What Can We Assume About an Alien Spacefaring Race?

Mudcat

Man of a Thousand Memes
Joined
Apr 6, 2011
Messages
6,474
This is a thread intended to discus alien lifeforms and what they might look like, not the possibility that they may have visited us in the past. Hopefully everyone will enjoy, participate, and debate in all good fun.

Scientists recently-ish determined that much of the universe probably harbors life of one sort or another. If it's animalistic in nature, then if some of the strange and baffling creatures that call earth home is any indication then it can be just about anything.

But if it's intelligent life, maybe even one with a space faring civilization what then? What can we assume about it? A few sad individuals on the forums might say that we can't assume anything because we only have one data set to learn from and that it can be anything. That alien life would most likely be very different from human beings.

I strongly disagree, and here is why:

In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.
 
Last edited:
A few sad individuals on the forums might say that we can't assume anything because we only have one data set to learn from and that it can be anything.
They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.
If you can't think of a way that something might be dexterous without opposable thumbs you probably aren't even exploiting that one dataset you've got well enough yet.
 
Don't they look like Bigfoot?

I don't see why they couldn't.

If you can't think of a way that something might be dexterous without opposable thumbs you probably aren't even exploiting that one dataset you've got well enough yet.

What are you talking about birds that use sticks as tools to fish out bugs? So tell me, when is the last time you seen a monument or a rocket build by a society of birds? When is the last time you seen birds design, build, or maintain their tools?

Thumbs or bust.
 
Last edited:
So tell me, when is the last time you seen a monument or a rocket build by a society of birds? When is the last time you seen birds design, build, or maintain their tools?

Monuments? Have a look at bower birds.

Frankly, this is a silly argument. Just because they haven't, doesn't mean they wont. Who's to say what birds will be up to in a million or 10 million years time......a mere blink of the eye in terms of our planet's development. If there are other planets harbouring intelligent life, why should they be on the same timetable as us?

Mike
 
Monuments? Have a look at bower birds.

A bowerbird nest:

http://andreazampitella.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/10/Satin-Bower-Bird-Nest.jpg
An ancient monument:

http://www.englisharticles.info/wp-content/uploads/2011/02/Ancient_Monuments-300x215.jpg

Oh yeah, that's a really accurate comparison.:rolleyes:

MikeG said:
Frankly, this is a silly argument.

Than why are you here? Also it isn't an argument, it's a debate.

MikeG said:
Just because they haven't, doesn't mean they wont. Who's to say what birds will be up to in a million or 10 million years time......a mere blink of the eye in terms of our planet's development.

Birds have been around for a few billion years and they haven't yet. I think it's a safe bet to say that they never will.

MikeG said:
If there are other planets harboring intelligent life, why should they be on the same timetable as us?

I don't recall making the assumption that the planet is on the same timetable as ours. They could be a few billion older than earth, or a few billion years younger.

I would think that the title of the thread should make this very apparent but I'm talking about alien civilizations. Each would inherently develop at their own pace, like each civilization has here on earth. But since we are talking about a spacefaring civilization that should make it blindingly obvious that they are more advanced than us even if it's not by much.

How you missed all this is beyond me.

Edited by Locknar: 
Hotlinks removed, breach of rule 5.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Bi-lateral symmetry. Sensory organs located near the brain. Senses/brain in a protective casing of some kind located on the creature's tallest point. Food intake/waste expulsion on opposite "ends."
 
I would think that the limiting factor of biology being compatible with technology would be more about the anatomical convenience of carrying things and looking at the things in your grasp and the possibility of dexterity, than strictly about the thumb grasp. Octopus tentacles don't help much cause if you ever drop a thing it goes away into the ocean; elephant trunks don't help much because they need their trunk for all sorts besides just carrying a thing; birds come closest but are still at that 'drop a thing it goes away' disadvantage in addition to the 'hopping on one foot' disadvantage, and both elephants and birds have difficulty manipulating something and looking at it at the same time.
 
Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.

I can see why the individual drones wouldn't be terribly creative; it's not clear to me why the hive as a whole (or the ruling caste) couldn't be.

Some insects have 'hive mentality,' some don't, so I wouldn't rule out insectoids based strictly on that. Terrestrial insects, however, have some pretty harsh limits on brain size due to their reliance on an exoskeleton and, as I understand it, a respiration system that scales up very poorly, so I suspect that our insects are an evolutionary dead-end if you want space-fairing aliens.

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.

There are other creatures out there that do some very dextrous (if I may use that term) manipulations with their mouths or tentacles. I'm not ready to rule out other approaches simply because us opposable-thumbers got there first.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet.

Why would we assume that? Wouldn't they build their spaceships to accommodate themselves?

So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments.

I suspect that the environments in human-built manned spacecraft have far, far less variation than we see in the nature, even among the areas inhabited by humans. Would aliens handle it differently?

This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

not seeing this, for a variety of reasons.

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.

Again, I suspect that they'd design their ships to accommodate themselves. Also, I have lived in houses (designed for humans) that had inhabitants that were not bipedal and definitely had tails, and they were able to move about quite freely.

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

I agree that it eliminates paranormal abilities, but they are not limited to our senses or communications modes.
 
A few sad individuals on the forums might say that we can't assume anything because we only have one data set to learn from and that it can be anything.

Followed, of course, with your humanoid set of assumptions.


This is a thread intended to discus alien lifeforms and what they might look like, not the possibility that they may have visited us in the past. Hopefully everyone will enjoy, participate, and debate in all good fun.
(emphasis mine)

Followed by your ridiculing the first few posters who disagreed with your assumptions.

Pity. I was going to play. Looking elsewhere.
 
In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.

This is not a given. it's easy to imagine an organism that launches their pods high and far, and occasionally one of those pods escapes the thin atmosphere... There you have it, space travel without spaceships.

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.

Again, given enough time and complexity, a hive might stumble upon some very nifty things. It's not out of possibility that, say, hyper-advanced arthropods with long lifespans and big brains (and lungs) could stumble upon advanced physics without leaving the hive mentality. If they had a communication system that allowed them to effectively unite their brains (think biological Internet), via pheromones, or small electric charges, or even bioluminescence, then they could dominate very difficult concepts very fast, even with relatively small brains.

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.

This one is just silly... they can have, for example pincers, or tentacles, or maleable protoplasm. The idea that tools are limited to thumbs is very silly. And the idea that a bowerbird can produce monuments that are more advanced than anything some of our much brainier ancesters ever did is nothing short of awesome.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs.

Unless they can just freeze-dry themselves without damage, like tardigrades. Actually, highly intelligent tardigrades would be one of the most formidable species I can imagine.

And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet.

Say what? Why would a space faring species put an atmosphere in their ships that would be diferent from the one they can survive in?

So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

This one is a mess... So you think a lizard couldn't survive in the ISS? Or that it would be such a huge problem to launch a water-filled capsule?

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships.

Yes, elephant sized humanoids would not be space faring because ships are so small... if only there was a way to compensate for size when building the damn things.

This eliminates plantoids.

What eliminates plantoids is that its difficult for plant life to manage the metabolic requirements of walking around. But if you have a carnivorous plant evolving to get more and more calories by predation,and then developing something similar to a nervous system and a brain, then it would still be, strictly speaking, a plantoid, although the photosynthesis part could be of very small importance.

This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.

Yes, because a species with a vastly different anatomy would be constrained by human ship design. I can see it now "Yes, I have this cool propulsion system, but nobody can sit in the pilot chair because we have no asses... I guess we have to scrap the whole thing and go back to the caves, trying to figure out if rocks are edible."

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

Again, it depends what you mean. Supernatural, by definition we can rule out. But maybe some form of communication could stump us and fit into the "psychic" category. For instance, fast pulse bioluminescence could easily be confused with telepathy.

What I get from your post is that your knowledge of the world you live in is lacking, and so is your imagination. Great topic, though :)
 
A bowerbird nest:
Oh yeah, that's a really accurate comparison.:rolleyes:

You didn't ask for an accurate comparison. You said, in a mocking tone that's becoming familiar, "when is the last time you seen a monument .......build by a society of birds". I provided an obvious example. There are others. Many others. Oh, and I presume you meant to say "when was the last time you saw........built by.....

.......it isn't an argument, it's a debate.
Tiresome semantics.

Birds have been around for a few billion years and they haven't yet. I think it's a safe bet to say that they never will.
Please tell me you're joking.

I don't recall making the assumption that the planet is on the same timetable as ours. They could be a few billion older than earth, or a few billion years younger

You have difficulty with the idea, clearly, that if your alien creature had visited this planet only, say, 20 million years ago, then they would have gone away without finding any intelligent or tool using life forms at all. Our planets, and their inhabitants, only have to be on very slightly different timetables for there to be vastly different outcomes in the event of a visit one-to-the-other.

How you missed all this is beyond me.

Charmed. However, I haven't missed anything in your posts, and certainly not the tone........You clearly have missed rather a lot in mine, as I have just explained.

Mike
 
Last edited:
We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
WTH? Wings, tails, and abundance of limbs are an advantage in zero gravity.
 
A few sad individuals on the forums might say that we can't assume anything because we only have one data set to learn from and that it can be anything. That alien life would most likely be very different from human beings.

I strongly disagree, and here is why:
I strongly disagree with your disagreement, and here is why (I hope you won't label me a "sad individual"):

In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts. They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language. Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.
We can eliminate "animalistic life forms" as we know them. It may well be that the perceptions, motivations, and modes of thought of these spacefarers is so inscrutable, so--well, alien--to us as to be unrecognizable as meaningfully sentient.

Since developing any kind of technology
Maybe the capability evolved naturally.

requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.
Unless the hive mind is of a type that increases in spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, the more individuals join the hive. Maybe their entire history of civilization is a story of incrementally expanding the upper limits on hive membership, each generation larger than the last, and each bootstrapping themselves to the next level of intelligence and technology.

Maybe they'll land on our planet as a few dumb brutes, equipped with smart machines to do their thinking for them, and as they consume and breed they get smarter and smarter, until they have no more need for their machines, and it's too late for us to stand a chance against their superior intellect.

Also see "psychic abilities" below.

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology. Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.
Or octopi.

Or intelligent elephants. Intellephants.

Or hive-minded birds that can oppose their beaks to their claws and their own claws and beaks to each others' beaks and claws to form elegant, elaborate grasping mechanisms far beyond our primitive "hands".

Or some kind of really smart starfish that opposes its pseudopods at will and as necessary.

Or a Jellybrain, that just envelopes stuff in cerebral goo and relaxes and stiffens volumes within the goo to manipulate objects.

Or intellephants. I'm kinda proud of that one (acknowledgements to Niven and Pournelle, who had the same idea long before I did).

See also "aquatic life forms", below.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.
Imagine an aquatic life form that manufactures by secreting layers of specially-formulated ceramics and glues from specialized glands, and finishes them against pods and protusions evolved for this purpose.

Ignoring fire, the wheel, and the internal combustion engine, they might skip straight to a technology based on organically-formed resistors, transistors, capacitors, etc. They'd become masters of magnetohydrodynamic effects.

They'd secrete outer carapaces that function as pressure vessels, environment containers, and radiation shields. Their ship would need no atmosphere, as each of them, snail-like, would already be carrying his home on his back all the time. They could brachiate about the vacuum-exposed scaffolding of their vessel on thought-controlled prosthetic pseudopods (see "psychic abilities", below), and plug into tanks of gases, liquids, and nutrients as necessary.

As long as their outer shell is adapted to a variety of environments, that's all the adaptation they need.

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids.
Why not assume that plantoids would be content to sit quietly in one place and grow, during the long march across the stars? Maybe it plants small clusters of waldos, robots made in its own image, at strategic points about the vessel to effect repairs? Why not a whole forest of alien Canadarms, and in the grove at the forest's heart a sentient, sedentary world tree that controls them all through a network of cybernetic nerve-vines?

This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.
You're assuming that spacefarers want to spend a lot of resources mimicking planetary gravity.

Let's face it: human morphology is flatly retarded for living in space. Having two legs is a waste of resources on the ISS. Astronauts would be much better served with an extra pair of arms down there.

And wings in zero-g would be straight-up awesome. Can you imagine the Ur-crows of Corvus Nine cawing their birdy butts off at us, as we flail ineffectually around in the giant volumes of their Mothernest, trying to swim through the air towards some kind of handhold?

We also know that regardless of whether they're from the next solar system over or the far side of the galaxy they must still live in this universe. Which means that they are subject to the same laws of physics that we are. So this eliminates psychic abilities or what not.

Depends what you mean by "psychic abilities".

We're making great progress on prosthetic limbs that are directly controlled by brain activity. What about creatures that have already evolved built-in bluetooth circuits in their heads?

There's your spontaneous, creative, innovative hive mind right there. The more nodes join the network, the more computational capacity they share, and the more ideas they process. Maybe "mathematics" is just something that happens when enough of them get together in one network. Maybe they don't even have a spoken language at all. What language does a computer CPU speak to itself, when it's indexing memory addresses in a translation lookaside buffer?

Maybe individually, they have no more spoken language than a cat, and jointly they have no more need for a spoken language than you do in your dreams.

To a hive mind that uses radio as a form of telepathy, our attempts at electronic communication might come across as clumsy (or brutal) psychic attacks, and our spoken language might come across as nothing more than the pointless meat-flapping of "animalistic life forms".

They might look at all our tools and monuments and assume that we are devolved creatures, living in the ruins of a now-defunct hive mind civilization.
 
Last edited:
In order to be able to develop a space faring technology, the race developing it must be able to conceive, transmit, and understand certain concepts.

I certainly agree with this.

They must also have the ability to use mathematics and posses a written and spoken language.

I don't agree with this. They just need a means to communicate and store information. It doesn't have to be written and spoken.

For example, they could communicate visually instead by spoken words. Bees do this with "dance", cephalopods do this by rapidly changing the visual patterns on their skin, and deaf humans do this with hand signals.

Plus there are other ways to communicate, such as by scent or touch.

So it's not necessary that they have a spoken language.

But some form of written language is probably likely, because in pre-technological times they'll have needed to develop some method of storing information. Although, alternative methods to writing have existed in the past, like sequences of different types of knots in a string to communicate a message.

Right off the bat we can eliminate animalistic life forms.

Umm.... you've lost me here.

Exactly what do you mean by "animalistic" life form, and how does it differ from a "non-animaliistic" life form? And why can we eliminate it off the bat?

Since developing any kind of technology requires spontaneity, creativity, and innovation, we can safely eliminate any kind of life that has a hive mind mentality. Such as insects.


Hive mentality? You mean like a hive mind?

Such a thing has often been speculated about, but never observed. How do you know that a hive mind would not be capable of spontaneity, creativity or innovation?

They must also be tool users. This means they must be able to design, build, use, and maintain their tools and technology.

Well, obviously. A spacefaring race implies spaceships. Spaceships don't grow on trees, so you need tools to build them.

Thus we can assume that they would have opposable thumbs. This eliminates... Well, anything that doesn't have opposable thumbs.

Why would you need opposable thumbs to use tools?

It's already been pointed out that birds can use simple tools, and they don't have opposable thumbs. Wouldn't it be possible for a tool-using species have some other form of manipulating appendages?

Maybe tentacles, claws, or an elephant's trunk? Maybe they have hands designed differently from ours, with fingers radiating outward in different directions from the palm of their hand, giving them fingers which oppose each-other so they don't need thumbs.

Even a human with their thumbs cut off can build and use tools, it's just more difficult.

We know that in order to survive in space they would need to provide their own atmosphere needs. And due to such mundanities as atmospheric pressure, temperature, and so forth we can assume that the atmosphere on board their ship or ships is far different from what's on their planet. So we can assume that they would have to be available to survive in a variety of environments. This eliminates anything cold blooded, or any aquatic lifeforms.

There's no problem keeping a spaceship warm. Since you're in space, you've got great insulation, like living inside a vacuum flask (aka a thermos). In fact, the big problem is getting rid of waste heat, so I don't see how that eliminates anything cold blooded.

Maintaining a high-pressure spaceship isn't really that difficult, but even low-pressure ones we have are sufficient for most earth life to survive in, so there's no reason the alien species would have to have a particularly versatile or hardy constitution.

Aquatic lifeforms probably wouldn't be be capable of a high-tech civilization anyway, because it's hard to build fires hot enough to smelt metal when you live underwater.

We know that they would have to be mobile enough to move freely through their environment, especially in the cramp quarters that exists on space ships. This eliminates plantoids. This also pretty much eliminates anything that is not bipedal. This also effectively eliminates anything with tails or an abundance of limbs or wings.


Why does this eliminate anything not bipedal? Non-bipedal creatures often manage to squeeze into spaces that are very tiny for their size.

And why would a tail be a problem? It's not like you'd need a wider corridor or higher ceiling to make room for a tail.

I don't understand this objection.

Besides which, The cramped quarters on a spaceship exist because they're designed to be the minimum size in which a human can move. Wouldn't any spacefaring species also design their spaceships the right size to accommodate their own bodies?

You have a point with plants, but they could possibly build remote-controlled drones. In fact, they'd probably have to build remote-controlled drones in order to construct the space-ships for them. (Not that this would be likely, given that plants don't have brains.)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom