there.


Turns out, you would have been dead wrong. Even more than just finding what you said was impossible, MULTIPLE such objects were found. One of them even turned out to have become one of Neptune's moons looooooooong ago.

So. The hypothetical You in that conversation...
Do you think he acted skeptically, or fanatically?
...
.
Within the existing state of the art of any time period, "impossible" is a legitimate response to unsupportable belief.
.
Your sample sucks, because "those that know" were postulating the existence of the belt before its discovery.
No doubt based on thinking about what might be out there to explain observations.
.
The woo guy coming up with "it's out there, I know it is!" with nothing more than a very bad grasp of the state of the art, which is typical of the woo guys, can rant about all kinds of boojums and be wrong ALL the time, even when something that with a great stretch of the definition might be discovered to fit his rantings.
 
Do you have any real case to illustrate your point with, instead of you imagining what you think is the case?
 
I would argue that instead of fanatics being on these boards, that there are just downright rude people; from both sides of the coin. Many discussions and debates have disintegrated into degrading those who believe in those things that which have yet to be proven. Those who are challenged that believe in such things as bigfoot, ufo's, psychics instantly put a wall up and they too become just as degrading to those who are skeptical. I've always held the belief that being skeptical does not exclude one from being open minded, and being open minded does not exclude a dose of skepticsm.

At times, it's difficult to find civil debates on the boards. At times I can understand the frustration that can be brought about by an extremely stubborn believer even when they are presented with logic and facts. Just checkout the 9/11 boards and you'll understand why, but I truly believe it is not a license to degrade, disrespect or mock others. Sorry guys, but there are some skeptics here that do put themselves above others to the point of arrogance...just sayin..
 
Last edited:
.
Within the existing state of the art of any time period, "impossible" is a legitimate response to unsupportable belief.
.
Your sample sucks, because "those that know" were postulating the existence of the belt before its discovery.
No doubt based on thinking about what might be out there to explain observations.
.
The woo guy coming up with "it's out there, I know it is!" with nothing more than a very bad grasp of the state of the art, which is typical of the woo guys, can rant about all kinds of boojums and be wrong ALL the time, even when something that with a great stretch of the definition might be discovered to fit his rantings.

I agree that my sample isn't the best. More in response to Hume Fork below on that.

The difference between woo and science hypothesis, is that woo has this typical, as you said "i know it is" mentality.
Science on the other hand starts by not stating, but asking "is it possible?"
Also, stretching the definitions is solely the blame of science. Stretching the universe to fit the model; Creating imaginary energies out of nowhere just to fit the model.

Do you have any real case to illustrate your point with, instead of you imagining what you think is the case?

Yes, I suppose I do.
But as a newly active user, I don't think that calling people out by name would be a necessarily good move towards making friends...

JoeBentley, thank you for so readily proving my exact point within THIS very same thread.
You aren't even willing to discuss that you MIGHT be doing something wrong?
How is that different from religious nuts sticking to their bs for centuries on end, without ever being willing to open the debate?
 
Last edited:
JoeBentley, thank you for so readily proving my exact point within THIS very same thread.
You aren't even willing to discuss that you MIGHT be doing something wrong?
How is that different from religious nuts sticking to their bs for centuries on end, without ever being willing to open the debate?

Because we have evidence to support our views.

Because we constantly revise our views to better fit the available data instead of demanding reality is somehow wrong.

Because we are willing to abandon even our most cherished beliefs if new evidence shows they are not accurate.

Because we follow a methodology that assures we have the best chance of coming to accurate views instead of just blindly parroting dogma.

Because we do no promote not thinking as a virtue.

Do you want me to go on?
 
when you take the conspiracy out of ETH woo, all your left with is the reliability of the source, I see nothing wrong in pointing out to people that often their source is from a profession where making interesting things up to make money is part of the process
I'm not making that up, check out the statistics
http://www.pcc.org.uk/statistics/index.html
:D

I agree. The distilling of information, whether written or video or audio, is extremely important.
I just don't agree that the source should be the overriding factor in seeking truth.
By that logic, we should discount at least X% of Einstein's writings, because he was working in a patent office?
You know, patent office employees throughout history have been known to be a shady bunch of thieves...

you can try it the other way if you like, by going over every single piece of evidence and explaining how its wrong, I tried that, over a 5 year period it bought no joy at all and of course, if at any part of that process they suspect your a disinformationist, then you've wasted your time. So imo its best not to bring your personality or that of the wooster into it, but the character of the source
Ok, this I do get. Fully.
Re-explaining the same thing over and over for every different viewer who newly enters a discussion is quite tiresome.
I have however over the years learned another truth in that regard.
It is exponentially easier for me to remember in which thread, and within a range of 1-5 pages within that thread, said information was discussed - than for a new entrant to read through all (possibly hundreds of) the pages to find same said information.

Double-edged knife I think. A response like "That item was already discussed in the [part 2] thread on this topic, somewhere around page 50-60" is MUCH better and more accommodating than "pissoff we're done with that photo"


You say thats unethical in your opinion, but thats like saying you'd take advice on nutrition from a poisoner, theres a saying thats thrown around a lot in history circles, "Always consider the source" its rule number one when examining new information. Getting a woo to consider his sources isnt bad processing, its sound advice, then when they are in a receptive state of mind you can show them the truth, from reputable trusted sources
;)
I might. Not blindly, though. Same as I don't even take the medication my doctor prescribed without at least looking into it for a few minutes...
On the other hand, I will grant you that - I am more likely to participate in blind consumption recommended by a doctor than what I am to do the same for a Pest Control specialist.


the way you're saying it, you're making it sound like I just hurl insults til they start crying.
I apologize for making it seem that way, even though the cartoon in my mind makes me giggle just a bit. As much as that would be on equal entertainment value as "Idols", somehow I doubt your show will make to live TV...

But on the same tone, is it any different from doing that, when you simply jump onto their insecurity (distrust of journos) just to win and get it over with quickly and simply?
 
I agree. The distilling of information, whether written or video or audio, is extremely important.
I just don't agree that the source should be the overriding factor in seeking truth.
By that logic, we should discount at least X% of Einstein's writings, because he was working in a patent office?
You know, patent office employees throughout history have been known to be a shady bunch of thieves...
well, no not really, if he only ever worked at a patent office that would be one thing, but as he only worked in a patent office a couple of years before earning his PHD in the same way that when I left school I worked in Mcdonalds I don't think the example valid
btw, don't ever eat Mcdonalds "fillet of fish", Tartare sauce can hide a multitude of evils
:D
I apologize for making it seem that way, even though the cartoon in my mind makes me giggle just a bit. As much as that would be on equal entertainment value as "Idols", somehow I doubt your show will make to live TV...
Obviously I would need more sequins then
;)
But on the same tone, is it any different from doing that, when you simply jump onto their insecurity (distrust of journos) just to win and get it over with quickly and simply?
No, you have misread my position, I wasn't saying this is the only method I do that works, I was saying this is the only method I've used that has had any real success. Its not just shouting "all journos are scum" til they give in. You also have to know more about the true facts than the person you are discussing it with as well as knowing what their woo source is saying, I think thats whats most important, if you keep coming up with facts which they then check and corroborate where none of their source can be checked they will slowly start to understand that you know what you're talking about, at that point, then you suggest that their source is unreliable, because quite simply, their source isn't telling the truth.

Lets try one shall we, Sitchin who claims he can read Sumerian said that Anunnaki translates as "those who from heaven to earth came", (I've heard this one from woos so many times, I'm sure you have as well).
so wiki should corroborate that right, its a quite simple translation of one word, someone who can read Sumerian wouldn't get that wrong unless they wanted to, heres the wiki page on the Annunaki, what does it say the word means
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anunnaki
Now we have a problem, as you'll soon discover from looking for references of the word on other non sitchin inspired websites. Either Sitchin is wrong, or every Academic who's ever read cuneiform is because they are all in agreement that it doesn't mean what Sitchin says. The claim of "academia" got it wrong is only tenable when there's disagreement over a subject, not when its unanimous
Thats when you tell them Sitchin is journo scum
:D
 
Last edited:
Some people here know so much, that they pretend to be arrogant so the rest of us don't feel intimidated by their actual perfection.
Damn considerate of them.

I'm slightly stunned that you couldn't find a better example of fanaticism hiding behind skepticism. Usually, though, its likelier to be an uneducated person hiding behind open-mindedness.
 
<snip>
<stuff and wiki and spooy language stuff>
Thats when you tell them Sitchin is journo scum
:D

Yeah, I got that part.
Although shouting "That dude is scum!" until someone cries was yet again, another awesome image in my mind. (Have any brown colored robes and a wicker basket?).

What I am saying, at the end of all this, is that I would have ended the discussion with the woo at <stuff and wiki and spooy language stuff>.

I don't feel that the journoscum statement is needed. I'm not doubting you that it worked.
I just don't think it is worth my personal credibility to step on somebody else's, for the mere ends that I feel needs achieving.

I suppose what I would HOPE FOR, is that the woo will eventually ask me
"Why would he lie like that?!", and my response would invariably be "To scare people into buying his books", to which woo would say "BAH! Nobody does that!".......

awwww hell, im seeing your point... at some point I suppose it HAS TO come up in some form or another...

Lemme go think this over... it is 2am ya know?!
 
Having been a lurking reader for some relatively medium amount of time, I have seen some quite horrible reponses from so-called skeptics on this Forum.

So I decided against debating this further within those threads, but instead (as appropriate), separate that discussion into it's own thread.

First and foremost, some definitions, as to make my intent and point come across as clear as possible.
I do however encourage any discussion of these definitions as well!

Skeptic:
A person that challenges knowledge, until nothing but truth remains.
Skeptics will normally accept no information as-is, but rather disseminate the given information for fallacies, misinformation, falsehoods, and other inconsistencies - until nothing remains but that which is reliable, provable, and quantifiable as true.
These same values (SHOULD) hold true in challenging the information generally thought to be previously true.

Fanatic:
A person that blindly accepts and/or believes information presented to him.
Fanatics will normally accept any reasonable sounding information, without investigating claims made therein.
Moreover, they will often refuse to see the errors within such information, even when such errors are presented in clear form.
The values of fanatics within previously proven information can vary from situation to situation, as it suits their beliefs.


Which of these are YOU?
If I were a betting man, 90%+ of forum-goers here would loudly proclaim themselves as skeptics. Those same people would take a great offense to what I am about to say.

You're not a skeptic. You're a fanatic.
A rather vast majority of people who call themselves skeptics, would actually not be as skeptic as they claim themselves to be.
Behaviorally, on these forums, I have noticed a rather disturbing trend.

The trend of "No, not now, not ever, impossible".

It's quite easy to spot he divide where skeptics fanatics end, and skeptics start.

A little short story, let's rewind and imagine we are there, at that time.

The Kuiper Belt was "discovered" in the late 1980's. (1987 I think - damn you I'm lazy right now!)
The hypothesis of it's existence has long since been discussed, however.

(The following is an imagine scenario, mixed with factual information)
From that point on, many scientists have been investigating this belt.
At some point, I was one of them.
The following exchange took place between me and you:

Me: Hey, Don't you think there could be REALLY big things in there?
You: Obviously some bigger than others, how big did you have in mind?
Me: Oh, I figure there might be stuff in there as large as Pluto, maybe bigger.
You: Wait, PLANETS inside the belt?!
Me: Yeah. I think it's possible.
You: I don't.
Me: Well, I'm gonna go peek at it some more, see if I can fund some scope for it.
You: Don't waste your time. It's impossible.
Me: What is impossible? Getting funding?
You: No. It is impossible for anything THAT large to be in there.


Turns out, you would have been dead wrong. Even more than just finding what you said was impossible, MULTIPLE such objects were found. One of them even turned out to have become one of Neptune's moons looooooooong ago.

So. The hypothetical You in that conversation...
Do you think he acted skeptically, or fanatically?

I tell you right now, THAT exchange was NOT between 2 scientists of skeptic nature. THAT conversation has 1 fanatic in it...


Is it really ethical for us, here in this forum, to behave that way?
Are we just committing the same crimes as the woo-salesmen by preying on people's weaknesses?
Did you discredit a source of possible information to a fanatic because he was a Journalist; Fully knowing that the fanatic might discard that source because he is distrustful of Journalists?

Even knowing that the Journalist's information is a lie, by proven tests etc - Should we allow ourselves such lowblows and cheapshots just to swing the argument our way?
Shouldn't we, the skeptics, take the high road and maintain to disprove the fallacies by scientific method, instead of just leaning on "because I already know"?

Just because you already know, does not mean that everyone should know.
Dismissing questions about it, theories around it, or discussions into it is NOT how I think we should conduct ourselves.

Anyway, just my take on how we, here in this forum, are fast behaving more and more like the enemies we have sworn to conquer.


Um and your sample size and sample error are?
 
Appearing superior to one's opponents is easy when you get to write their lines for them. Just ask Jack Chick.
 
40194f974aa21db75.jpg
 
I was uncool before being uncool was cool...
Which is uncool.


(freaking sigh squared.)
 
But as a newly active user, I don't think that calling people out by name would be a necessarily good move towards making friends...
When you are in a group where the majority have similar, in this case, sceptical, views, then you can converse without a preliminary round of polite, small talk and can make the assumption that this is okay. In other circumstances because people generally try not to offend, then one chooses different methods of talking and discussing.
I have always enjoyed the robustness of views expressed in JREF.
 
I am here to assert the obvious multiple times in a row but I wish to present it as if I am doing it for the first time or with intellectual honesty. I will point out the obvious even in lieu of the fact it's clear this will not add to the conversation in an effort to assert my own convictions one day at a time.

I hurt you as a child and I will hurt you as an adult.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom