EU finally designates Hezbollah a terrorist organization.

Virus

Philosopher
Joined
Jun 19, 2006
Messages
6,875
It's about time. After all, they did just blow up a bus full of tourists on European soil and had a plot fail in Cyprus.

The EU only designated their "military wing" as terrorists but I guess that's better than nothing. There is no separate "military" wing of Hezbollah, there wasn't one of the IRA but it was a useful fiction for both sides because it let the terrorists enter negotiations while saving face.

"It is good that the EU has decided to call Hezbollah what it is: a terrorist organization," Dutch Foreign Minister Frans Timmermans said on the sidelines of a meeting of EU foreign ministers who decided on the blacklisting.

"We took this important step today, by dealing with the military wing of Hezbollah, freezing its assets, hindering its fundraising and thereby limiting its capacity to act."

Mark Dubowitz, the executive director of the Washington-based Foundation for Defense of Democracies, wrote The Jerusalem Post by email, that "The decision will be partially welcomed by Washington and Jerusalem but it still ignores the evidence, including statements from Hezbollah's own leadership, that Hezbollah is not a two-winged organization neatly divided between political and military arms."

In all, a good move. Hezbollah raise a lot of money in Europe and now that source of funding has been cut off. Their major funding source is Iran, which is under heavy sanctions. Another major source of funds is drugs. They have networks all over South America and work with FARC, a leftist drug gang in Columbia.

If Hezbollah had a facebook page, it would look like this.
 
The EU only designated their "military wing" as terrorists but I guess that's better than nothing. There is no separate "military" wing of Hezbollah, there wasn't one of the IRA but it was a useful fiction for both sides because it let the terrorists enter negotiations while saving face.

The IRA was the "military wing" of the IRA.
 
The EU takes with one hand and gives with the other. This rather nebulous declaration will have no actual effect, while the new attitude to illegal settlements might well do. Time will tell.

The EU is clearly not persuaded by the Bulgarian bombing, since any attack on Jews will be blamed by Israel on Hezbollah. There are any number of neo-Nazis in that part of the world who might have had a hand in it, or it might be gang-related. I doubt we'll ever know the truth of it.

What the EU is concerned about is the fading nature of international borders in the old Mandate territories. Designed for European imperial purposes in the 1920's they are now utterly dysfunctional, and in the case of the Lebanese border a complete fiction.
 
The EU is clearly not persuaded by the Bulgarian bombing, since any attack on Jews will be blamed by Israel on Hezbollah. There are any number of neo-Nazis in that part of the world who might have had a hand in it, or it might be gang-related. I doubt we'll ever know the truth of it.

Yes, of course, those devious Israelis will just accuse without any evidence. There is no reason to listen to them. And no one else is making the same claims.

Actually, both Bulgaria and Cyprus have accused Hezobolla. (The Cyprus case involves a person paid by Hezbollah to get information on the movement of Israeli tourists. He was convicted in court.)

Where did you get the idea that the EU was not persuaded from? From what I read the evidence was enough for most EU members but other considerations took precedence. One of the main opponents was France. They real reason France objected the decision was the possible political difficulties that such a move will create in Lebanon and its relations with the EU. What changed the equation? Hezbollah involvement in the civil war in Syria.
 
Yes, of course, those devious Israelis will just accuse without any evidence. There is no reason to listen to them. And no one else is making the same claims.
The Israeli government has an interest in demonising Hezbollah in order to restrict their funding and to justify any attack on Southern Lebanon that Israel might decide to make in future. I'm not going to trust information from a government which has an interest in the matter at hand.

Actually, both Bulgaria and Cyprus have accused Hezobolla. (The Cyprus case involves a person paid by Hezbollah to get information on the movement of Israeli tourists. He was convicted in court.)
The Bulgarian and Cypriot justice systems are not strong supports, and one wonders where they get their information from. Does it all ultimately trace back to Israel, or do they have their own inside sources?

Let's not forget that the Israeli sources are the same ones which couldn't prevent Hezbollah driving Israel out of Southern Lebanon and were caught by surprise in 2006. These are visible failings, observable on the ground, not sources which must, for operational reasons, remain secret. I remain unconvinced.

Where did you get the idea that the EU was not persuaded from?
The timing and the rather equivocal nature of the decision.

From what I read the evidence was enough for most EU members but other considerations took precedence.
Bombs on tourist buses in Europe is not something European governments take lightly. Many Europeans holiday in Europe, and by bus. I don't see them letting "other considerations", not even French interests in the Levant, obstruct action if they were convinced. As it is, I gather only the Dutch government has made Hezbollah illegal, and that government has some issues about Muslims.

One of the main opponents was France. They real reason France objected the decision was the possible political difficulties that such a move will create in Lebanon and its relations with the EU. What changed the equation? Hezbollah involvement in the civil war in Syria.
Precisely, and basically what I was saying. There's no doubt nor attempt to conceal that Hezbollah has been fighting in Syria and the French-drawn Lebanese border is losing any signficance it ever had. Nation-states find that sort of thing very disconcerting.
 
Yeah or maybe, and I'm just throwing this out there as a wild theory, Hezbollah was labelled a terrorist group because they're terrorists.
 
Yeah or maybe, and I'm just throwing this out there as a wild theory, Hezbollah was labelled a terrorist group because they're terrorists.

Err this is the EU we are talking about.
 
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.

never forget Ivan is Human
 
Err this is the EU we are talking about.

It took about 20 years of bombings, hijackings, rocket barrages, assassinations and murders for them to finally admit they were terrorists but better late than never.
 
It took about 20 years of bombings, hijackings, rocket barrages, assassinations and murders for them to finally admit they were terrorists but better late than never.

Oh I doubt it. Did they mess with farm subsidies or something?
 
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.

never forget Ivan is Human
And Al Capone ran soup kitchens...

This whole "military wing" vs. "political wing" is ridiculous, it's the same organization.
 
Precisely, and basically what I was saying. There's no doubt nor attempt to conceal that Hezbollah has been fighting in Syria and the French-drawn Lebanese border is losing any signficance it ever had. Nation-states find that sort of thing very disconcerting.
Know what else is disconcerting? When a "political party" has a private military more powerful than the national military. And this private army has been used to attack Lebanon's neighboring countries.
 
And Al Capone ran soup kitchens...

This whole "military wing" vs. "political wing" is ridiculous, it's the same organization.

Oh come on even the CIA isn't that incompetent. Divide and rule. The trick is to arrange for the guy who wants to spend money on hospitals to have a political edge over the guy who wants to spend money on guns. Then you kill them.
 
And Al Capone ran soup kitchens...

This whole "military wing" vs. "political wing" is ridiculous, it's the same organization.

You have missed the point once again, and the strategic relaites, Hezzbollah is a politcal organisation that ahs a military side and a non military side, most organisations like this do and to reduce these organisations to jsut terrorism is a blunder that will onyl make matter worse in the long run.

It is ridiculous to think its all about absoulutes and jsut one bloc or thing.
 
You have missed the point once again, and the strategic relaites, Hezzbollah is a politcal organisation that ahs a military side and a non military side, most organisations like this do and to reduce these organisations to jsut terrorism is a blunder that will onyl make matter worse in the long run.

It is ridiculous to think its all about absoulutes and jsut one bloc or thing.
So is Nasrallah the head of the political or military wing?
 
You have missed the point once again, and the strategic relaites, Hezzbollah is a politcal organisation that ahs a military side and a non military side, most organisations like this do and to reduce these organisations to jsut terrorism is a blunder that will onyl make matter worse in the long run.

It is ridiculous to think its all about absoulutes and jsut one bloc or thing.

You realize that arguments like yours would apply equally, with no changes in wording, to organizations like the Nazis, right?

Sometimes a whole organization is just tainted scum.
 
You have missed the point once again, and the strategic relaites, Hezzbollah is a politcal organisation that ahs a military side and a non military side, most organisations like this do and to reduce these organisations to jsut terrorism is a blunder that will onyl make matter worse in the long run.

It is ridiculous to think its all about absoulutes and jsut one bloc or thing.
This sounds like the reminder we always get when discussing HAMAS that "oh! But they also run Gaza! They are responsible for public services A, B and C! Why do you forget this? Surely you must mention this to achieve balance!".

I don't think anyone is saying that every single person affiliated with Hizbollah is training to become a martyr, more than we're saying that every single resident in Nazi Germany worked in death camps, or that every single employee in the Vatican works full-time committing or covering up sex crimes. Of course every organization has people working in administration and whatnot, covering more mundane tasks.

However, none of this changes the fact that Hizbollah is a terrorist organization.
 
Last edited:
Hezbollah like most organisations of this type is a mixture of a terrorist body and a politcial one, Fatah was the same the IRA was the same nothing is balck and white in this sort of conflict and to try and simplify it like that and ignoring strategic realites will not help bring about a lasting peace in the area.
On the contrary, I strongly believe that demonizing and ultimately removing extremist scum like HAMAS and Hezbollah from the picture would go a long, long, long way towards bringing a lasting peace to the region.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom