Brian Good Challenge: Name one independent architect or engineer who agrees with NIST

nomasters

New Blood
Joined
Apr 7, 2013
Messages
14
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

The challenge, hereby named for its creator Brian Good (not me, btw), is to name one independent architect or engineer who has publicly expressed agreement with NIST's collapse sequence.

The conditions are as follows:
  1. The architect or engineer must be free of professional ties to NIST. People who have worked for or with NIST in any capacity do not qualify as independent.
  2. The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
It is worth noting that nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge. Can any of you?

Good luck!
 
"Nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge?"

Hey, after Jammonious' dismissal of every eyewitness to planes impacting the WTC, any "challenge" in a similar vein is going to seem rather pale.

Nevertheless, I'll pop some popcorn.
 
as AE911 failed to convince the majority of their fellow Architects and engineer since years now, there is absolutely no need for your challenge. Considering that they sell videos and stuff since many years, it seems that their evidence is extremely weak as they fail to convince profesionals in this field.
 
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

The challenge, hereby named for its creator Brian Good (not me, btw), is to name one independent architect or engineer who has publicly expressed agreement with NIST's collapse sequence.

The conditions are as follows:
  1. The architect or engineer must be free of professional ties to NIST. People who have worked for or with NIST in any capacity do not qualify as independent.
  2. The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
It is worth noting that nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge. Can any of you?

Good luck!

Well that's easy. I am a credentialed engineer, and I have no issue with NIST. I have no ties to NIST or the US government in any way, ever. I am not anonymous, having posted my credentials and the means to verify them on this board.

Suck it down.
 
Sorry abaddon, I don't see any verification of your real name and credentials. Nor do I see any verification of your independence from NIST.

0 for 3 so far. Not a good start, I must say!
 
99.9 percent of all engineers know 911 truth is wrong.

Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations
...
Good luck!
1800 people who can't think for themselves, engineers at a rate less than mental illness. Why can't Gage lies attract more than 0.01 percent of all engineers? Because Gage is selling BS only fools fall for.

I am an engineer, and the WTC complex collapsed due to impacts, fire, and gravity. Gravity is also the major source (releasing E=mgh) in CD.

No one needs NIST, only the failed 911 truth movement who can't figure out 911 in the first place. They never read NIST, and have no clue what NIST said; do you? No.

Can anyone in 911 truth show evidence to support 911 truth idiotic claims? No.

99 percent of all engineers will say impacts and fire. Prove me wrong, you can't, 911 truth can't. If it was not for the Internet, 911 truth would be easier to ignore; 911 truth only product, nonsense.

Engineer beachnut says impacts and fire, like NIST did it. I knew this on 911, and everything since has backed up my fires impression. The first people to figure out 911 and take action were Passengers on Flight 93; 911 truth came in last - and are still clueless. What do you think? What is your claim on 911; why does 911 truth give a pass for the 19 murderers?

Why does 911 truth have an obsession with NIST, and the 1800 plus can't produce one rational claim on 911?
 
[*]The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
Yet oddly, these criteria do not apply to YOU. I am quite happy to identify that I am an engineer, agree with NIST, provide the means to verify that I am what I say I am and I am not afraid to do so. You, on the other hand, hide behind the cloak of anonimity. Who are you, and what are your credentials?
 
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

The challenge, hereby named for its creator Brian Good (not me, btw), is to name one independent architect or engineer who has publicly expressed agreement with NIST's collapse sequence.

The conditions are as follows:
  1. The architect or engineer must be free of professional ties to NIST. People who have worked for or with NIST in any capacity do not qualify as independent.
  2. The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
It is worth noting that nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge. Can any of you?

Good luck!

Structural engineer Dipl.-Ing. Christian Feist, who certifies structural plans for sometimes very large buildings (such as lignite coal fired power plants). He is a friend of mine and, frankly, the only member of a relevant profession I have talked with in person about this.

However, the challenge is bogus on several counts:

  1. The 1800 are not a relevant group - the vast majority of them are not experts at all in this matter (they either lack expertise in the relevant fields of structural engineering and fire protection, or they are ill informed about the facts at hand)
  2. The 1800 are not merely "not satisfied with the official investigations" - they make the disproven nonsense claim that explosives brought down the towers
  3. With regard to the bogus claims peddled by con man Richard Gage that these non-experts parrot, the challenge is not whether engineers agree with NIST, but with whether engineers disagree with thos bogus claims of explosive demolition. Brian Good erects a false dichotomy. You can very well disagree with some aspects of NIST's findings and thus be "dissatisfied" and still call Gage's group of 1800 parrots the frauds and fools that they are.
  4. Why should we take a janitor serious?
 
Over 1800 independent architects and engineers are not satisfied with the official investigations of the collapses of World Trade Center Buildings 1, 2, and 7. Is there even one who will say that he or she is?

The challenge, hereby named for its creator Brian Good (not me, btw), is to name one independent architect or engineer who has publicly expressed agreement with NIST's collapse sequence.

The conditions are as follows:
  1. The architect or engineer must be free of professional ties to NIST. People who have worked for or with NIST in any capacity do not qualify as independent.
  2. The architect or engineer must have verifiable identity and credentials. This means no anonymous message board users.
It is worth noting that nobody up to this point has ever met the challenge. Can any of you?

Good luck!

Perhaps you could tell us which part of the NIST report these 1800 architects and engineers are not happy with.

Perhaps they could do their own investigation and compile their own report.

It is worth noting that up to this point they have never met the challenge.
 
Sorry abaddon, I don't see any verification of your real name and credentials. Nor do I see any verification of your independence from NIST.

0 for 3 so far. Not a good start, I must say!

What a research fail. Once again, for the hard of thinking...

David Burke MIEI.

scan0001.jpg
Yup, 6000 miles away from your idiotic ideas, thankfully.
 
Wow, look what we have here.

beachnut: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials.

abbadon: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials. Shows some sort of official looking paper, which could be real or fake, from someone named "David Burke", who could be anyone. Sorry, no dice.

Oystein: mentions a name, but provides no verification of identity or credentials. We don't even know that "Christian Feist" really agrees with NIST.

Disbelief and Spanx: can't name anybody.

Strike four, strike five, strike six, strike seven, strike eight. Lucky for you guys this ain't baseball.
 
Yet oddly, these criteria do not apply to YOU. I am quite happy to identify that I am an engineer, agree with NIST, provide the means to verify that I am what I say I am and I am not afraid to do so. You, on the other hand, hide behind the cloak of anonimity. Who are you, and what are your credentials?

My identity and credentials are irrelevant to the challenge. We already know that the case against NIST - and in favor of a new investigation - enjoys overwhelming support in the architecture and engineering communities, with or without me. More than 1800 voices against NIST, vs. 0 for NIST. That's not just overwhelming. That's unanimous.
 
Last edited:
Wow, look what we have here.

abbadon: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials. Shows some sort of official looking paper, which could be real or fake, from someone named "David Burke", who could be anyone. Sorry, no dice.

Call the Institute of Engineers. Did you do that? No. Of course you didn't. Go right ahead and ask for member number 031769.

Now what are your credentials?
 
Disbelief and Spanx: can't name anybody.

Did I say I could ?

Why don't you answer this simple question.

Why haven't the 1800 in question, compiled there own report. Or at least tell me which part they all have a problem with.

This should be an easy Question which should be documented.
 
Last edited:
Wow, look what we have here.

beachnut: claims he's an engineer, but provides no verification of identity or credentials.

... .
You presented evidence you are gullible, serving 911 truth, spreading nonsense.

Why should I send a photo of my degrees? I only have a masters in engineering.

It only takes a grade school education to debunk 911 truth. I am over qualified.

I am a pilot too. http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/DSC_4570-1.jpg
http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/Iamapilot.jpg my FAA ticket... do you have a degree? No.

I already posted that, and I think I posted by diploma as an engineer, but you can't post any evidence to support Gage; when you do I will run down my degree. Which I will not have to do.

http://i286.photobucket.com/albums/ll116/tjkb/AircraftCourseOrg800.jpg
I have an ATP, and as seen, I am a trained aircraft accident investigator. What are you besides a 911 truth follower, in a failed movement of lies?

You have no case against NIST, you have failed words, failed opinions based on fantasy. Why does 911 truth bash NIST? They never read the reports. How does Gage know what he is against?

Welcome to JREF, your score is 0 so far.

Comedy tonight...
.... More than 1800 voices against NIST, vs. 0 for NIST. That's not just overwhelming. That's unanimous.
That's your fantasy. Make silly claims, claim victory, run away.
 
Last edited:
Those 1800 independent architects and engineers include some whose stated qualifications are no better than mine. It really is a very small number compared with the total number of architects and engineers in USA. Worse there is no independent verification of what many of these people believe in now as they did something several years ago to have their name added. Very few are currently doing anything on the issue.

Conclusion: the list is irrelevant.
 
My identity and credentials are irrelevant to the challenge. We already know that the case against NIST - and in favor of a new investigation - enjoys overwhelming support in the architecture and engineering communities, with or without me. More than 1800 voices against NIST, vs. 0 for NIST. That's not just overwhelming. That's unanimous.

And I met those criteria. You simply don't like it because it flies in the face of your fantasy. And you cower under the cover of anonimity.

What is your name and standing? Or will you continue to shiver under the camoflage of anonimity, fearing to reveal yourself?
 
Call the Institute of Engineers. Did you do that? No. Of course you didn't. Go right ahead and ask for member number 031769.

Now what are your credentials?

What good would calling do? The person behind number 031769 could be anybody from a cook to a janitor to a dog walker.

I never claimed to have any credentials in the relevant areas, but so what? There are 1830 others who agree with me and DO have the credentials! This challenge isn't about that, however. It's about finding an independent, verified architect or engineer who agrees with NIST. So far, there are none.

Why is this so hard for you guys? Shouldn't you be able to find somebody who is well known in his or her field, maybe from a university or a reputable firm, who has publicly endorsed the NIST report? If not, why not? Could it be that nobody is willing to jeopardize their professional reputation by supporting something that they - and all of their colleagues - know is a sham?
 
What good would calling do? The person behind number 031769 could be anybody from a cook to a janitor to a dog walker.

I never claimed to have any credentials in the relevant areas, but so what? There are 1830 others who agree with me and DO have the credentials! This challenge isn't about that, however. It's about finding an independent, verified architect or engineer who agrees with NIST. So far, there are none.

Why is this so hard for you guys? Shouldn't you be able to find somebody who is well known in his or her field, maybe from a university or a reputable firm, who has publicly endorsed the NIST report? If not, why not? Could it be that nobody is willing to jeopardize their professional reputation by supporting something that they - and all of their colleagues - know is a sham?

1000 engineers I graduated at two schools agree it was impacts and fire. Oops, you lost this one. Who do you have, a bunch of failed nuts who joined Gage. Are you an engineer? If you were your chance of falling for Gage crap would be less than 0.1 percent.

I can only find less than 0.1 percent of engineer who agree with the failed claims of 911 truth; Gage has some of them listed. You lost this one.

Come back when you get 50 percent of engineers. Good luck.


Is Brian Good an engineer? This Brian Good? http://screwloosechange.blogspot.com/2009/02/brian-goods-greatest-hits.html
No, Brian is not an engineer, he spreads nonsense on 911, and is too lazy to ask engineers himself.
Cool part, anyone with a grade school education can debunk Gage's failed engineers and other Gage cult members.

Being an engineer does not make you rational; as proved by Gage's engineers.

Too bad you are not an engineer; counting you an Brian Good.
You lost so far, JREF 2, you 0. We could lower this to grade school level, we could be at 2 and 2, of you and Mr Good have a diploma.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom